Olympics Countdown:

Winter Olympics Countdown
01d:
17h:
03m:
52s
  • Begins Feb. 12, 2010

Fourth-Place Medal, a Yahoo! Sports blog covering the Olympics

Thu Aug 07, 2008 12:16 am EDT

The Olympics needs more politics

Whenever I hear or read a discussion about the Olympics and political issues, be they human rights, censorship, or what have you, eventually someone says, "Why can't we take the politics out of the Olympics, and just make it about the athletes and the competition?" Oddly, the answer to this question begins just like the answer I give my eight year old when he asks why we can't do something that he would like to do and I would not.

Because we just can't, that's why. Politics and the Olympics are as frustratingly intertwined as that string of Christmas lights that you swore you would put away nicely and neatly organized, and yet, come December, you'll be cursing again as it comes out of the box hopelessly entangled.

In Sunday's New York Times, Tom Scocca argued, quite effectively, that much of the treasured symbolism attached to the modern Olympics came into being at the 1936 Summer Games in Berlin, and, as a result, now "the Olympic Games are also, as a matter of record, a fascist spectacle, sustained by global corporatism."  Hey, if we're going to blame anyone, why not start with Hitler? But if we look at the history of the Olympics since Berlin, it's clear that political issues - local, national, and/or global - have played a role, whether as context or something more substantial, but often the political environment of the Games makes them that much better, that much more memorable.

We remember athletes like Cathy Freeman in Sydney; her victory lap carrying both the Australian flag and the "unofficial" Aboriginal flag emphatically articulated her pride in her status as the first individual Aboriginal gold medalist. Freeman ran a respectable time, one of the 10 best all-time, but we remember her because of the context, because of the attention she brought to her heritage, an issue of no small importance in Australia, and because she rose to the occasion in her homeland. Similarly, we remember Katarina Witt's poignant, moving tribute to a war-torn Sarajevo at the 1994 Winter Games in Lillehammer.

On sheer volume, most Olympic performances are forgotten by all but those people closest to the competitors. Some, like Bob Beamon's long jump, are distinguished by the stunning magnitude of the achievement. But, by and large, what we remember is the emotion of the athletes, the drama of the moment (the thrill of victory - and the agony of defeat), occasionally magnified by a larger significance.

Which is why I propose that instead of trying to take politics out of the Olympics, we do the opposite, and inject more and more and more, until the Olympics are as juiced as a mid-1990s major league baseball slugger. If Turkey wants to join the European Union, fine, but they're going to have to win at least five gold medals in Beijing to get into the club. Otherwise, you Turks are stuck in the global economic backwater. Likewise, the G8 should be made up of the top eight nations in the medal count of the most recent games (so long, Canada and Great Britain; hello, China and Australia). Here at home, let's settle the presidential election by decathlon; forget about super delegates, let's talk superheavyweights. Oil crisis? Simply index the price of a gallon of gas to the women's 1500 meter time (current world record, 3:50.46); I think that might make us all stand up and cheer.

Okay, so there are a few flaws with this plan (like if it had been in place in the 1970s, I'd be blogging for Pravda.com about the Spartakiads right now). But you can't separate politics from the Olympics, no more than you can separate politics from great art, music or literature. If you believe that the Olympic Games represent athletic virtuosity, the highest ideals of sport, then trying to eviscerate them of all political significance is like trying to discuss Picasso's "Guernica" without any reference to the horrors of modern warfare. You are left with some guys running real fast and a very confusing, if precisely painted, black and white mural.

Is it more complicated? Sure. More difficult? Maybe, but why do you think an aging Luciano Pavarotti performed at the 2006 Winter Olympics in his native Italy? And why are we going to enjoy the sublime genius of Lang Lang in Friday's Opening Ceremony? Because the host country wants the world to see its best, and the best want the world to see them there. Look, it's not as if the fate of the planet rests in every table tennis match point or synchronized swimming score. But occasionally, thankfully, the Olympics are about a little more than swifter, higher, stronger.

Photo via Getty Images

digg delicious
more

19 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. RhinoDJ
    1. Posted by RhinoDJ Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:14 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Why is it such a big deal that our athletes wore protective masks in a polluted city and had to issue an official apology when I see Asians everywhere here in the Bay Area and other places wearing them? They are offended? Afraid of infection or disease from an unclean country? I am offended as well. This is ludicrous media crap.
    Politics IS what the olympics has always been about, the athletes are just a sideshow. P.S. pay no attention to the proverbial man behind the curtain.
  2. salix
    2. Posted by salix Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:51 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I guess you don't mind if guests you invited to your home washes the clean dishes first before begin eating.
  3. kellco
    3. Posted by kellco Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:49 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    beijing is dirty and nasty!
  4. Beijingwelcome you
    4. Posted by Beijingwelcome you Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:34 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    As a Chinese citizen, I can safely say that Beijing is now cleaner, so please don't ignore the effort we have done!
    I will not be against anyone to wear face masks in Beijing: it's nothing, they can do what they like to do.
    It's not easy to understand China if you do not konw about China's history. So when you talk about today's China, please know somenthing about what China was, and don't just make comparison with your country, we have only been developing for 30 years.
    One thing I cannot understand is why someone will be always cheering when there is somenting bad happended in China and why they will be against anything that is good to China~
    Please come to visit China and to talk with Chinese then you will see a true China!
    Beijing welcome you ~
  5. mkbush
    5. Posted by mkbush Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:08 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    i'm not offended by anyone who chooses to wear face masks in Beijing, just look at the figures for number of people dying of lung cancer in China each year, you'd be crazy not to wear them.
    Before you start questioning my perspective, 我是北京人来的。北京空气好的话别人怎么也说不坏,反之亦然。
  6. moon_gdfts
    6. Posted by moon_gdfts Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:26 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    It's unfortunate and unfair that there are always unobjective reports and misunderstanding about China. It's true that China has some problems as any other countries, but it's developing and improved a lot . Seeing is believing. Beijing welcome you, China is open to all of you!
  7. snowman30
    7. Posted by snowman30 Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:58 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    on the medal standings i see that you list a country by the name Macedonia.There isn't asuch a country.There is only the former yugoslavic rebublik of macedonia(FYROM).Macedonia is a northern province in GREECE.
  8. Alex S
    8. Posted by Alex S Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:50 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The Chines have made great efforts to clean up Beijing. That effort should be recognized. It should also be recognized that these efforts, as great as they have been relative to the past situation, are not good enough. The Beijing air quality is still unacceptable for international events. In spite of the unsatisfactory air quality, in spite of the fact that bottled water is a must, and in spite of the unfair and rough handling of various protesters, it is my hope that the Games will proceed unhampered.
  9. Michigander21
    9. Posted by Michigander21 Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:35 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Despite desperate Chinese attempts to weigh the events in their favor, the Mass Execution and the timed event Partial Birth Abortion will not be included. The Chinese regime is outraged that the games at which they most excel have been denied.
  10. Sky Endeavour
    10. Posted by Sky Endeavour Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:23 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Eevery one loves his own country! So before you being proud of your own country, please respect others' country, and we will respect you.
  11. Kat
    11. Posted by Kat Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:47 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    very impressed by reference to Picasso's Guernica, Bill!
    (astonished that a few days earlier someone called you a sports geek!)
  12. Jono
    12. Posted by Jono Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:40 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    china = communist? communist = every 1 equal in wealth --- fact is its not that way. shows that china's politics is wrong and need to be attacked to be put right or changed completly
    i think they shouldnt be wearing just masks, they should wear gas masks. also they broke their promise of it been below a limit, which should mean the olympics should be called off
  13. usa!usa!usa!
    13. Posted by usa!usa!usa! Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:07 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    why in the world would they hold the olympics in a dirty third world country. how about the next olympics be held in bangledesh or in a desert. the americans should boycott the olympics because of health concerns, having to compete in such a filthy, dirty place.
  14. prince_of_dragons
    14. Posted by prince_of_dragons Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:48 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    mkbush:
    Have you ever heard of smokers and Beijing has lots of that? Dumb Western idiot.
    usa!usa!usa!
    Mexico City was awarded; why not China imbecile.
  15. sunstarmedic
    15. Posted by sunstarmedic Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:48 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Must polictics really penetrate every minute of our lives. I think the world could use a break from itself.
  16. nick
    16. Posted by nick Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:37 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Completely wrong!!! We do not need more politics in the Olympics. Politics ruins sports. You can argue the Miracle on Ice was a great political statement but, was it really? It was a hockey game at the end of the day. Politically though what did that game significantely do to either country? Bragging rights that someone could win a hockey game? Look at what politics is doing to sports just in our own country. Stepping into baseball about steroids and possibly throwing the greats that played the game behind the slammer for perjury. You got politics stepping into football about spygate and just tapping some practices and games. Here is the simple solution. Let politics stay where it belongs. Let the games play on and let the spirit of competition resume. Everything does not have to be about politics and making a political statement. China is China they are there own country they have their rules and we as Americans have our rules. Lets forget about the politics and watch these men and women represent their countries proudly and be judged on their performances and not by (what some would say their duty) making political statements. Lets just play the game.
  17. Cardinals
    17. Posted by Cardinals Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:35 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    hmm, why yes China is in a third-world country state with little economic wealth and leverage in the UN.
    The other point I would make coming from an Asian-American standpoint is that Americans really are still suffering from the media effects of the Cold War. You see those posts about communism? Dude, how do you not get the fact that China is now adopting capitalism, which is the main reason for their recent economic boom? Has popular media mentioned this even once? And if it has, has it ever not included a qualification?
    I think politics dominates some Olympics more than others, and the choice of Beijing only affirms the political aspect. But I think countries right now have a good balance btwn politics and the Olympics (ca.Iraq's
  18. WildGurl4453
    18. Posted by WildGurl4453 Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:50 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    just wait til the summer olympics are held in a place like Phoenix, AZ. Forget the polotion of china, think about Phoenix. An average summer temperature of between 105 and 110. Where by 8am the ambient outside temperature is already in the upperr 90s... Think of the athletes that would have to compete in that weather. Nights in Phoenix don't get much better in the summer where the night time temp in the summer rarely drops into the high 80s...
  19. Mellow
    19. Posted by Mellow Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:53 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I wanna laugh at those who bash at the air quality when they never even been to Beijing. Oh I believe whatever I see in the media. ONLY.

Fourth-Place Medal

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

The Vancouver Bloggers

Fourth-Place Medal is edited by the contributors linked below. Please send them tips and such.

Y! Sports Blogs

Yahoo! Sports Blog Recent Readers

Olympic, Olympiad, the Olympic rings, Faster Higher Stronger, Citius Altius Fortius and related marks are owned by the International Olympics Committee, the Canadian Olympic Committee, the Vancouver Organizing Committee for the XXI Olympic Winter Games, or their related entities. This site is neither endorsed by nor affiliated with any of these entities.