26 / 32

4. McCants

4. Keith McCants, Tampa Bay, 1990
Art Schlicter will own this slot forevermore thanks to his gambling problems, but in the last 30 years the worst #4 selection has to be McCants. A spectacular college linebacker at Alabama, he was never anything more than an undistinguished pro player, and only played six years in the league.

NFL draft: Biggest first-round busts

You'd think a first-round draft pick would guarantee you a good chance of landing a successful player. Not so. Picks at every single position in the first round have failed to pan out, whether from lack of talent, injuries, front-office follies or bad attitudes. Here are the worst picks at every draft position of the first round. – Jay Busbee