Puck Daddy - NHL

As we mentioned in the Three Stars dishonorable mentions, there was some rather terrible officiating around the NHL last night. But as any fan, player or coach of the Columbus Blue Jackets and Tampa Bay Lightning will tell you this morning, those two teams probably got the worst of it.

In Tampa, Mike Smith was facing Milan Hejduk of the Colorado Avalanche in the shootout when he lost control of his stick. The rest is infamy:

Man, we haven't seen Rick Tocchet that upset since the Packers failed to cover the number on Monday Night Football. Hejduk's goal turned out to be the game-winner in Colorado's 2-1 victory. Damien Cristodero of the St. Pete Times explained that the only applicable rule in this situation is "26-4, which states that a goal will be awarded when, during a penalty shot, a shot is disrupted by a deliberately thrown stick."

Was Smith deliberately tossing his stick at the shooter? If he was, he sort of sucked at it.

Cristodero continues on Lightning Strikes:

What is strange is that such a play is not reviewable. As Mike Murphy, the NHL's director of hockey operations, said after the game, the only thing reviewable is if the puck was in the net. It wasn't so there could not be a review.

We have that kind of technology and the play like that can't be reviewed? Come on. You knew it was going to be a controversial call. The officials talked about it for an extended period of time. Don't you want to be sure you get it right?

What a joke. Almost as bad as officials refusing to speak with media after games like this, but not nearly as bad as those dopey wireless microphones the referees try to use never, ever working. Go to Radio Shack, Gary. They're probably having a sale.

Meanwhile, in Columbus, Ken Hitchcock was angry. Like, "you ate the last cookie and didn't throw away the box?" angry.

The Blue Jackets were in OT against the Dallas Stars in a 5-5 tie when Manny Malhotra appeared to end the game 13 seconds into the extra session (head to the 4:45 mark of the video for the goal):

Hitchcock was furious after the game:

"We won the hockey game," Hitchcock said. "We won the hockey game. It was a good goal. I don't care what anybody says, we won the hockey game.

"We outplayed them They can put up whatever score they want down there, they can put up whatever score they want in the National Hockey League. We won the hockey game.

"That player did not kick it. All he tried to do was get out of the way of the goaltender."

Malhotra held his tongue a bit, but was still outraged:

"I couldn't have kicked it if I tried ... I didn't understand the explanation. For them to say it was a kicking motion this ranks right up there. It's a really frustrating way to lose a point."

This one is closer call than the Lightning folly. But Malhotra's clearly being jostled by Daryl Sydor, and doesn't appear to intentionally guide the puck into the net with his skate because there's really no way for him to react that quickly to Marty Turco's save.

So we have one injustice that can't be fixed with replay, and one injustice caused by replay. And not a single referee willing to answer to them. Pathetic.

digg delicious
more

124 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. princessandie77
    1. Posted by princessandie77 Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:18 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    the "kicking" call is the same one that got Morrow last year in the play offs. It maybe time for the NHL to take a look at that rule.
  2. joe h
    2. Posted by joe h Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:26 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Lol @ the Mike Smith goal. Wow.
    Malhotra can go to hell. Another wasted 1st rounder for the Rangers. BAH
  3. Maraldo
    3. Posted by Maraldo Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:34 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I don't think Mike Smith threw his stick. Looks like he just dropped it. If he did try to throw it you're right Wysh, he really sucked at it.
  4. Bubbabanjo
    4. Posted by Bubbabanjo Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:05 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Man is that a god awful hideous jersey. Man are those "Bolts" owners nuts!
    Ooooooooooooof.
  5. Hans Gruber
    5. Posted by Hans Gruber Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:58 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Was Brett Hull in the crease in 99?
  6. N. Y. NIGHTMARE
    6. Posted by N. Y. NIGHTMARE Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:06 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    they screwed the bolts much worse... i think manny knew he was kicking by the way he turned his foot.
  7. G
    7. Posted by G Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:12 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Wow! Terrible! I'm just glad the poor officiating that has gone on all year long is finally getting some legitimate publicity. 2 controversies in one night has to be unavoidable, even for Gary Bettman (SUCKS).
    Also, great point about the referees radios. I havent heard one that works all season. The NFL has been using mics for 20+ years! The NHL should just raid an old stock room at the NFL offices, they must have a bunch lyin around somewhere. Shouldnt be too hard to get in either, hasn't the NFL laid off all its security by now. Awful.
    P.S. Congrats to Mike Smith on the great effort and what might be the shootout save of the season.
  8. GT
    8. Posted by GT Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:14 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    This is just a thought, so please people, don't get all uppity about this suggestion...but have they ever considered allowing the puck to be kicked in? It would do away with trying to determine "distinct kicking motion", would increase scoring somewhat, and it probably wouldn't be a very effective way to score, thus would only happen a few times a season. You think we should get into this?....Just a thought.
  9. MCDevils
    9. Posted by MCDevils Thu Sep 03, 2009 6:49 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    More bad news for the BJs.... impressive rookie Derick Brassard in last night's game started a fight with Stars' rookie James Neal (another one of those silly fights started in response to a perfectly clean hit). Not only did Neal completely dominate Brassard in the scrap, giving him a nice cut over the eye, but Brassard apparently injured his shoulder during the fracas and will be out 3-4 weeks.
  10. Max Hunter
    10. Posted by Max Hunter Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:50 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Is it just me, or do the refs REALLY suck this season - compared to previous seasons?
  11. Jefe
    11. Posted by Jefe Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:30 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    As unfair as the kicking call may have looked last night, when I saw the replay I knew it was going to be called off. I am not arguing intentional or not, but there have been a few Morrow disallowed goals where the kicking motion was less distinct than this one. Although I know "intenional" is part of the wording of the rule, but as you see how Toronto ruled on this one and others in the past, intentional does not appear to be part of the ruling. Malhotra did distinctively kick it forward past Turco and in the replay you can see he was looking down at it. Now if it was intentional is arguable but that is inconsequential. I can remember at least 2 goals called back on Morrow that were less "distinct" and appeared less "intentional" than Malhotra's so I knew it was coming back. We have been screwed by this before, so it feels a little better being on the other end of this call.
  12. firethecannon
    12. Posted by firethecannon Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:11 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I think the jackets call is worse. The referees made a decision in the Tampa game that turned out to be the wrong one. They blew it, but they didn't have the luxury of replay. The rule might be terrible, but blown calls happen.
    In the jackets game the correct call was made on the ice and then overturned by Toronto. It is a lot worse in my mind to blow a call when you have 5 minutes to review it. It would have been impossible for Malhotra to kick the puck. He was supporting himself with one leg and being pushed from behind. Terrible call and Hitch has every reason to be upset. It will be interesting to see what the leagues reaction is to his comments.
  13. Matt
    13. Posted by Matt Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:18 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I was going to say - no surprise that was Tim Peel working that game.
    He's now (with Mr. Magoo's retirement) the worst official in the NHL.
  14. bob_billy
    14. Posted by bob_billy Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:10 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Boy, the Bolts can't buy a break this year, and we all know Barrie & koules have tried. I can't even stand TB but there is no way Smith threw his stick, looks like an unintentional drop to me. Well a t least they got the charity point I guess. I especially loved the way the fans started chanting bulls**t, great! Damn skills competitions.
  15. Ed K
    15. Posted by Ed K Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:21 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I don't think all the refs really suck this season. Just Tim Peel. Personally, I was amazed at the Lightning analyst's delusional view that Smith stopped the puck before losing his stick (uuuhh...no), but that's still a terrible call. Could you imagine how many goals would've been awarded against Hasek if that was called that way every time?
  16. Maraldo
    16. Posted by Maraldo Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:34 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    @ GT
    Allowing the puck to be kicked in has been debated before. I think the NHL's main beef with it is player safety, with guys falling around the crease and goalies sprawled out, and people start kicking at the puck, could get a little ugly.
  17. Brodie30
    17. Posted by Brodie30 Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:46 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    @ 14 I still say Kevin Pollock, Dave Jackson, and Eric Furlatt are worse. But Peel is definitely climbing. In his defense, it may have been the other ref that told Miller to GFH. But whomever said it (if they did) has real ego problems, which is not a good trait for an official.
  18. Sctlaw
    18. Posted by Sctlaw Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:10 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I have never lost control of my goal stick in that manner, maybe Smith did, but that given he has far more skill and muscle control than I have I think his intent was to imped the puch with the stick including intentionally letting go of the stick. Even if it was not completely intentional, hes got to keep a hold or control of the stick, otherwise he opens himself up for such a call.
  19. cent100q
    19. Posted by cent100q Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:21 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    you must have missed the caps game - officiating was so horrible that the game got completely out of hand in the 3rd, people were gunning for each other left and right for revenge. a couple hits (semin's new injury) were probably suspension worthy.
  20. Jefe
    20. Posted by Jefe Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:30 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Turco's errant stick the other night in the shootout looked more intentional than Smith's last night and Turco wasn't called, but I guess that ref actually knew th rule. The officiating has been real bad lately. Beyond the goal contraversy last night (which was called 'right', but this is more of an argument of changing the rule), there were multiple blantant trips, one of which caused a breakaway, that weren't called. There was a blantant boarding that was so bad I was surprised we weren't on the power play after the commercial break. Lots of interference hits where guys were getting leveled and the puck was no where near them. Add in a couple of blantant cross checks and I was wondering if these refs were even paying attention to the game. The refs would let all this blantant stuff go on and then call those really weak hooking and holding BS calls. Plus many bad offsides calls/non-calls and early whistles (to clarify I am talking about going both ways, some of these hurt us and some favored us in this atrocity of officiating). I have been to many of the Stars home games and watched most if not all of the Stars' games and the officiating has been god awful this year at least at our games. Concern for players safety on the ice- FAIL. Calling a clean fair game- FAIL. Maybe if Bettman wasn't so worried about the image of the NHL, which he has been eroding since he took over, we could focus on getting decent officiating in our league instead of discusing why Bettman's spawn is so sheltered that she doesn't know what sloppy seconds is. Here is a hint- the NHL is getting the NBA's sloppy seconds with Bettman, major emphasis on sloppy.
  21. bfrank27
    21. Posted by bfrank27 Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:47 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Mike Smith should take some lessons on how to throw equipment from Scotty Hartnell.
  22. jibblescribbits
    22. Posted by jibblescribbits Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:34 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I think the moral of the story is to always hold onto your stick no matter what the circumstances, despite what my boss says about professionalism.
  23. Death by Leafs
    23. Posted by Death by Leafs Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:16 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    @ 9, GT:
    the no-kicking rule is to protect players/goalies. if guys think its alright to throw their legs around, goalies are gonna start getting cuts & severed tendons on their hands, or worse (and players are much less protected). the intent of the rule is one of the things the nhl actually gets right. the salming & malarchuk accidents were bad enough, you don't want the circumstances to be in place for a repeat.
  24. Mark V
    24. Posted by Mark V Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:33 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I find the whining by the Tampa fans to be quite humorous, especially from Smith himself. To say that he made the save and then " had to drop the stick because my stick was going to come up in the air" was laughable. Why is he worried about his stick coming up in the air?
    Also the Lightning did not lose the game due to that call. They lost the game because their top three scorers couldn't get a single goal past a backup goalie who had a 3-8 record in shootouts. Blaming someone else is easier than owning up to your own shortcomings.

Puck Daddy

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Greg Wyshynski

Puck Daddy is an NHL blog edited by Greg Wyshynski. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Puck Daddy Recent Readers

Watch Live Hockey Online with GameCenter Live™