5 / 32


27. Rae Carruth, Carolina, 1997
Regardless of how well he played on the field, he helped organize the murder of his girlfriend and unborn child, and remains in prison to this day. There’s worst-case scenarios for your draft picks, and then there’s Carruth.

NFL draft: Biggest first-round busts

You'd think a first-round draft pick would guarantee you a good chance of landing a successful player. Not so. Picks at every single position in the first round have failed to pan out, whether from lack of talent, injuries, front-office follies or bad attitudes. Here are the worst picks at every draft position of the first round. – Jay Busbee