Player Ratings: Italy U-17 2-1 USA U-17

  • Print

Italy

Francesco Bardi 9: If there was not a goalie competition in the Italian camp before this game, there is one now. He was brilliant in all aspects of the game. He should be credited for an assist on the first goal. He stopped a penalty kick, and a shot from 8 yards out. The goal was not his fault.

Felice Natalino 5: The fullback did well at times to try to slow down the American attack, but he was beat around the edges at times and at the start of both halves he conceded chances.

Federico Mannini 3: It was a nightmare start for Mannini and the game did not get any better for him. He was cautioned early which means he is out for  the next game. Minutes later he gave up a penalty kick without any pressure on him.

Simone Sini 5:
The captain kept the team in order and weathered through some of the storm when the U.S. went on the attack.

Lorenzo Crisetig 5: He seemed to be running on tired legs in the second half. He put in plenty of work in the midfield in the first half.
 
Alessandro De Vitis 6: Capitalized on the wealth of space in the first half in the midfield. Had a quiet second half.

Giacomo Beretta 8.5: He was strong on the ball. His goal was very well taken. He should have had two or three but he scored the first one and that was all the Italians needed of him.

Michele Camporese 5: In comparison to his center back partner, his day looked great. But he was beat to the end line a few times and he was lucky that Bardi saved him a few times too.

Pietro Iemmello 8.5: It was an exquisite header to send his fellow forward in for the first goal. It was an even better strike to give the Azzurrini the game winner.

Marco Fossati 7: He was good in the attack and very involved in the play in the first half. In the second, the Italian chances dwindled and so did his effect on the game.

Federico Carraro 8: The tremendously skilled Florentina youngster was dangerous on the ball. His free roaming role behind the strikes gave the U.S. defense fits in the first half.

Substitutes

Leonardo Bianchi 5:
He was in there to keep possession of the ball and not let the U.S. generate chances. He did an acceptable job in both categories.

Alessando Scialpi 4: His free kick late in the game was a terrible effort. His other contributions to the match were minimal.

Simone Benedetti 3: Brought on as an extra defender in the last minutes of the game, but he did not prevent any U.S. attack.

USA

Earl Edwards 6: It is hard to blame Edwards for either goal. He did stop a breakaway in the second half and he was quick off his line in the first to keep the Italians honest.

Jared Watts 4: He gave away too much space to the Italian forwards. It looked as if he respected them too much. His defensive lapse almost made the score 3-1. 

Tylar Polak 4.5: He did venture into the attack a handful of times, but he did not produce any clear cut chances to show for it. His turnover with seconds left was inexcusable.

Eriq Zavaleta 4: Same problems as Watts. He also did not need to concede the foul or the red card in the dying seconds but that had little to do with the final result.
 
Zachary Herold 4: He kept Beretta onside on the first goal. He was beat often by the strike tandem. He did not offer the U.S. anything going forward.

Marlon Duran 6: He had trouble with the Italians in the first half. He seemed lost on where he should have been defensively. After instructions at half time, he played a great second half.

Nicholas Palodichuk 7: His goal was an excellent finish. He was decent in the first half but very good in the second.

Alex Shinsky 6.5: To his credit, his motor never stopped working. He needed more chances with the ball to use his speed.

Luis Gil 9: The performance he gave today should go down in Youth Team legend, but it will be overshadowed by terrible finishing and unlucky bounces. The bicycle kick, the skillful dribbling in the midfield, and the assist on the goal. Do yourself a favor and remember what we just saw a 15 year old do.

Stefan Jerome 6.5: He had a few moments out there where it looked like the Italians were scared to defend him. His speed and power made them back up to their end line but his touch and vision let him down a few times.

Jack McInerney 5:
He was very involved in the play. He had a ton of touches on the ball, but he never had the final touch today. When the U.S. needed a true striker the most, he did not show up to play.

Substitutes

Dominick Sarle 4: He did not do much of anything in his 25+ minutes on the field. His attempt at crossing failed to produce anything.

Victor Chavez 5:
If he finishes that chance, he looks like the best substitution ever made, but he squandered the shot. Chavez plays hard, he just needs to be better inside the box.

Juan Agudelo 6: In less than ten minutes on the field, he created two goal scoring chances. His touch was still a bit heavy , but his speed really shined against tired legs.

J.R. Eskilson, Goal.com

If you follow the U.S. Men's National Team, you'll love their dedicated page on Goal.com!

Go to Goal.com for the world’s most comprehensive soccer coverage.

Updated Nov 4, 1:20 pm EST
digg del.icio.us
more

26 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. jeff g
    26. Posted by jeff g Thu Nov 5 3:09pm EST

    Report Abuse

    good job jack!heard so much about you just to see you blow it twice.too bad jack cracked under pressure.another thing about the american teams at all ages is that outstanding keepers are a must due to the inconsistant (and too often non-existant) defending.let's just hope it is'nt a complete blow-out in s.africa in the summer!otherwise.........bummer!
  2. Gaday
    25. Posted by Gaday Thu Nov 5 3:58am EST

    Report Abuse

    it was a terriable and a fantastic match yesterday swisszeland vs germany,germany play very well yesterday they lost to a better side,but my own concern is today's match Nigeria VS newzeland.
  3. COPAmundial
    24. Posted by COPAmundial Wed Nov 4 9:41pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Josh, sit on it!!!. You only understand games that have TECNICALS!!!
  4. COPAmundial
    23. Posted by COPAmundial Wed Nov 4 9:39pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Scott is a retardo who knows nothing about soccer!!!
  5. COPAmundial
    22. Posted by COPAmundial Wed Nov 4 9:38pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Scott, sit on it!!!
  6. Giuvà
    21. Posted by Giuvà Wed Nov 4 8:08pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Very interesting comments for sure. I was hoping to see a little bit more respect for the Italian team as well as the American team.

    A note here for reference:

    I came to America to have a better life and I have. I have also worked hard to preserve my culture and language here. I respect all that America has to offer and I would love for them to excel in soccer. It does come to the point where I want to see respect passion and honor between teams. I hope that I am an example of how I would like an italian to be: respectable in presence.

    We will see what will happen during the World Cup...
  7. Valentinos
    20. Posted by Valentinos Wed Nov 4 7:30pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Hey Scott Your your a rascist. Plus you lost
  8. Scott
    19. Posted by Scott Mon Jun 22 10:22pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Great to see a boring, unimaginative crap team like Italy get a spanking by a team that knows how to play the game the way the game was meant to be played. Anyone who thinks Italy are a "real team" are either a) Italian or b) need to get a grip. I've always thought it strange that a country known for its flamboyance and artists can field teams that suck so much to watch--ok they're effective but they suck. Any team that plays not to lose instead of playing to win deserves what Italy got today. GOOD JOB BRAZIL
  9. Shalini
    18. Posted by Shalini Mon Jun 22 7:57pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    All Italy player either play golf or drink Brazilian's urine to play better footbal.
  10. andy
    17. Posted by andy Sun Jun 21 11:34pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    so what if the u.s's best athletes dont play soccer. whats the point of even making that comment? they dont play soccer so theres no point in mentioning it. also, why is everyone talking about the u.s on a story about italy vs. brazil? anyway, italy's defense would have been much much better today if de rossi and zambrotta hadnt kept leaving the back three wide open. the gap between mid and defense was enormous. everytime zambrotta went forward, he left room on the left that cannavaro had to fill, which moved both chiellini and dossena. not even sure if de rossi was really even out on the field today. pirlo though is simply beautiful to watch. if he gets good players around him, italy will be very dangerous. just my thoughts though
  11. <i>yaimoui</i>
    16. Posted by yaimoui Sun Jun 21 11:05pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I don't be amazed after defeat to Brasin . They are looking to lie the world by looklike as their qualities that they have but in actuall when you 're growing to old the body not allow you to do as you do in the young that is the answer for cheating Italy player and Series A. and without Fefa and lovely (doggy) referee helped , how didn't they success anything.
  12. josh
    15. Posted by josh Wed Jun 17 1:49pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    also if USA's best athletes played soccer we would be unstoppable, but they all play Football and Basketball. So go suck it you italian @#$%s.
  13. josh
    14. Posted by josh Wed Jun 17 1:44pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    i agree with rahoyt, they should give twellman a chance with the national team.
  14. rahoyt
    13. Posted by rahoyt Wed Jun 17 11:35am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Bradley has done a poor job as coach. His young players aren't getting better. He seems to have no long term plan with them. Spector, Onyewu, and Demerit were as bad as Bornstein. Defenders just allow shots; watch how the Italians fight to stay on ball and block the shot. And defense against De Rossi's goal was disgusting; if you're not going to play defense at least get the heck out of the keepers way so he can see. Why did Rossi go play for the Italians? Because they play their best players. The US has always has fielded the favorites of the coach. Arena had his favs; Bradley has his. Rossi never felt he was politically blessed and that really matters in US soccer. I really am amazed that Twellman has never been given a shot; he is a fierce competitor.
  15. ECA
    12. Posted by ECA Wed Jun 17 1:22am EDT

    Report Abuse

    everyone who bashes on the U.S. for soccer is a loser themselves. the americans played a man down for a good portion of the game on what should have not even been a red card. half of the people on this board leaving comments are idiots. and the person who said USA sucks is the biggest idiot. i think the U.S.'s only problem is they have the wrong players travel with the team. we have way better forwards, midfielders and defenders that bradley just doesn't pick for the team. and everyone needs to jump off the jozy altidore band-wagon cuz that kid isn't doing anything. he stands around up top. bradley needs to get some veterans out there like twellman or someone else and quit going with these young and inexperienced players.
  16. COPAmundial
    11. Posted by COPAmundial Tue Jun 16 11:58pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    USA will also lose to Honduras in Honduras and to Costarica in USA!!!!!
  17. sam23
    10. Posted by sam23 Tue Jun 16 11:57am EDT

    Report Abuse

    In my opinion, USA played well against Italy. Italy is the world champion with wealth of talents (when you see Luca Toni coming in as a sub and no place for Del Piero in the squad). There are only handful of US players, Howard, Donovan, and perhaps Bradley, who are capable of playing international games at the same level like these Italians do. Rossi, who is the Villareal heart and soul comes in as a sub, whereas, Altidore, who hardly even gets any playing time in the second tier Spanish League leads the starting lineup for the US. Players like Bornstein, Clark, Feilhaber, and Kljestan are only good at the club level; they can never provide the versatility against the top teams. So based on what USA has to offer and being a man down, if you think, they played a solid match against one of the soccer power houses to keep the scoreline 3 -1. If they hadn’t lost Clark so early in the game, the game could have ended up in tie.
  18. John N
    9. Posted by John N Tue Jun 16 8:54am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Are you kidding with these ratings? Aside from Howard, Onyewu and Bradley no one rated more than a 4. They looked like kidds playing a mans game.
  19. Thomas B
    8. Posted by Thomas B Tue Jun 16 1:44am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Its all MY fault. In my head I complemented Ricardo after Honduras and said he must have matured - if he can keep his composure and not take stupid penalties, maybe he is an answer. But if I were Italian, he would be the one to bait.

    Still, I did not knock and wood and accept all the blame for that oversight.

    Bradley does not have the feet to play midfield against good teams. We have to have someone quicker and with more creativity and skill on the ball. MB tries hard. Italy will be the slowest midfield we play here. Sasha seems to be regressing. Edu is hurt. Holden doesn't get the call. I hate changing every game, but I hope we see Adu and Torres at some point against Brazil. Benny I think still has an upside if he can get PT and a consistent role.

    Is it true that Iniesta was actually born in New Jersey too, and wants to come play for the US? :)

    Howard made all the plays anyone could have expected him to and read things well.

    Onyewu is gaining my confidence. Has any other American improved?

    We lack the talent to compete in competitions like this and our soccer IQ doesn't seem to be getting any better, but we also suffer from lack of coninuity. We can't expect to win at this level when we are still expirementing with lineups and formations. Italy's core has been there for years, then they just have to integrate a new player like Rossi here and there. Our "core" which one time included DMB, Convey, Obrien, etc. never materialized.
  20. <i>goals2103</i>
    7. Posted by goals2103 Tue Jun 16 12:17am EDT

    Report Abuse

    I don't think you can judge a goalkeeper's performance (such as Tim Howard's) on any sort of scale. The majority of the time, the blame can be put on the field players, and not on the keeper. And you can't judge a keeper on shots that are impossible to save. There are shots that are taken that nothing can be done about them. Playing keeper is the most nerve-wracking position in the sport.
  21. David L
    6. Posted by David L Mon Jun 15 11:52pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    these are terrible ratings, what game were you watching? onweyu the best player for the US? he had tons of mistakes during that game

    have u ever even played football?
  22. Caligiuri Fan
    5. Posted by Caligiuri Fan Mon Jun 15 11:26pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Adu can't get time in Portugal or France because of racism in Europe. The same reason Altidore is buried in Spain. Europeans hate blacks.
  23. Southside JB
    4. Posted by Southside JB Mon Jun 15 10:58pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Jozy has got to take that shot when he's in that close. Bradley works hard both ways and that's what the USA needs from more of their players. DaMarcus, when will he try to push forward and attack? Landon has got to keep attacking and take a shot sometime!
  24. Southside JB
    3. Posted by Southside JB Mon Jun 15 10:50pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Dempsey just doesn't work hard all the time and gives up the ball too easily. Would like to see more hustle out of him. He should watch the Brazil/Egypt game and see how the Egyptian players hustled all the time, a great effort from them!
  25. Edgar G
    2. Posted by Edgar G Mon Jun 15 10:11pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    adu are u kidding jajajajaja he cant even buy playing time in portugal or in france he should just go back to the poor level mls where he belongs he is a so over-hyped. as expected u.s. fails to beat a great power like italy. even the american born rossi chose to play for a real soccer team not some nobodies from the u.s. so now american born players (that are good aka g.rossi)will hope to have immigrant parents so they can play for that country and not for the u.s. they will use a get out of jail card and bail on the u.s. and go and be great players like for example uhh g. rossi who is only 22 and his development was in europe.so next i will be looking forward to seeing brazil beat the poor u.s. and its "players"
Sign in to post a comment, or sign up for a free account

Video Spotlight