Tue Dec 02, 2008 5:10 pm EST
The KHL's plans for its first-ever all-star game are pretty spectacular. The Jan. 11 contest will be played outdoors in Moscow's Red Square; and as a result of a fan vote, the format will feature "Team Yashin" (Alexei Yashin's group of Russian and former Soviet Republic players) against "Team Jagr" (consisting of foreign-born players).
So it's like the League's base constituency against "The World." Huh ... wonder where they go that from?
Inspired by this team-captain format, Eric McErlain of NHL FanHouse came up with a rather revolutionary idea for the NHL All-Star Game: Allowing two superstars to pick their own squads.
In his example, it would be Pittsburgh Penguins star Sidney Crosby's "Team Crosby" against Washington Capitals' star Alexander Ovechkin's "Ovie Style." Here's how he sees it playing out:
First off, I'd keep the voting the same way it is now, with fans voting five skaters and a goalie from both the Eastern and Western Conference. But once you get those results, all other bets are off. Next, you match your two designated team captains with the coaches who have won the honor of coaching a team based on the best record in each conference.
What comes next is a live draft aired between periods of the NHL Winter Classic. Working together with the designated coaches -- for sake of example, we'll say Claude Julien is matched with Ovechkin and Todd McLellan is paired with Crosby -- the team captains will draft their All-Star teammates, with the only proviso being that the first six selections must come from the player pool elected to start the game by the votes of the fans. Each team will select three players -- alternating one at a time -- during each between periods break.
McErlain writes that after the televised draft, "the two teams will continue to alternate picks one at a time until the traditional rosters are complete." Then the NHL leaks out the picks over the next week or two to keep the interest intense. (This would obviously rely on watertight security and silence about the picks, which is impossible in our media culture.)
Other than tainting the Winter Classic with this gimmick -- there's no need for it to appear on that broadcast -- there's some wacky virtue to this bat-poop crazy idea. Like, for example, if Ovechkin won the first pick and selected Evgeni Malkin. Yowzer.
What do you think? Too nutty? Good for one year? Keep the All-Star Game as-is?
One last Ovechkin note: His official Web site AlexOvechkin8.com is up and running. You, too, can own the official Alex Ovechkin 'Great 8 Chain & Pendant' for $175.
Puck Daddy is an NHL blog edited by Greg Wyshynski. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Detroit 3, Montreal 2 (Nov. 21)
Posted Nov 20 2009
Dallas 5, New Jersey 3 (Nov. 21)
Posted Nov 20 2009
Chicago 5, Edmonton 2 (Nov. 21)
Posted Nov 20 2009
Edited by MJD
Edited by 'Duk
Edited by J.E. Skeets
Edited by Greg Wyshynski
Edited by Matt Hinton
Edited by E. Brennan
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Steve Cofield
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Andy Behrens
35 Comments
1 - 25 of 35
Report Abuse
Go Pens!
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Here's my dream All-Star starting line for the east:
LW - C - RW
Ovechkin - Malkin - Crosby
or
Ovechkin - Crosby - Malkin
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
I think that's Bettman's plans. Kill the souls of those who actually care enough about hockey, so that they will be willing to go along with his "bizonker" ideas in the future.
Report Abuse
Laraque-Lucic-Godard vs
Boogard-Hordichuk-Stortini
Wyshynski enforcer all-stars wouldnt stink!
Report Abuse
But seriously, if they ever go to this gimmick, Crosby and Ovechkin should not just be the de facto team captains. If anything, it would just bruise a lot of egos. Make the captains the top two points leaders of the previous season (so Ovechkin & Malkin for this past season). Then you would at least have some semblance of entitlement to the guys who are running the show, not just whoever the NHL decides to ordain as the showpiece of the league - if Crosby or Ovechkin go in the tank for the next few years, why should they be in charge of anything? That would be like the Patrik Stefan Allstars facing off against the Brian Berard Allstars.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
How cool. How freaking cool.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Their all-star game is OUTSIDE!
I'm not saying replace the Winter Classic with the All-Star game, but consider doing these games in some different locations than just NHL arenas.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
But, if we really want to make it interesting we would play NHL vs KHL. I know a lot to people are thinking that the NHL would wipe the floor with the KHL, but dont forget that during the lockout-shortened season back in 1994 Wayne Gretzky took Mark Messier, Steve Yzerman, and a team of handpicked All Stars to play against European club teams and got humbled on more than one occasion. (Does anybody know the win loss record on that?) To be fair to Wayne and Co. the group was short staffed on the Blueline and carried a few non-All Stars, including Marty Mcsorley, on the roster.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Or how about Avery picks...Oh wait that's pretty much going to end this thread.
Report Abuse
The end of the season trophies are the best form of pro sports recognition regardless; screw the ASG.
Finally, "wonder where they go that from?" needs a "t" in there.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
1 - 25 of 35