Buzzing on Yahoo Sports:

Dr. Saturday

12 for ’12: Mizzou, A&M are the same fish in a new pond

Matt Hinton
Dr. Saturday

Early narratives for the coming year.

View gallery


Thesis. After 16 years as respectable, middle-class members of the Big 12, Missouri and Texas A&M;s defection to the SEC will prove to be a lateral move.

Point. Given some of the projections of doom for the Tigers and Aggies in their new league, you'd think they'd given up a chance to burn path of destruction through the old one. In fact, they're just trading one second-tier niche for another.

Mizzou hasn't won a conference championship since 1969, in the old Big Eight; A&M hasn't won a claimed a conference crown since 1998, its last appearance in the Big 12 Championship Game. That was also the year Mack Brown was hired to resurrect Texas, just ahead of Bob Stoops' arrival at fast-fading Oklahoma in 1999. With the traditional regional powers restored to their traditional glory, A&M spent the last decade playing second banana not only to the Longhorns and Sooners, but also to traditional also-ran Texas Tech, which beat the Aggies seven times out of eight from 2001-08. Before the abrupt midseason turnaround in 2010, the Aggies had gone a full decade since their last top-25 finish in the final polls. It hasn't finished in the top 10 since 1994, in the dying days of the old Southwest Conference. When Missouri landed at No. 4 in 2007, it was its first top-10 finish in almost 40 years, and hasn't been replicated.

After decades of going head-to-head with the likes of Nebraska, Oklahoma and Texas — not to mention short-lived runs into the national elite by conference rivals Colorado, Houston, Kansas State, SMU and now Oklahoma State over the years — neither program is going to see anything in the SEC it hasn't encountered on an annual basis in terms of quality opposition; they're just trading one set of heavy hitters for another. Still, A&M and Mizzou have both have remained competitive and consistent enough to ensure a steady diet of bowl games, with nearly identical records over the last decade as their new second-tier peers in the SEC, Arkansas, Ole Miss and South Carolina, none of which has won the conference since its last expansion in 1992, either.

View gallery

Counterpoint. In terms of wins and losses and subsequent spoils, expansion is a zero-sum game: The SEC has added two teams, but hasn't added any more bowl tie-ins or a semifinal round to qualify for the SEC Championship Game or something. As competitive as those spots already are, just being able to (more or less) hold your own in the scrum after devouring a cake-y non-conference schedule in September isn't going to go as far as it used to. Within the middle class, there may be virtually no difference between the fifth and sixth-place teams in the final standings and the ninth and tenth-place teams, but there will be a great divide between postseason opportunities and the fates of certain coaches whose records fall on the wrong side of the coin.

If that happens to be the new kids on the block in their first year or two — and brutal schedules are awaiting both of them, especially Texas A&M in the West Division — it may be a while before the SEC Superiority Complex deigns to acknowledge them as equals. The last time the league expanded, grudging equality only took Arkansas and South Carolina about a decade.

Noise. Financially, A&M and Missouri are certainly going to be better off than they've ever been in the Big 12: Last year, the SEC divvied up $220 million, or about $18.3 million per school, dwarfing the Aggies' and Tigers' cuts from the uneven distribution plan in their old league. But that was before the Big 12 negotiated a whopper of a deal with Fox Sports and decided to distribute all revenue evenly last October. If they'd remained in the fold through the next round of negotiations for the Big 12's primary television rights, both schools would have eventually raked in at least as much as they'll be making in the SEC, if not more.

Takeaway. Overheated reputations aside, life in the SEC doesn't figure to dramatically change the Aggies or Tigers' fortunes in either direction. As in the Big 12, A&M and Mizzou both should maintain a steady .500 existence within the conference, experience the occasional peaks and valleys, and enjoy regular trips to second-class bowl games — more or less the same trajectory Arkansas and South Carolina have traveled since joining the league in 1992, and one the Aggies and Tigers should be more than accustomed to.

Of course, that doesn't account for the high of victory-by-association if the SEC continues its success in the BCS Championship Game, or the year-round circus ginned up by the likes of Paul Finebaum and SEC Media Days, the one area in which the conference is clearly miles ahead of the rest of the country. For ego and lowest-common-denominator entertainment value, the move is a step up. For anything you can actually measure, it's just a change of scenery.

- - -
Matt Hinton is on Facebook and Twitter: Follow him @DrSaturday.

View Comments (2)

Recommended for You

  • UFC Fight Night 52 Results: Mark Hunt Blasts Roy Nelson with a One-Punch Knockout

    Fans had been wanting, waiting, and wishing for a fight between heavyweights Mark Hunt and Roy Nelson. At UFC Fight Night 52 on Saturday in Tokyo, all the patience paid off, as the two big bruisers finally stepped into the Octagon opposite each other. Both men were swinging for the knockout from…

    MMA Weekly
  • What's Your Definition of Success?

    Success means different things for different people, that’s why we’ve started “The Success Project”.

  • Florida State quarterback Jameis Winston will not play Saturday night against Clemson

    Florida State dropped some big news late Friday night. After originally stating that Heisman Trophy winning quarterback Jameis Winston would be suspended for the first half of Saturday night’s game against Clemson, the school announced via a statement from interim president Garnett Stokes and…

    Dr. Saturday
  • Rex Chapman arrested for allegedly stealing $14,000 in merchandise from Arizona Apple Store

    Former NBA guard Rex Chapman, who played 12 seasons for four teams over a well-regarded career, was arrested Friday for allegedly stealing more than $14,000 in merchandise from a Scottsdale, Arizona Apple Store. According to area police, the 46-year-old Chapman stole the items over seven different…

    Ball Don't Lie
  • Dion Jordan Trade Rumors: Dolphins regret not making deal with Eagles?

    Hey, it's another Dion Jordan trade rumor. It feels like it's been forever since we've had a Dion Jordan trade rumor that involves the Philadelphia Eagles, hasn't it? Last place we left off was where the former Oregon Ducks pass rusher was reportedly targeted by his former head coach Chip Kelly…

    SB Nation32 mins ago
    Sun, Sep 21
    10:00 AM PDT
    Washington at Philadelphia
    Preview Game
  • Thiago Silva's ex-wife posts video of him allegedly high on cocaine and searching their house

    While the court case against Thiago Silva may not be going forward, is ex-wife is apparently publishing her own evidence of his actions. Well, this certainly does not look good for Thiago Silva, and could get a lot worse depending on what other

    SB Nation
  • Ravens release statement following ESPN Outside The Lines story

    The Ravens offered a brief statement concerning the ESPN Outside The Lines story that published early Friday evening. The Ravens will address all of these next week in Baltimore after our trip to Cleveland for Sunday's game against the Browns." John Harbaugh will likely get asked about the report…

    SB Nation
  • Play

    Fallon Fox -- Hey Ronda .... SHUT UP AND FIGHT ME ALREADY!

    Transgender MMA fighter Fallon Fox is firing back at UFC champ Ronda Rousey -- telling her to cut out the excuses about "bone structure" ... and FIGHT HER ALREADY!!! Fox -- who was born a man -- is clearly upset with Rousey for saying it's "unfair" for Fallon to fight against naturally born women…

  • Players react with disdain to Roger Goodell's news conference

    On Friday afternoon, NFL commissioner Roger Goodell ended more than a week of silence by holding a tense, slightly contentious news conference. Topics included the NFL's missteps in handling the Ray Rice and Adrian Peterson cases, the league's new domestic violence and personal conduct policies,…

    Shutdown Corner
  • Wozniacki, Ivanovic reach Pan Pacific final

    Ana Ivanovic of Serbia ousted top seed Angelique Kerber in straight sets Saturday to reach the final of the $1 million Pan Pacific Open against US Open finalist Caroline Wozniacki. Denmark's Wozniacki, seeded second and looking to get over her loss to world number one Serena Williams in the US Open…

    AFP25 mins ago
  • Report: Bridgewater Won't Start Without Adrian Peterson?

    The following is an interview with Jason Cole of Bleacher Report. .on what he's heard regarding the status of rookie quarterback Teddy Bridgewater, allegedly from speaking to a Minnesota Vikings coach. For starters, I understand that Adrian Peterson has been the centerpiece of the Minnesota…

    SB Nation
    Sun, Sep 21
    10:00 AM PDT
    Minnesota at New Orleans
    Preview Game
  • Ron Washington's misguided news conference could be hiding ugly truth

    The NFL’s descent into ugliness over the past two weeks taught the sports world the power and import of the whole truth, something apparently lost on the crisis-management team Ron Washington hired. The bizarre, uncomfortable news conference Washington held Thursday to shed light on his resignation…

    Yahoo Sports
  • Play

    'NFL Fantasy Live': Top 5 fantasy defenses for Week 3

    Find out where your team's defense ranks when NFL Media's Akbar Gbajabiamila shares his top 5 fantasy defenses for Week 3.

    NFL Highlights
  • Extraordinary day: Thiago Silva cut, Anthony Johnson suspended, Wanderlei Silva retires

    Two cases of domestic violence, an athlete holding a gun, allegations of drug use and an unhappy fighter ripping his organization highlighted the news that happened Friday in the UFC. Iconic light heavyweight Wanderlei Silva, one of the most popular fighters in mixed martial arts history, announced…

  • UFC Fight Night 52 results: Miesha Tate wins uninspired decision over Rin Nakai

    Miesha Tate looked to continue her comeback tour against Octagon newcomer Rin Nakai on the main card of today's (Sat., Sept. 20, 2014) UFC Fight Night 52: "Hunt vs. Nelson" Fight Pass event at the Saitama Super Arena in Saitama, Japan. Success .

    SB Nation
  • WWE releases two Developmental roster members

    Multiple sources are confirming that WWE has released two members of the NXT/Developmental roster today.  Neither had been featured prominently on television, but both had appeared. One of the releases is Kendall Skye (real name Kendra Smith), a

    SB Nation
  • Thornton on Wilson's offseason comments: 'I don't need somebody else telling me we can't do it'

    Count the former captain among the many who believe the Sharks don't need a rebuild or culture change. Anyone who believed the start of training camp would bring with it an instant dissipation of all the frustration, anger and drama that characterized a bizarre Sharks offseason was woefully…

    SB Nation
  • Drogba dedicates time to mentoring Hazard as Belgian seeks to raise his game

    One of the most interesting aspects of Eden Hazard's footballing personality is the way he seems to get attached to the older generation of stars. Last year he latched onto Samuel Eto'o, and this time around it's apparently Didier Drogba who's taken it upon himself to shape Hazard into the sort of…

    SB Nation
  • Mayweather called before Nevada boxing commission

    Once again, Floyd Mayweather Jr. has some explaining to do. Nevada boxing regulators have ordered Mayweather to appear before them next week to answer questions about scenes aired on the Showtime network prior to his fight Saturday night against Marcos Maidana. Specifically, they want to ask…

    The Associated Press
  • Adrian Peterson's reported text messages reveal warped view of manhood that goes beyond NFL

    One of the saddest and most revealing details about the Adrian Peterson child abuse allegations/indictment is this reported text exchange with the mother of one of the children who was whipped. "… toughest of the bunch," Peterson wrote. Peterson was trying to make his child into a man before the…

    Yahoo Sports