Roy S. Johnson Blog

Fri Jul 17, 2009 5:28 pm EDT

Just say yes, Brett, then duck

Maybe the only way Brett Favre will see that it's time for him to go on with the rest of his life is for him to just step up and say, "I'm in." Just quit playing with the high school kids down in Hattiesburg, Miss., hop a private jet for Minnesota, grab a purple jersey and have at it.

He said earlier this week that he'll let the Vikings know his decision before Minnesota reports to training camp at month's end. Why wait, Brett. As I tweeted yesterday: What are you going to learn between now and then that you don't already know.

Your heart will not change, and right now it's clearing telling you to play.

Whether he's motivated by the same drive that prompts other aging athletes to play until they have to be dragged from the turf, or by some twisted desire to stick it to Green Bay for how the team let him go, all signs point to Favre joining the Vikes, whom he's been teasing for what seems like an eternity.

He underwent surgery to repair his throwing arm, and is now working out four days a week with the Oak Grove high School football team (above). "I'm trying to get everything to where I feel 100 percent when I go in," he told the AP. "I can't go in any less."

Favre won't be 100 percent, not at 39 years old, and not after 18 seasons under center for Atlanta (for a hot minute) Green Bay and the Jets.

But he's going anyway, much to the consternation of many – especially fans of the Packers who view him as a turncoat for even entertaining the idea of playing for an NFC North rival.

It's a bad idea, but the only people who seem not to know that are the Vikings brain trust – owner Zigy Wilf and head coach Brad Childress – and Favre.

It's a bad idea because Favre is clearly more favre than Favre. It's easy to attribute his almost pitiable performance with the Jets in the second half of last season to his injured arm. But it was often his legs that made him look as if there was a sign on his back saying, "Hit me as hard as you can."

When he was able to throw the ball, the gunslinger no doubt shot blanks way too often, unable to make the laser pass necessary to beat a defense.

Maybe the Vikings see something I don't. Yes, even at a few sacks and INTs less than 100 percent, Favre has more pure talent than current QBs, Tarvaris Jackson, John David Booty and Sage Rosenfels – maybe more than all of them combined.

But numbers don't lie, and for Favre, whose digits will someday carry him into the Pro Football Hall of Fame, the only figures that matter are 39 (his age) and 16 (the number of regular season games).

Being the editor of Men's Fitness, I'm a firm believer in age being just a number. However, I'm also mindful that in NFL years, 39 might as well be 69 and while Favre isn't risking the kind of permanent damage an aging boxer might, it could still get very ugly for him.

Though Favre hasn't missed a game since his first season with the Packers in 1992, injury or fatigue could cause him to sit at some point (which, of course, puts him right there with almost every other NFL QB). The plan must be to have Favre start and play in as many games as possible – knowing the team has two QBs (Jackson and Rosenfels) with significant experience – then be ready for the playoffs.

The Vikings also possess the league's best running back, Adrian Peterson, so they must also feel as if there will be less of a burden on Favre to win games than there might be for almost any other QB in the league.

Last season, the Vikes went 10-6, good enough for the NFC's third seed, but lost at home to Philadelphia in an NFC wild-card game, 26-14.

There's a big gap between the wild card and the Super Bowl, but the Vikings think Brett Favre, or rather brett favre, is the closer.

And no doubt, so does Favre.

So let's get on with it.

AP photo

digg delicious
more

234 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. citrusmac92
    1. Posted by citrusmac92 Fri Jul 17, 2009 5:43 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    i really dont care if he plays or not but if he wants to play then he should say i wanna play if he doesnt he needs to say he doesnt.....quit playing with peoples' minds already Brett. After 5 years of the "will you play next year" dilemna, cut the circus and just say it already.
  2. HuyD
    2. Posted by HuyD Fri Jul 17, 2009 5:44 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Why another useless Favre story? Just wait until he officially announces before you write anything. I thought writers were supposed to be creative...i guess not this one...
  3. Ben P.
    3. Posted by Ben P. Fri Jul 17, 2009 5:52 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    im so sick of news showing of brett favre, like it is so tiresome to see this man over and over again on tv.
    At first I felt bad for him leaving but now its just annoying the hell out of me.
  4. huskerfanbb
    4. Posted by huskerfanbb Fri Jul 17, 2009 5:55 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The sad fact is that the Vikings "brain trust" didn't do squat to address the quarterback situation for the team in the offseason. Matt Cassel was available for a 2nd round pick and they had the cap room--so that should have been a no-brainer, but they blew it. They also blew it on Cutler if they had any chance there, so now it is what it is.
    Even at 39, Favre would represent a significant upgrade at the position for the Vikes. With Adrian Peterson and a solid defense, Favre might not have to face too many "win it or go home" situations. Their defense can probably make up for a few bonehead picks and sacks that Favre will give them--and he is much more likely to make that 3rd down play they desperately needed most of last year (Frerotte made a few of those, but not enough). They need to be able to do SOMETHING besides run Adrian Peterson on 3rd and 5. Favre would give them that.
    As a football fan, it is kind of sad to see this once great warrior limping to the end of his career and I certainly hate the media circus and the "all Bret Favre all the time" joke that ESPN has become--but as a Vikings fan I can't say I won't be looking forward to number 4 in a purple uniform even if it's just for a year.
  5. Mr. X
    5. Posted by Mr. X Fri Jul 17, 2009 5:57 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I agree, if he's going to play, then just come out and admit it, 2 weeks wont make him change his mind now.. but what I dont agree with is the people (packers fans) that want him to retire and not play for the Vikings .. It's his life, if he wants to play and some one is willing to let him play, then let him play ! .. GO COWBOYS !!!
  6. paul g
    6. Posted by paul g Fri Jul 17, 2009 6:01 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The whole thing is a publicity act in my opinion. Brett Farve is a great qb, but his time is done. He has done what most atheers only dream about. Hang it up already Brett. Yes, the only thing keeping the Vikes out of the Super Bowl is a qualtiy qb. Brett is not that guy. They should have went after Cutler.
  7. Kevin
    7. Posted by Kevin Fri Jul 17, 2009 6:08 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    While Joe Namath was playing QB for the LA Rams, a young linebacker sacked "Broadway Joe." As he looked down on Namath, he urged him to get out of the game as he pulled him up with his oak tree like hand, attached to his titanium arm....A New York Times writer got wind of this encounter and wrote an article to the back page of Time magazine entitled, "To an Athlete Getting Old." In this article the writer argues the difficulty SUPERSTAR athletes have in retiring, like Namath, like Favre. He noted how the song "Forever Young" plays in the minds and hearts of these athletes, which motivates them to think they can emulate on the playing field.....to no avail. My point is Brett should retire and walk away from the game...gracefully. His stint in New York was had its peaks and valleys, so it wasn't a total lost for him; however, for the Vikings to encourage him to play, and for Favre to think he can still play, displays an ignorance only surpassed by Favre's agent trying to make this happen. For, in truth, the new breed of "twitter" trash talkin, youtube exposes, kiss my ass Beotch, NFL players will not only relish in sacking the once great Favre, instead of offering him a hand to get up after a sack, they will point and taunt and twitter to the world what they did. I hope he doesn't sign with the VIkings; cold weather is hell on aged bones....
  8. r8ders13818
    8. Posted by r8ders13818 Fri Jul 17, 2009 6:28 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    These blogs are so long what a waste of space they talk about the same crap over and over again, they make it seem like if everyday something new happens and it dont. Its all about whether he says yes or no. Brett is a great QB but to make long story short just decide already PLEASE!
  9. rudepoopdude
    9. Posted by rudepoopdude Fri Jul 17, 2009 6:33 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I'm not annoyed at Favre at all. I'm annoyed at Roy S. Johnson, the writer of this blog. As a writer of Mens Fitness, or mens fitness, you should stick to your magazine and keep your lame thoughts to yourself. I've read your magazine before, it's terrible.
  10. Just Ask
    10. Posted by Just Ask Fri Jul 17, 2009 6:34 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    We Packer fans will never forget you Brent!
  11. Jeff F
    11. Posted by Jeff F Fri Jul 17, 2009 6:35 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Let Brett take as long as he wants! People who are upset are ignorant! Favre did not blow the last 6 games for the Jets last year, it was the horrible play calling and coaching! If Minnesota can get him, HE WILL take them deep into the playoffs and possibly the SB!! Adrian Peterson WILL run for 2000, because of finally a decent QB!! TV??? Worst than Tony banks!!! GO BRETT!!!!!!!!
  12. Zeb C
    12. Posted by Zeb C Fri Jul 17, 2009 6:41 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Favre is a great QB and will be in the hall of fame whenever he does retire. I think even if Brett Favre does come back and starts at QB for the Vikes that doesn't put the Purple People Eaters in the Superbowl. Sure the vikings will be better with a experienced QB and they will win a few more games with Favre taking snaps than they will with Jackson, Rosenfels or whoever else they got at QB. I see the Vikes winning 9 or 10 games and making the playoffs. Probably win a wild card game but will get taken out by the Giants or Panthers or some other team.
    Will be fun to watch Favre as QB of the vikes when they go back to Green Bay and play the Pack. Wonder how the cheese heads will treat ol Favre.
    Favre should of retired as a Packer.
  13. Tyler E
    13. Posted by Tyler E Fri Jul 17, 2009 6:48 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Favre was great. He was still good in NY for most of the season. He is better then the current QB options and Matt Cassel by leaps and bounds. The Viks "brain trust" were praying for a fallout in Philly with Mcnabb. That didn't happen. Favre is there best bet at QB. Thank goodness they didn't take Cassel. The Viks line will keep him upright long enough for him to dump it to the now exceptional receiving corp. Sleeper fantasy pick = viks rec. Bernard Barian with Favre throwing it his way...
  14. The End.
    14. Posted by The End. Fri Jul 17, 2009 6:53 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    as a packers fan, brett is dead to me as soon as he put on that viqueens jersey on!
  15. SCOTS-IRISH
    15. Posted by SCOTS-IRISH Fri Jul 17, 2009 6:56 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I can see clearly why Brett is waiting. To see if his arm holds up!! To the writer of this pathetic, I agree with #9, stick to writing magazine articles and stop speculating about someones abilities, of which you know nothing about. Hang in there Brett!!!
  16. Jeremiah A
    16. Posted by Jeremiah A Fri Jul 17, 2009 7:28 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Hey cheeseheads, its VI-KINGS and this is a year you will NEVER forget. Purple # 4 jersey, oh the sweet irony...
  17. Jeremiah A
    17. Posted by Jeremiah A Fri Jul 17, 2009 7:29 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    and roy s johnson, you should NOT be writing on football, quite obviously.
  18. Sandra G
    18. Posted by Sandra G Fri Jul 17, 2009 7:31 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I love Favre and he's had a good run. I think it's time to hang up the cleats before he becomes the latest member of "the great ones who stayed past their prime" club. How many comebacks can we honestly expect from him?
  19. big lou
    19. Posted by big lou Fri Jul 17, 2009 7:33 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The Packers did nothing wrong to Favre. He was the one that held the team hostage for several years. Now he's mad at them? Screw him, he's always been a phony.
  20. Earl of Funk
    20. Posted by Earl of Funk Fri Jul 17, 2009 7:42 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Mr X dumba$$!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! If Troy Aikman went and played for Washington or Philly, you would've cried your eyes out in your ten gallon hat.....shut the F&*%K up
  21. windycityflyer777
    21. Posted by windycityflyer777 Fri Jul 17, 2009 7:45 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    As a bears fan, Favre going to Minnesota would give us a hard time. But we've handled him pretty well when he was a packer, so we'll have to see how he does there. I think he should stay retired (he'd probably just get injured because he's old), but it would be fun watching him play the Packers.
  22. Earl of Funk
    22. Posted by Earl of Funk Fri Jul 17, 2009 7:46 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Jeremiah [profane] - "and roy s johnson, you should NOT be writing on football, quite obviously".....hey, neither should you. Crawl into your little purple smok and bring a towel....you'll be crying most of the season
  23. windycityflyer777
    23. Posted by windycityflyer777 Fri Jul 17, 2009 7:47 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    As a bears fan, Favre going to Minnesota would give us a hard time. But we've handled him pretty well when he was a packer, so we'll have to see how he does there. I think he should stay retired (he'd probably just get injured because he's old), but it would be fun watching him play the Packers.
  24. EyeQon
    24. Posted by EyeQon Fri Jul 17, 2009 7:49 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Well you being an editor for Mens Fitness and a Favre to Vikings (which WILL be a Super Bowl team) hater, your credentials hold Shi#t to the wind.......You're an idiot!................Plain and Simple!!
  25. BareBonz
    25. Posted by BareBonz Fri Jul 17, 2009 7:50 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    As a fan of the Packers and once a fan of Favre I hope he plays. All I want to see is the Vikqueens and Favre come to the frozen tundra and see his career end. He is the enemy now and could care less about him. If the man would have acted more professional about things then maybe a would think differently.
    He will be laid out with a career ending injury.

Roy S. Johnson Blog

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Contributors

Related Photo Gallery

Yahoo! Sports Blog Recent Readers