Malcolm Butler's last-second interception return may have cost people a lot of money

<a class="link rapid-noclick-resp" href="/nfl/players/28244/" data-ylk="slk:Malcolm Butler">Malcolm Butler</a> cost gamblers a lot of money. (Getty Images)
Malcolm Butler cost gamblers a lot of money. (Getty Images)

Tennessee Titans cornerback Malcolm Butler might be the most hated player in the world among a certain group of football fans. With his last-second interception return during Saturday’s game against the Washington Redskins, Butler cost some people a lot of money.

[Play in our Week 16 DFS contest: $1M prize pool. $100K to first. Join now!]

Scroll to continue with content

We’re talking, of course, about those football fans who decided to wager some hard-earned gummy bears on the game. At most sportsbooks, the over/under for the contest was set at 37 points or higher.

With one second left, the under seemed certain to hit. Down 19-16, Washington heaved a desperation Hail Mary from deep in its own territory. The ball was intercepted by Butler.

Nine times out of 10, the cornerback would take a knee in his situation. Butler didn’t do that. He ran the ball all the way back, scoring a touchdown as time expired. The Titans won the game 25-16, meaning the over hit literally at the last second.

The gambling implications didn’t end there. At most sportsbooks, the Titans were favored to win by at least 10 points. All the Titans needed to do was kick the extra point to give bettors a push. To the surprise of many, that didn’t happen.

Due to a rule change during the offseason, the Titans didn’t have to attempt the extra point.

Since the extra point would not have impacted the outcome of the game, the Titans didn’t kick it. The team won by nine points, infuriating everyone who bet on them to cover.

This is what gamblers refer to as a bad beat. And while Butler’s interception may not have been the worst bad beat of all-time, it’s still pretty rare for a last-second play to greatly impact not one, but two, significant betting lines.

– – – – – – –

Chris Cwik is a writer for Yahoo Sports. Have a tip? Email him at or follow him on Twitter!

More from Yahoo Sports:

Subscribe to The Yahoo Sports NFL Podcast
Apple PodcastsStitcherGoogle Podcasts

Lakers in driver’s seat to pair LeBron, A.D.
Steelers’ Smith-Schuster tells fantasy owners he’s playing
’Miami Miracle’ football up for auction; price will be steep
Man United rolls in first post-Mourinho match, and that’s no coincidence

What to Read Next