You could also easily fill a second team with either All-Stars (Shea Hillenbrand, Scott Cooper) or batting champions (Carney Lansford, Bill Mueller).
Get the latest news and analysis on all of your teams from NBC Sports Boston by downloading the My Teams App
Picking the actual top five isn't easy, especially if we eliminate some of the aforementioned players, who will appear on other lists (we're limiting each player to one appearance overall).
The first two are Hall of Famers and no-brainers. After that comes a long-time standout, a World Series hero, and finally, a budding star who we suspect will finish his career even higher on this list.
Who are the best third basemen in Red Sox history? Ranking the Top 5 originally appeared on NBC Sports Boston