Big League Stew - MLB

As the decade winds down to its final moments, Big League Stew is reflecting on the biggest baseball moments of the 2000s. Next up are the top playoff and record-breaking home runs from 2000-09, an up-for-debate list we created by taking each blast's history, impact and moment into account. Please note that we'll be doing a separate list of big regular season home runs — think Mike Piazza and Glenallen Hill — in December.  

1. Barry Bonds(notes) hits No. 756, passing Hank Aaron for all-time lead — Aug. 7, 2007

When Bonds launched a pitch from Washington's Mike Bacsik(notes) deep into the San Francisco night, he did more than just start a lottery ticket free-for-all in the bleachers of AT&T Park. The home run ended Hank Aaron's 12,173-day run atop the career homers list and provided the climactic moment in a saga that spanned several years and introduced the world to BALCO, Greg Anderson, Victor Conte, the cream and the clear.

Though many still want to attach an asterisk to his final total of 762 or recognize Hammerin' Hank as the rightful record holder, there's no doubt that Bonds' homer made the biggest impact upon baseball since 2000. Not only did it break arguably the sport's greatest mark, it made baseball fans explore weighty topics like ego, greed, race, truth, loyalty, nostalgia and idolatry. You may not agree with this selection, but even Time has to tab the controversial for Man of the Year when it's unpopular, yet still completely warranted.

* * *

2. Boone's homer crushes Red Sox, sends Yankees to World Series Oct. 16, 2003

It seemed like the Yankees' reign — and the Red Sox's misfortune — would never end when a little third baseman led off the bottom of the 11th inning of Game 7 with a home run off Tim Wakefield(notes). The homer clinched the sixth Yankee pennant in eight years and gut-punched the hopes of New England, which was dreaming of a World Series bid only three innings earlier with Pedro Martinez(notes) on the mound. There's no disputing this place as it was the only Game 7 walkoff of the decade, but in a weird twist it would prove to be the Yankees' final big highlight until the 2009 championship was clinched. Boone hurt himself in a pickup basketball during the ensuing offseason and was replaced by a fella named Alex Rodriguez(notes); Boston would win two titles before New York won another.

* * *

3. Albert Pujols(notes) hits moon shot off Brad Lidge(notes) in 2005 NLCS — Oct. 17, 2005 

If you hadn't watched this one live, it'd be hard to believe that a three-run home run in Game 5 of the '05 NLCS could be ranked this high, especially when the Cardinals were eliminated in Game 6. But those who bore witness to Pujols' home run will still be talking about it 50 years from now. The hit was equal parts majesty (hit near the train tracks atop Minute Maid Park) and devastation (Astros fans were one strike away from getting to celebrate the franchise's first World Series berth at home) and it still causes most fans to curse in amazement upon seeing the replay. The ball traveled so high and far that even the Astros made a joke to Lidge that they could see it outside their plane windows on the flight after the game. Quite simply a Hall of Fame moment for a Hall of Fame player. 

* * *

4. Scott Podsednik(notes) walks off the White Sox in Game 2 — Oct. 23, 2005  

Paul Konerko(notes) made a lot of Chicago memories with a grand slam against the Astros earlier in the game and Geoff Blum(notes) made himself the answer to a trivia question with a 14th-inning homer a couple of days later. Still, the Sports Illustrated cover went to Scott Podsednik for his unlikely walkoff off Lidge — talk about your horrible weeks — in the bottom of the ninth inning. Pods did not hit a home run during the regular season — he hit one in the ALDS against Boston —but his fly to right field put the White Sox in the driver's seat for their first World Series title since World War I. 

* * *

5. Barry Bonds sets single-season record with 73rd home run — Oct. 7, 2001

A number of factors contributed to the apathy that America aimed toward Bonds' march to the single season home run mark in 2001. The summer of Big Mac and Sammy had occurred only three years earlier, Bonds was not an embraceable superstar and a large amount of his home runs were being hit when half of America was already asleep. The tragic events of 9/11 then pushed the chase to an understandable trivial spot and Bonds' final home run received such a relatively small amount of attention that one wonders if the Dodgers' Dennis Springer even remembers where he was when No. 73 was hit.*

There's an argument to be made that Bonds' season — which occurred as more fans were becoming wiser to PED use — ended baseball's "chicks dig the long ball" phase. Even still, this home run rewrote a line in the history book and set the bar that all future home run hitters will take a run at. *Springer was on the mound at AT&T Park 

* * *

6. Derek Jeter(notes) becomes Mr. November in 2001 World Series — Nov. 1, 2001

Game 4 of the 2001 World Series started on Halloween night, but the calendar had already turned to November when Derek Jeter provided one of the defining moments in his career. With Byung-Hyun Kim(notes) well past his expiration date on the mound, Jeter pushed the Arizona reliever's 61st pitch of the night over the short right-field porch in old Yankee Stadium. The home run touched off a huge celebration in the Bronx, crushed Kim in the first of two straight games and evened the best World Series of the decade at two games apiece.

* * *

7. David Ortiz(notes) keeps Red Sox alive in 2004 ALCS  — Oct. 17, 2004

David Ortiz hitting a game winning two-run homer off Paul Quantrill in the bottom of the 12th inning seemed like a "well at least the Red Sox won one" type of moment when it happened in Game 4 of that soon-to-be-legendary 2004 ALCS against the Yankees.

Of course, it turned out to be the equivalent of the movie monster opening his eye.

Well, no. The foreboding eye opening was probably caused by Dave Roberts(notes) stealing second while Big Papi's home run was more like Boston turning into Hulk Hogan and resisting the last slap to the face before launching into the routine leading to the big boot and leg drop

* * *

8. Magglio Ordonez(notes) seals ALCS sweep, sends Tigers to World Series — Oct. 14, 2006

Not every memorable postseason home run has to happen in the bottom of the ninth in the seventh game of the World Series. A good example would be Magglio Ordonez's mammoth three-run homer off a "pretty nasty Huston Street pitch." The blast completed an ALCS sweep of Oakland and sent hometown Detroit fans to their first Fall Classic since 1984.   

* * *

9. Alex Gonzalez wins Game 4 with 12th-inning leadoff — Oct. 22, 2003

Here's the toughest debate we had on the list: Because he played for the Marlins, no one seems to remember Alex Gonzalez roping a Jeff Weaver(notes) pitch over the left field wall at Pro Player Stadium for a 12th inning win over the Yankees in Game 4. But Gonzalez's homer is only one of 14 walkoffs in World Series history, so how are we going to include Jeter's and Podsednik's but exclude the one from A-Gone? The Marlins would go on to win the next two games to win the franchise's second World Series and if the teams (and shortstops) were reversed, you can bet people would insist this home run to be ranked much, much higher. 

* * * 

10. Chris Burke(notes) ends longest game in postseason history with walkoff — Oct. 9, 2005

It was the game that wouldn't end. The Astros and Braves battled for 17 1/2 innings with Atlanta putting off elimination as long as possible and Roger Clemens(notes) coming out of the bullpen to pitch three innings of relief. Then, with one out in the bottom of the 18th inning, Chris Burke roped a pitch from Joey Devine(notes) into the left field Crawford Boxes at Minute Maid Park. The homer sent Houston to its second straight NLCS and, eventually, the first World Series in franchise history. The Braves, meanwhile, haven't been back to the playoffs. 

* * *

Just missed: Yadier Molina(notes) helps the Cards in 2006 NLCS Game 7, Matt Stairs(notes) downs Dodgers in 2008 NLCS Game 4, BIG homers from Mark Teixeira(notes), Hideki Matsui(notes) and A-Rod in 2009 World Series, Chase Utley(notes) ties Reggie Jackson's mark in '09, A-Rod becomes fastest player to 500th, Griffey passes 600, Scott Brosius victimizes Kim in '01 World Series Game 5, Jim Thome(notes) hits a monster shot in 2008 AL Central tiebreaker, Big Papi resurrects Red Sox against Rays in '08 ALCS and sweeps the Angels with walkoff in '04, Shane Victorino's(notes) grand slam off CC in '08 NLDS, Manny Ramirez's(notes) walkoff against Angels in 2007 ALDS, Jeff Kent(notes) and Jim Edmonds(notes) hit walkoffs in back-to-back games in 2004 NLCS, Alfonso Soriano(notes) hits walkoff against Seattle in 2001 ALCS

Like we said, we'll be doing a regular season home run post, but what big homers do you remember from the 2000s?

digg delicious
more

208 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. DICK SMOTHERS
    1. Posted by DICK SMOTHERS Wed Nov 25, 2009 2:12 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    ....and they still won'tlet him play.
  2. DICK SMOTHERS
    2. Posted by DICK SMOTHERS Wed Nov 25, 2009 2:13 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    ....and they still won'tlet him play.
  3. DICK SMOTHERS
    3. Posted by DICK SMOTHERS Wed Nov 25, 2009 2:15 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    ....and they still won't let him play.
    yeah, i said it.
    not once, not twice....but thrice.
  4. j_n_16
    4. Posted by j_n_16 Wed Nov 25, 2009 2:18 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    What was really amazing about the Pujols homer is that if you listened closely enough, you could hear Brad Lidge's confidence shattering.
  5. Charles
    5. Posted by Charles Wed Nov 25, 2009 2:18 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Barry Bonds didn't pass Hank Aaron's record, he cheated. Aaron is still the Home run Champ.
  6. sam spade
    6. Posted by sam spade Wed Nov 25, 2009 2:24 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Agreed!!! And they still........
  7. sam spade
    7. Posted by sam spade Wed Nov 25, 2009 2:52 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    How about a reverse asterisks? Hank Aaron had at least 25 HR's as a designated hitter with the then American league's Milwaukee Brewers. with Barry being banned while others are playing, it has to be said that he would have at least 25 more if not 50 more by now. His intentional walk totals per his HR per at bat could yield more HR. It's 8 years later and last count it was 69 million of your tax payer dollars. They should put a whole shire up to him at the HOF. those who say it's tainted can have their section and those who say that he's been a victim of a government witch hunt, should be able to present our perspective that he should have 50 to 70 more. When they don't convict him of anything and maybe the dirty cop, IRS Special Agent Jefff Novitsky goes to jail or his illegal tactics are revealed(See today's story on the 9th Circuit court of Appeals hearing), it won't change opinions but this historical event should be preserved forever so everyone for all time will know what has happened to Barry Bonds at the hands of the government and the media. I'm betting it will be way over 100 million when it's done. The only way to do justice to his career and this unprecendented story is his own wing. What has made sports stars the greatest of all time is not their performance on the field but some type of off field battle with the government. It ain't 762 that has made him bigger than baseball, it's the time, effort and money spent to get him that makes him a historical figure to be studied forever.
  8. Allen
    8. Posted by Allen Wed Nov 25, 2009 2:52 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Brad Lidge still hasn't recovered from that homer.
    And weren't the Cubs in the World Series in 2003?
    Oh Bartman, I forgot. Sorry.
  9. BrianD
    9. Posted by BrianD Wed Nov 25, 2009 3:29 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Paul Konerko's grand slam in Game 2. I was at the game, it was complete pandemonium there. Never heard it as loud before, and with the exception of Pods' walkoff two innings later, since.
  10. Ryan
    10. Posted by Ryan Wed Nov 25, 2009 3:37 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    I though Aaron's home run in '03 or Jeter's walk-off in '01 would definitely be on this list, and I was right. Too bad that ****stain Barry Bonds is on this list twice, though....
  11. AgentUtah
    11. Posted by AgentUtah Wed Nov 25, 2009 3:43 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Brad Lidge did manage to go 41-for-41 in saves and help his team win a World Series, so I guess he got over it. Granted, he did stink this year. "He's still our closer!"
  12. AnGeL~FaN
    12. Posted by AnGeL~FaN Wed Nov 25, 2009 3:51 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    How about Speizio hitting the game tying homer for the 2002 angels?
  13. Allen
    13. Posted by Allen Wed Nov 25, 2009 3:53 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Number 5, Number 5, Number 5, Number 5, Number 5, Number 5, Number 5, Number 5, Number 5, Number 5, Number 5, Number 5, Number 5, Number 5, Number 5.
    And isn't it interesting.
    Brad's saves equaled 41 out of 41.
    4 plus 1 is 5.
    And again, 4 plus 1 is 5.
    Then added together you get 10 and divide that by 2 (2 41s) and it's 5.
    Oh oh!!!!!!
    Poor Brad.
    Number 5, Number 5, Number 5, Number 5, Number 5, Number 5, Number 5, Number 5, Number 5, Number 5, Number 5, Number 5, Number 5, Number 5, Number 5.
  14. Allen
    14. Posted by Allen Wed Nov 25, 2009 3:55 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    And it happened in game 5 of 05.
    OH NO!!!!!
    It was just in the Cards!!!
  15. Junta Kinte
    15. Posted by Junta Kinte Wed Nov 25, 2009 4:14 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Nothing for Ichiro's inside the park homerun in the All Star Game?
  16. Ray
    16. Posted by Ray Wed Nov 25, 2009 4:26 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    How can you guys call Barry Bonds 756 and 73 home runs great accomplishments without any mention of his obvious steroid use. Come on guys! The other accomplishments are awesome. Don't taint baseball any further with these abusers. Fine, its not easy to hit a baseball. But we all know that Barry Bonds would have never got there without the "juice". He was barely a 30 plus, let alone 40 homer-a-season kind of player.
  17. dfreshhookup
    17. Posted by dfreshhookup Wed Nov 25, 2009 4:56 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Not having Mike Piazza's first game in New York post-9/11 homerun on this list is a disgrace.
  18. rootbeersoup
    18. Posted by rootbeersoup Wed Nov 25, 2009 6:35 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    "He was barely a 30 plus, let alone 40 homer-a-season kind of player."
    Neither was Hank Aaron, really. It's about longevity.
  19. The Unsilent Majority
    19. Posted by The Unsilent Majority Wed Nov 25, 2009 6:38 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Two tributes to Mr. Steroids in one blog...well done.
  20. sam spade
    20. Posted by sam spade Wed Nov 25, 2009 6:43 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    remember you saw him play. Please remember the spectacle that 756 was. How did he do it? there was an all out blitz by the media and the government to force him to quit before the record. Fans issuing death threats. everything imaginable. Most people would have quit. Especially; after he had knee surgery. We'll never witness such an event again. We'll never see someone that good again. Whether a hater or a fan, you have to admit that no one could have broken the record but him. when his record is broken, it won't be with such hatred in the air. A-Rod will quietly break the record. Since he's already admitted it, there will be no record to protect. It will be ho-hum. so please remember, whatever side you're on, you'll never see a baseball moment like 756. when A-Rod has the record the only question will be how many would Barry have hit if he were allowed to continue his career. 812 should be where he's at now. Oh yeah! I forgot one thing, the pitcher was suspended in the minors for steroid use. I am right about that one.
  21. sam spade
    21. Posted by sam spade Wed Nov 25, 2009 7:02 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    without the 2001 HR, 73, we wouldn't even have the media dubbed steroid era. everyone was happy with the summer of Sammy and Big Mac. the investigation started then 2002. No 73, then we'd still have single season Mark McGwire 70. Hank Aaron but he was largely ignored in favor of Ruth until Barry's chase of his record. If it was someone other than the hated Bonds or if hadn't been broken at all. No investigation of any kind and no"steroid era".
  22. Johnny Appleseed
    22. Posted by Johnny Appleseed Wed Nov 25, 2009 8:46 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Really? Jeter's "Mr. October" shot (which came in a losing series) over Ortiz's ALCS Game 4 "Don't let us win tonight" (quote courtesy of Kevin Millar) blast? Not even an honorable mention to Ichiro's inside the parker? How about Johnny Damon's series-sealing 04 ALCS Game 7 Grand Slam getting a little love? After that HR, the Yankees and Red Sox were delaying the inevitable.
  23. Johnny Appleseed
    23. Posted by Johnny Appleseed Wed Nov 25, 2009 8:48 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    October, November... whatever. You get the point.
  24. Anrkist
    24. Posted by Anrkist Wed Nov 25, 2009 9:33 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Whatever happened to that Chris Burke guy.
  25. Bob the Viking
    25. Posted by Bob the Viking Thu Nov 26, 2009 3:23 am EST

    Report Abuse

    *

Big League Stew

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

'Duk

Big League Stew is an MLB blog edited by Kevin Kaduk. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Contributors:
David Brown, Alex Remington,

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Big League Stew Recent Readers