Eagles mailbag: Who is the Eagles' 2019 MVP so far?

Dave Zangaro

Since the Eagles play on Monday night this week, we have an extra day to wait for their game against the Giants. 

So let's take a dip into the mailbag. As always, thanks for all your great questions. 

We'll get to some more tomorrow. 

This is a simple question, but it's not a simple answer. Far from it. I spent way too much time thinking about this question, so I'll walk you through some of my thought process. First, I came up with a list of players I deemed eligible: Carson Wentz, Rodney McLeod, Jordan Howard, Miles Sanders, Brandon Graham, Lane Johnson, Brandon Brooks, Zach Ertz, Fletcher Cox. 

Wentz: I had to include the quarterback, but he isn't playing as well as he needs to play. I still think he's far from their biggest problem, but he's not the MVP either. 

McLeod: You wouldn't know he's coming back from injury and he's been solid. But he hasn't really made many splash plays either. 

Howard: The Eagles were 5-4 with Howard and are 0-3 without him. That shows how important he has been to this team. But he's about to miss his fourth straight game, so he's eliminated. 

Sanders: An interesting choice. The rookie running back got off to a slow start but is averaging 4.5 yards per carry and has been one of the most explosive playmakers on offense. 

Graham: There aren't many players who are exceeding expectations this season, but Graham is one of them. He has 7 1/2 sacks to lead the team and has been consistently good, even before those sacks started piling up. 

Johnson: He missed one game with a concussion, but the right tackle has been as solid as they come this season. He was rewarded with a big contract and should be heading back to the Pro Bowl. 

Brooks: Like Graham, Brooks is one of the few players exceeding expectations. He missed most of one game after a return of his anxiety, but aside from that, he's been their most reliable offensive lineman. And that's after coming back from an Achilles tear. 

Ertz: Ertz has been the Eagles' best offensive weapons again this season. He has 70 catches for 736 yards and three touchdowns. He's on pace for 93 catches for 981 yards. Another great season, but a drop from his numbers in 2018 and he's made more mistakes this year. 

Cox: He's still their best player and he has come on incredibly strong, but he got off to a slow start coming back from injury. He always has a strong case. 

My verdict: I'm going with Graham. On offense, my pick would have been Brooks, but I'm going with the best player on what has been the stronger unit. Graham got paid this offseason and has been very good and consistent. He has a shot at his first 10-sack season and is still as stout in the run game as ever. 

(Note: It's not a good sign that it was this hard.) 

I don't think so. Right or wrong, the Eagles are committed to Ronald Darby and Jalen Mills as their starting corners. Now, if one of them were to get hurt, they'd have a decision. Ultimately, I think Maddox is either a nickel corner or a safety. As unorthodox as it might be for a guy of his size (5-9, 184), I really liked him at safety last year. 

During the 2018 season, Jim Schwartz compared Maddox to Cortland Finnegan. But I have another comp for Maddox. When he was playing safety last year, I saw a little Bob Sanders. Not saying he'll be that good, but a smaller safety with ball skills who can still hit. The Eagles will have a decision to make on McLeod this offseason. If he's not back, I'd think about Maddox at FS. 

Tough question because they've lost these games in different ways. Since the offense barely showed up in two of those three games, I'll go with the lack of offensive consistency. Even in the game when they scored 31, they couldn't get points late. 

As much as they don't look like contenders, it's Doug Pederson's job to try to win games. And this team still has a really legitimate shot to make it into the playoffs. And if they win the division, they get a first-round home playoff game. I know it's unlikely this team goes on a run to the Super Bowl, but they have to at least try to get to the playoffs and see what happens. Remember, they were pretty darn close to advancing to the NFC Championship Game last year after starting that season with a 4-6 record. Gotta at least try. 

I have actually talked to people about this before. I really don't think they could bring him back. They made their decision to go with Carson Wentz - and it wasn't even like they thought about it. Bringing back Foles would put so much unnecessary pressure on Wentz, it wouldn't be fair. From a football standpoint, it would make a ton of sense. But everything the Eagles do should be with Wentz in mind. I wouldn't do it. 

Click here to download the MyTeams App by NBC Sports! Receive comprehensive coverage of your teams and stream the Flyers, Sixers and Phillies games easily on your device.

More on the Eagles

Eagles mailbag: Who is the Eagles' 2019 MVP so far? originally appeared on NBC Sports Philadelphia