But when the Panthers were down to their final chance to surprise the Kansas City Chiefs at Arrowhead Stadium on Sunday, Carolina head coach Matt Rhule called for a 67-yard field-goal attempt to win it.
it was the Panthers’ fourth loss in a row and the Chiefs’ fourth win in a row.
The Panthers played with a nothing-to-lose approach in the game, and it was close throughout. They took a 14-6 lead in the first half and led 17-13 at halftime.
Bridgewater completed 36 of 49 passes for 310 yards and two touchdowns, as well as running for a score in the fourth quarter that cut into the Chiefs’ nine-point lead.
McCaffrey, playing for the first time since Sept. 20, ran for 69 yards and a score and had 10 catches (on 10 targets) for 82 yards and another TD.
The Panthers actually outgained Patrick Mahomes and the Chiefs, 435 yards to 397, and rang up 30 first downs, tying their season-high mark.
Shorthanded on defense, the Panthers struggled to contain Mahomes — 30 of 45 passing, 372 yards, four TDs — even while the Kansas City run game was held to 30 yards on 12 carries. Tyreek Hill caught two TDs, and Travis Kelce had 10 grabs for 159 yards.
The Panthers got the ball back with 1:26 remaining at their own 9-yard line after a defensive stop — and no timeouts remaining. Two defensive penalties to the Chiefs and four Bridgewater completions had the Panthers in business, though, with 10 seconds remaining at the Chiefs’ 49-yard line.
A short pass to McCaffrey didn’t gain any yards, and it took five seconds off the clock. The Panthers threw once more to McCaffrey to make it a shorter try, but the pass was incomplete.
Matt Rhule on would-be record-breaking field goal
Should Rhule have kept the offense on the field for a Hail Mary?
He opted for the kick that would have been 3 yards longer than Matt Prater’s 64-yard record — and on the 50th anniversary of Tom Dempsey’s 63-yard record breaker that stood for more than 43 years before Prater broke it in 2013.
Slye had hit a 47-yarder with ease earlier in the game. He’d hit 19 of 22 FG tries this season, and his career long is 55 yards, although Slye just missed a 65-yard attempt two weeks ago.
According to Twitter reports during pregame, Slye was hitting on tries 60 yards and longer. He also was short on a field-goal try from — yep — 67 yards in college in 2015.
The attempt that counted in this game was pushed right. But Slye had the leg for it.
Here was Rhule’s reasoning:
Matt Rhule said having wind at Joey Slye's back went into decision to go for the 67-yarder.
— Joe Person (@josephperson) November 8, 2020
Should Rhule have had Bridgewater uncork one? Or was turning it over to Slye’s big leg the right call?
More from Yahoo Sports: