In a recent episode, a man named "John" brought along what he said was an authentic Willie Mays game-used uniform from 1961, the prime of his Hall of Fame career with the San Francisco Giants. Not just a top, either, but a uniform — jersey
and pants — and it was a beaut:
The agreed-upon price between John and shop representative Corey Harrison? $31,000.
The garments included many of the key details required to identify authentic game-worn Giants clothing from 50 years ago: The woolen flannel materials, a Spalding label and the stitching of Mays' name, along with his uniform number and measurements, into the clothing. (Willie was a size 42 jersey, with a 33-inch waist and a 26-inch inseam on the pants — which didn't go down to the cleats in those days.)
It's not impossible to fake something like this — especially now, when there's a strong market for legitimate reproductions. Also, as Chumley cautioned, the uniform looked almost too pristine to be 50 years old, and to have been used in games by Willie Mays:
"This doesn't look game-worn. Willie Mays was a bad ass. He was sliding around in the dirt and the grass. I'd imagine there'd be a bunch of stains on it."
Further, as Corey pointed out, players of Mays' generation didn't get many uniforms to rotate annually. You'd figure most game-worn stuff of the time would be beat up. Apparently, these clothes just slipped through time mostly unscathed.
The seller didn't say so on "Pawn Stars," but I found an earlier video of him taking the jersey to "Antiques Roadshow," that
modern classic from PBS. He admitted to having the garment "pressed" but said he wasn't even sure what it was made of, and seemed afraid to clean it. The man from Heritage Auctions told him it might be worth up to $35,000 — at an auction. So naturally, the man took the Mays collection to ... a pawn shop in Vegas .
and "Pawn Stars"? This dude is a trollop when it comes to reality show finds, isn't he? He didn't need to get top dollar. He just needed to be on TV so we could all watch him get appraisals. I feel so ... used. Anyway...)
The pawn shop also brought in a local memorabilia expert, who said the uniform was legit. He couldn't, however, confirm that Mays ever actually wore it in a game. That detail usually keeps the price down, and probably did in this case. Another Mays jersey, which was proven to have been worn by him when he played for the minor-league Minneapolis Millers in 1951, went for
$44,063 at auction in 2011.
The Giants jersey seller said the uniform had been a family heirloom since the late 1960s, adding:
"I'd like to just cash in on it. I've had it sitting in the closet. It's time for it to go."
Well, no sentimental hogwash there. But if it really were stuffed in a closet in a box, but preferably in a garment bag, those conditions would help to keep it fresh.
Other than the uniform itself, the best part of the episode was the haggling the seller did with Corey, who obviously was trying to get off cheaply. The seller opened with $45,000, and Corey responded with $20,000. Low-ball much? He clearly was unhappy to come up to $31,000 after the guy called his bluff and said he was taking his business elsewhere.
And where was that, exactly? "Cash in the Attic"?
Big BLS H/N: The Huffington Post Love baseball? Even like it a little? Follow @AnswerDave, @bigleaguestew, @KevinKaduk on Twitter, along with the BLS Facebook page!