Roy S. Johnson Blog

Wed Mar 26, 2008 5:35 am EDT

More than a Wie bit concerned

Michelle Wie

Associated Press

She's only 18.

She's only 18.

She's ...

If I keep saying it (OK, typing it), maybe I'll stop thinking that we've seen the best of Michelle Wie. Maybe I'll not acknowledge that feeling in my gut that the young woman TIME magazine once declared as "one of 100 people who would shape our world," whom Arnold Palmer once said might influence golf as much as Tiger Woods "or more," may not reshape anything at all – except her already-sizable bank account.

But she's only …

And yet, it doesn't look real good right now. Late last week, Wie withdrew from the upcoming Safeway International, citing yet another wrist injury, this one incurred on the range at Stanford, her school and my alma mater. Doctors there subjected her to every alphabet test imaginable – MRI, CAT, etc. – and her handlers tell us it's nothing serious, just a strain. But after Wie essentially lost much of 2007 over a wrist injury that reportedly first occurred over a year ago, I'm more than a tad concerned that we've not heard the last from Wie's wrist.

And that's not good. For a golfer, a wrist injury may be the most debilitating injury imaginable, or at least tied with a funky back. At the moment of impact with the ball, it may be the most critical part of the body, certainly an area that absorbs the most shock. A tender wrist, let along an injured one, renders everything else moot – tempo, hip turn, head movement, follow through. None of them matters if the wrist is wrong.

Oh they can certainly heal, just like any other part of the body. And Wie is no doubt in her prime healing years. But an injured wrist makes it difficult to practice. And until fully healed it's susceptible to being re-injured easily – like by trying to cut the food on your plate or turn the steering wheel.

But let's face it, my worries for Wie extend beyond her wrist.

It's not as if she's dazzled us with her game for quite awhile now. It's been two years since she was more of a contender than a sideshow. In 2006, she finished third in two events, including the U.S. Women's Open. She also took fifth at the LPGA Championship. She was finally starting to show us that she had as much game as flame, that she was as skilled a golfer as she was powerful off the tee.

She was almost making me stop being annoyed at those who managed her career, the people – including her father, B.J. – who steered her to too many men's events where she only experienced defeat and humiliation by missing cuts. Or who fueled the hype machine that landed her on magazine covers before her time and duped Madison Avenue into making her rich before she earned the right to be so. (At the age of 15, some guessed Wie would earn up to $13 million in endorsements in her first year, which would have placed her third among Forbes' list of highest-paid woman athletes – behind only Maria Sharapova and Serena Williams.)

She was to be a 6-foot-tall global marketing machine who could smack a golf ball 300 yards and rock the runway in high heels.

There was buzz of Wie clothing and jewelry lines. Brandon Steiner of Steiner Sports Marketing once told USA Today: "Once the apparel line gets rolling and you have a couple other major endorsements her earning could reach $30-40 million a year."

Right now, though, there is simply no buzz. There's no sizzle about Wie and I can't help blame those who placed greed above the long-term welfare of, yes, a child.

Even worse, there are still lingering negative vibes from 2007 when Wie and her camp were criticized for pulling out of a tournament after 16 holes, citing, duh, a wrist injury when she was playing so badly she was in danger of losing her ability to accept sponsor exemptions – the only way Wie can play in an LPGA event since she is not a member of the LPGA Tour.

I know, she's only 18. I keep telling myself that and, like others, still give Wie the benefit of the doubt because she is so talented, so engaging, so smart (hey, she is at Stanford!) and, yes, so young.

But I still can't help but wonder: Have we seen the best of Wie?

digg delicious
more

129 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. Namer A
    1. Posted by Namer A Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:11 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Well well well, looks like finally others are starting to realize what I knew was going to happen back when Wie first started playing mens events. Perhaps the worst thing to ever happen to Wie's career was her almost making the cut at the Sony Open in her first attempt.
    I remember the old Yahoo boards where I got bashed by about everyone except WhiskeyEcho when it came to talk of Wie. Doesn't take much to lose a "perfect" swing. Especially at such a young age when she was still growing (perhaps not vertically, but mentally). Of course, what does BJ care? His use of his daughter already made him millions, so what does it matter if she fizzles out now. Some people just should not be parents. Simple as that.
  2. Kelly L
    2. Posted by Kelly L Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:49 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I compare her too Britney Spears. Britney, when was the last time you sang live in a concert? Michelle when was the last time you won an event? Take the money and run. Good for both of them.
  3. Matt A
    3. Posted by Matt A Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:38 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    She is EASY on the eyes!
  4. spagettibender1
    4. Posted by spagettibender1 Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:34 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    She's is one of sports biggest DUDS.
    For someone who "is technically superior to Tiger, and has the best swing in golf history" she is a complete ZERO.
    I for one have had it with overhyped "sports darlings".
    Two years ago when she turned pro Wei mentioned she would like to play in the Masters.
    She must be delusional.
  5. photomanras
    5. Posted by photomanras Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:10 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    She is a very HOT young lady but I do believe the wrist issue is getting old. I hope she can come back but if not- she can always model or do other things a young sexy lady can do..
  6. Greg D
    6. Posted by Greg D Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:43 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I would agree with the idea and with some of the others..... I think she has a BIG hole to dig out of and I think the least of her worries are her wrist. Biggest problem is her immaturity and her attitude and the root cause of it all.....her stupid parents. She has done everything the wrong way and I think she has lost most of the fans that were at one time pulling for her. Like Britney, I think she is becoming a joke and is now in a situation where people would prefer to see her fail. She has a lot of work ahead of her and her first step should be to donate a whole bunch of that unearned money she has made to charity, and then stay off the radar until she is fully healed and can actually play some golf........
  7. Greg D
    7. Posted by Greg D Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:43 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I would agree with the idea and with some of the others..... I think she has a BIG hole to dig out of and I think the least of her worries are her wrist. Biggest problem is her immaturity and her attitude and the root cause of it all.....her stupid parents. She has done everything the wrong way and I think she has lost most of the fans that were at one time pulling for her. Like Britney, I think she is becoming a joke and is now in a situation where people would prefer to see her fail. She has a lot of work ahead of her and her first step should be to donate a whole bunch of that unearned money she has made to charity, and then stay off the radar until she is fully healed and can actually play some golf........
  8. Erik C
    8. Posted by Erik C Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:55 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Good riddens to hear of her continual golfing demise. Sponsorship exemptions into PGA events when there are players with families that have to fight through Q-School and monday qualifiers to pay for gas? She has been a media child who could "drive for show" but could never "putt for dough". Have you seen her pathetic touch around the greens? There are plenty of women golfers in the world that deserve the chance she got when they have the short game to win. But, her 6' frame and posse of promoters hyped her up so the corp's bit hook and sinker. Oh and lets not even get into this Stanford education she's receiving. Have you heard her interviews? Certainly no Rhoad Scholar. I suspect largely in part due to her being a headliner that she was admitted.
  9. kevin t
    9. Posted by kevin t Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:54 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The problem with Michele Wie is she has a ton of talent..physical but is very weak from the mental standpoint. In golf you need your mental strength to be stronger than the physical part. She has no skills is "WINNING" tournaments and that's gonna be her downfall. She doesn't know "how" to win. in golf that critical. She has never won before. that's why amateur golf is so important. She has a ton of talent but it will be wasted in the end. She did get a pay day for it so she got a return on it but from a sport standpoint it will be a waste of talent. Her dad is the biggest reason. He laughed all the way to the bank. Now he's kicking back why she struggles from a public viewpoint. It's her that's suffering..not him. And that's the worst part of the whole deal. I saw the trainwreck coming from day 1. I'm not a fan of hers. Never have been and never will be!!
  10. Phillip Bland
    10. Posted by Phillip Bland Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:37 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I don't think Michelle Wie loves golf anymore. For so long, it has simply been the means of making her father rich-as has neen noted on this board. The solution would be quite simple. All she needs to do is play a few rounds with me. The sheer passion for the game and competitve fire I display as I struggle to break 90 would reinvigorate within her an intense desire to overcome all obstacles between herself and greatness. And I would get to play golf with one of the hottest golfers in the world. haha. Of course, if that doesn't work there is always Butch Harmon.
  11. bogey man
    11. Posted by bogey man Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:19 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Wie,wie, wie all the way home. Her parents pushed her way too early. Wrist injury is getting old. Just an excuse. She was a flash in the pan. Big Nike contract was a waste of money.
  12. Fred C
    12. Posted by Fred C Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:23 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    First, comparing her to Britney Spears is plain stupid. IMO Michelle is simply does not have the burning desire to totally dedicate herself to golf. She is enjoying school and hanging out. I do beleive that within the next two years it will be either boom or no more golf at all.
  13. howie feltersnatch
    13. Posted by howie feltersnatch Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:58 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    ..her next stop is playboy, she has to lose a little weight, get some nice implants, and she ready ..we all think that, and i'm sure she has been contacted, lets face it she was average at best, and burned out, check that her father burned her out...stage parents have to go, anyway either nudie mags or the stripper pole or porn, is the logical step
  14. lefty
    14. Posted by lefty Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:01 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    young -talented rich - many advantages -no tears for michelle
  15. toddcommish
    15. Posted by toddcommish Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:14 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    How can you look at that smashed-with-a-frying-pan face and say she's hot? Have you seen Paula Creamer, Cristie Kerr, Natalie Gulbis, and Erica Blasberg? She is the biggest sports marketing fiasco of all time, surpassing even the Dan/Dave decathlon mess... And her dad is to blame. BJ pushed her and pushed her, and created a psychological mess. It's like he thought he was Earl Woods and Richard Williams rolled into one. All he has now is a messed-up daughter.
    Oh, and $20M of Sony's money.
  16. Physgolf
    16. Posted by Physgolf Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:10 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Ya'll can't "dig out of a hole." The phrase is used to indicate a frustration of not being able to change. For example, "Getting Britney Spears sober is like trying to dig out of a hole. The hole just gets deeper."
    Michelle will be back, older, wiser, better. Some athletes mature later than others, and she has a great swing.
    And all you sexists who remark about how "hot' she is, go take a cold shower and grow up.
  17. mike m
    17. Posted by mike m Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:57 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    As far as i can tell, Wie is taller than most stripper poles, so they would either have to lenghten the poles or shorten the stages. Anyways, in the long run, it probably wouldn't matter---during her first twirl around the pole she most likely would reinjure her wrist.....Maybe she could get a job lying on her back.........like BJ must be doing now. Talk about talent gone down the sewer!
  18. YL
    18. Posted by YL Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:37 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I think see'll bounce back. With all this negative publicity, she'll have the motivation to work on her game. She's got the talent to make it happen.
  19. JR
    19. Posted by JR Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:42 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Has anybody here had a wrist injury? Did anybody pay attention to the article about how important the wrist is to a golfer? Michelle broke her wrist in a fall in late 2006. My mother broke her wrist back in the '60's and it still hurts when the weather changes. As far as her mental ability is concerned, she's probably not street smart because she has been very sheltered, but she's very intelligent. You can't go to the high school she attended, get the grades she did and get into Stanford without being intelligent. She's in her first semester and she's taking hip hop dance, humanities and JAPANESE (J forgot to mention that) while trying to balance practice time. Remember, she's not on scholarship so she can take anything she darn well pleases. There may be something to the idea that she doesn't love golf anymore and who can blame her? All she's gotten the past few years is grief because she hasn't won a tournament. Natalie Gulbis stayed in amateur golf and it took her 5 years and over 150 starts to finally win one. Jill McGill has been on tour since the mid '90's and still hasn't won. Neither have caught the criticism that Michelle has. And what's her big crime? She tried to meet her 2007 commitments and play through an injury with, admittedly, disasterous results. David Ledbetter still believes in her and so do I. Bottom line is that while Michelle, and her parents, may have done some things that people don't agree with, including me, she hasn't done anything wrong, illegal or hurt anyone with the decisions she's made or had made for her. She's still a work in progress and I'm waiting for the finished product whether that's a golfer or whatever she is happy doing.
  20. Toni S
    20. Posted by Toni S Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:05 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The next step for Wie is to launch a career with a record label and then perhaps a Disney movie.
  21. china m
    21. Posted by china m Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:23 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    good article, except one spelling error.
  22. niceguy1st
    22. Posted by niceguy1st Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:37 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Wie may well be done. No one less than Tiger said months before Wie turned pro that she should stay an amateur and learn how to win. Turning pro was a horrendous decision by her parents grabbing for the short-term gold rather than the long-term success. If she was an amateur she could be playing golf for Stanford, learning more about competition and having the time of her life.
    These wrist injuries, though real at first, may well be her way of avoiding playing golf while she may actually be enjoying college. We won't ever know...but we will look back at her 5 years from now and remember her as the Ty Tryon of the LPGA.
  23. rich j
    23. Posted by rich j Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:40 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Most of you posters are total idiots. You are jealous that a wonderful young girl became rich by developing and using her talents. You are jealous of her decisions to do what she wants in a free society. You hate her parents because they love her, and are willing to take the fall for this unfortunate set of injuries that have taken Michelle away from the competitive spot light for now. What you don't know is that she is determined to overcome her setbacks, and will be back on top of golf in the next year. So go ahead all you "Bubbas", and get excited reading your Playboy mags, hoping to see Michelle in there someday!
  24. dcfan
    24. Posted by dcfan Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:39 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The future is hard to predict. It takes more than physical talent to win on the tour. It takes a lot of character to do the hard things while practicing to build your game and executing consistently during a tournament. If she pays the price and makes smart decisions, maybe she could compete. Or not. It depends on her to do the right things, the hard things. Bottom line...show me the scores.
  25. James D
    25. Posted by James D Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:00 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I feel bad for the companies that signed her to million dollar deals. She should give them all the money back that they have paid her. Maybe her and John Daly can hang out, 2 people that had all the talent in the world but were screwed up by different things.

Roy S. Johnson Blog

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Contributors

Related Photo Gallery

Yahoo! Sports Blog Recent Readers