Lawrie left the game at Cincinnati in the middle of the second inning with a broken right index finger after being hit by a pitch. He was replaced by Steve Tolleson.
But before he left he had a sacrifice bunt that set up Colby Rasmus' two-run single, giving the Blue Jays a 2-1 lead.
Jose Reyes, who left Saturday's game after fouling a ball off the side of his left knee, pinch-ran for Bautista, who had reached on an error, and stayed in the game to play shortstop.
Bautista has been scheduled for an MRI on Monday.