Nottingham Forest and Everton face points deduction after Premier League spending breach charges

Morgan Gibbs-White and Anthony Gordon - Nottingham Forest and Everton charged for Premier League spending breaches

Everton hit out at the Premier League as they face a second points deduction after being charged with spending breaches alongside Nottingham Forest.

A “clear deficiency” in rules was cited by the Merseyside club as the league moved to punish them again, two months after they were docked 10 points.

England’s top tier said in a statement that Everton and Forest had “each confirmed” breaches in the league’s Profitability and Sustainability Rules. But as the pair were referred to independent commissions, Everton attacked a fast-track process already facing scrutiny while the complex Manchester City case remains unresolved.

The Premier League enraged Everton by applying its normal three-year £105million maximum on club overspend calculations. Forest, promoted in 2022, were said to have breached a lower threshold on losses at £61million.

Everton claim that including two of three years for which the club has already been sanctioned creates a legal minefield given the club is already appealing the prior punishment. “The club must now defend another Premier League complaint which includes the very same financial periods for which it has already been sanctioned, before that appeal has even been heard,” Everton said. “The club takes the view that this results from a clear deficiency in the Premier League’s rules.”

Everton to argue loans required for infrastructure costs

Another gloomy precedent set by Monday’s charge means Everton, already just one point above the relegation zone, face the prospect of a third potential spending row next season. One of the league’s key arguments with Everton is over loan repayments covering 2021-22 and whether they could be offset against the Bramley-Moore Dock stadium development or working capital.

Everton and Forest had been told they would be charged just hours before an announcement from the Premier League. “Everton FC and Nottingham Forest FC have each confirmed to the Premier League that they are in breach of the League’s Profitability and Sustainability Rules (PSR),” the competition said.

Only the “most exceptional cases”, including the 115 charges facing City, are exempt from new Premier League rules that any club charged with a standard financial rule breach must be completed within 12 weeks. The new rules compelled Everton, Forest and all other clubs to file 2022-23 accounts by December. 31, instead of March under the old rules.

Farhad Moshiri - Nottingham Forest and Everton charged for Premier League spending breaches
Everton are already appealing a 10-point penalty for earlier PSR breaches committed under the ownership of Farhad Moshiri - Getty Images/Alex Livesey

But both Everton and Forest believe they have strong cases to fight the prospect of fresh penalties under the new fast-track punishment model. Forest will argue for dispensation to include profits from the sale of Brennan Johnson two months after the end of the period in question. Forest said it “intends to continue to cooperate fully with the Premier League on this matter and are confident of a speedy and fair resolution.”

A total of 30 new players arrived in the season after Forest secured promotion to the Premier League in 2022, ending an absence of 23 years from the top division.

The team’s record signing had been Morgan Gibbs-White from Wolves at £25 million, which increased to £30 million when the club avoided relegation.

Other significant buys included Taiwo Awoniyi (£17.5 million from Union Berlin), Neco Williams (£17 million from Liverpool) and Danilo (£16 million from Palmeiras).

Yet it was the signings of free agent Jesse Lingard (who was earning a basic £80,000 a week before bonuses), Paris St-Germain goalkeeper Keylor Navas and a litany of players who never featured which appeared to be calculated, yet expensive, gambles.

Keylor Navas playing in goal for Nottingham Forest last season
Keylor Navas was one of a number of Nottingham Forest signings out on heft wages - AP/Rui Vieira

In contrast, Everton’s transfer dealings in recent years have been relatively modest. The departure of £250,000-a-week James Rodríguez had been a major relief for the wage bill as he left the club in the autumn of 2021. Over the ensuing year, Richarlison was sold to Tottenham for around £50 million, Anthony Gordon fetched more than £40 million from Newcastle but Amadou Onana, Dwight McNeil and Neal Maupay arrived for multi-million pound fees.

In vowing to fight the latest spending charge, Everton added: “The Premier League does not have guidelines which prevent a club being sanctioned for alleged breaches in financial periods which have already been subject to punishment, unlike other governing bodies, including the EFL.

“As a result – and because of the Premier League’s new commitment to deal with such matters ‘in-season’ – the club is in a position where it has had no option but to submit a PSR calculation which remains subject to change, pending the outcome of the appeal....Everton can assure its fans that it will continue to defend its position during the ongoing appeal and, should it be required to do so, at any future commission – and that the impact on supporters will be reflected as part of that process.”

Forest will say they were right to hang on to Brennan Johnson

Forest, meanwhile, have enlisted leading sports lawyer Nick De Marco as they attempt to avoid becoming the third top flight club to be punished over alleged breaches after Everton and City.

Forest reported an annual loss of £45.6 million in their last accounts but the Premier League has deemed the club breach a limit of £61m across the three years and said: “Due to Nottingham Forest spending two seasons in the Championship within the three-year assessment period, the maximum loss for the club is £61 million.”

In the previous year, ending June 2021, they recorded a loss of £34.4 million, reduced to a loss before tax of £15.5 million.

Nottingham Forest owner Evangelos Marinakis  - Nottingham Forest and Everton charged for Premier League spending breaches
Nottingham Forest owner Evangelos Marinakis has spent more than £250 million on players since their promotion in the summer of 2022 - Getty Images/Richard Heathcote

The sale of Johnson to Tottenham, as Telegraph Sport reported on January 2, will be a key plank in mitigation. Johnson was sold for £47.5 million on deadline day – a record sale for the club – and Forest will insist that they would have received a far lower fee if they had accepted an offer earlier in the summer. Brentford failed with two offers of £30 million and £35 million for the Wales international in June and July respectively.

Everton were handed the biggest punishment in Premier League history by an independent commission in December. They have appealed against the decision to dock them 10 points, which will be heard and concluded before the end of the season.

Manchester City were charged in February with 115 alleged breaches and that case remains ongoing with the club strongly denying the charges. Chelsea are also being investigated after referring evidence to the Premier League in connection with transfer deals struck during the Roman Abramovich era.

Forest are currently 15th in the Premier League, while Everton are a point and a place above the relegation zone.

Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month, then enjoy 1 year for just $9 with our US-exclusive offer.