Puck Daddy - NHL

Like the source of Taco Bell's ground beef and the possibility of a "Lady In The Water" sequel, the potential for Toronto Maple Leafs Coach Ron Wilson losing his job at this point in the season is something I've refused to contemplate.

That was until I hopped on HNIC Radio with Jeff Marek yesterday and it became apparent that Wilson's removal was, for many observers, a distinct possibility given the Leafs' stumble out of the gate and the unreasonable expectations placed on both coach and team.

Unreasonable in the sense that the Toronto Maple Leafs were not going to lead the NHL in goals scored and win at a .666 clip (though numerically appropriate, considering the subject) like they did in their preseason tease.

Unreasonable in the sense that, as Marek pointed out, Burke traded what's suddenly looking like a lottery pick to the Boston Bruins for first-line player who isn't in the lineup until the end of November. No pressure there.

Unreasonable in the sense that despite the improvements on the blue line, this is still the worst defensive team in hockey (24 goals against) with two goalies -- Vesa Toskala(notes) (5.57 GAA, .810 save percentage) and Jonas Gustavsson(notes) (3.08 GAA, .890 save percentage) -- who couldn't stop a nose bleed.

Melrose'ing Wilson now does ... what, exactly? Expedites the rebuilding process? Makes the goaltending suddenly Vezina-quality? Heals Phil Kessel(notes) like Jesus laying hands on a leper?

Don't misunderstand: Wilson's not infallible in this mess. But the cases against him don't justify what would be panic city in T.O.

Christopher Botta of FanHouse was one of the first with the knives out last night after the team's 7-2 loss at the New York Rangers; stopping short of calling for Wilson's head but carving him up as a quitter for abruptly ducking out of his postgame press conference:

Wilson likes to give the media lectures on the kinds of questions reporters should ask, yet he seems to have no answers for his last-place hockey team. Facing a Rangers team that played the night before, the Leafs were the whupped team in the third, getting out-scored 4-0 and, worse, displaying no heart. This team wins the occasional fight, but little else. Monday night, they didn't even have any fight left in them.

Damien Cox has been selling crazy on this Leafs team since he realized his prediction of a playoff seed may have been a tad, ahem, premature. But the Toronto Star columnist sees Wilson's reign as an 87-game body of work instead of a five-game regular-season sample. Now, he doesn't think Wilson will be axed, but ...

Given that the team does not own a proven NHL starting goaltender, the need for quality defensive play is greater now than at any time previously during Wilson's reign. Yet the club ran around at Madison Square Garden last night even worse than they did at home to Pittsburgh on Saturday.

It would be a shocker if Burke pulled the plug on Wilson, and don't bet on it. But coaches do get canned after starts like this. It happens.

Here's one from the fantasy department for you. Imagine if Burke axed Wilson and turned to ex-Phoenix coach Wayne Gretzky to coach the Leafs.

Would Gretzky do it? Could he possibly turn it down? Now that would be a shakeup.

But again, that's pure fantasy, not even worthy of being called speculation. Try idle chatter.

Or idiocy.

The blogs have ranged from scathing indictments of Wilson to reasoned assessments of his lot in life. See if you can figure out into which category Mark Gregory's rant on the Bleacher Report falls into:

The players have not responded to Wilson. Wilson's loyalty to let his overpaid players play, and his stubborn insistence on playing Toskala even though it is apparent to everyone there was a problem four games ago.

Time to throw Wilson overboard before the whole Leaf season sinks, like the Titanic. Time to change those who refuse to change. Evolve or die, things must get better for the Leafs, because they can't get any worse.

Sports and The City is pining for an old flame:

Granted it's only been a year and change, but horrendous defensive zone play and suspect penalty killing have begun to define Wilson's tenure in Toronto. Hopefully that'll change once Jonas Gustavsson takes up permanent residence between the pipes, but I'm worried. Enough to be thinking about the ex, Paul Maurice. And no Leafs coach should ever leave me pining for Maurice's return. I just can't shake the feeling: if Wilson couldn't get it done in San Jose, there's no way he accomplishes anything of substance (playoffs!!1) with the Maple Leafs.

But it's GM Brian Burke taking a hit elsewhere on the Web. Greg Caggiano on Metro Hockey takes an outsider's approach to the Leafs mess and writes that Burke has gone from "Genius to Mockery." From Metro Hockey:

One may argue that the season is still early and there is time for improvement. But as said in tonight's game by Sam Rosen, Colton Orr(notes) is currently their best forward. Need anything more be said? There are still seventy-five games remaining, but current GM of the St. Louis Blues John Davidson used to always say, "The points you win in October are the points you don't need in April." Meaning simply that it does not matter when the game is, a win is a win, and a loss is a loss.

Following tonight's 7-2 loss to the Rangers, Leafs' head coach Ron Wilson walked up to the podium and said, "I'm done." Then walked away. The clock may already be ticking for him, and it should be for Burke as well, who has turned this once proud organization into the mockery of the NHL.

Finally, Pension Plan Puppets gets it right (as usual): It's pretty damn hard for a coach or a team to play with any confidence when an empty net would improve the current state of Leafs goaltending:

Ron Wilson has complained that things are really depressing and it's not too hard to understand why. If I was busting my ass only to see a terrible goal it would sap a lot of the will out of me. Especially if I killed myself during training camp to get the opportunity to make the team or improve my standing while the black hole in net was gifted his position and gets nothing but support from the coach. But that's just me. I've never had to play on a team with at least two superior options in net that didn't see the ice because of reasons beyond comprehension to every outside observer.

Several things can and will occur before Wilson is dismissed, assuming the GM would ever jettison his handpicked coach (er, uh, we mean someone else's handpicked coach, because Burke was with the Ducks at the time, you see). Young players like James Reimer(notes) or Tyler Bozak(notes) could infuse a little hunger or competition into the lineup. Francois Beauchemin(notes) and Mike Komisarek(notes) could, in theory, begin earning a few pennies of their wages. Some dramatic transaction to salvage the goaltending could occur. (And Joey MacDonald's(notes) between the pipes tonight against the Colorado Avalanche, with Toskala "hurt.")

One or two wins, and that preseason swagger could return, right?

But Wilson? Safe. For now. Barring an Epic Fail that sees the Leafs go winless in, like, their first dozen games. It's still early, and he's a smart coach. Just not when it comes to spelling:

That Gianta. Quite a player.

digg delicious
more

95 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. eyebleaf
    1. Posted by eyebleaf Tue Oct 13, 2009 11:28 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Joey MacDonald!!!!1 Thanks for the link, gents.
  2. Curt S
    2. Posted by Curt S Tue Oct 13, 2009 11:48 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Playoffs!!!!1
    Bring back the Frosh Line. Get Tlusty in the lineup at all costs. Ease up on the Truculence (!!!1) because it's led to a lot of penalty time. Schenn paired with Kaberle, drop Komisarek to Beauchemin's pairing to let him re-coup some confidence with somewhat diminished responsibilities. For godsake, play Jason Blake. I have no idea why this guy is constantly in the dog house but he is the team's most reliable point producer. He's no stud but at least he can play in the offensive zone.
  3. Curt S
    3. Posted by Curt S Tue Oct 13, 2009 11:48 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    Playoffs!!!!1
    Bring back the Frosh Line. Get Tlusty in the lineup at all costs. Ease up on the Truculence (!!!1) because it's led to a lot of penalty time. Schenn paired with Kaberle, drop Komisarek to Beauchemin's pairing to let him re-coup some confidence with somewhat diminished responsibilities. For godsake, play Jason Blake. I have no idea why this guy is constantly in the dog house but he is the team's most reliable point producer. He's no stud but at least he can play in the offensive zone.
  4. Conrad
    4. Posted by Conrad Tue Oct 13, 2009 11:56 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    For years the Leafs were esentially Rangers North, spending instead of building, throwing everything against the wall to see if it sticks instead of being patient. They finally committed to a rebuild and seemed to be sticking with it. And then they got Burke who, let's face it, is not the guy you get to build a team but the guy you get to take that team up a notch. He trades away two first rounders, essentially saying that he was done building (Schenn and Kadri? That's all they get out of a rebuild?) and potentially setting up a division rival for years. (They're enjoying having Rask, too.) They blew it early.
    How long did the Penguins and Caps have to suck to get to where they are now? Why can't Toronto just commit to doing a rebuild right?
  5. The Bog
    5. Posted by The Bog Tue Oct 13, 2009 11:59 am EDT

    Report Abuse

    LOL @ Gianta. Maybe Wilson was taking a stab at his size in his notes, since his previous 2 notes were about how small the Habs are.
  6. dylan
    6. Posted by dylan Tue Oct 13, 2009 12:01 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I'm off to go scour DGB to learn anything about this third option goalie, but anyone have a snappy one-liner about MacDonald? Also I liked The Lady in The Water, not as good as Villiage but a nice bed time story (as advertised).
  7. Runnin up on ya !
    7. Posted by Runnin up on ya ! Tue Oct 13, 2009 12:09 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    was watched the game last night and it was funny to see toskala giving his d-men hell then gives up a softy right afterward. funny but what has toskala accomplished as a goalie to reprimand the guys in front of him like he has nothing to do with it?
  8. NYR34
    8. Posted by NYR34 Tue Oct 13, 2009 12:15 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I was at that chuckler last night, and was shocked at how good the Leafs made the Rangers' offense look. That's when you know you're bad ;)
  9. Josh Smith
    9. Posted by Josh Smith Tue Oct 13, 2009 12:16 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    For all the Leaf fans pining for Joey MacDonald, there is a reason why the last place team in the NHL last season declined to re-sign him. In reality, he is an AHL starter and makes a very shaky backup at the NHL level.
  10. GT
    10. Posted by GT Tue Oct 13, 2009 12:22 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    It's all a conspiracy....Americans managing the biggest Canadian hockey team. They are trying to sock it to them for payback in winning the gold in 2002.
  11. Wandy.Rood
    11. Posted by Wandy.Rood Tue Oct 13, 2009 12:33 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Does this unrelenting support for Ron Wilson have anything to do with him being Team USA's head coach, you self-serving jackass?? Do us all a favour and get back to work on chapter 11,297 of your never ending tribute to Ovechkin. When we want real analysis we'll go to Mirtle's site.
    Team USA is infallible and can do no wrong!!!11
  12. W.F
    12. Posted by W.F Tue Oct 13, 2009 12:40 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    To add further evidence to ppp's claims that this team had no cofidence in their goalie, look at the replay of the Rangers fifth goal (I think there were just too many to be sure). Instead of playing defence and challeneging the shooter Jeff finger is dropping back and trys to make a glove save. You should have enough cofidence in your goalie to make a save from outside the slot and not feel like you have to block everything going towards the net.
    Blocking shots are important but making sure players aren't getting a second and third chance to knock in a (huge) rebound is more important.
    The defense clearly has no faith that Toskola can clear or handle the initial shot
    and it's taking taking it's toll on every other aspect of the defensive zone coverage.
  13. parklanedave
    13. Posted by parklanedave Tue Oct 13, 2009 12:42 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    LISTEN ALL.... i would luv to see the leafs succeed... but no cup in 40 years!???? people you are being scammed i have been to rinks all over the u.s to ohl game in canada& in europe but what this ownership is doing is a scam... 500$ for a family of four parking.. & food... WAKE UP until I repeat UNTIL... this team gets NEW OWNERSHIP nothing will change... NOTHING.. who do you think is stopping toronto from getting another team... hmmm??? its pathetic& the ONLY ONE THAT LOSES OUT IN THE END IS "US" THE FANS..... END OF....
  14. Russ Cargill
    14. Posted by Russ Cargill Tue Oct 13, 2009 12:44 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I don't think kessel will stop the bleeding. They have decent snipers now...what they actually needed was a top 10 set up man. Kessel for Jordan Staal straight up no chaser!?!
  15. Runnin up on ya !
    15. Posted by Runnin up on ya ! Tue Oct 13, 2009 12:45 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Hey...Wandy.Rood....Yarry Take...Wes Walz or whatever grunt your going to be next month. give it a rest.
    BTW...your not showing your hockey IQ with your cute little flip of names your using. it was cool the 1st time now it's just passe
  16. NYR34
    16. Posted by NYR34 Tue Oct 13, 2009 12:50 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Oh, and Wysh,
    As a fellow New Order fan I thought you'd have liked that in the closing minutes of the game at MSG, "Blue Monday" started playing over the speakers during a timeout. Even if it was the Orgy remake...
  17. c_bates
    17. Posted by c_bates Tue Oct 13, 2009 1:09 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I don't think any goalie can help that team. They were horrible to a man last night, you can't always blame the goalie even though they are the easiest to blame. When the Rangers 3rd line pins you in your own end 5 on 5 like they are on a PP for 2+ minutes, you are in trouble. Toskala isn't making big saves or stealing games but he isn't the only one to blame for this mess. Schenn looks lost, Beauchemin has looked horrible and Komisarek has only excelled at taking penalties. Combine that with no forward that gives any sort of presence up front and you have the 2009/2010 Toronto Maple Leafs. I feel sorry for Phil Kessel when he finally does come back, hope he has thick skin.
  18. Matt S
    18. Posted by Matt S Tue Oct 13, 2009 1:14 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The whole thing is just absurd. The Leafs have been a big load of suck for a heck of a long time and expecting them to do anything this early in the season is insane. Burke is more to blame than anyone, in the pre-season he was like a broken record, his answer to everything was "we're a playoff team". Well, that's a pretty bold statement and the media were drooling over the likeliness of Bruke being completely wrong. They shot themselves in the foot. Or Burke did.
  19. Spock
    19. Posted by Spock Tue Oct 13, 2009 1:43 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Matt S. I'm not sure that the media was drooling over the likeniness that Burke was completely wrong about the Leafs being a playoff team. From what I read, a lot of them were actually buying into what Burke was feeding them . . . . the Leafs draft picks, because they would be a playoff team, would probably be the 15th pick or so of the draft, thus not a steep price for Kessel. Moreover, a lot of people actually thought that Burke fleeced the Bruins in the Kessel trade (both Leafs and Bruins fans). It's only 5 games into the season, and Burke may still be proved correct. They're only 1 point away from 2nd to last place in the league standings, thus things are not as bad as they appear.
  20. Tacks
    20. Posted by Tacks Tue Oct 13, 2009 2:13 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    i suppose the rumor that the coach is not well liked and the locker room is a disaster is not really a rumor right?
  21. Justin
    21. Posted by Justin Tue Oct 13, 2009 2:33 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    First off Burke is OVERATED!! You can't really blame Wilson, he has NO ONE to coach. But what Wilson has done wrong is give the veterans a ton of playing time which they don't deserve. I mean Jamal Mayers is useless. They should of hired Steve Yzerman as GM.
  22. Sean
    22. Posted by Sean Tue Oct 13, 2009 2:51 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Curt S - Go Hawks Go
  23. Chris
    23. Posted by Chris Tue Oct 13, 2009 2:55 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Is it possible that Toskala is worse not being injured? Should have let kadri and bozak play the guys on the roster are no better probably not as good.

Puck Daddy

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Greg Wyshynski

Puck Daddy is an NHL blog edited by Greg Wyshynski. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Puck Daddy Recent Readers

Watch Live Hockey Online with GameCenter Live™