Ball Don't Lie - NBA

Tue Dec 09, 2008 2:40 pm EST

Lay into, but lay off of Kevin McHale


After a while, even an owner as oblivious as Glen Taylor will get the right idea.

You have an idea about Glen Taylor, I'm sure. He's the Timberwolves owner who doesn't like to be spurned (who does?), and took to various alternative papers and city mags to discuss just why his Timberwolves never went over the top. It had to be something some agent did. Something Kevin Garnett pushed for. Oh, I know. It was Flip Saunders. Mostly Flip's fault.

It couldn't be that, for years, the Timberwolves had a top-heavy team that wasn't good enough to ever make it to the second round, mainly because they were beaten by better teams every time out. That they were good enough to make the playoffs, but not bad enough to ever garner a high lottery pick to turn things around. And when the team had lottery picks in 1996 and 1999, they made the safe and proper picks that everyone rightfully applauded.

You can kind of see where I'm going with this. And where Glen's going with this. Kevin McHale is going to coach the rest of the year, and he'll probably move on after the season at Taylor's behest.

The Timberwolves have screwed some things over throughout the years, but it always seems like there's more blame to go around than there are things to blame people over. Yes, Kevin McHale has been pretty lousy at times over the last decade, but he's also put himself in a position to be lousy by making some pretty solid moves of his own.

I've been pretty wary of McHale since he started with the Timberwolves in an executive position, mainly because it came less than a year after he wrote this rip-job of the NBA for Sports Illustrated. I know that he talked about not missing the drudgery of playing in the league more than the league itself, and he made some salient points in the column, but he didn't exactly come across as someone willing to put the time into what is an exacting and exhausting job.

But he's been at it for over 14 years now, until this week, when he gave up his executive position to coach the team he put together. And though McHale isn't much of a coach, it should be on him to try and turn this mess around.

Because he hired Randy Wittman. And he stuck with him entering this season knowing full well just how goofy some of Wittman's rotation choices have been throughout the years, and with two different teams.

The national TV guys made noise this week about how the Timberwolves "haven't been the same" since they traded KG, but that's because they haven't paid attention to the team since Minnesota traded KG, and don't know that this was about as good a move as a team could make with an aging superstar making over $20 million a year.

But that's what happens when you don't pay attention. You'll see it in the comments section below, "shouldn't have traded KG." Because that's what the Wolves need, now. A 32-year old power forward instead of a 23-year old power forward.

I supposed you'd like me to get to a point, eventually. Let me try one:

McHale's been awful for this team at times, mostly awful, but he's also made some very sound moves, and a lot of his failures seemed like the right move at the time. This doesn't mean he deserves to stay on with the Timberwolves past this season (Fred Hoiberg will likely take on his own coach, and McHale will gleefully take on his own couch), but this doesn't mean McHale's been an abject failure.

For one, we wouldn't even be talking about Kevin McHale as an NBA executive had he not taken a chance on Kevin Garnett back in 1995. This was the first player to jump straight to pro basketball from high school in decades, and the success rate for such a jump varied from the comical (Darryl Dawkins) to the sublime (Moses Malone) to quite forgettable (Bill Willoughby, and I'm not joking here, I had to look his name up because I drew a blank there for 30 seconds).

He jumped on Garnett, and a little while later, he jumped on Flip Saunders as coach. And those were two big risks. At my parents' house right now is a rolled up piece of Chicago Tribune from 1996, used to wrap Christmas lights around, with a Sam Smith column excoriating McHale for drafting an obvious flop and hiring his old Minnesota buddy to run the show. Just killing him for it.

But McHale soldiered on. And he made mistakes. He got the Stephon Marbury trade (the first one) right, but his selection of Paul Davis in 1997 showed his utter uselessness when it came to finding non-lottery talent. A decade's worth of chances, and not a winner in the bunch.

Then, with Marbury moping in March of 1999, he chucked Stephon to the Nets instead of holding his feet to the fire, acting as if Stephon was going to jump as a free agent that summer for more money. He wasn't. Only the Chicago Bulls had cap space that summer, they were saving it for 2000, and Marbury probably wouldn't have played for Chicago anyway. He could make the most money with Minnesota, even if it wasn't on KG's level.

And though McHale did well in grabbing a near-All-Star in Terrell Brandon and a lottery pick for Marbury, that summer's draft could have gone better. Not a lot better, but better. He took Wally Szczerbiak instead of Shawn Marion or Andre Miller or Rip Hamilton, and Will Avery over Ron Artest or Andrei Kirilenko. The problem with ripping McHale for these moves comes with the fact that a lot of teams passed on Artest and Kirilenko. It doesn't make it right, but the Wolves needed a shooter like Wally and someone who could eventually take over for Brandon.

The problem was that Avery stunk, which I didn't see coming at the time, and Wally is kind of a (rhymes with the second word in the phrase "rhythm stick"). Szczerbiak went to Puerto Rico with KG that summer to play for the US National Men's team, and reminded anyone who would listen that he was less than a year younger than KG, despite Garnett's longish NBA history. Not the best start.

And that was it. With the Joe Smith nonsense (who puts that in writing, McHale?) making it so Kevin didn't have a chance to blow any more of those first round picks in the low 20s that the Timberwolves were due to earn, that was the team's big chance to make a move. And they made an OK one. And they were an OK team that lost to better teams every spring in the first round. Doesn't make KG a choker. Doesn't make Saunders a bad coach. Just makes them a 45-win team that lost to 55-win teams year after year.

McHale's next chance to do something with an asset came in 2003, and he knocked it out of the park. Traded Terrell Brandon's expiring deal and Joe Smith's expiring game to several outlets, bringing in Latrell Sprewell and Sam Cassell. Cassell had a year for the ages in 2003-04, Sprewell was a solid minutes sponge, and KG was in his prime.

The result? A team that would have probably made the Finals that year had Cassell not gone down with an injury in the playoffs, forcing Darrick Martin, Fred Hoiberg, and Kevin Garnett to back the ball across half court at times during the Western Conference Finals.

Should have probably picked up a backup, Kevin.

The next moves were lousy. Traded Cassell and picks for the right to overpay Marko Jaric. Offered Sprewell an outrageously-bad contract (three years, $21 million) that Spre (luckily for Minnesota) didn't sign. Traded a player with slim trade value in Wally for two players with no trade value in Mark Blount and Ricky Davis. Davis' contract expired before Wally's, but it was half the size of Szczerbiak's (a big trading chip right now, and one that helped bring Ray Allen to Boston), and McHale then had to make move after move to try and pare down the largesse of Davis and Blount's deals.

And then he traded Garnett for a 21-year old power forward who responded with a 21 and 11 year, got some draft picks, cash, cap space, and a whole host of solid young rotation talent.

Both teams should have been deliriously happy with the deal, and yet McHale took all sorts of grief for it. Jokes about McHale helping his old team (Boston) run by his old buddy (Danny Ainge). Forgetting, of course, that Kevin Garnett is going to be lazing on a beach in Malibu in five years, and Al Jefferson is going to be on the All-Star team.

He also hired Randy Wittman, and in the end, that may have done him in. Wittman is incredibly inconsistent, alternating fits of fury with all sorts of excuse-mongering and player pampering. His rotations are strange, he seems to lose players, there's not a lot development, and there hasn't been a lot of winning. Other than that, a steady hand.

So, 1500 words to tell you this: McHale's been bad, at times. But he's also done quite a bit for this team, this franchise, and that city. And though we're going to spend the next five months giving him stick for appearing helpless coaching the team he's put together, understand that this team has draft picks, impending cap space, and a roster full of young contributors. Rashad McCants and Randy Foye may have been wasted draft picks, but you know what? They're gone in a year or two, if Hoiberg does it right. 

Rip him if you must, and you must, but don't make it a black and white affair.

digg delicious
more

18 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. dfhoops31
    1. Posted by dfhoops31 Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:42 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    wow kelly you really sound like your the dummest person ever. kevin mchale has not done anything good for this team and if you think he has you are a retard.
    GET THIS MORON OUT OF THE STATE
  2. ao
    2. Posted by ao Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:42 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    i think KD is partially right, they paid Garnett too much money and couldnt build a championship caliber team around him. But that is mchales job, Garnett is not even close to being a clutch player and the year ET and sprewell played well the T-wolves made it all the way to the WCF.
  3. You gotta love the Clownboys
    3. Posted by You gotta love the Clownboys Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:44 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Let me get this straight Kelly, McHale has been good because he drafted some good players, even though any team that have been top in the lottery gets good players these days, look at OK City, Sacramento, Memphis, the may be rock bottom but no one would argue that they have bad players. And he got some good players also after they traded their all star to a team that had been a top lottery team for several years also the Celtics. I like to give the managers and coaches some space, some time, you can't get miracles in a couple of years. But if you are telling everybody that McHale is not so bad because after 15 YEARS he's left the team with some good players and 1 significant playoff appeareance, and without mentioning that he's got in his team one of the best players of this generation. Just look at the job that some guys have done in a very similar situation if not worst in PORTLAND and tell me that McHale has done a decen job again.
  4. eric b
    4. Posted by eric b Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:52 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    KD - I think one reason that McHale is seen as such a failure is that he's had 14 years with which to fail. Nearly every team in the league has switched GMs more than once since McHale took over for the Wolves and McHale has done very little to warrant that kind of job security in an unsecure market. Also, I think McHale has lacked any sort of vision as to what his basketball team should look like in the big picture or over the long term. The individual mistakes on draft picks happen to everyone (even Jerry West drafted Dahntay Jones at 16, ahead of Josh Howard among others), but good GMs formulate a plan and are able to execute it despite mistakes (or they get fired trying). McHale never did this - his most planned out move was Joe Smith. Each move was an attempt to fix a previous individual mistake and when you pile singular mistakes on top of each other you don't succeed long term, even when you make a couple of good decisions (Spree and Cassell). While McHale was in charge of putting the team together, at some point the buck went past him and stopped with Taylor who seemed unwilling to get rid of McHale no matter what. That isn't Kevin's fault at all, but he ends up taking all the heat for it because he's the name everyone knows, not Taylor. He's one of few GMs over the last 15 years that has been given the time and patience by his owner to formulate a plan and then execute it over the course of a few seasons, but you never got the sense that he had a plan to begin with.
  5. tarheels28
    5. Posted by tarheels28 Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:45 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    KD, well said, but I'm pretty sure you meant to put Paul Grant as the draft pick in 1997. I have no clue memory, but I do remember Paul Davis from his Michigan State days, and knew he wasn't drafted in '97.
  6. Big Time
    6. Posted by Big Time Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:23 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    KD-
    Absolutely, unequivocally the best take of McHale's tenure here in Minny. As someone who has been on the inside for quite a few years, this is spot on.
    Great stuff.
  7. mcwelk
    7. Posted by mcwelk Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:14 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    This column is the equivalent of one of McHale's wrong-foot, high-release turn-around jumpers (that went in).
  8. KOBE4PREZ
    8. Posted by KOBE4PREZ Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:43 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I don't care what the people of the great state of minnesota think's about you KEVIN MCHALE you are doing a great JOB , keep driving this franchised too the ground. YOU are just as OVERRATED as management as you were a player. Hey Mchale can you send us KEVIN LOVE to the LAKER'S for a shinny new coin?
  9. gobig_or_gohome300
    9. Posted by gobig_or_gohome300 Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:10 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I've been following the Wolves for a long time... and I can't find anything I disagree in this. I was actually excited when they drafted Will Avery.
    Nevertheless, he did make a number of moves that together should have resulted in a lost job. And I don't think you gave enough words to his inability to assess talent with his midround picks. Ndudi Ebi anyone?
  10. eric b
    10. Posted by eric b Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:52 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    haha Ryan, you said Ndudi....
  11. nja700
    11. Posted by nja700 Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:39 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I completely agree with almost every point you made. A lot his moves were only terrible in hindsight, and a few seemed to be genuinely good moves at the time. He's not completely terrible, and he's not nearly as bad as Matt Millen was for the NFL's Lions. The only problem is that McHale's inexplicable, staggering failures (Jaric trade, bad draft picks, and especially the Joe Smith debacle) aren't even close to being effectively mitigated by the successes. Even including the stroke of genius that was the drafting of KG. Although the team has stockpiled young talent and picks and cap space since the KG trade, it's still so far behind other young teams in the rebuilding process that I don't see any change for a while. The roster makes no sense at all.
    Sadly for eric b, the pronunciation of the worst draft pick of McHale's tenure (Ndudi sounds like "endi") does not sound like the euphemism for poop. It would be pretty appropriate, though.
  12. Daniel L
    12. Posted by Daniel L Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:35 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Yes, McHale made a few good moves, but those good moves were TEN YEARS AGO. He drafted Garnett in '95 which was good, and when he traded Marbury in I think '98 he got a decent deal.. I don't even consider the acquisition of Marbury a good deal as he gave up a decent bench player and Ray Allen, who will go down as one of the best shooters of all time, to get Marbury. So in the last 10 years what has he done? He has lost the team several draft picks, screwed up several others (Will Avery, Ndudi Ebi, McCants, Randy Foye, and EVERY 2nd round pick except Craig Smith). For 10 years he drafted terribly, never brought in good free agents except for Cassell and Sprewell for 1 season, and made several awful trades, acquiring Jaric, Mark Blount, Ricky Davis, etc. The Joe Smith thing alone should be a good enough reason to fire him (if it was truly all his fault), but combine that with an inability to bring in talent through all channels (draft, trades, free agency), and how exactly has he been okay? Since drafting KG he has been terrible.
  13. StreetHistory.com
    13. Posted by StreetHistory.com Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:33 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Good read. You definitely know your T-Wolves history. I agree with most of what you said.
  14. rightsaidfred
    14. Posted by rightsaidfred Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:38 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Great players very seldom make great coaches. They can't use themselves as substitutes in a lineup that doesn't know how to win.
  15. Toby B
    15. Posted by Toby B Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:14 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    McHale is a bum, without the other celtics so called greats he would have been just another big man with no talent
  16. moon man
    16. Posted by moon man Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:12 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Ridiculous that you don't even mention the last two draft-day trades: Trading a 6-5 point guard, Brandon Roy, to the Blazers for a 6-0 scoring guard, Randy Foye. And trading a 6-5 point guard, OJ Mayo, for two horribly bad defensive players, Mike Miller and Kevin Love.
    I like Love and Miller on the offensive end, but they stink on defense. The Wolves should have Roy right now, or failing that, Mayo. And you don't even mention that. Pretty lame.
  17. igotsoul2
    17. Posted by igotsoul2 Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:43 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    McHale did make a few decent moves, but don't forget the grip of bad picks he's made: Rashad McCants (did any other GM have him pegged as a lottery pick?) over Danny Granger when Granger had inexplicably slipped out of the top ten in 2005, trading Brandon Roy for Randy Foye in 2006, drafting Corey Brewer in 2007 over guys like Stuckey and Young, and while it's too soon to judge, early returns on the Mayo - Love/Miller trade haven't been great either.
    Oh, and one other omission, in 2002, McHale thought giving Chauncey Billups the mid-level exception was too much, but proceeded to ink career back-ups (I'm putting it nicely) Marko Jaric, Mike James, and Troy Hudson to multi-year deals worth at least that much.
  18. booz
    18. Posted by booz Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:40 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    McHale is single-handedly responsible for the turn around of the franchise. He has helped fans like me witness things we could have never imagined possible 10 years ago.
    Go Celtics!

Ball Don't Lie

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

J.E. Skeets

Ball Don't Lie is an NBA blog edited by J.E. Skeets. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Ball Don't Lie Recent Readers