May Starter Rankings
Here is the May edition of my rest-of-season position rankings and overall top 300 for 5x5 leagues. I’m using five-game eligibility, so plenty of players have added new positions since Opening Day. Because I love you, I’ve also tweaked the top 300 to include previous rankings this year.
Listen to the Rotoworld Baseball Show for the latest player news, waiver claims, roster advice and more from our experts all season long. Click here or download it wherever you get your podcasts.
Click to see other May ROS rankings:
Top 300 | SP | RP | OF | 1B | 2B | SS | 3B | C
ROS Starting pitcher Rankings
May | Starting pitchers | Team | April |
1 | 2 | ||
2 | 3 | ||
3 | Phillies | 5 | |
4 | 4 | ||
5 | 7 | ||
6 | Mariners | 6 | |
7 | Dodgers | 10 | |
8 | Twins | 8 | |
9 | Twins | 14 | |
10 | 11 | ||
11 | Max Fried | Braves | 12 |
12 | Mariners | 21 | |
13 | Brewers | 26 | |
14 | Dylan Cease | Padres | 22 |
15 | Royals | 23 | |
16 | Cubs | 37 | |
17 | Giants | 17 | |
18 | Zac Gallen | 18 | |
19 | Astros | 13 | |
20 | Phillies | 15 | |
21 | Guardians | 16 | |
22 | Astros | 30 | |
23 | Zach Eflin | 25 | |
24 | Twins | 24 | |
25 | Braves | 34 | |
26 | Reds | 32 | |
27 | Cardinals | 58 | |
28 | Yankees | 31 | |
29 | Cubs | 28 | |
30 | Dodgers | 36 | |
31 | Mariners | 39 | |
32 | Dodgers | 9 | |
33 | Orioles | 42 | |
34 | Reds | 54 | |
35 | Orioles | 20 | |
36 | Angels | 61 | |
37 | Rays | 55 | |
38 | 48 | ||
39 | Blake Snell | Giants | 40 |
40 | Padres | 35 | |
41 | Mets | 45 | |
42 | Pirates | 136 | |
43 | Yankees | 43 | |
44 | Blue Jays | 41 | |
45 | Padres | 27 | |
46 | Blue Jays | 49 | |
47 | Rays | 46 | |
48 | Tigers | 96 | |
49 | Mets | 60 | |
50 | Pirates | 33 | |
51 | Diamondbacks | 50 | |
52 | Marlins | 19 | |
53 | Rangers | 73 | |
54 | Phillies | 81 | |
55 | Yu Darvish | Padres | 38 |
56 | Yankees | 62 | |
57 | MacKenzie Gore | Nationals | 97 |
58 | Cristopher Sanchez | Phillies | 59 |
59 | 103 | ||
60 | Blue Jays | 76 | |
61 | Paul Skenes | Pirates | 132 |
62 | Astros | 69 | |
63 | Sean Manaea | Mets | 53 |
64 | Marlins | 115 | |
65 | Diamondbacks | 63 | |
66 | Rays | 92 | |
67 | Orioles | 52 | |
68 | Shane Baz | Rays | 65 |
69 | Erick Fedde | 158 | |
70 | Ronel Blanco | Astros | 139 |
71 | Marlins | 66 | |
72 | Braves | 75 | |
73 | Red Sox | 87 | |
74 | Yankees | 67 | |
75 | Rays | 90 | |
76 | Bryan Woo | Mariners | 83 |
77 | Braves | 70 | |
78 | Kenta Maeda | Tigers | 68 |
79 | Yankees | 95 | |
80 | Jose Soriano | Angels | 60 RP |
81 | Keaton Winn | Giants | 150 |
82 | Reese Olson | Tigers | 84 |
83 | Dodgers | 74 | |
84 | Royals | 119 | |
85 | Alex Cobb | Giants | 78 |
86 | Reds | 79 | |
87 | Astros | 44 | |
88 | Rangers | 86 | |
89 | White Sox | 189 | |
90 | Diamondbacks | 85 | |
91 | Giants | 116 | |
92 | Diamondbacks | 57 | |
93 | Red Sox | 82 | |
94 | Guardians | 72 | |
95 | Yankees | 133 | |
96 | Javier Assad | Cubs | 143 |
97 | Jon Gray | Rangers | 98 |
98 | Casey Mize | Tigers | 111 |
99 | Orioles | 80 | |
100 | Guardians | 88 | |
101 | Cubs | 107 | |
102 | Red Sox | 121 | |
103 | Guardians | 51 | |
104 | Giants | 104 | |
105 | Lance Lynn | Cardinals | 89 |
106 | Dodgers | 100 | |
107 | Jose Butto | Mets | 157 |
108 | Cubs | 147 | |
109 | Ben Brown | Cubs | 180 |
110 | Orioles | 56 | |
111 | Red Sox | 93 | |
112 | Christian Scott | Mets | 176 |
113 | Rangers | 126 | |
114 | Matt Manning | Tigers | 101 |
115 | Angels | 77 | |
116 | Athletics | 105 | |
117 | Twins | 71 | |
118 | Cody Bradford | Rangers | 91 |
119 | Seth Lugo | Royals | 125 |
120 | DL Hall | Brewers | 94 |
121 | Trevor Rogers | Marlins | 161 |
122 | AJ Smith-Shawver | Braves | 110 |
123 | Reds | 109 | |
124 | Orioles | NR | |
125 | Mariners | 212 | |
126 | Twins | 391 | |
127 | Dodgers | 131 | |
128 | Cubs | 137 | |
129 | Brewers | 112 | |
130 | Marlins | 162 | |
131 | Marlins | 129 | |
132 | Angels | 135 | |
133 | Orioles | 113 | |
134 | Dodgers | 124 | |
135 | Rays | 142 | |
136 | Bryce Elder | Braves | 165 |
137 | Angels | 108 | |
138 | Reds | 114 | |
139 | Guardians | 221 | |
140 | Reds | 128 | |
141 | Brewers | 146 | |
142 | Royals | 153 | |
143 | Phillies | 200 | |
144 | Landon Knack | Dodgers | 261 |
145 | White Sox | 138 | |
146 | Pirates | 313 | |
147 | Mets | 154 | |
148 | 122 | ||
149 | Brewers | 167 | |
150 | Athletics | 174 | |
151 | Cardinals | 134 | |
152 | Emmet Sheehan | Dodgers | 102 |
153 | Jake Irvin | Nationals | 214 |
154 | Cade Horton | Cubs | 223 |
155 | Louie Varland | Twins | 99 |
156 | Rangers | 118 | |
157 | JP Sears | Athletics | 127 |
158 | Spencer Arrighetti | Astros | 233 |
159 | Rays | 163 | |
160 | Steven Matz | Cardinals | 120 |
161 | Jack Leiter | Rangers | 324 |
162 | Slade Cecconi | Diamondbacks | 241 |
163 | Joe Boyle | Athletics | 140 |
164 | Cubs | 117 | |
165 | Jose Urquidy | Astros | 106 |
166 | Pirates | 173 | |
167 | Yariel Rodriguez | Blue Jays | 169 |
168 | Mets | 171 | |
169 | Cade Povich | Orioles | 276 |
170 | Diamondbacks | 182 | |
171 | Yankees | 194 | |
172 | Pirates | 123 | |
173 | Angels | 181 | |
174 | Cardinals | 149 | |
175 | Ricky Tiedemann | Blue Jays | 130 |
Dropping off: Spencer Strider (No. 1), Shane Bieber (No. 29), Eury Pérez (No. 47), Bowden Francis (No. 141), Sawyer Gipson-Long (No. 144), Michael Soroka (No. 145), Zack Thompson (No. 148)
I’m still pretty low on the Red Sox pitchers. Yeah, Andrew Bailey is obviously a great pitching coach, but that’s just such a tough ballpark and defensive situation. The Red Sox have also thus far been in a pretty easy portion of what is quite likely the league’s most difficult schedule. Tanner Houck has definitely taken a big step forward and Kutter Crawford was already quite good, but I still think it’s going to be pretty difficult for them to remain difference makers in mixed leagues.
Paul Skenes has gotten up over 70 pitches in his last two Triple-A starts and made it through six scoreless innings on Tuesday. It doesn’t sound like he’s made his final start for Indianapolis, but the move to Pittsburgh can’t be far away.
In spite of his delayed debut, John Means was one of my favorite end-game picks this spring, and I should be excited now that he’s rejoining the Orioles rotation this weekend. However, his velocity still isn’t all of the way back after Tommy John. Maybe he’ll get stronger with time, but I’m not as optimistic about him as I was. At least he is in the great situation in Baltimore, especially since he’s a flyball left-hander pitching in Camden Yards half of the time.
Jordan Wicks is someone I was planning on moving way up before he went on the IL with a forearm strain. That’s typically a very scary diagnosis, but it sounds like it might be a pretty minor one. If so, he seems like a mixed-league guy to me. His velocity is up a bit, and he had a 28/9 K/BB ratio in 23 innings before going down.
