Roy S. Johnson Blog

I'm done with debating whether Michael Vick should play. I believe once a citizen has paid dues for his crime, he should be able to earn a living. I also believe in forgiveness.

Lord knows I've needed some myself.

Moreover, Vick is going to play. Neither the torrent of venomous comments that accompany any story written anywhere about Vick, nor the threat of protesters, nor, clearly, the NFL commissioner will prevent that from happening.

Sometime by Week 6 of of the upcoming season, Vick will take the field in the NFL.

And he just might be a better quarterback than he ever was prior to serving nearly two years for bankrolling a dogfighting operation.

In fact, I'm willing to say he will be a better quarterback.

Certainly not on the first snap, or during the first series or first game. Probably not even during the first season.

But sometime before Vick takes his last snap, he'll prove to be better than the three-time Pro Bowler who was one of the game's most exciting players.

That will either be a towering task or pretty easy, depending on whether you believe Vick - who, in six seasons in Atlanta, led the Falcons to the playoffs twice and to the conference title game after the 2004 season - was a top-tier QB or a bust.

Most have set the bar pretty low for him, citing, essentially, atrophy. The layoff no doubt will have an effect. While he looks good in a suit (pretty much the only way we've seen him since he was released from prison), Vick is far from peak condition. And he hasn't been hit by any frothing 260-pound defensive ends in a while.

On the other hand, the latter may yet be a reason why he's probably healthier than any player reporting to training camp. Any injuries, nicks or bruises are surely healed. 

He's 29 years old. That's younger than Peyton Manning and Donovan McNabb. It's younger than Chad Pennington and David Garrard. It's younger than Jake Delhomme. It's younger than Tom Brady.

And it's light years younger than Kerry Collins and Kurt Warner.

It's even two months younger than Tony Romo.

Vick will be rusty, and at times he'll look bad, especially for a guy who relied on quick feet and instinct.

But no matter where he ends up (Seattle just might be the perfect franchise and city for him), age will not be a factor in Vick's success.

Though maybe somewhat dormant, his skills will still be there. His legs, his arm. He will still marvel.

It will take more than talent, of course. But beyond the talent around him, the offensive scheme and, maybe most importantly, the coach Vick plays for, the biggest factor in Vick's football future, and the reason he'll ultimately be a better quarterback, is that he's had to become a better man.

Prison breaks a man. And by all accounts, Michael Vick has been humbled. He's been forced to look at the depths of his heart and assess not just who he is but, most critically, who he wants to be.

I'm not really sure what "remorseful" means anymore -- the word gets tossed around so much as the emotion every tattered athlete must show in order to be forgiven that it means about as much as the final quarter of a preseason game. But whatever the definition, Vick has shown it enough to be conditionally reinstated by Roger Goodell.

I'm good on the remorse front.

I'm waiting to see what kind of man Michael Vick has become.

And if he's a better Michael Vick than the one we knew, being a better quarterback will be easy.

Reuters photo

Follow me on Twitter: www.twitter.com/roysj

digg delicious
more

596 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. Latasha C
    1. Posted by Latasha C Thu Jul 30, 2009 11:42 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I for one can't wait to see him back on the field. He has paid his debts and then some for what he did. People protest anything to push their own agendas. I say let the man play. Bottom line, if you love the game you will watch, but you do have a choice here. Lots of games play on different stations, so if you don't like it then change the channel!!! Stop crying about it already. No one condones what he did, it was truly a sick and twisted thing but now it is time to put that aside and let him get back to doing what he does best, and that is entertain us, and always give us a good show.
  2. mkucharski2
    2. Posted by mkucharski2 Thu Jul 30, 2009 11:42 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Vick should come to SD
  3. Christy H
    3. Posted by Christy H Thu Jul 30, 2009 11:48 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    go mike
  4. Christy H
    4. Posted by Christy H Thu Jul 30, 2009 11:50 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    please mike go to the cowboys!!!! tony romo, sucks.
  5. Rob S
    5. Posted by Rob S Thu Jul 30, 2009 11:50 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Whatever. As long as he stays the hell away from my Seahawks. I don't want his sorry butt on my team.
  6. Dan G
    6. Posted by Dan G Thu Jul 30, 2009 11:55 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Michael Vick should never be let into the NFL again. He tortured and killed dogs. I think they should stop convicted felons from being in the NFL. It is a priveledge not a right to play in the NFL.
  7. Rob S
    7. Posted by Rob S Thu Jul 30, 2009 11:57 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Has everyone forgotten the whole Ron Mexico thing? The "water bottle"? Flipping off his fans? The positive drug test?
    Vick was a crappy human being long before he decided to start a crime ring and torture and kill dogs. And he was an awful quarterback. Great athlete; terrible quarterback.
    I'd rather see Seattle draft a quarterback with their two first round picks next year or keep playing Hasselbeck until he's 40 than sign Vick and watch him underthrow all of our receivers and screw up in his personal life again.
  8. Matt W
    8. Posted by Matt W Thu Jul 30, 2009 11:58 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Why does everyone go crazy about Michael Vick and the dog fighting? Donte Stallworth KILLED A MAN yet there are no protestors going after him, no hate groups, or any comotion really. I'm not saying what Vick did was nothing, I love dogs and have one myself, but aren't we all biasing more towards Vick?
  9. Rob S
    9. Posted by Rob S Fri Jul 31, 2009 12:09 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Matt W:
    You're absolutely right about that. People should be MORE shocked and appalled by Donte Stallworth and Leonard Little. But that doesn't mean they should be LESS appalled by what Vick did. America's laws regarding drunk driving are a ludicrous joke is the problem. It's akin to walking around, firing a gun at random, and yet it is treated as a wrist-slap "oh well, everyone does it" kind of joke. It's not; it is a serious matter. But the fact that it is not treated as such does not diminish what Vick did. People always say "Well Donte Stallworth killed a man and only got 30 days! Vick just killed some dogs and got 23 months!" The problem there is not that Vick got too much; it's that Stallworth (and Little) did not get nearly enough.
  10. honestthought
    10. Posted by honestthought Fri Jul 31, 2009 12:10 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    It doesn;t matter whether MV is is superwomderful FB star, or right or wrong.....What I am worried aboout are innocemt people who might get in the crossfire of the ugly angry people. Do they make Kevlar uniforms? There are so many people who feel they can take the law into their own hands, and innocents might be ib the way. Can't the NFL see that? It's too risky!
  11. Tim
    11. Posted by Tim Fri Jul 31, 2009 12:18 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Keep hating because hes coming back and theirs nothing you can do about it. He paid his debt to society, hes a free man. Vick deserves another chance and I believe his going to do great things. Cant wait to see Vick play!!
  12. Zeb C
    12. Posted by Zeb C Fri Jul 31, 2009 12:18 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Going to be a Sleepless in Seattle 2 staring Mike Vick! Looks like the Seahawks might be the team Mr. Vick signs with. We will see, M.Vick's old coach Jim Mora is there and the 2 of them would be re-united once again. I think Vick will be used as a running back or a return man otherwise a 2nd or 3rd QB option.
    You know, lot's of Sports athletes have done some really horrible, stupid, and ridiculous things in the past and even now in the present times. It makes you wonder what the hell were these guys thinking? These guys have it made. For somebody like Vick who was set. Vick was the QB of a Pro NFL team (the Falcons), he had ton's of commercials, all his shoes and merchandise, along with many fans adoring him. Vick is not the only one to throw away all of that and oh yeah all the money he made GONE! I am interested in seeing how Vick will do and if he really learned from his mistake. There is going to always be the haters and the forgivers. For now my old Falcons Vick # 7 jersey hangs in the closet collecting dust, maybe it will be worth something someday or maybe I should go burn it.
  13. mindtour
    13. Posted by mindtour Fri Jul 31, 2009 12:22 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Without Michael Vick there is no game that I have to see until the playoffs!! No match-up, no rivalry!! Without Michael Vick I can just wait and check Yahoo on Monday morning and be quite satisfied!!
    There...it is said!!
    So all you haters consider what you just read and ask yourself...except for maybe following your favorite team, will you be just like me!!?? Ho-humming the NFL??!!
    Because, with Michael Vick...I'm springing for a 42 inch and upgrading my cable!!!
  14. Danny
    14. Posted by Danny Fri Jul 31, 2009 12:26 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Vick should go to Carolina Panthers, they need a QB
  15. skeet m
    15. Posted by skeet m Fri Jul 31, 2009 12:29 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Great post Roy. Great point of view, and for those of you who don't think he should be back, may God help your souls, because if you don't have the heart to forgive somebody, who has admitted he made a mistake, who is doing his best to make himself a better person, with help from one of the greatest people ever in football, Tony Dungy, and can't forgive him I sincerely hope you can find someone to forgive you for you're mistakes, because if I was them, you probably wouldn't deserve it.
  16. Geno72
    16. Posted by Geno72 Fri Jul 31, 2009 12:32 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    I can't wait to see MV7 back on the field! As a life long Falcon fan, I was hurt when we let him go. He is the most dynamic athelete to ever play QB. This guy that some of you are saying sucked has been to the Pro-Bowl 3 times. Might I add that those participants are voted on by their peers, not these couch potato fans that THINK they know Football! Furthermore, MV7 has paid his dues for these horrendous crimes he committed against thes ANIMALS. Just because some of you treat them as family members doesn't mean that they are! If your dog was to bite a small child, it would be put down like the ANIMAL that it is! MV7 is a great QB! He is a winner on the gridiron! Ask your beloved Brett Favre, that he outplayed on a couple occasions, if he is a great QB & i'll bet he agrees! The rest of you need to get off your high horse & forgive as Jesus forgave us. Who are you people to pass judgement anyway?!!!
  17. D-Lux
    17. Posted by D-Lux Fri Jul 31, 2009 12:46 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Look at it this way. If someone goes to jail for anything that gets put on their record. Everyday people who were convicted of crimes are given job interviews and go out and look for work. The NFL is the same. Owners and GM's look for and hire people to work for their team, their company. So if a team wants to hire Michael Vick that is their business decision. I understand what he did was wrong but he served his time according to our court system. The NFL is a business not the criminal justice system. He has been punished by the law, now it is time for him to find a job, and if I was the owner of a team how could I pass on maybe the most athletic quarterback ever? That is the business decision that teams are faced with.
  18. Q WEST
    18. Posted by Q WEST Fri Jul 31, 2009 12:47 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Sorry I have to ask another question? Did Dog Fighting just start last year? WOW years has went by shoot decades better yet centuries has past this wasnt something that was just created or just started yesterday or last year so what was the real reason for targeting MIKE VICK for this, What about all the chicken fights or better yet back during the Roman Empire when they were killing each other for sport. So I ask teh question again WHY did they really target MIKE VICK and take everything away from him. No one really wants to talk about that like Dog Fighting just started last year PETA has been around for how many years, why are they only worried about the DOGS and not the rest of the animals that are being killed by the so called hunters. WOW
  19. Robert C
    19. Posted by Robert C Fri Jul 31, 2009 12:50 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    If you grew up in a family environment where dog fighting was readily accepted....you would fight dogs too.
    Not saying what he did was OK, just saying that I don't believe he fully knew how the rest of the world viewed dogfighting.
    Let him come back. He paid a higher price than many who have committed much more heinous acts.
    Nobody picketed against any NFL players that killed people in drunk driving crashes...but they will against a guy who hurt animals....strange.
  20. johnnysmashum
    20. Posted by johnnysmashum Fri Jul 31, 2009 12:55 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    I would love to see Vick play again even more in Jacksonville and all of you haters eat a (D) you probably are doing far worst things sleeping with your sister or mother or both man you people blows
  21. Geoff D
    21. Posted by Geoff D Fri Jul 31, 2009 12:57 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    nice out to lunch article [profane]face.
  22. Geoff D
    22. Posted by Geoff D Fri Jul 31, 2009 12:58 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    i see the [profane]tard vick lovers are still at it. i think we should find a fenced off area for all of you
  23. Geoff D
    23. Posted by Geoff D Fri Jul 31, 2009 1:01 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Matt W, stop being retarded. stallworths was an accident. vicks was intentional. for christs sake i wonder about some people, and have for some time.

Roy S. Johnson Blog

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Contributors

Related Photo Gallery

Yahoo! Sports Blog Recent Readers