Detroit Tigers rally to force extras, but whiff away in 10th in 4-3 loss to Guardians

·5 min read

The Detroit Tigers were swept by the Cleveland Guardians in three games at Comerica Park, capped by Thursday's 4-3 defeat in extra innings.

The Tigers (43-70) — worst in the American League Central and the third MLB team to reach 70 losses — have fallen short in 23 of 30 games dating to July 9, including consecutive losses since owner Christopher Ilitch fired general manager Al Avila before Wednesday's game.

Designated hitter Kerry Carpenter finished 0-for-4 with three strikeouts and has not reached base through two games in his MLB career.

Detroit Tigers third baseman Willi Castro (9) catches a fly ball hit by Cleveland Guardians DH Jose Ramirez (11) during first inning action Thursday, August 11, 2022 at Comerica Park.
Detroit Tigers third baseman Willi Castro (9) catches a fly ball hit by Cleveland Guardians DH Jose Ramirez (11) during first inning action Thursday, August 11, 2022 at Comerica Park.

MITCH ALBOM: Tigers dump Al Avila, whose moves too often came up empty

SHAWN WINDSOR: Christopher Ilitch must own Tigers' futility. He (sort of) did in firing Al Avila

Detroit's offense scored seven runs in the three-game series, and on Thursday, the underperforming lineup posted seven hits, two walks and 14 strikeouts. The seven hits came from Victor Reyes (single), Javier Báez (single and home run), Willi Castro (two singles and a double) and Jonathan Schoop (double).

Two runs from the Tigers in the bottom of the ninth inning knotted the score at three and sent the game to extra innings. Manager A.J. Hinch brought in closer Gregory Soto to pitch the top of the 10th.

Soto retired the first two batters, but 24-year-old rookie Oscar Gonzalez slapped a second-pitch sinker into right-center field. The ball traveled far enough for Jose Ramirez — the free extra-innings runner — to score from second base for a 4-3 lead.

Three Tigers hitters — Reyes, Báez and Harold Castro — failed to push a run across in the bottom of the 10th against right-handed reliever Bryan Shaw. Báez and Castro struck out swinging to strand Greene (who opened the inning at second) at third to end the game.

Detroit Tigers center fielder Riley Greene (31) bats against Cleveland Guardians starting pitcher Zach Plesac (34) during first inning action Thursday, August 11, 2022 at Comerica Park.
Detroit Tigers center fielder Riley Greene (31) bats against Cleveland Guardians starting pitcher Zach Plesac (34) during first inning action Thursday, August 11, 2022 at Comerica Park.

Rally Cats

The Tigers, trailing 3-1, rallied against right-hander Trevor Stephan in the bottom of the ninth inning, as Guardians closer Emmanuel Clase was unavailable due to his recent workload. Harold Castro and Willi Castro reached on a walk and a single, respectively, before Schoop ripped a double past the third baseman and into left field.

Down 3-2, the Tigers had runners on second and third base with nobody out. Carpenter struck out for the first out, then Miguel Cabrera — pinch-hitting for Tucker Barnhart — was intentionally walked to load the bases.

Righty Enyel De Los Santos replaced Stephan for a matchup with Eric Haase.

Haase hit the ball back toward De Los Santos.

The ball deflected off the pitcher and bounced to second baseman Andres Gimenez. He flipped to shortstop Amed Rosario covering the bag for the second out, but in the process, Willi Castro scored. Gimenez dropped the ball on the transfer, preventing an attempt at a double play. The Tigers challenged the out call at second, but it was upheld upon review.

Rookie Riley Greene, who finished 0-for-5 with three strikeouts, struck out swinging to strand runners on the corners.

Sacked by Plesac

Guardians right-hander Zach Plesac, who entered with a 4.49 ERA in 20 starts, faced the most pressure in the fourth inning, when Báez's one-out single and Castro's two-out double put two runners in scoring position.

But Schoop popped out to first on a first-pitch fastball.

In the sixth, the Tigers finally scored.

Plesac quickly retired Greene and Reyes — the top two batters in the Tigers' order — before battling Báez for the third time. Báez hammered a third-pitch fastball in the strike zone for a solo home run. The ball traveled 380 feet and cleared the wall in left field.

He has a team-high 11 home runs this season.

After Báez's homer, Harold Castro drew a walk.

Plesac escaped further damage by striking out Willi Castro looking with a ninth-pitch curveball. He also struck out three straight batters in the first inning: Greene (fastball, swinging), Reyes (changeup, swinging) and Báez (fastball, looking).

Plesac allowed one run on four hits and one walk with seven strikeouts across 6⅓ innings, throwing 63 of 100 pitches for strikes. He recorded 14 swings and misses with all four pitches: four fastballs, two changeups, two curveballs and six sliders.

Running up that Hill

Right-hander Garrett Hill, making the seventh start of his MLB career, worked under duress for most of his outing, but the 26-year-old rookie gave up three runs (one earned run) on four hits and two walks with one strikeout.

The Guardians scored one run each in the second, fourth and fifth innings.

JEFF SEIDEL: Christopher Ilitch has big task ahead: Find GM that lines up with A.J. Hinch

EVAN PETZOLD: How Tigers can go about cleaning up mess left by general manager Al Avila

Detroit Tigers starter Garrett Hill (50) pitches against the Cleveland Guardians during second inning action Thursday, August 11, 2022 at Comerica Park.
Detroit Tigers starter Garrett Hill (50) pitches against the Cleveland Guardians during second inning action Thursday, August 11, 2022 at Comerica Park.

In the second, Báez tried to turn a double play after Harold Castro's diving stop, but the shortstop threw wild to first base as Hill rushed to cover the bag. Báez's 18th error this season allowed the runner to score easily from third base for a 1-0 Guardians advantage.

Another error doomed Hill in the fourth. After Andres Gimenez reached on a hit-by-pitch, Oscar Gonzalez reached safely on a fielder's choice. Willi Castro, the third baseman, committed a fielding error and both runners were safe.

A two-out RBI single from Luke Maile increased Cleveland's margin to 2-0.

The Guardians scored their third run — Hill's first earned run — in the fifth, when Steven Kwan connected with a curveball at the bottom of the strike zone for a solo home run and a 3-0 lead. It was Kwan's third homer this season.

For Hill's 89 pitches (54 strikes), he tossed 45 four-seam fastballs (51%), 22 sliders (25%), 12 sinkers (13%), six changeups (7%) and four curveballs (4%). He recorded three swings and misses and 14 called strikes.

Four relievers held the Guardians scoreless: Jose Cisnero in the sixth inning, Jason Foley in the seventh, Will Vest in the eighth and Luis Castillo in the ninth. Vest worked around two hits and recorded the lone strikeout among the group.

Báez was responsible for his 19th error in the ninth inning.

Contact Evan Petzold at epetzold@freepress.com or follow him on Twitter @EvanPetzoldRead more on the Detroit Tigers and sign up for our Tigers newsletter.

This article originally appeared on Detroit Free Press: Detroit Tigers whiff in 10th inning in 4-3 loss to Cleveland Guardians