Rosedale Robbery: Social media reacts as officials steal Floyd of Rosedale from Iowa
It looked like Cooper DeJean had saved the day once again.
Against all odds, the Iowa Hawkeyes were going to survive and beat the Minnesota Golden Gophers. Whether the final score was 16-12 or 17-12 or 18-12 with a potential two-point try pending, Iowa was once again going to have won in spite of its offense.
There’s another conversation to be had about Iowa being in the situation it was in in the first place and just how unsustainable its offense is, but let’s deal with the immediate aftermath here.
After a potential game-winning drive stalled out at Iowa’s 41-yard line, the Hawkeyes elected to punt it away to Minnesota instead of going for it on 4th-and-10. The Hawkeyes had all three of their timeouts to work with and would turn one final time to their defense to try and get the football back with one final chance to drive and kick a game-winning field goal.
Inexplicably, the Gophers actually chose to throw the football in between runs of just one and three yards from running back Sean Tyler on the ensuing drive. That meant Minnesota would be punting the football away to DeJean and Iowa.
As Minnesota punter Mark Crawford’s punt skipped past midfield, DeJean signaled for his return team to get away from the football, seemingly deciding not to attempt a return.
Then, at the last moment, DeJean sprung into action, snaring the football at his own 46-yard line. DeJean slipped out of an initial would-be tackle from Minnesota’s Brady Weeks and then raced past a host of Gophers and tiptoed the sidelines to stay in bounds.
DeJean then cut back, evaded another Gopher punt coverage member at the Minnesota 32-yard line and ended his dizzying display with a 54-yard punt return touchdown. It sent Kinnick Stadium into a frenzy.
What a moment. Just like Michigan State. DeJean to the rescue.
COOPER DEJEAN! IOWA HAS GONE MAX IOWA AND GETS A PUNT RETURN TD TO LEAD 16-12!!! pic.twitter.com/sAq9NdBa0u
— Sickos Committee (@SickosCommittee) October 21, 2023
Then, of course, the officials decided to get in the way and mar a heroic Hawkeye victory and take away a defining, game-winning moment to capture the Floyd of Rosedale.
After review, the officiating crew ruled that DeJean had signaled for an invalid fair catch, ruling the play dead at the Iowa 46-yard line.
Iowa’s offense did get one final crack at it and of course the sequence led to sophomore quarterback Deacon Hill being sacked and then promptly throwing a game-sealing interception.
Hawkeye fans were collectively outraged. And it feels like the majority of the college football world feels that Iowa was robbed versus Minnesota, too.
Take a look at the reaction and outrage below.
The explanation
REFS SAY THERE WAS AN INVALID FAIR CATCH SIGNAL pic.twitter.com/IHRDlvYy2K
— Heavens! (@HeavensFX) October 21, 2023
You be the judge
THEY CALLED THIS AN INVALID FAIR CATCH??? OH NO IOWA pic.twitter.com/iImEwl6RPH
— Sickos Committee (@SickosCommittee) October 21, 2023
Revised final score
12-16*
— Cassidy O’Leary (@cassi134) October 21, 2023
Not on this planet or any other
In no universe is this a fair catch
— Nicholas Baer (@Nicholas_Baer) October 21, 2023
The worst
That might have been the worst call I’ve ever seen what in the heck
— Lucy Rohden (@lucy_rohden) October 21, 2023
The absolute worst
Thats the worst call in the history of sports.
— Dan (Taylor's Version) (@Dan_Welter) October 21, 2023
'Football guys' say the officials got it right
I asked 3 football guys I know about the Dejean call. “It was the right call but they never call it” is what I keep getting back. Tough stuff. Iconic individual effort out of 3.
— Chris Williams (@ChrisMWilliams) October 21, 2023
Nobody letting up
From this angle, Cooper DeJean's arm does not appear elevated above the helmet, and I don't see any Minnesota players letting up as if he called for a fair catch. https://t.co/rX6hvDQM4e
— Ryan M. Jaster (@Hawkologist) October 21, 2023
Sick
Absolutely sick to my stomach.
That is an awful game-changing call and Iowa, Kirk Ferentz, the players and the fans deserve to go full scorched Earth on anyone who tries to say otherwise.#Hawkeyes
— Cody Hills (@ByCodyHills) October 21, 2023
All-time awful
The referees can’t distinguish a fair catch from pointing to the football.
That’s all-time awful.
— David Eickholt (@DavidEickholt) October 21, 2023
What even is the definition?
Someone please give me definition of fair catch!
— Josey Jewell (@josey_jewell) October 21, 2023
Even Larry agrees
Man Iowa got totally screwed I will admit it
— Cyclone Larry (@CycloneLarry69) October 21, 2023
What color is the dress?
The DeJean play is clearly a "what color is the dress?" thing. It was designed to tear us all apart. I see a confusing quasi-fair catch. I understand how you see him telling people to get away from the ball
— Alex Kirshner (@alex_kirshner) October 21, 2023
Absolutely ridiculous
That is an absolutely ridiculous call in the Iowa game
No way that is calling for a fair catch— Big Game Bengal (@BengalYouTube) October 21, 2023
oh my god they said he called a fair catch
— Robby Kalland (@RKalland) October 21, 2023
Return the W
Minnesota should be too ashamed to accept that victory
— Patrick Daugherty (@RotoPat) October 21, 2023
Coop afterwards
Cooper DeJean said he did not call for a fair catch pic.twitter.com/7eOz360beN
— Blake Hornstein (@BlakeHornTV) October 21, 2023
Cooper DeJean: I’ve never called for a fair catch with my left hand.
“Personally, I was not calling for a fair catch.”
Adds that the officials never came over to him to explain.
— David Eickholt (@DavidEickholt) October 21, 2023
Scorched Kirk
Might have all-time press conference coming from Kirk Ferentz.
Here’s how it started…
If the Big Ten fines him for whatever he’s about to say, I’ll start a fundraising effort to match every dollar and send it to the Univ of Iowa Children’s Hospital, too. #Hawkeyes pic.twitter.com/RJoy61iWir
— Cody Hills (@ByCodyHills) October 22, 2023
Kirk Ferentz says that he’s never seen a worse call in his career.
Adds that they went from checking to see if Cooper DeJean was out of bounds and then they went to looking for a bunch of other things.
— David Eickholt (@DavidEickholt) October 22, 2023
Trent has spoken
NOT A FAIR CATCH pic.twitter.com/w39L3cY9m6
— Trent (@BarstoolTrent) October 21, 2023
Armed and dangerous
Cooper Dejean a 1st round Draft pick. Robbed at Kinnick Stadium pointing toward the ground. I guess again He was armed and dangerous with the Football ! Go Hawks #Higginized
— Roy Higgins III. (@higginized) October 21, 2023
Robbed
I need an explanation of that call. #Robbed
— Ed Hinkel (@EdHinkel) October 21, 2023
Just brutal
I feel so bad for Cooper. My heart hurts
— Sam (@sammmidd) October 21, 2023
And then there's this
Some might say Iowa lost the game because of that bad call on the punt return. But Iowa had 14 possessions in that game, and only once did they drive it across midfield. Their TD drive, they got the ball at the Minnesota 46. That's freaking pathetic.
— JMinKC (@jontificate) October 21, 2023
Two things can be true
Multiple things can be true:
Iowa didn't play well enough to put Minnesota away and their offense is historically bad.
Iowa won that game and it was taken away from them by a terrible call.
— Andrew Downs (@AndrewCDowns) October 21, 2023
Both of these can be true, too
Both things can be true:
Cooper did not call a fair catch.
Iowa’s offense is pathetic and infuriating
— Hawkeye Recruiting (@Iowa_Recruiting) October 21, 2023
The offense is more incompetent
Iowa had the game stolen from them by an incompetent call.
They also had 7 drives for 2 yards offensively. This offense is more incompetent than those crooked refs.
— Trent Condon (@trentcondon) October 21, 2023
And yet! J-Bo speaks
But it did! That’s how the game turned out to be. One official cost us the game
— Jordan Bohannon (@JordanBo_3) October 21, 2023
A nice reminder
Please do not give the referees a hard time, you don’t know how difficult the position they’re in is. Some of them have families to feed and money riding on the outcome.
— RedditCFB (@RedditCFB) October 22, 2023
Not now, Tom...
Did you know Iowa can still win the Big Ten West?
— Tom Fornelli (@TomFornelli) October 21, 2023
If you're into the interpretation thing
Iowa fans have to know they didn’t call DeJean for a “valid signal”
They called him for an invalid signal, which is completely up to their own interpretation of what constitutes an invalid signal https://t.co/nM0Jlv8MqF
— Slater (@SlaterKinnick_) October 21, 2023
Gross
The Pig is headed back to Minneapolis. 🐖@GopherFootball goes into Iowa City and beats Big Ten West leader Iowa. pic.twitter.com/ql6XL66ZX5
— Big Ten Football (@B1Gfootball) October 21, 2023
Contact/Follow us @HawkeyesWire on Twitter, and like our page on Facebook to follow ongoing coverage of Iowa news, notes, and opinions.
Follow Josh on Twitter: @JoshOnREF
We occasionally recommend interesting products and services. If you make a purchase by clicking one of the links, we may earn an affiliate fee. Hawkeyes Wire operates independently, though, and this doesn’t influence our coverage.