Tue Nov 10, 2009 11:59 am EST
One look at the Puck Daddy inbox over the last few weeks reaffirms that DirecTV is winning the war of attrition in its stalemate with Versus. Earlier this season, we'd receive a few emails a day from fans enraged at both sides of the dispute; they've been reduced to a trickle now, and the fact that the NHL's cable partner is 'network non grata' on DTV seems like it's become the norm.

Versus told us this morning what it's told us in previous conversations: That negotiations are ongoing and that there is a "zero total dollar increase" on the table that DirecTV has yet to counteroffer, while DTV continues to claim Comcast is asking for more money to air Versus programming. It's a faceoff in which neither side is blinking, thanks to DirecTV not seeing an overwhelming number of viewer defections over Versus and Versus being able to boast about record ratings despite not appearing on DTV airwaves.
Multichannel News had an update over the weekend, and pointed to one reasons why Versus hasn't been hit hard in viewership totals:
The ratings amelioration has come without DirecTV's 14 million-plus homes, as much of that subscriber loss has been made up by sneak previews on a number of cable operators and Dish Network, which has provided Versus a full berth of its homes. As such, Versus' sub count has only declined to 71 million homes from 75 million, before the DirecTV drop.
The Dish free preview, though, is slated to end on Nov. 30. However, sources familiar with the negotiations indicate that Versus and Dish are moving toward a more permanent, expanded placement for the network.
That's good news for Versus, but doesn't exactly move the puck on these talks with DirecTV. What will? It's a long-shot, but Comcast's talks for acquiring NBCU might become a factor.
From Multichannel:
Some observers in the sports TV community say another factor that could perhaps impact the Versus-DirecTV stalemate is Comcast's reported push to form a joint venture partnership with NBC Universal. They point to the potential for Versus to add replays of Notre Dame football games, and/or a pair of live Fighting Irish contests that NBC Sports can contractually shift to cable. Moreover, Versus would likely become one of NBC's stable of Olympics networks for London in 2012 (the deal wouldn't likely be closed in time for the upcoming Winter Games in Vancouver next February) and beyond, as expected to bid for the 2014 Olympics in Socchi, Russia and Rio De Janiero in 2016.
"DirecTV is playing a game of chicken. If Comcast gets NBCU, Versus could add some additional properties and become a stronger network. They could pull the offer and price might go up," said one executive familiar with the Comcast's thinking.
Again, that all seems so far down the line that it won't affect the current stalemate between Versus and DirecTV, but we're not an "executive familiar with the Comcast's thinking," so who knows?
We're on the record as saying that an NBC/Comcast merger would dramatically change the NHL's television landscape. Not sure if it does anything in this DTV/Versus mess. Keep in mind, however, that this battle has yet to spill over into Comcast's local sports networks on DTV; if Comcast eventually uses NBC properties as leverage, we could be seeing World War III between these media giants.
We're hazy on DirecTV's end game here when it comes to Versus. If it's the elimination of inflated fees from Comcast, that's on the table. If it's the ability to place Versus in a lower level of distribution, that's within DirecTV's rights; but to ask subscribers to ante up for a network it's spent the last few months disparaging as a collection of informercials seems counterproductive at the least.
Dish Network is adding viewers, but not an overwhelming total. Whatever the resolution here is with Versus, it appears to be DirecTV's finger on the trigger. Give them credit: This dispute has angered millions of hockey, football and general sports fans, and DTV has weathered the storm -- at least for the first two months.
One more hockey television note: Sports Business Journal has a piece on League-owned networks, and NHL Network was included in it. From SBJ, what's ahead for the NHL Net from COO John Collins:
One of the reasons the NHL depends on NHL Network for live games, highlights and preview shows is to give its viewers content that is in short supply elsewhere on TV.
"As of right now, we think the NHL is not getting its fair representation in the broader world of sports," Collins said.
In addition to live games, Collins expects to bolster that programming with highlights and inside access that networks don't have. He expects the better programming will play a part in helping the network expand its cable and satellite distribution footprint.
"Our longer-term plan is to get that network as broadly distributed as we can and really deliver on the promise of serving these fans, primarily with access," Collins said. "It's live game content, but it's also access that they can't get anywhere else."
Do you folks watch NHL Network? On The Fly is an indispensible highlights show, even with the banal commentary. But we find -- and this isn't a new gripe at all -- that there simply isn't enough there to rival, say, the MLB Network's coverage.
What do you want to see on NHL Network to improve it?
Puck Daddy is an NHL blog edited by Greg Wyshynski. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Vancouver 5, Colorado 2 (Nov. 20)
Posted Nov 19 2009
Montreal 3, Washington 2 (Nov. 20)
Posted Nov 19 2009
Chicago 7, Calgary 1 (Nov. 19)
Posted Nov 18 2009
Edited by MJD
Edited by 'Duk
Edited by J.E. Skeets
Edited by Greg Wyshynski
Edited by Matt Hinton
Edited by E. Brennan
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Steve Cofield
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Andy Behrens
48 Comments
1 - 25 of 48
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
As confused as I am, I kinda wish we could all just get along, and have NFLN, NHLN, MLBN, and NBAN all under one affordable TV package, and not have to slave after ESPN for all the scores, stats, etc. I watched MLBNetwork all summer, and thought that their programming was down-pat: Live updates throughout the night until all games were over, recaps of games earlier in the day, and even live-look ins of exciting moments in progress (i.e. Bases-loaded, one out situations). Then, all morning, one-hour recaps, highlights, player interviews and expert opinions. Kind of like Baseball Tonight, but better. In the afternoon, classic games and the like.
If NHLN is similar to that (which I think it is), I'd like to watch it.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
And yes, I watch NHL network all the time. NHL on the Fly could use some personality (like hire Buccigross away from ESPN), but heck, I can't compare it to SportsCenter on MLB Network, because I don't watch those... I watch hockey.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Irrespective of the vs/direct dispute, I have always thought that if Bettman (excuse my french) wanted to promote the sport of hockey, instead of trying to force feed it to non-hockey markets, he should encourage CBC or TSN to be carried by American satellite and cable companies. Then let nature take its course. It is a great sport that will be watched by some, but not all. But certainly is should be available to more households than can currently view it.
Report Abuse
If you haven't had your subscription picked up yet, call DTV, tell you are considering dropping them and tell them if they give you Center Ice you'd consider it a good faith move to keep you around while they sort out the Versus mess. They will turn on your Center Ice and not charge if you aren't a subscriber or they will issue you a $160 statement credit if you already have Center Ice.
It isn't much leverage over them but if enough people do it, it'll hit'em in the pocket book a bit.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
-Sign a package for CHL (major junior) games...they showed the Memorial Cup; why not show a few major junior games?
-TSN hockey programming. In addition, simulcast their games that don't compete with Versus on Wednesday/Thursdays. In HD.
-Increase coverage of the WJC and the World Championships. I know Universal Sports has the rights for the World Championships; at a minimum broker a same-day replay deal.
-Go back to showing the Saturday HNIC doubleheader, or at least show the early game (if they have a 3pm game).
-Show the HDIC tripleheader.
-Borrow the NFL Network model and show replays of games condensed into a 60-minute format; maybe a "game of the night".
-Air non-compete first-round playoff games that do not compete with Versus/TSN exclusives (as an example, last year's NJD/CAR series was ignored everywhere- why not just simulcast someone else's feed?).
Report Abuse
And while I think the NHL Network analysts are good guys and knowledgeable, they are a FAR cry from watching the Hotstove segment on CBC. There's no reason why good analysts can't be charismatic and entertaining as well. Let's get some of them on NHL Network, someone like Kelly Hrudey. He'd be great. Though I wonder if the stiff and mechanical NHL Net hosts are the bigger part of the problem. If you watch MLB Network, which is FANTASTIC, you can't help but notice how energetic and entertaining the hosts are. And the MLB player-analysts play right off that energy.
As for Versus, I'm bitterly accepting the dispute for now. But when the playoffs roll around, DirecTV better have an answer or I will be terminating my service.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
I would be weary of showing other Leagues, it is the NHL Network after all. But for now if it means showing Live content, then so be it. World Juniors would be perfect, heck, even AHL 'Game of the Week' works. Replay IIHF games from the Olympics. And again, everything that can be shown in HD, make sure its in HD, including ALL Live programming on the Network.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
1 - 25 of 48