Big League Stew - MLB

Since they usually involve faceless minor leaguers, it seems like it's been awhile since baseball has had a drug suspension that anyone talked about past an obligatory headline or mention. To date, only the suspensions of Rafael Palmeiro and Jason Grimsley have gained any traction and that was because one involved a would-have-been Hall of Famer (Raffy) while the other (Grimsley) had links to other superstars. 

Unfortunately for Philadelphia fans, we can add reliever JC Romero to the discussion list, though his inclusion can be attributed to the telephone-game-type circumstances (or complete lack thereof) surrounding the 50-game suspension for "negligence" that he and Yankees minor leaguer Sergio Mitre just received from Major League Baseball.

To try and sum up a complicated situation: Last July, Romero bought a supplement from GNC. The MLBPA had previously approved the supplement and Romero says he was under the belief he was doing nothing wrong. He had the supplement approved by two different nutritionists (though he failed to call the drug hotline). He was tested twice during the season and when one of the tests came up positive on Sept. 23, he immediately stopped taking the supplement. (The other test came back positive on Oct. 12). On Nov. 21, the MLPBA sent out a letter to players saying that it had made just a little bit of a mistake. Three substances in the previously "harmless" supplement would cause players to test positive.  

The whole thing becomes even more controversial once you listen to Romero and his contention that there was an extended lag time between MLB knowing that the supplement was illegal and the league notifying the MLBPA (which would, in turn, notify the players).

Since he or the MLBPA don't plan to appeal the decision, Romero — the winner of Games 3 and 5 of the World Series — will miss the first two months of the season and will forfeit $1.25 million worth of salary. (He had the option of admitting his guilt back in October and taking a reduced sentence of 25 games, but declined in part because it would have caused him to miss part of the NLCS and then the World Series.)

As you might imagine, Phillies bloggers are not taking this news too well ...

•  Says Chamo Davis of The Fightins': "Using tactics employed by shady, imperious organizations past and present, the powers that be in Major League Baseball ("Taking Substance Abuse 33% More Seriously!") have decided to suspend Phillies reliever JC Romero for fifty games next season."

•  Says Tim Malcolm at Phillies Nation: "JC Romero is paying a price that he seemingly never deserved, or saw coming. There's no reason to doubt Romero's innocence here — the facts show he's been victimized. It's time the organizations to blame clean this up, and now, before they further taint the baseball's image."

• Says the Good Phight: "Romero has become a fan favorite for his terrific performance and emotive mound demeanor. I don't see him taking this lying down by any stretch of the imagination, particularly as it sounds like there were multiple failures of communication between the MLBPA and the Office of the Commissioner."

Then there's The 700 Level, which is trying to spark another Philly t-shirt craze with "Free JC" shirts bearing the above logo. Given the way this case was bungled by more than one party not named JC Romero, it seems like a cause worth sporting. 

What do you think? Should Romero be held accountable for taking the supplement?

digg delicious
more

77 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. Jamie Mottram
    1. Posted by Jamie Mottram Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:28 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    "Free JC"? What does Jason Campbell have to do with anything?
  2. powdersdad1
    2. Posted by powdersdad1 Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:17 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Good luck Philly - the dude has a history of cheating and you're lucky he showed up during the World Series. His track record with the Twins was spotty, at best.
  3. gorensteineric124
    3. Posted by gorensteineric124 Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:11 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    powersdad your an idiot the drug was legal but now its not and now hes suspended ididot he did not cheat
  4. domenick2x
    4. Posted by domenick2x Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:46 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Powdersdad is referring to a prior positive test for a precursor of testosterone, which was from a pro-conception drug that both JC and his wife were taking. JC was, as powdersdad knows, cleared of any wrongdoing in that situation - and JC and his wife got pregnant shortly thereafter.
  5. million_dollar_sleeper
    5. Posted by million_dollar_sleeper Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:20 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I'm a twins fan. I always thought jc Romero was juicing. He had the biggest thighs of anyone in baseball. They belonged under the head of Barry bonds. And the fact that jc and pierzynski led the league in conferences. Jc is a meat head juicer.
    I was right about clemens (my proof being his face changed shape to look like giambi) and I was right about Romero. When will Bobby abreu get busted? Or does he just eat a lot of peanuts? Look at that beanie on top of his neck
  6. domenick2x
    6. Posted by domenick2x Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:46 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Million $ - you're the meathead. The guy has numerous clean tests, and gets busted for a tainted OTC supplement? Bonds, for all his juicing, NEVER TESTED POSITIVE. Designer steriods are designed to... get this... avoid showing positive on the tests.
    If Romero has been juicing, he's either a) ridiculously lucky, or b) stupid as all hell.
    And if you are talking about thighs, my Aunt Mildred must be juicing. She waddles when she walks!
  7. xxxODDSMAKERxxx
    7. Posted by xxxODDSMAKERxxx Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:53 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    hilarious domenick!!
    and hes juicin. if he wasnt, then y wouldnt he appeal with the MLBPA on his side?
  8. Jordan F
    8. Posted by Jordan F Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:25 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    why does he get a choice of when he gets suspended? they found out about this in the middle of october - suspend him then.
    instead, he decides to wait until next season and in the process they make it to the playoffs and win a world series with a guy who has tested positive?? regardless of the fact that the players association botched this one, the mlb still sucks at giving punishments out to these guys.
    it's disgusting that two tests came back positive and he was still allowed to participate in the playoffs, let alone finish the season.
  9. "THE PUNISHER"
    9. Posted by "THE PUNISHER" Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:34 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Free jc romero!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
  10. Josh
    10. Posted by Josh Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:41 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Listen to these haters. Two apparent Twins fans and Jordan from (?). MLB screwed up. They screwed up the McGwire/Bonds fiasco and now they are over compensating for their previous mishandling by putting the burden on the players to a ridiculous degree. MLB APPROVED this supplement--found out they made a mistake--didn't immediately notify the players/MLBPA-- and accuse Romero or other players of negligence? Really? It's laughable.
    Million $... What were you right about re: Romero? That he was taking the supplement? Sounds like you need a hobby if you have spent your time predicting that Romero was taking this GNC supplement.
    Now imagine that your workplace treated you like this...
  11. PhoenixP
    11. Posted by PhoenixP Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:40 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Its a little ridiculous Kinda like the football case in court. Its all about money in the end the teams and the Sport want the money they pay these people to play. Any excuse they are shadier then the juicer's. There are all kinds of info out there. A hotline. WHy would anyone call the hotline about a substance that baseball approved. Its like your boss approving your vacation then changing his mind while u were on it then firing you when u got back bc you went on it an didn't call a hotline that handles it after u already got approval. NO workplace would ever allow that to stand or Union except this one. Its sad that such a thing happened at all.
  12. Don P
    12. Posted by Don P Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:39 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    If the supplement wasn't on the approved MLB list (not the MLBPA list) and he chose not to call the hotline, sorry but JC you've gotta sit. You earn a big salary, you shouldn't risk it by not playing within the rules to the T.
  13. valiantofficer
    13. Posted by valiantofficer Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:31 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    jc is a good guy. My family has a long relationship with him, and he was screwed over by the MLB. First, he's told the supplements are ok. Days later, he gets a positive test after JUST being told, by the way jc, those supplements? yeah they could return positivew test results. total bs.
  14. IAMdio
    14. Posted by IAMdio Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:43 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Mitre and Romero were each suspended for 50 games. Hey MLB what about Barry Bonds?
  15. Jordan F
    15. Posted by Jordan F Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:25 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    "MLB APPROVED this supplement--found out they made a mistake--didn't immediately notify the players/MLBPA-- and accuse Romero or other players of negligence? Really? It's laughable."
    What kind of burden are you talking about? You mean like the burden of just going up to the team doctor and say: "Hey, check this out for me to see if it's ok." That's some hell of a burden. Maybe the pills shouldn't come with labels but the players should instead: "Caution: This player can't think for himself."
    Just because someone approves it doesn't mean you shouldn't get it checked anyway. It's common sense. ESPECIALLY during a playoff race where you can't afford to miss games for something so stupid.
    The point is that yes, they screwed up big time before, and they screwed up again now. Sure, for getting the drug wrong, but more importantly because of the way they handled the punishment.
  16. AJ
    16. Posted by AJ Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:23 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Bonds? 162 games and counting.
  17. sam spade
    17. Posted by sam spade Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:12 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    This shows the hypocrisy of the media. They are the ones who insisted of stiff iron clad penalties. Now, they are saying that "they", the media had run amok with this witch hunt. they now want to make exceptions to this and that. They found that everyone was doing it or in an evironment of performance enhancing dietary supplements which are approved and which are not. I have asked over and over again for an approved substance list from MLB and the NFL. Why is it such a secret?
    And can I turn it around, Barry Bonds black balled without any positive test for anything. Now, that we have more information, can anyone see that what has happened to Barry is wrong; also? As we get further and further away from the media and the government run amok; if Barry never plays again; he will be certifiably the greatest of all time because of these unfair policies of baseball, the media and the government. He will have never been defeated on the field and the league will continue to be populated by those who have admitted it and who has tested positive.
    Hasn't Barry Bonds gone through more than Hank Aaron? It was only high tech.
  18. sam spade
    18. Posted by sam spade Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:12 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Until some journalist publishes the approved supplement list , for the public to view and so the players aren't confused then this is what it has always been a racist witch hunt to get Barry Bonds that put out a dragnet that has gotten everyone including the innocent.
  19. Jordan F
    19. Posted by Jordan F Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:25 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Actually now that I think of it there's really on a few scenarios how this could have happened:
    1) Romero checks the approved list of drugs and randomly picks one without looking at what is in it. He deserves his suspension for negligence then.
    2) Romero does look at the ingredients in the drug and doesn't find out what they do. I seriously doubt he knows what 6-OXO Extreme does off the top of his head. He still deserves his suspension for negligence.
    This one is a hypothetical, but what if:
    3) Romero actually does think for himself and he gets the product checked out by his personal doctor in lets say April or so. The doctor tells him the product contains some banned substance, but Romero keeps this information to himself and uses the drug anyway. He'd be hoping he wasn't going to be caught, but if he was he could use the MLBPA as a cover...
    Obviously I don't know him well enough to accurately say if three is something he would do, but you can't really argue with 1/2. How can you take something without knowing what is in it or what it does? Is he just going by some guy with big muscles on the cover? THAT'S why he's been suspended for negligence...
  20. hank
    20. Posted by hank Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:32 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    If my pee was subject to testing and my reputation and million$ were riding on the result, I'd avoid anything from GNC like the plague. Maybe drink raw eggs, like Rocky. Duh.
  21. k c
    21. Posted by k c Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:16 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    This idiot didn't even call the MLB hotline that's designated to answer questions about supplements. This is what zero tolerance looks like. He'll be lucky if the Rays don't sue him for the 2 WS wins he had against them.
  22. JoZ
    22. Posted by JoZ Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:37 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Romero took something the league said was ok. Then they told him he was going to be suspended and asked if he wanted to serve a 25 game suspension immediately or be allowed to compete in spite of his supposed guilt and unfair advantage. Then, they suspend him for taking something they told him he could take.
    The league's actions are indefensible.
  23. jimmy
    23. Posted by jimmy Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:12 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    phils fan
    hate to say it,if there is a hot line to ask what he can and can not take?
    then he is either stupid or knew he was taking!
    he lost what 1.8 mil?
    i would call to ask if i could eat a cheese
  24. snake51
    24. Posted by snake51 Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:09 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    If a product can be purchased legally, then the MLB has no right to suspend any player for using it...period. If a product is banned, then the league has the responsibility to make sure this product is pulled from the shelves, or at least make certain that all players are aaware of the ban. Tony k, I don't want to hear about there being a "hotline" to call to see whether or not a substance is banned. If it is sold legally, then it is legel to take it. End of story.
  25. Shaun T
    25. Posted by Shaun T Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:17 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Ignorance is no excuse, try telling a cop who pulls you over for DUI that you didn't know there was booze in that "Long Island" Iced Tea you were drinking.
    The fact is this is cheating, JC's numbers were down, he had a failed year in Boston and went to the Phillies to rebuild his career with a banned substance. His ring should be taken away from him.

Big League Stew

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

'Duk

Big League Stew is an MLB blog edited by Kevin Kaduk. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Contributors:
David Brown, Alex Remington,

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Big League Stew Recent Readers