Big League Stew - MLB

On Thursday, the fellas at Fire Joe Morgan announced they were returning their scalpels to the surgical tray and calling it a blogging career. The news spread quickly through the blogosphere and surely brought sighs of relief from the writers that were frequently targeted. Our own Jeff Passan was twice a victim and yet he still laments the passing of a worthy Internet adversary. 

The first time I was FJM'd, my friend Jon sent me a giddy e-mail. For years, he had delighted in every shame that befell me — crash-and-burns with women, sloppy nights at the bar or the time he whacked my kidney with a broom handle and caused me to piss blood for a week — and yet never had I seen him so tickled.

I knew about Fire Joe Morgan. It was a blog that found the most absurd in sportswriting, broadcasting and, occasionally, life, and picked it apart sentence by painful sentence. Its contributors, each adopting a pseudonym — the ring leader was Ken Tremendous — were dangerous for three reasons. They were brilliant. They were angry. And they were funny as hell.

Now, I was in their scope. I had figured myself impervious. I covet logic. They preyed on those who didn't, originally their namesake, ESPN's dunderhead broadcaster, and then all others with a keyboard, a paycheck and a voice.

Problem was, I had slipped. I grew up watching Omar Vizquel. I admired his fielding magnificence. There was an emotional attachment. One day, I wrote that he deserved a spot in the Hall of Fame. Though I still believe a good argument can be made, I did not posit it. I praised his sacrifice bunts. If you ever wanted to be FJM'd, all you had to do was laud sacrifice bunts.

The vivisection that ensued hurt, and I found it wasn't quite as funny when it was your work. I understood, though, because FJM were like the ombudsmen of the baseball-writing world — only they were total dicks.

No one escaped their wrath. Thousand-word columns turned into 2,000-word rebuttals, biting and merciless and so full of bile that the writers' livers had to be superhuman. Writers never acknowledged when they got FJM'd. It was like getting a letter that began: Dear Moron.

They saved the most epic posts for Joe Morgan himself, breaking down his chats, his rants on TV, his interviews. In a way, I felt bad for the man. He was a ballplayer. To expect him to understand anything, let alone advanced statistical metrics, was a lot to ask. He did thrust himself out there week after week, though, spouting his opinions like they were gospel, and, hey, the fourth estate exists for a reason.

Accordingly, FJM's popularity grew, and eventually the main contributors outed themselves. Ken Tremendous was a man named Michael Schur. He plays Mose Schrute, the ping-pong-playing, beet-worshipping cousin of Dwight on "The Office," and is one of the show's lead writers and executive producers. The other two main writers were Dave King (aka dak), who wrote for "FrankTV," and Alan Yang (aka Junior), the surgeon on my Vizquel piece, who was with Carson Daly's show.

"It's pretty pathetic when a guy from Carson Daly rips you," my wife said. "You're not even good enough for Mose."

(Finally. I get him back. Through my wife. I am pathetic.)

My name saw the pages of FJM once more, when I tried to assign odds to teams entering the second half of the season. My grasp of numbers was pathetic, an FJM sin that led to this headline from Junior: "Jeff Passan: Royals Are Locks To Win The AL Central."  I quickly corrected the error, and Junior duly noted it. Turns out, the guys weren't such bastards after all. Ken Tremendous and I emailed occasionally. He loved baseball. He had a baby son. He was like me, only rich and funny.

The love of baseball, in fact, was the reason that FJM happened in the first place. All three are Red Sox fans, and they started the site to make each other laugh. Along the way, they happened to strike a nerve with hundreds of thousands of others who needed a good chuckle.

Whether deconstructing a writer's irrational love affair with David Eckstein or pointing out the countless food metaphors that we drop on stories like sprinkles on a sundae, FJM, despite its one-note shtick, never got stale.

To see Thursday night's announcement of the site's death, then, was sad. Baseball writers had lost their foremost check and baseball fans their funniest outlet. Sure, they weren't always right, and their cultish adherence to sabermetrics bordered on ridiculous. But the bad was trivial, and the good was great.

Three and a half years and 1,377 snarling posts after it started, Fire Joe Morgan is gone and may it rest in peace. Until the Red Sox sign Eckstein in December, anyway.

digg delicious
more

42 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. Matthew I
    1. Posted by Matthew I Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:22 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Great eulogy Jeff. I died a little inside when I opened up FJM this morning.
  2. Butt Pirate
    2. Posted by Butt Pirate Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:03 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I like Joe Morgan. I'm glad he will finally be allowed to broadcast in peace.
  3. King Crackhead
    3. Posted by King Crackhead Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:31 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The only thing worse than Joe Morgan is Jon Miller's slurping of Joe Morgan.
  4. The Thrilla in Vanilla
    4. Posted by The Thrilla in Vanilla Thu Sep 03, 2009 11:01 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    In all seriousness, a great case for the HoF can be made for Omar Vizquel. Don't waffle! Be a man! You're 40!
  5. F.D.Snafu Esq.
    5. Posted by F.D.Snafu Esq. Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:45 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Stone got that one right, I won't miss the two of them together at all.
  6. AndreBar
    6. Posted by AndreBar Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:59 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    That doesn't make any sense, Stone. Pluck the 'Duk, I'm confused!
  7. Kyle Thoby
    7. Posted by Kyle Thoby Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:55 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    FJM was amazing compared to BLS is like comparing Cristian Guzman to freekin' Pujols. Ill prove it
    FJM career OPS+ -126
    BLS -84
    case closed!
  8. YoYo Ma
    8. Posted by YoYo Ma Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:15 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I agree with parts of your original article re: Vizquel's HOF-worthiness. Seems like either 1) it was a mistake to induct ozzie smith or 2) the visceral reaction one gets watching vizquel play some of the best defense of his era at least brings him to the fore for discussion.
  9. Dave B
    9. Posted by Dave B Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:12 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I like Joe... Now Tim Mccarver, that guy sucks! I cant even watch any games he's a part of.
  10. BC
    10. Posted by BC Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:03 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I learned a lot of baseball when Joe Morgan was one of the Giants announcers. I would vote Omar Visquel in to the Hall of Fame. Hes a dancer playing shortstop. Catches the ball with the back of his glove to make quick double play turns. Hes a great guy too. Hes what baseball is all about to me. Guy making it even tho hes not the best with the bat. He is as valuable as any guy on the team. Give me gloves at short and catcher. They dont have to hit. I pitched some kind of ball for 35 years and the best teams I was on, played defense.
    Its easy to pick apart people on the air. Hard to do that job. Everything is under scrutiny.
    And I agree about Tim McCarver. I heard everything he had to say about baseball by 1993. Get some new blood in there with a newer attitude.
  11. cuffablimp
    11. Posted by cuffablimp Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:34 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Joe Morgan holds his own well @ 65 but he strays a bit when claiming players use people then drags them down an uncharted road.. I didn't get it but it looked rather contemptuous coming from a pretty bright guy who usually does a great commentary. He's not going to be around forever but he should look before he leaps sometimes..
  12. joe d
    12. Posted by joe d Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:14 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Good riddance to this stupid web site. I don't know what a good man like Joe Morgan did to merit this abuse from some pathetic shut ins ? I guess there's some kind of karma in that it seems that these losers were the ones who got fired. Maybe they can borrow some money from Joe Morgan now that they're unemployed
  13. Walter B
    13. Posted by Walter B Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:40 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Morgans biggest problem is he feels he has to say something after every pitch. Usually something with no meaning and could've been saved for his wife at the kitchen table. Talking about himself till you want gag. The site is gone, but please, "Fire Joe Morgan"! Timmy boy can go too! Bye Joe!
  14. TimR
    14. Posted by TimR Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:12 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Well done.
  15. chief
    15. Posted by chief Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:07 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Joe Morgan was a great baseball player not only physically but mentally. He is without doubt the most knowledgeable commentator ever to work a baseball game. Just listen to him and you will learn so much about the game.. He does have a tendancy to be very prejudice in favor of black players most of the time.
  16. Kyle Thoby
    16. Posted by Kyle Thoby Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:55 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    joe d is a moron. it was a free website. noone got fired.
  17. Mike Chaloux
    17. Posted by Mike Chaloux Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:13 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Joe Morgan sucks! If some guy hit a 550 foot homer Joe would be talking about why the centerfield couldn't grab it and how great a guy he is. Get a new job!
    Tim McCarver is even worse. If the Yankees arn't playing, he shouldn't be announcing it!
  18. Barry H
    18. Posted by Barry H Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:16 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    And good riddance to them..the arrogant bastards...unlike Joe Morgan they had nothing worthwhile to say...just mean spirited....nothing else..
  19. therock
    19. Posted by therock Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:37 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    please Joe Morgan is a hofer he loves baseball maybe instead of announcing a real baseball network such as ( WELL WE NEED ONE DONT WE NBC,CBS PLEASE) COULD USE HIM FOR STUDIO INFO.
  20. bob
    20. Posted by bob Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:07 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Joe is a racist! And when is the Fire Tim McCarver site start up? I swear he made a pact with the devil to get were he is. He is the worse announcer in any sport!
  21. Al M
    21. Posted by Al M Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:52 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    That was a Cutter....no kidding!
  22. Bob O
    22. Posted by Bob O Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:46 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I found Morgan to be inane. But why the hate on McCarver? I've always found him to be smart and articulate. He's opinionated, but he always gives his reasons, and he's often right. And he does so BEFORE the play unfolds. Maybe years of abysmal NY sports broadcasts --the unrepentant homers who play by play the Yanks and Mets -- have made him seem profound, but at least he's articulate and doesn't settle for "hitters must hit" and "pitchers must throw strikes."
    Anyone care to elaborate the McCarver hate?
  23. randall b
    23. Posted by randall b Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:31 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Joe Morgan, probably like Jeff Passan, is extremely critical of Pete Rose.
    The issue of Rose is way overdone and Morgan has absolutely no forgiveness
    for his fellow teammate. I really lost a lot of respect for Morgan when I heard
    that. He absolutely had no loyalty to Pete. Joe Morgan's analysis is sometimes
    shaky in my opinion, and I agree that he doesn't know when to shut up. Joe Morgan
    is lame.
    Tim McCarver lost my respect when he talked over and belittled Brett Boone during
    a Yankees world series broadcast. To me, McCarver showed a lot of arrogance during
    that episode in the broadcast booth. It certainly wasn't very classy. I have a hard time
    forgetting that one and I always felt McCarver's true personality was revealed that night.
  24. msalig
    24. Posted by msalig Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:28 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    On the field. Joe Morgan... As good as anyone who ever played. He was a gamer. In the booth .. not so much. I think as only one person has said it isn't so much listening to his ramblings but listening to Miller attach his lips to his rear end is more than any fan should have to take. Who is John Miller? Why do we care what he thinks. He should be play by play and Morgan does the color. I think he is scared of Morgan. As for those who don't understand what's wrong with McCarver.... What is right with him? Ever since the Deion incident he has been lost. Not because of it but he has gone over the edge. He is maybe the most biased announcer ever. Once you know who he is pulling for he doesn't shut up about it. There should be a fire Tim McCarver site now. If anybody wants to start one I'm in.
  25. Czheck
    25. Posted by Czheck Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:33 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    poor joe morgan len casper bob brenly are way worse WHITE SOX BRING DJ BACK SKREW STEVE STONE

Big League Stew

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

'Duk

Big League Stew is an MLB blog edited by Kevin Kaduk. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Big League Stew Recent Readers