Bad draft class? Many fifth-year options not picked up for 2016 first-round picks

One of the benefits a team gets when it drafts a player in the first round is the fifth-year option on those contracts. If a player does well, a team gets a fifth year out of that player before worrying about them hitting free agency.

Typically, if a player shows promise, exercising the option becomes an easy decision. While it’s far from a guarantee that the fifth-year option gets picked up, it’s not a great sign when teams decline.

[Join or create a 2019 Yahoo Fantasy Football league for free today]

This year, based on various reports, 12 of the 31 2016 first-round picks didn’t have their fifth-year option picked up, and Corey Coleman and Paxton Lynch have already been released from their rookie contracts (there were 31 first-round picks because New England’s was taken away as a result of the deflate-gate scandal).

When close to half of the first-round picks in a class don’t get their fifth-year option, that’s not good.

Who are the 2016 picks who had their options declined?

Here’s the list of players who, according to’s tracker, won’t have their fifth-year options exercised, along with their draft position (Coleman was the 15th pick and Lynch was 26th):

8. Tennessee Titans OT Jack Conklin

10. New Orleans Saints CB Eli Apple

14. Oakland Raiders S Karl Joseph

15. Cleveland Browns WR Corey Coleman (traded, released)

19. Buffalo Bills DE Shaq Lawson

20. New York Jets LB Darron Lee

22. Washington Redskins WR Josh Doctson

23. Minnesota Vikings WR Laquon Treadwell

25. Pittsburgh Steelers CB Artie Burns

26. Denver Broncos QB Paxton Lynch (released)

28. San Francisco 49ers G Joshua Garnett

29. Arizona Cardinals DL Robert Nkemdiche

30. Carolina Panthers DT Vernon Butler

31. Seattle Seahawks OL Germain Ifedi

Want a reminder that nobody in last week’s draft is a sure thing? Read that list again.

Other than Conklin, who was a surprise because he has been a solid tackle for the Titans, most of the players on that list have ranged from disappointing to outright failures. Many in that class are quite good, especially at the top — Jared Goff, Carson Wentz, Joey Bosa, Ezekiel Elliott, Jalen Ramsey to name a few — but overall the 2016 class will also be remembered as one with a bad hit rate.

Eli Apple was the 10th pick of the 2016 draft by the Giants, but has been traded and won't have his fifth-year option exercised by the Saints. (AP)
Eli Apple was the 10th pick of the 2016 draft by the Giants, but has been traded and won't have his fifth-year option exercised by the Saints. (AP)

Many 2016 first-rounders will be free agents in 2020

There are good reasons to pass on the fifth-year option. The salaries go up for the fifth year, if the option is exercised. The top 10 picks get an average of the 10 highest salaries at their position, and the rest of the first round is an average of the third through 25th highest salaries for their position. That’s a significant investment. However, the salaries aren’t guaranteed unless there’s an injury, lessening the risk.

Last year, 12 fifth-year options were declined. The year before, nine players were declined or released before their rookie contracts were up. So 14 of 31 isn’t that far off the norm. But it’s a high number.

Just because a player doesn’t get the fifth year picked up doesn’t mean he’s a bust. Chicago Bears cornerback Kyle Fuller might be the best example of a player breaking out in his fourth year after having his option declined. Players like Conklin, Apple (who was originally a Giants draft pick and traded to the Saints) or Doctson, who are still getting significant playing time, could end up seeing the light turn on in 2019, making those respective teams regret not using the fifth-year option.

There were many mistakes made in that 2016 draft, and some teams seem ready to move on.

– – – – – – –

Frank Schwab is a writer for Yahoo Sports. Have a tip? Email him at or follow him on Twitter! Follow @YahooSchwab

More from Yahoo Sports: