Roy S. Johnson Blog

As a player, Zina Garrison was known for her speed. She was pigeon-toed, not at all imposing. But when she was on the other side of the net, there seemed to be four Zinas, one for every corner of the court.

In her own way, she was a pioneer among African-American female tennis players, sandwiched between Althea Gibson, whom she befriended in the last years of the legend's life, and the Williams sisters. In fact, she was a bit of a prequel to Venus and Serena Williams, emerging from Houston's inner-city public courts to become a junior national champion who rose to as high as No. 4 in the world.

Unlike the Williamses, Garrison never won a Grand Slam singles title. Yet she won 14 singles and 20 doubles titles, finishing with a solid 587-270 singles record. Her personal highlight reel features a 1989 triumph over Chris Evert in the quarterfinals of the U.S. Open, a win that sent Evert into retirement. Then there was Garrison's run through Wimbledon the following year. She eliminated French Open champion Monica Seles in the quarters and the world No. 1 Steffi Graf in the semis before losing to friend and mentor Martina Navratilova in the final.

Now comes the flipside – an ugly lawsuit against the USTA alleging racial discrimination in the organization's treatment of Garrison in her five-year tenure as Fed Cup caption.

Captain Garrison was 5-5 in Fed Cup matches and never reached a final. But there were highlights there, too. Just maybe not enough for the USTA, which chose not to bring her back at the end of 2007. They let her coach one more year, giving her a No. 2 "coach," Mary Joe Fernandez, who was also publicly announced as her successor. Last year, in essence, Garrison wasn't even a lame duck. She had no legs.

Race suits are never pretty, even when they are clear, easy and incontrovertible – which this one isn't. Most often they disintegrate into he said/she said affairs, where both sides are ultimately bruised. Or they're settled and only the lawyers win.

This isn't the USTA's only brush with alleged racial discrimination. It is also being sued by former administrator Marvin Dent in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York. Dent, who is black, alleges he was bypassed for the position of director of tennis at the National Tennis Center in favor of Whitney Kraft, who is white. Dent also alleges a pattern of discrimination at the USTA, which it has denied.

Three years ago, the USTA entered into a consent decree with New York's attorney general that forced it to create an open process for hiring chair umpires. That followed a suit by two black umpires, alleging the USTA allowed racist comments directed toward African-American umpires. The decree lasted two years.

Garrison alleges unequal treatment relative to her counterpart, U.S. Davis Cup captain Patrick McEnroe – specifically unequal pay and unequal resources. She also argues that while she was never given more than one-year deals, Fernandez, with as much coaching experience as me, was signed for three years out of the box – and at a salary higher than Garrison's, the lawsuit alleges.

Garrison claims that the USTA may seek to justify Fernadez's deal by saying she is required to take on additional public duties.

But perhaps more disturbing are the alleged comments attributed to Sara Fornaciari, the Fed Cup chair. If true, they embody the underlying thread of racism that still must be eliminated.

Garrison alleges in the suit that Fornaciari "routinely referred to Garrison as the 'Black Ghost,' to impugn Garrison's reliability."

At a Fed Cup semifinal in Stowe, Vt., in July 2007, Fornaciari allegedly told Garrison after a media interview: "That was the most intelligent media comment I have ever heard you give."

Garrison took it to imply that she was "generally inarticulate and stupid," according to the suit.

In August that same year, Garrison alleges that Fornaciari told her to go to a tent at a USTA sectional event because she might "get a lot of minority business." Garrison says in the suit she was "troubled by the implication that she could network only with other minorities."

Some of the allegations may seem benign, but they tugged at Garrison, who writes that she later called Fornaciari to say she was unhappy with the tone of her comments.

"In response," says the suit, "Fornaciari launched into a vitriolic attack against Garrison and other African-Americans, including the Williams sisters. She told Garrison she was trying to 'help' her, stating, 'Let's face it. You can't talk. Nobody ever knows what you are saying.' "

Garrison challenged the tone of Fornaciari's remarks, but Fornaciari, according to the suit, "became irate and announced in a loud and angry tone, 'I will never speak to another black person again.' "

The USTA would not make Fornaciari available but had a statement:

"The USTA takes all allegations of discrimination seriously and takes pride in its numerous diversity initiatives and achievements," USTA spokesman Chris Widmaier said.

"The USTA elected not to renew Ms. Garrison's Fed Cup captaincy based on her performance, and strongly denies any allegation of discrimination asserted by Ms. Garrison.

"During Ms. Garrison's five-year tenure as captain, the United States Fed Cup team did not advance to the Fed Cup final, its longest drought in the competition's 45-year history."

The suit also alleges that Garrison was also blamed for not being able to regularly recruit the Williams sisters, the two top American players, to play the Fed Cup (more than once, one or both of them would commit to playing, only to be sidelined by injury, which the suit alleges the USTA viewed with suspicion); and that in replacing Garrison the USTA wanted a "public face" and concluded she did not have "the look" it wanted for the team.

Like some other sports, and numerous corporations, the USTA likes to tout its "diversity initiatives," whatever they may be. That's all well and good, but when the words from the men and women charged with leading these initiatives and their enterprises represent the antithesis of what those initiatives aim to achieve, it tells me we still have a very long way to go.

And some places are not getting there fast enough.

Licensed photos

digg delicious
more

120 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. inkman
    1. Posted by inkman Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:26 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    it's just incredible the number of wanton remarks white people make that are racially charged, yet are made so nonchalantly...of course if a black person objects, they will be labeled too sensitive and troublemakers. Basically, blacks are fodder for ridicule in this country and racism is to whites like ducks to water..they can't help it. Corrupted by their own power and exploitation of others.
  2. Joe B
    2. Posted by Joe B Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:05 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Oh please! When is all this racial crap going to stop? Zina, if you had a 10-0 record, you would still be the coach. You weren't getting the job done. You were replaced. Get over it. It happens to coaches all over America, in all sports, and from all walks of life. You should not be held to a different standard just because you are black. You were expected to win. You didn't. It is as simple as that. Get over yourself and get lost with your ghetto trash ways.
  3. Chris C
    3. Posted by Chris C Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:22 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    So so record and not that good when she was Captain of the Fed Cup= racial discrimiantion lawsuit. The Williams sisters blow her away. Sheesh racial discrimination give me a break.
  4. J. D
    4. Posted by J. D Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:26 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I have no doubt that Zina Garrison is the victim of overt and systemic racism in this case. What valid argument can there be for Mary Joe Fernandez getting a higher salary and a 3 year contract. Patrick McEnroe's record must be worse than Garrison's but he seems to stay around. Zina has demonstrated enough integrity over the years that she is not the type of person to make up stories about Fornaciari. The big problem of racism in North Americais that when it is occuring, the focus gets put on the victim to prove that racism exists. Tennis is no different than soccer. Racism is there and it is being perpetuated at multiple levels. The first step in eradicating racism is to acknowledge that it is pervasive and that it will continue without drastic changes.
  5. calmwaves_25
    5. Posted by calmwaves_25 Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:16 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Wow, playing the race card and race game even when the other side's subject was even another minority (Fernandez). What a new low.
  6. Muriel D
    6. Posted by Muriel D Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:30 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Maybe one day people will realize that there is only one race, the human race. Irish American, Italian American, Chinese American, African American, etc., are not races in themselves but varities of the human race. It has been proven scientifically that we are more alike than different. White America needs to get over it and quit looking for someone to step on to try and prove their superiority. I believe they are intimidated by the Black American's ability to master just about any sport they decide to engage in and since we're all Americans we should embrace this. I think that the USTA needs to step up to the plate and let everyone know that any form of discrimination is just not acceptable and whoever this Fornaciari is, the USTA should let her know that there is zero tolerance for this kind of behavior. The Williams sisters are the only ones keeping the American women in competition, and if they don't play in the Fed Cup and since Lindsay Davenport will not be able to play, Fernandez is not going to get to the semi-finals, much less the finals, with the competition the Americans are left with. Now let's seen how long Fernandez will be around.
  7. jq1234_2000
    7. Posted by jq1234_2000 Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:42 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    JD:
    "I have no doubt that Zina Garrison is the victim of overt and systemic racism in this case. What valid argument can there be for Mary Joe Fernandez getting a higher salary and a 3 year contract. Patrick McEnroe's record must be worse than Garrison's but he seems to stay around."
    Oh, yeah, you are so sure she is victim of racism when you even don't know Patrick McEnroe led men's team to WIN Davis Cup.
  8. Chris S
    8. Posted by Chris S Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:14 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    lets say for arguement sake it was racism so what. who cares? besides zina garrison and a handful of whoevers really who cares. if it truely was a race thing big deal so get on with it already. everyday people of all color are subject to racism, sexism, and most importantly who gives a [profane]ism. no matter how much the media, the government, the church, the tree huggin hippies and or the good reverend al sharpton himself push for equality it a"int a happening. just got to bite down and move on. all the lawsuits all the speeches all the prayer all the kings horses and men a"int gonna bring us together in the end. its something called human nature .love it or hate it thats how were geared. if you want to do something meaningful unlike this topic try rubbing your eye with a pickle.
  9. jthom20851
    9. Posted by jthom20851 Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:43 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Inkman, you dont even know if those remarks were made, she is trying to get money from a lawsuit so she has reason to lie..kind of like that black girl who falsely accused the Duke lacrosse players of raping her and filing a lawsuit trying to cash in.
  10. sistersgirl
    10. Posted by sistersgirl Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:56 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    As a victim of racism it is very hard to overcome repeated treatments and ugly remarks. It is not sensetive to comment about such unfair comments being directed directly at you. Yes,often we are said to be sensative and not a team player when we complain about such racist remarks made in our presence and directed to others around us. It is not good to ignore such remarks at NO TIMES. If remarks go unnoticed ,patterns of such behavior will escelate into hate thus destroying atempts at love. We must face every encounter of racism in a manner that is positive ,thus letting the person or persons know it is unacceptable and unappreacitive., and not tolerated. Otherwise it will continue. I don't think any American Athelete should have to represent our country in a hostile enviornment. America you tell me when will we cease to stop hating those few blacks who train long and hard to represent the USA.. America, why don't you who condone racism walk a mile in the shoes of one who has experienced such cruel treatment,.Do not fail to povide real true and honest feedback. I promise you will never want to experience blackness again.
  11. Chris C
    11. Posted by Chris C Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:22 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Zina was an average player at best, average or less coach at most. By the way i don't see blacks dominating all sports. They don't dominate baseball, or hockey, or tennis for that matter other then the Williams sisters, nor skiing, gymnastics, soccer, etc. etc. I do believe you need to get over your inferior superiority complex. Did i mention that Tiger Woods is mostly not black. Asian, Cherokee, and black. Basketball and football are trully the only sports they dominate at. Just facts and figures from their actual perecentages of participation in each sport.
  12. Sonny J
    12. Posted by Sonny J Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:39 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Who is this Fornaciari? She sounds like she needs an attitude adjustment. The RACE is human race. This
    Fed Cup chair person, Fornaciari, is just RUDE !! I think perhaps she should square off with Zina or Venus or Serena. I'm sure all the Black people would be happy if this predjudice female dog would never speak to them ever. USA's women tennis henges on the power of the Williams sisters and like it or not they are LADIES and not just black females. As a matter of fact, they are both well educated and speak the English language fluently and whatever country they visit, they learn enought of that language to communicate some. Fornaciari and USTA you need to step up and take your licks for your actions. Tennis is a good sport and I really think that there isn't a place for the likes of Fornaciari in the sport. What nationality is this person?! Education is power!!
    Not prejudice. Who is the President of the United States of America?
  13. Bill M
    13. Posted by Bill M Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:40 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Posted by Joe B Fri Mar 13, 2009 11:06 pm EDT :
    "You were expected to win. You didn't. It is as simple as that. Get over yourself and get lost with your ghetto trash ways"
    Thank you for some what an ass you really are.
  14. Reny A
    14. Posted by Reny A Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:57 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    This is crap. Black rule this country, US woman's tennis is dominated by blacks, music industry is controlled by blacks, you hardly see a white man in NFL or NBA. If you are not good at your job, in this case winning fed cup for US, you are NOT fit for the job. period. Zina has no right to discuss in public about USTA either. Another point, don't compare men's and woman's tennis. Men's game earn more spectators and revenue which is the driving force of any sporting event. I recommend Woman's tennis to be enrolled as a charity organization. I'd rather watch a match featuring men seeded 100 and 101 than women seeded 1 and 2.
  15. richard w
    15. Posted by richard w Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:40 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    You look at a dark skinned person and the first thing they say ,"ur prejudice"......................i'm sick of it !!!!!!!!! it's really getting old.....
  16. abdiver12
    16. Posted by abdiver12 Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:44 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Zina Garrison had a poor record and lets face it, she doesn't come across as very articulate, charismatic, or intelligent when she speaks. That has to do with who she is as a person, not her color. I despise racism of every kind and am a huge fan of Barack Obama but in this case, I think Zina honestly deserves to lose her job.
  17. Mark T
    17. Posted by Mark T Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:06 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I think that Garrison has a good point when she says that she was given one year contracts instead of a multi year contract.
    The alleged statements made by Fornaciari are quite disturbing and if true, Zarrison has to be compensated.
    I just hope that the Williams sisters are watching and do not play in the Fed Cup.
    By the way, I think that a lot of whites are ignorant and not necessarily racist.
  18. kenneth
    18. Posted by kenneth Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:46 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    i work with inbred whites who make hurtful racial comments all the time and think it's cute. i feel sorry for them almost. zina!!, shame on you. why did you want to work for the racist usta anyway?. that's a loser organization. tthey will not ever produce a grandslam champion again. venus and serena are not products of that system and that makes them angry.
  19. RicardoG
    19. Posted by RicardoG Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:43 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Zina was an average player at best, average or less coach at most. By the way i don't see blacks dominating all sports. They don't dominate baseball, or hockey, or tennis for that matter other then the Williams sisters, nor skiing, gymnastics, soccer, etc. etc. I do believe you need to get over your inferior superiority complex. Did i mention that Tiger Woods is mostly not black. Asian, Cherokee, and black. Basketball and football are trully the only sports they dominate at. Just facts and figures from their actual perecentages of participation in each sport.
    Maybe you need to check your percentages one baseball, hockey, soccer, team sports therefore meaning it would be hard for one person to dominate. Second look at individuals records in baseball most home runs Barry Bonds, don't want to give him credit, okay the man before Willie Mays, Babe Ruth is next but after him is Ken Griffey Jr. Basketball and football are of course predominately black sports and had it not been for the injuries the Williams would have dominated tennis longer than they did oh by the way isn't Serena number 1 and Venus is back in the top 5. Anyway i do not think that is Zina Garrison's fault that USA Fed Cup is in a drought she does not have the talent to win unlinke P Mac does with Roddick, Blake and the Bryans. Although I like Mary Joe is not fair that she has a 3 year contract when she has yet to do anything. I also think that ZIna Garrison is a classy woman who not make false claims out of thin air. People are always get touchy when the issue of race comes into play because we are too afraid to deal with America's long history with slavery and overt racial discrimination these things do still exist and no we don't have "to get over it" we have to make sure these things don't happen.
  20. 10sd
    20. Posted by 10sd Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:36 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Considering the state of womens' tennis in the US, the fact that Zina was able to garner a .500 record with a U.S. Fed Cup team is actually quite impressive. It's unlikely that Fernandez will be able to do much with her teams since there's only one other woman from the U.S. in the top 100 right now besides the Williams sisters. And good luck getting them to play on a Fernandez squad if they're in Garrison's corner.
  21. wen
    21. Posted by wen Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:43 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    why is black people so fussy about being black.whats wrong,they immediately throw into notion that they are being discriminated.its just so very pathetic.
  22. jabtennis
    22. Posted by jabtennis Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:26 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    What sport did Forniciari play? How does she happen to be running the USTA? Was she ever in the top 100? 500? Did someone buy this job for her? Enough said! Sonny J., I have to agree with you! I have followed Zina Garrison's carreer and I am surprised she put up with such blatant discrimination for so long. Let's face it; without tennis talent US is not going to be winning anything, especially without the Williams sisters. Patrick McEnroe has Roddick, Blake & Co.; how much better is his record? The US gives the same purse to men and women tennis players -all kudos to the USTA! Why then the differential between the coaches of the Davis Cup and the Fed Cup?
    Coaches are used to being fired if they don't produce...Yes! ...why then all this nasty vitriol from the supposed leader. Fire the coach if you are not satisfied with her, but cut the racial crap or hire a few Russians to play for your team or start developing elite players.
  23. jabtennis
    23. Posted by jabtennis Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:26 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    What sport did Forniciari play? How does she happen to be running the USTA? Was she ever in the top 100? 500? Did someone buy this job for her? Enough said! Sonny J., I have to agree with you! I have followed Zina Garrison's carreer and I am surprised she put up with such blatant discrimination for so long. Let's face it; without tennis talent US is not going to be winning anything, especially without the Williams sisters. Patrick McEnroe has Roddick, Blake & Co.; how much better is his record? The US gives the same purse to men and women tennis players -all kudos to the USTA! Why then the differential between the coaches of the Davis Cup and the Fed Cup?
    Coaches are used to being fired if they don't produce...Yes! ...why then all this nasty vitriol from the supposed leader. Fire the coach if you are not satisfied with her, but cut the racial crap or hire a few Russians to play for your team or start developing elite players.
  24. a.k.a  [MOVIO]
    24. Posted by a.k.a [MOVIO] Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:24 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    This Fornaciari should keep her head straight and desist from those racist comments, even if Garrison records wasn't good enough Mry Joe Fernandez record was not better either, when it comes to black, they want to scrutnized everything so they could find excuse for denier, talking about sports, blacks are the best in any of the sports they are in , soccer blacks are the best, from pelle to many africans who never get the credit they deserves in white world of discrmination, baseball, trach and field,america football, its thesame, if blacks decides to play hockey, white boys will dissapear, for i don't think they will be able to take the beatings every night, now is okay to fight on the ice, i bet you, if blacks are the ones fighting every night , it would been a violent sports, just look what they are doing to Barry Bond, they try to send to jail and ruine his record, the white can't take it to see another black man as home run king, clement purge himself, yet no one is after him. when Richard williams said his daughters will be number one and two, the white medial almost crucify him, but he was right, the white just can't sleet without dreaming of blacks as threat to their imaginary kingdom.
  25. jthom20851
    25. Posted by jthom20851 Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:43 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Boo Hoo, Boo Hoo...they made hurtful comments and now im sad Boo Hoo..lets see, i think now i will try to be financially compensated for it for my sadness..i hope she doesn't get a dime! she should be appreciative that she was given the chance to do the job, if the USTA was so racist she would never have been given the job at all.

Roy S. Johnson Blog

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Contributors

Related Photo Gallery

Yahoo! Sports Blog Recent Readers