WASHINGTON -- Another sloppy defensive performance looked like it would doom the Capitals, but a furious three-goal rally in the second period turned what looked like a sure defeat into a stunning 4-3 victory, their first at home this season, over the Toronto Maple Leafs on Wednesday.
Toronto took an early lead off a short-handed goal from Kasperi Kapanen. Jonas Siegenthaler then was slow to react to a streaking Ilya Mikheyev who torched him to put the Leafs up 2-0. Jakub Vrana made it 2-1 late in the first, but Toronto looked like they had this game well in hand.
But the Caps rallied and completely turned things around in a stretch of just 1:18 in the second period.
Observations from the win
Maybe it's not the goaltending….
We learned a lot from this game about the goaltending. First off, Braden Holtby is not the problem when it comes to keeping pucks out of the net. Obviously he has to be better than he was on Monday, but the defensive breakdowns from Monday were back again on Wednesday. The worst was a misplay by Siegenthaler who was far too slow to recognize Mikheyev streaking up the ice through the middle. When he received a pass from Kapanen it was already too late. Mikheyev easily skated around Siegenthaler to create the breakaway and the goal.
The second thing to note, Samsonov is very good and is going to be very good, but he is still raw and still developing. The biggest issue I see in his game is his tendency to overcommit. When the puck was on the side of the net, Samsonov would sell out in anticipation of the shot. There was one instance in the first period where the puck was passed to John Tavares and Samsonov slid over so hard to cover it, he almost took himself out of the net completely. Tavares' head was down as he tried to control the puck, but if he had his head up, he would have passed that puck back to the middle and it would have been an easy goal.
"He's extremely athletic," Todd Reirden said after the game. "You go back to some other guys that are his size from his homeland that are active like that, one of the things they have to do when they come over is be a little bit more under control just because of the puck movement and the skill level of guys changing pucks side to side that you don't take yourself out of plays."
To his credit, Samsonov settled down after the first period, which Reirden also noted. I wonder if it will be hard on goalie coach Scott Murray to coach two players with such contrasting styles. Holtby is the exact opposite of Samsonov with calm, cool movements that some detractors incorrectly identify as a disinterest.
So what do you do Friday? You put Holtby back in. If you don't then you are needlessly creating a goalie controversy. It doesn't mean anything if you don't play the backup two-straight games, but it means a heck of a lot if you go back to Samsonov after an OK, but not great game. There's no need. Go back to Holtby and hope that he has had enough time to reset and go forward knowing you can be comfortable putting in Samsonov 25-30 games.
John Carlson is incredible
The debate is now over. For years there were still the people who would cling to their old bias and reach out to me on Twitter complaining Carlson was overrated because they saw him turn the puck over that one time a few years ago.
Carlson went from good to great in the Stanley Cup year, to elite in 2018-19 and now he has gone even beyond that. This is a superstar player.
WIth one goal and two assists, Carlson now has 14 points on the season (and was briefly leading the entire league in points). From where I was sitting in the press box, I was essentially directly down the line from him on the Jakub Vrana goal. Carlson had the puck and it looked like he had no outlet to pass whatsoever. He faked the shot, and suddenly I saw the seas part and there was a direct lane to Vrana for the one-timer. I saw it as it happened, but Carlson clearly saw it before it happened and anticipated that play. It was brilliant.
But you already knew he was good on offense. The knock on him has always been his defense, but we need to get over that. Morgan Rielly is a highly regarded defenseman across the league and someone, with 72 points last year, who received some votes and consideration for the Norris last season. No one could have watched Wednesday's game and come away thinking that Rielly is more important to his team than Carlson is. If you did, you were watching a different game than I was.
Carlson is an elite defenseman and I will say it now, he will be a Norris finalist this season.
It took the Caps 78 seconds to turn a game that looked similar to Monday's debacle into a win. Evgeny Kuznetsov glided into the offensive zone faster than anyone on the ice could skate and tucked the puck around the outstretched pad of Michael Hutchinson. Just 11 seconds later, Nicklas Backstrom cashed in on the hard forechecking work of T.J. Oshie. The flustered Leafs took two penalties giving Washington 1:51 of a 5-on-3 power play which Carlson scored on. Suddenly a 2-1 deficit for the Caps turned into a 4-2 lead all in a stretch of just 78 seconds.
Play of the night
Kuznetsov passed the puck up to the offensive blue line. A skating Carl Hagelin tapped it to Carlson who entered the zone, pulled back and handed it off to Kuznetsov who took over.
When Kuznetsov gets the puck there are three Maple Leaf players in front of him. He pumps the legs once and then glides in on net and somehow he is behind all three players and in alone on Hutchinson with relative ease.
This is art.
Kuznetsov's speed virtually never changes during the play. There's no frantic, choppy acceleration, just a smooth glide that allows him to skate in, wait out Hutchinson and tuck the puck around his outstretched pad all in seemingly one fluid motion.
Stat of the night
With one goal and two assists, Carlson now has 14 points on the season. At the time, that led the NHL. Both Connor McDavid and Leon Draisaitl passed him later on Wednesday with multi-point performances, but for a few hours, Carlson was the league-leader in points.
Quote of the night
Todd Reirden on how he felt when the team went down 2-0:
"I have to tell you tonight I wasn't concerned when we were down 2-0. I thought they converted on a couple chances but I had a good feeling about our team tonight, that there was no panic, we stayed with our game, we built and built and built, shift after shift and it was a matter of time. I was confident in our group tonight. Despite what happened last game, I felt felt strong about it."
So while Twitter was imploding and people were gathering the pitchforks and torches in the first period, Reirden had no doubt. That's why coaches don't read Twitter.
Vrana has a two point game tonight
— jimmy hutchins (@CAPSNFIVE) October 16, 2019
Vrana had one goal and another hit the post. So close!
the leafs get raptured during the second period
— formerly burakovskyeet (@vranaenae) October 16, 2019
This could explain what happened in those 78 seconds.
Top Line will have at least 4 points and John Carlson with a Goal and assist 👍🏻
— Stephen (@Steve_purcell32) October 16, 2019
Ovechkin (1 assist), Backstrom (1 goal, 1 assist) and Oshie (1 assist) did combine for four points. Carlson meanwhile had one goal and two assists. Nice job!
The cow was in section 225 or, as I like to call him, Sir Loin.
That you won't include my bold prediction in your recap 😢
— Mahesh Prasad (@UnleashTheHeshy) October 16, 2019
During line rushes Samsonov and Holtby rock/paper/scissors/lizard/Spock for who goes in net tonight. https://t.co/rMuqiIQ0Bo
— Neil Greenberg (@ngreenberg) October 16, 2019
What the heck are "lizard" and "spock?" Is this a thing? Have I been playing rock, paper, scissors wrong?
MORE CAPITALS NEWS:
Victory Tour: Delle Donne announces Caps starters
Mailbag: Can Samsonov overtake Holtby?
Uncertain Timetable: Not clear when Kempny returns
A 78 second rally turns a sure loss into the Caps first win at home originally appeared on NBC Sports Washington