Fri May 22, 2009 1:25 pm EDT
The Rooney Rule could go down as the second-most influential move ever when it comes to impacting diversity in sports. Second to the Brooklyn Dodgers signing Jackie Robinson, of course.
The NFL mandate requiring GMs to interview at least one non-white candidate for head-coaching vacancies has been so effective that hiring a black head coach is no longer news. (At least not in the NFL; in college sports it still inspires cries of "Hallelujah.")
The league is considering expanding the rule to include GM vacancies. (Jerry Reese of the New York Giants, above, and the Detroit Lions' Martin Mayhew, below, are two of the NFL's three African-American GMs. Ozzie Newsome of the Baltimore Ravens is the other.) Essentially, owners will be holding themselves accountable.
As they should.
Why stop there? The rule should be expanded to all openings – from radio and television announcers to team doctors to marketing, sales and finance positions.
The disintegration of color barriers and misconceptions in sports rightfully began on and around the field. Players and coaches are the most visible participants, and most highly paid. Opening those positions to all was not only right but it was vital to the long-term viability and credibility of all sports.
But I've long been troubled by the reality that no matter how wide the net is cast for athletes and coaches, it still reaches only a very small, elite group of men. Yes, men. Every young man in America is told they stand a better chance of becoming a physicist than playing professional sports. Yet ask them what they want to be when they grow up and almost every one of them (including my own son) will say, "Play pro ball."
The better reality is that there are myriad jobs in pro sports, ones to which almost any kid (boy or girl) can aspire. Jobs in accounting, ticket sales, arena management, training, public relations and on and on.
The league is doing pretty well, actually, when it comes to race. Last summer, it received a B+ on racial hiring practices among top team management, administration, physicians, head trainers, and broadcasters on the annual Racial and Gender Report produced by Dr. Richard Lapchick at the University of Central Florida.
That was despite the fact that the NFL did not provide Lapchick with data for the survey – it was the only pro sports league not to do so – nor did it corroborate data gathered and submitted by UCF prior to publication. With insufficient data, the league was issued an I (Incomplete) in gender hiring. In 2004, the last time it received a grade on gender hiring, the league received a D+. "The record of NFL teams regarding the hiring of women remained poor," the report said, "especially compared to the significant progress on race."
Sticking its chest out about the Rooney Rule yet not participating in the most credible measurement of race and gender hiring in sports is, frankly, hypocritical. That must change.
Subsequently, expanding the Rooney Rule to include all positions would not only allow the NFL to add women to the interview process, it would also send a critical signal to young men and women nationwide who are aspiring to "play pro ball" that they can do so without having to be an elite athlete.
Photos by NY Daily News and AP


Edited by MJD
Edited by 'Duk
Edited by J.E. Skeets
Edited by Greg Wyshynski
Edited by Matt Hinton
Edited by MJD
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Steve Cofield
Edited by Andy Behrens
Posted Nov 27 2009
Posted Nov 27 2009
NFL: Our Locks to Win, Week 12
Posted Nov 25 2009
118 Comments
1 - 25 of 118
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
This real reason i don't like this rule it forces teams to make meaningless interviews with people they don't wont. It then makes it a waste of time and money for both parties just to fill a meaningless rule.
Report Abuse
Why is that a good thing? Is diversity so important as to ignore the quality of the game itself? If it is then why not just have them all sit in a circle and sing "Kumbaya" or something else stupid for their paychecks? Why not just make a hundred professional "ball" leagues and let everybody play? People go to games to see elite athletes; without them, nobody would go to games, the leagues would fail, and then none of the athletes, elite or not, will be "playing pro ball."
As far as expanding the Rooney Rule to GMs, an owner could easily get around it by hiring a guy, giving him a title along the lines of "Director of Football Operations," and letting him make the football decisions. SImple as that.
Report Abuse
I don't want to say the rule isn't needed, but if an owner is not racist, they'd want to bring in whoever was best for the job -- so why would they prejudge a minority if he was a great candidate (granted, it may force them to explore an "unknown" guy who could turn out to be good)
or if they were racist.....it's just lip service then because they won't hire the guy
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
The "R.R." does have its falls, as were posted. Now guys, who likely have no shot at a job are getting interviews as PR. But you know what? It's at least very well qualified guys, who if not for their race, might have already been in these higher positions.
So in my opinion, the rule has helped the league.
And what Roy is saying makes sense. Why not make the rule "global" through out the business? Why not include women?
It does suck to MAKE these huge organizations change their policies. But on the otherhand, why have they not done it on their own??
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
So what, if African-Americans are 12% of the population and 30% of the NFL head coaches? What percentage of the NFL *players* are African-American? I can guarantee you that it's a lot higher than 30%, although I don't know exactly.
It may be, though, that the RR has served its purpose, and can be dropped. Ozzie Newsome and Jerry Reese have proved themselves to be elite GM's (and I'm a Giants fan, I'll admit to a little bias here, but his drafts have been awesome so far). Any team that wants to win has to see that, has to know that they can't afford to overlook qualified non-white candidates. And any team that does discriminate is more likely to lose, and it serves them right.
Women in NFL front offices? The problem with the argument is that the NFL fan base is predominantly male, and women who understand the NFL, and its fans, well enough to get the kind of jobs the OP is talking about are probably few and far between. If there's a woman out there who's qualified and wants it badly enough, though, I'd bet on her making it.
Report Abuse
Here's a stat for you written by a black sports reporter from KC ... in the NFL ... the teams with the most whites on the rooster are the winning teams. Hmmmmmmmmm ... it makes you wonder doesn't it but then again if you watch the news/sports reports and hear about a player breaking the law and in trouble .... 9 of 10 times that player is black.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
If you want to go all the way with this rule, then each team should also be required to have on their rosters players in the correct percentage of races in the population. Then I would support hiring people of all colors in the other jobs.
We have now had a person of color as president of the US, Supreme Court Justice, Sec. of State, various Generals, CEO's, etc. This nonsense needs to end. Scrap the Racist Rooney Rule!
Report Abuse
Also at this point if we like is said in the article take it to all jobs then again whites and all minorities need to be interviewer for all positions. Also I hate to say this but the Rooney Rule is an African America Rule. NOT a Minority rules. Please anyone tell me how many people of Oriental decent or Spanish decent have been interviewed for these head coaching jobs.
I am all for equality but make sure when Morris was hired as the new coach in Tampa Bay was a white candidate interview? Maybe I dont know I am just saying you need it all ways. Also was a person of other decent rather than just African America interviewed?
Bottom line is we have Obama in the White House! THE WHITE HOUSE PEOPLE! If he can make it to the highest profile job in this country do we really need a Rooney rule anymore. Or Affirmative Action at all?
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
1 - 25 of 118