Sun Apr 26, 2009 1:05 am EDT

(UPDATE: If you've not read the letter from Rangers GM Glen Sather to the NHL asking for League sanctions against the Capitals and Verizon Center, it's worth it. Seems that fans using "graphic language, about whether Dan Girardi and Marc Staal have a sexual relationship" somehow led to an NHL head coach throwing a water bottle at paying customers, and it's the arena's fault that it happened.)
Contrasting the brief memos the NHL has sent out in previous postseason suspensions with its novel-length message about John Tortorella's suspension for Game 6 against the Washington Capitals on Sunday reveals just how momentous this decision was the League.
The New York Rangers coach was suspended Saturday for "squirting a fan with water and throwing a water bottle that struck a fan during Game 5," which you can see in a video clip we were one of the first to publish on Friday. It was the right decision, because it was the NHL's only decision. And for a coach that's preached mental toughness and discipline in words and deeds, it was a moment of hypocrisy.
From the NHL:
"While it is a difficult decision to suspend a coach at this point in a playoff series, it has been made clear to all of our players, coaches and other bench personnel that the National Hockey League cannot -- and will not -- tolerate any physical contact with fans," NHL Senior Executive Vice President and Director of Hockey Operations Colin Campbell said. "We do not take this action lightly. It is the result of an entire day of investigation and evaluation that included the retrieval and review of videotape of the incident and discussions with Mr. Tortorella, other Rangers' bench personnel and a number of other people, including the security personnel at the Verizon Center.
"That investigation revealed that Mr. Tortorella squirted a fan with water before Mr. Tortorella was doused with a beverage. While, in these circumstances, it always is easy to allege mitigating circumstances, the fact is we do not tolerate contact with our fans in this manner. That is communicated before each season in a memo that is issued by the League to all of the management, coaches and players of every team."
I've heard both Darren Pang and now Darren Dreger of TSN offer some words of pity for Tortorella:
He's crushed because he is not going to be on the bench and a part of trying to help his team close out their series with the Washington Capitals on Sunday. He's incensed because - again according to sources - the Rangers repeatedly put in a request for additional security and they feel that request wasn't materialized
Dreger writes that there's no excuse for Tortorella's actions; so why try and provide one?
Tortorella crossed an un-crossable line for a professional coach, athlete or official: potentially criminal interaction with a fan. Pierre Lebrun of ESPN figured Torts would only earn a steep fine because of where this playoff series sits after five games. But the League's decision was made for it the first time the world saw the water bottle leave Tortorella's hand. He had to be suspended for this, no matter the circumstances.
Symbolically, this should go down as one of Tortorella's lowest moments as a head coach. Here's a guy who made the ultimate statement about intolerance of undisciplined play and selfish egotism by benching Sean Avery for Game 5; his team promptly skated out and acted like they were getting paid by the boneheaded penalty, before Tortorella chucked a water bottle at a paying customer for a suspension.
What the hell kind of message is that?
From a hockey perspective, there's no telling what a change behind the bench for Game 6 will have. Does Avery play? Do the psychological games between coach and underperforming players -- shuffling lines, taking away power-play time -- continue with Jim Schoenfeld (no stranger to postseason suspensions) behind the bench?
And how much does this circus help the Capitals' chances for at least a Game 7?
Puck Daddy is an NHL blog edited by Greg Wyshynski. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Montreal 5, Columbus 3 (Nov. 24)
Posted Nov 23 2009
Posted Nov 23 2009
Top Goals of the Week: November 24
Posted Nov 23 2009
Edited by MJD
Edited by 'Duk
Edited by J.E. Skeets
Edited by Greg Wyshynski
Edited by Matt Hinton
Edited by E. Brennan
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Steve Cofield
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Andy Behrens
536 Comments
1 - 25 of 536
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Congratulations?
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Tortorella = Hypocrite
Torts is lucky the NHL didn't suspend him for 3 games...
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Technically, there are multiple reasons, but I digress.
Dan, when you're in that situation, you take every bit of the BS the fans throw your way. It's part of the job. Trash talking and heckling happen at every game to the visiting team, their coaches, their staff, and the refs. Their job (the visiting team, etc.) is to ignore it and go about their business. You're a professional athlete/coach of a professional sports team... the key word is 'professional.' Suck it up, and be an adult.
My question is, if you're a member of the Rangers, how do you take anything Torts says seriously now?
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Yes, it was a stupid move by Tortorella - he lost his cool in this situation. It tends to happen when you're losing 4-0 in a possible series-clinching game - not that it should be an excuse, but you see where he probably got pissed off. His response was totally unprofessional, but I can understand his anger. The suspension was undoubtedly warranted.
Also, he apparently had a beer dumped on his head by a Capitals fan. That is also a pretty classless manuever. Whether or not that happened, I don't know - I'm not sure anyone except Tortorella and the fans in that proximity really do.
Regardless, the Capitals have gained all the momentum in this series. As much as I'd like to say the Rangers will find a way, I honestly don't think they will. Lundqvist cannot carry them for an entire playoff run, and the defense can only do so much when the offense stagnates and turns the puck over.
I love the Rangers, but this just isn't their year. If they want to compete, they need a strong offensive presence on the first line. Plenty of playmakers and solid supporters on this team, but not enough pure goal scorers. There's always next year...
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
The NHL darling Ovechcan't better watch his Russian-spying ass too.
LET'S GO RANGERS!!!!!!
Report Abuse
I am a Rangers fan, I happen to find Sean Avery amusing and useful; with that being said, I agree that what he did in the third period of Game 4 was terribly selfish and unacceptable. However, the decision to bench Avery for Game 5 was downright foolish. The Rangers have been, for the entire season, a vanilla team. With the addition of Sean Avery into the lineup, the Rangers, to use Tortorella's words, "started to develop an identity." What he really should have said was, "Now that we have someone like Sean, teams will not just walk all over us and have their way." Is it really any surprise that late-season additions like Derek Morris and Nik Antropov, while talented, don't really warrant much attention during the games?
In fact, does any player actually warrant attention on the Rangers, other than Sean Avery? The ENTIRE Caps-Rangers series, Avery has made Norris-Trophy finalist Mike Green his personal pinata, crashed the net and pestered Simeon Varlemov, and been a generally disruptive force. Without him, the Rangers played a dispassionate game, void of any on-ice retribution, against a vulnerable opponent.
Who else on the Rangers is actually going to step up and pose some sort of threat to the Caps. Drury has a bum hand (and its not like he is exactly a physical presence to begin with), Gomez seems to spend more time getting knocked down than doing the knocking down, Colton Orr is a liability every time he steps on the ice, and Callahan is about 190 lbs and cannot be expected to be our only scoring threat AND our on-ice enforcer. Hell, with Tortorella stick waving performance on Friday, why don't we just throw him out on the ice to make sure the Rangers at least put up some sort of fight.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
1 - 25 of 536