Comments by Utah coach Kyle Whittingham on realignment have everyone talking
A few days ago, Utah football head coach Kyle Whittingham made some newsworthy remarks in a conversation with Utah-based radio host and podcaster Spence Checketts.
Whittingham was discussing the future of the BYU-Utah football rivalry, but what he said about that game also flowed into the larger discussion of college sports conference realignment.
It’s a much longer conversation, so you will want to listen to the full show to get the complete context. That said, this one paragraph is impossible to ignore. It reasonably caused a stir:
“Well, first of all, you use the word permanently, and I can say it’s far from that,” Whittingham said. “I think in two-to-three, maybe five years at the outside, everything is gonna change again. And so this may be just a quick couple years of the game (BYU-Utah) returning, and then everything is blown up again and people go their separate ways.”
Since BYU-Utah will be a conference game in the Big 12, people will obviously wonder what Whittingham thinks about the structure of conference realignment in several years. It is reasonable to think that a lot of changes (Florida State and Clemson to the SEC, for example) will occur. How far these changes spread is obviously something we’ll all wonder about.
Let’s gather some reactions to Whittingham’s comments and then make a few extra points at the very end:
VERY INTERESTING REMARKS
Utah’s Kyle Whittingham doesn’t seem to be sold on the long-term future of the Big 12. 👀 https://t.co/5H5Z2lISEV
— Heartland College Sports (@Heartland_CS) August 26, 2023
NOT REALLY THE POINT OF THIS
Utah has a small fan base & play in a small stadium. They aren’t going anywhere.
— Steven Rule (@Steven505rule) August 27, 2023
NOT SURE UTAH TO THE BIG TEN IS THE POINT OF THIS, EITHER
Ute fans still think they're destined for the B1G but the only problem is, there's at least 10 teams in front of them including 3 current B12 members. They simply don't bring enough to the table for the B1G.
— Aaron (@Aaron_Staats) August 27, 2023
NOT REALLY
Those people out at U are special.
— Relaxed but Uptight. (@Troubleallday) August 27, 2023
MEME TIME
— CarlitosCoog (@Yo_CarlitosWey) August 27, 2023
POLL VOTE!
Can we replace Utah? I hope at next year’s media days someone remembers to ask Kyle Whittingham if he still thinks Big 12 will be blown up in 2-5 years and Utah will go their separate ways
— Lott Hall (@Lott_Hall) August 28, 2023
EMBRACE DEBATE
Kyle Whittingham has repeatedly said for the past few years that he believes super-conferences will be the reality. Nothing he said to Spencer Checketts was inconsistent with his past statements on conference realignment. He was not taking a jab at the Big 12.
— John Coon (@johncoonsports) August 25, 2023
LEGAL STUFF
Utah signed the GoR to join the Big 12. That GoR lasts until 2031. Nobody is going anywhere until then. Somebody should inform Coach Whittingham that the Utes will be facing BYU for the next 7 years at least.
— ❄ Seth ❄ (@KUandUofAfan) August 25, 2023
SPECULATION
This is going to be 4 conferences of 28-34 teams each split into 4 divisions each where they will play 8 division games with 4 cross over games. Then the top teams in each 16 divisions get into the CFP playoff. Start off with a 2 game conference playoff as CFP.
— Gnaw On Wood (@Beav_fan_in_NE) August 27, 2023
SALTY
Translation: #utah is just making a truck stop in the #big12 trailer park conference lol https://t.co/dhKKjKuWqa
— DreamBackfield.com (@IntoPitt) August 26, 2023
OUR ANALYSIS
Florida State definitely wants out of the ACC. It seems the Seminoles are going to leave. It’s a question of when, not if. It might take four years, it might take six, it might take eight, but this domino will eventually fall. How much this triggers other actions will be one of the central questions of the future of realignment.
ACC STRATEGY
The ACC, if it does choose to add Stanford, Cal, and SMU, would be doing so precisely to guard against Florida State and Clemson (maybe other schools) leaving. The conference would have other schools in high-profile media markets to cushion the blow of schools leaving. This is the “volume” play the Pac-12 failed to make by adding San Diego State and SMU.
BIG PICTURE
No matter which school you root for, you know realignment is not a particularly logical thing. Arizona State at West Virginia will be a conference game in the Big 12. Oregon at Rutgers will be a conference game in the Big Ten. Stanford at North Carolina could soon become a conference game in the ACC. All this travel for athletes just doesn’t seem right to a lot of people.
Whittingham seems to be pleading for sanity and a redrawing of the whole map. If that’s one of the underlying points of emphasis in his remarks, he wouldn’t be wrong or misguided.
This is less about Utah versus BYU in football, more about trying to bring some sanity back to college sports. (Good luck, Kyle.)