Big League Stew - MLB

As the 2000s draw to a close, I'm sure that we'll be seeing plenty of all-decade lists and I'm sure that many of them will appear here on The Stew.

But ever since Dewayne Wise(notes) came down with that spectacular grab in Mark Buehrle's(notes) perfect game last Thursday, I've been thinking about where it would rank on a list of recent defensive plays. Was it in the top 10 of the decade? Top five?  The best overall?

Yes, it's jumping the gun a bit, but for the past week, I've run the question by a decent amount of baseball fans and asked them their thoughts on the best defensive plays of the 'Aughts. What follows is a collection of the top 10 moments from my informed view with a majority of the plays combining both skill and historical impact.

(Don't be fooled, though. Some plays were just too awesome to not include just because they took place during a regular-season game.)

It was a tough job and some good candidates like Reed Johnson's(notes) diving grab in D.C. last season and Juan Uribe's(notes) leap into the stands at the end of the 2005 World Series and any of the four unassisted triple plays during the decade were left out. But at the end, these were the 10 plays that I remember most. If you're so inclined, feel free to make your own suggestions or rankings in the comment section below. (Maybe we can make another list.)  

Without further delay, here are my 10 most memorable defensive plays of the 2000s:

10. Willy Taveras leaps for Tony Clark's drive, 2007 NLCS Game 2

It came in the league championship series that no one outside of Colorado or Arizona watched, but Taveras' catch was worthy of a much larger audience. Our own Jeff Passan counted 125 steps in the five seconds it took for Taveras to run down Tony Clark's(notes) attempt at a double and it was the talk of Colorado's 3-2 victory the next day.

* * *

9. Rick Ankiel throws out two Rockies at third, May 2008

This list wouldn't be complete without some long-range bombs and Rick Ankiel(notes) provided not one, but two memorable throws to Troy Glaus(notes) (above) against Colorado last season. Neither putout at third ever bounced and both were Internet sensations by the next morning. 

* * * 

8. Aaron Rowand breaks nose running into outfield wall, May 2006

Aaron Rowand(notes) had already become a cult hero in Chicago for his fearlessness in the outfield and it didn't take long to ingratiate himself to Phillies fans after being traded for Jim Thome(notes). After successfully capturing a long fly ball from the Mets' Xavier Nady(notes), Rowand had no time to slow down and performed a face plant for the ages, breaking his schnozz in the process. 

* * *

7. Jeff Conine nails J.T. Snow at home with help of Pudge, 2003 NLDS Game 4

This might be a bigger moment if it involved any team but Florida, yet you can't help but admire the throw from left field by Jeff Conine(notes) (aka "Mr. Marlin). The assist, caught by a rock solid Ivan Rodriguez(notes), stopped J.T. Snow(notes) from scoring, gave the Marlins a 7-6 victory and ended the Giants' hopes of returning to the World Series. It was the only time in postseason history that a series ended with a putout at the plate. 

* * *

6. Jim Edmonds robs Brad Ausmus, 2004 NLCS Game 7

Because this came early in the game and because Edmonds made a career of similar amazing catches, I'm probably not ranking this high as it deserves to be. Still, Edmonds' second-inning dive kept the Astros' lead at a manageable one run and eventually paved the way for a 5-2 Cardinals win (allowing the team to be swept by Boston in the World Series, but I suppose that's really beside the point). 

* * *

5. Torii Hunter breaks up Barry Bonds' moment, 2002 All-Star Game

Several current All-Stars just named Torii Hunter's(notes) theft of a would-be Barry Bonds(notes) home run as their favorite All-Star moment, but don't forget that it had plenty of historical implications despite occurring during an exhibition. If Hunter fails to make this catch in the first inning at Miller Park, it's quite possible that the game doesn't end in a tie and the Midsummer Classic remains a fun midseason exhibition instead of a World Series homefield advantage decider.

* * * 

4. Gary Matthews Jr. steals one from Mike Lamb, July 2006

Matthews' catch didn't record any universal significance outside of a game played between the Astros and Rangers, but it was probably the most difficult feat to pull off. Show this one to an audience 30 years from now and it'll still earn 10s across the board.  

* * *

3. Endy Chavez foils Scott Rolen at wall, 2006 NLCS Game 7

It's been almost three years and I still can't believe Endy Chavez(notes) brought back that home run from Scott Rolen(notes) to double Jim Edmonds(notes) off first base in the sixth inning of Game 7. The play's ranking is hurt somewhat by the game's final result — a Cardinals victory and World Series berth — but my appreciation for Chavez's unreal leap remains undamaged. 

* * *

2. Dewayne Wise preserves Mark Buehrle's perfect game, July 2009

It's only been five days and I still can't believe Dewayne Wise came back with Gabe Kapler's(notes) drive to keep Mark Buehrle's perfect game intact. Wise's catch was the right combination of athletic feat and impact to rank near the front of this list. If he doesn't make it, you're probably not reading this list right now. 

* * *

1. Derek Jeter flips ball to nab Jeremy Giambi at the plate, 2001 ALDS

A lot of the proverbial "haters" will point to this seventh-inning play as an example of simple overhype because it happened to a player on a New York team, but it's impossible to deny its total impact. Not only did it seal Jeter's reputation as a Yankee legend, it also helped preserve the Yankees' final 1-0 margin in a game in which the Bombers faced elimination.

If Jeter doesn't make this play, it's quite possible that the 2001 World Series — not only the best of this decade, but one of the best ever — never comes to be. 

digg delicious
more

44 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. Pluschy
    1. Posted by Pluschy Tue Jul 28, 2009 6:43 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    perfect choice for No. 1.
    What about Jeters dive into stands vs Boston?
  2. joser
    2. Posted by joser Tue Jul 28, 2009 6:46 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Good Number 1!!!
  3. First L
    3. Posted by First L Tue Jul 28, 2009 6:48 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Meh, i think Wise's catch should have been number one, though the Jeter flip would have been a close second.
    Perfect games dont come around too often.
  4. Gary
    4. Posted by Gary Tue Jul 28, 2009 6:49 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I think you missed Reed Johnson's catch last year against the Nationals: http://mlb.mlb.com/media/video.jsp?mid=200804252587970&c_id=chc
  5. turtle8142000
    5. Posted by turtle8142000 Tue Jul 28, 2009 6:52 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    No, the "haters" will point to the fact that the Jeter play does not fall under the same degree of difficulty as a lot of the other plays displayed here. If you're going to talk about it being amazing because it came during a high pressure situation, then you're definitely short-changing the catch made by Wise.
    The play itself is over-hyped not because he's a Yankee, but because he was an MLB poster boy. The simple reality is that the play has a lot more luck, and stupidity (sliding isn't fundamental or anything) than skill.
  6. Duk
    6. Posted by 'Duk Tue Jul 28, 2009 6:58 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Neither do Yankees World Series appearances!
    (rim shot!)
  7. Charles
    7. Posted by Charles Tue Jul 28, 2009 6:59 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Where are the two home run catches by Curtis Granderson? One against Wily Mo-Pena in 2007 and the other this year against Grady Sizemore.
  8. Kyle Thoby
    8. Posted by Kyle Thoby Tue Jul 28, 2009 7:00 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    jeters "dive into the stands" is nothing more then jeter having bad breaks. the ball was caught a full 5 steps before the stands. he fell in for dramatic effect and you all fell for it. jeter is so overrated its not even funny. saying jeter is an all time great is like saying bernie williams is a fall of famer. anyone who knows anything about baseball knows better, but you will get a heavy arguement out of most yankee fans
  9. Bronn
    9. Posted by Bronn Tue Jul 28, 2009 7:01 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Okay, I'll start the hate:
    If you switch the jerseys and put Jeter on the White Sox and Wise on the Yankees, Wise's play is the best in the past 20 years and Jeter's may not even make this list.
  10. Anrkist
    10. Posted by Anrkist Tue Jul 28, 2009 7:07 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Bartman didn't make the list?
  11. Jordan F
    11. Posted by Jordan F Tue Jul 28, 2009 7:07 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Thanks 'duk, I just watched #3 again and it depressed the hell out of me.
    Why is mlb.com's footage so screwed up I can't a bunch of these videos - specifically the Jeff Conine/J.T. Snow/Pudge Rodriguez play...
  12. NY SUX
    12. Posted by NY SUX Tue Jul 28, 2009 7:13 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Good one # 9 !
  13. Jimbo
    13. Posted by Jimbo Tue Jul 28, 2009 7:22 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    the david wright bear handed catch needs to be on the list
  14. Bronn
    14. Posted by Bronn Tue Jul 28, 2009 7:22 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Gary Matthews robbed a home run 2 years ago which is maybe the single best catch I've ever seen. It wasn't a playoff situation or anything like that, but it was a ball that was WAYYYY over the fence and he skied and grabbed it at full extension. And it doesn't make this list?
  15. Chains
    15. Posted by Chains Tue Jul 28, 2009 7:29 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    What about Mauer's awesome dive after a fake throw to first to tag a sliding Brett Gardner on May 17? Or, that crazy behind the back flip at first base in the in that Mets/Dodgers game. I know both are from this year, but I think they're still of some of these.
  16. Bronn
    16. Posted by Bronn Tue Jul 28, 2009 7:29 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I remember that #13, also a great play.
  17. ChrisG
    17. Posted by ChrisG Tue Jul 28, 2009 8:16 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Best play of the decade was Manny going back, leaping off wall, giving fan a high five than throwing ball back in. None of these is even close!!!!
  18. ChrisG
    18. Posted by ChrisG Tue Jul 28, 2009 8:18 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Manny's "Hi Five" catch: Play of the decade
  19. Ray Michael
    19. Posted by Ray Michael Tue Jul 28, 2009 8:24 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    #10, Steve Bartman didn't catch the ball. He wasn't the only one going for it.
    But keep obsessing over him. Cub fans got over him a long time ago.
  20. C. Trent Rosecrans
    20. Posted by C. Trent Rosecrans Tue Jul 28, 2009 8:41 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    bronn, you mean like no. 4?
    the jeter dive into the stands wasn't even the best catch of that game
    and giambi was safe
  21. Einstein
    21. Posted by Einstein Tue Jul 28, 2009 8:55 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Ever noticed something? Of the ten plays here, EVERY SINGLE ONE OF THEM involved an outfielder. Out of the 10, 7 were diving/HR-robbing catches. 2 were outfielders throwing out runners. And the #1, is Derek Jeter redirecting an outfielder's throw. Other than Jeter, no love for infielders? Why?
  22. blues_fan_mk
    22. Posted by blues_fan_mk Tue Jul 28, 2009 9:22 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    A fluky play botched by both teams shouldn't be on the list, let alone #1
  23. gaborik10m
    23. Posted by gaborik10m Tue Jul 28, 2009 9:48 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    No.1 Choice = FAIL
  24. Joshua F
    24. Posted by Joshua F Tue Jul 28, 2009 9:59 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I don't think there can be a top ten.... everyone always argues and whines about a catch not being on the list. it should be like the top 50 or 100. I know it would take forever but you would please all the fans and would be cool to see. Oh, and if someone ever does it dont rank them because that brings out even more controversy amongst everyone. Although I do like seeing peoples opinions about this and that. Personally I like the top ten even though i know there could be a ton more catches added to the list
  25. Jason
    25. Posted by Jason Tue Jul 28, 2009 10:06 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    How about that diving catch Coco Crisp made a few years back? I can't seem to find a video, but I do recall it being a nationally televised game.

Big League Stew

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

'Duk

Big League Stew is an MLB blog edited by Kevin Kaduk. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Big League Stew Recent Readers