YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

    Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

    To get started, first
    Big League Stew

    Fausto Carmona — err, Roberto Heredia — arrested in Dominican Republic for false identity

    Reports out of the Dominican Republic say that Fausto Carmona is not who we thought he was. (AP)For years, ballplayers from the Dominican Republic have had to deal with the suspicion that they're all older than the age on the back of their baseball card.

    Now they'll have to battle doubts about the name that's listed on the front.

    Reports out of the Dominican Republic on Thursday say that Cleveland Indians pitcher Fausto Carmona has become the second pitcher arrested this offseason for using a false identity. According to reports, the 28-year-old Carmona is actually 31-year-old Roberto Hernandez Heredia. He was arrested while trying to renew his visa at the American consulate in Santo Domingo.

    Last December, Miami Marlins reliever Juan Carlos Oviedo was arrested in the D.R. for using a false name (Leo Nunez) and age (28 instead of 29). The deception, however, didn't matter much to the Marlins, who just re-signed Oviedo to a one-year deal worth $6 million (the contract is dependent on the successful resolution of the legal matter).

    What this means for Carmona is anyone's guess. The right-hander just completed a four-year, $15 million contract with the Indians and now the team has three club option years in front of it. A $7 million option for 2012 was exercised back in October and it's unknown if the Tribe will take any legal recourse because they're getting a pitcher who's three years older than they thought.

    "We were recently made aware of the situation that occurred today in the Dominican Republic and are currently in the process of gathering information," Indians general manager Chris Antonetti told MLB.com. "We are not prepared to make any additional comment at this time."

    As ESPN.com's Jorge Arangure notes, the Indians can't feel too bad about the arrangement to this point. Carmona won 19 games and was an integral part of the 2007 team that was one ALCS collapse away from the World Series and it's not as if they've sunk mega-money into him. Maybe it will affect those final two option years, but I'd be surprised if they quibbled over the $7 million if he's able to return to the U.S. and pitch in 2012.

    Considering that Carmona might not have received a pro contract had he not taken this route to adopt a younger age, I don't think too many of us can begrudge his choice. People in desperate situations tend to do desperate things, especially if they're under pressure from outside influences. It's hard to say you would have done anything differently if you were in the same situation.

    But it also introduces another layer of mystery to the players we cheer for (or curse) each game. How many of these names have belonged to these men since birth?

    Want more Big League Stew all winter long?
    Follow 'Duk on Facebook and Twitter!

    Other popular content on the Yahoo! network:
    NFL Offerings: Joe Flacco is threatening to steal Trent Dilfer's title
    Devil Ball Golf: Tiger Woods irked by former coach's book
    Busted Racquet: The worst-dressed players of the Australian Open
    Fashion: Costco selling $1 million diamond ring

     

    32 comments

    • Buffy The Vampire Slayer  •  Zanesville, Ohio  •  4 months ago
      Is Jamie Moyer really 49?
    • Amir  •  Cincinnati, Ohio  •  4 months ago
      This story is uproariously funny, and understandable on Fausto's part. Picking the name "Fausto" should earn you more money.
    • masoro2001  •  San Francisco, California  •  4 months ago
      Tony Perez said growing up, Luis Tiant was one of his heroes.

      By the time he got to the big leagues, Tiant was younger than he was.
    • Captain Crest  •  Cleveland, Ohio  •  4 months ago
      He's been impersonating as an MLB pitcher the past few years, so it's no surprise.

      This is classic though. Only in Cleveland.
    • Brandon  •  Chicago, Illinois  •  4 months ago
      Albert Pujols is 35!
    • Josh E  •  Akron, Ohio  •  4 months ago
      My name's not Fausto Carmona, either. Can I have his next couple of paychecks?
    • A different Bill  •  4 months ago
      It's like there is no integrity in sports anymore. Cheating, lying, steroids, human growth hormones- where does it end?
    • AndreTheRed  •  Sacramento, California  •  4 months ago
      Falsifying documents should void his contract. He signed under a name other than his own and signed checks that had another person's name on it. People get deported for less.
    • bcw420  •  Oakland, California  •  4 months ago
      MLB stay out of the latin market and get into the asian market, no playing around with age there because the players are legitimate and good.
    • Rocketman  •  4 months ago
      He committed a crime here in the U.S. by using someone else's name and he should be deported like any other alien who commits a crime. He just joins as one in a host of millions who break our laws but are allowed to stay here. It demeans the law and encourages more people to do whatever they want without worrying about the consequences.
      • BrianS 4 months ago
        Who says they are allowing him back in???? That has not been decided. He'll have to re-apply and they will then decide. He'll likely have to wait years for that process to be completed.
    • GOLDENEYE  •  Nixa, Missouri  •  4 months ago
      hey ...do a background check....when i apply for a job i have to have one,and i was born in america
    • Santiago B  •  4 months ago
      Fausto Carmona's other name Choker In Big Games.
    • Lindsey Day  •  Fort Worth, Texas  •  4 months ago
      "It's hard to say you would have done anything differently if you were in the same situation." It's always entertaining when editorials judge me.
    • jeff  •  4 months ago
      He was here under false pretenses and now should have to forfeit any income made while here and be banned for life under penalty of death. By falsifying documents, he is no different than all the illegal immigrants flood across our border.
      • the secret asian man 4 months ago
        "banned for life under penalty of death" is pretty harsh, don't you think?

        the guy's teeth were so bad he couldn't even eat properly. "carmona" gained 20 pounds his first season in the minors after the indians paid for his dental work. if my family can't even afford to pay for dental work, i'd consider lying for a chance to get a multi-million dollar contact to take care of my family. i'd still have to be able to hit, throw and catch the ball.

        now, in the case of somebody like an andy marte - he was projected to be a can't miss player because he allegedly performed well against players that were supposed to be older than he (was). if it turns out that andy marte is really 4 years older, we would have never traded for him. so no matter what, the indians should be expected to address the issue of due diligence when it comes to confirming age/identity, and also downgrade the significance of projections of a player's upside based on age when there potential concerns about confirming a player's age.
    • Louie L.  •  Centro, Mexico  •  4 months ago
      it's roberto hernandez, not heredia. heredia is his mother's surname. the mariners made the same mistake with david ortiz. his full name is david ortiz arias, and the mariners listed him as david arias until he had the courage to correct it when he was traded to the twins. anyway, too bad, i thought the indians could have been sleepers in the AL central.
    • Tom  •  Atlanta, Georgia  •  4 months ago
      I wonder out loud if the Indians have the oysters to void this clown's contract for fraud (name/age) and what the almighty players' union would do about it. Chances are the union would say it's OK to defraud your employer; Bud 'I-have-22-large-a-year-and-a-private-jet' won't do anything; and everyone will sit around and wonder why baseball is irrelevant.
    • JamesF  •  Chicago, Illinois  •  4 months ago
      I knew he was older the moment I saw him fall trying to make it to first base.
    • abhorrent behavior  •  St Louis, Missouri  •  4 months ago
      while you read this 500 Mexicans just came in over the border illegally
    • PENS FAN  •  Tampa, Florida  •  4 months ago
      He should be suspended for choosing Fausto Carmona as his name.
    • everything4lessstore.com  •  4 months ago
      He should not even be allowed back in the USA let alone be in MLB. There has to be consequences.

    Yahoo! Sports Authors