Puck Daddy - NHL

Toronto Maple Leafs GM Brian Burke was candid about why the trade deadline this season was sort of ... weird. It was the economy, plain and simple, as teams got the jitters about payroll and about what the salary cap will look like in two years.

(Maybe we can blame the economy for that meth hallucination of a trade that will have Olaf Kolzig retiring as a Leaf.)

Still, in the end, plenty of moves were made ... just not by some of the teams we expected to be active. A quick glance at six franchises that sat this one out, and what it might mean for their postseason aspirations.

Washington Capitals: Completely conspicuous by their absence, and not because of the reason so many hockey pundits think. The Capitals weren't trading for a goalie, and if they were it wasn't going to be for anyone to compete with Jose Theodore. He's their guy. They committed to him in the offseason, and then recommitted to him when he finally stopped giving up goals on his first two shots of the game. So forget the goalie stuff; it's only what people with a narrow view of the team wanted to see.

The defense ... that's a different story. I've been saying for months that the Capitals could use an upgrade, and evidently the team knew it, too. GM George McPhee spoke with Capitals Insider and revealed that the team had a casual pursuit of Derek Morris but was certainly in the mix for another big name: Chris Pronger. The price was too high:

"For us to do anything, it had to be an upgrade on what we had, and based on what was out there, there were not a lot of upgrades we saw that we could do," McPhee said. "Guys like Pronger and [Florida's Jay] Bouwmeester, but the price to get into that game wasn't something we were willing to pay. We had some discussions with Anaheim and it wouldn't make sense to go after Bouwmeester and have the guy be a free agent."

"We had talked to Anaheim a little bit," he added. "But we got the sense that they probably were not going to trade [Pronger] and if they did, it was going to cost us prospects [Karl] Alzner, [Simeon] Valarmov and [John} Carlson, all these young kids that we've accumulated and that didn't make any sense."

Good on McPhee for rejecting that price tag. But now the Capitals go to war with Jeff Schultz, Milan Jurcina and John Erskine as the blue line muscle.

Detroit Red Wings: GM Ken Holland inquired about a few players, including Ottawa Senators forward Chris Neil, but ultimately decided that he didn't want to have to make a decision on a roster player in order to bring on any salary. The Wings aren't a team that "needed" to make a move, but adding a Neil or an Ian Laperriere would have been nice for postseason toughness. But that's why they keep Darren McCarty around, right?

Montreal Canadiens: In fairness, the team has added Mathieu Schneider and Glen Metropolit before deadline day. Neither of them is a replacement for Robert Lang. Getting Alex Tanguay back from injury isn't a trade. GM Bob Gainey wasn't aggressive at the deadline, basically waiting for his phone to ring with "something out of left field." It's nice that Gainey thinks this team is good enough to win as-is. It's also delusional in a brutally tough conference.

Vancouver Canucks: The team is on fire and playing good hockey, and Mats Sundin was a bigger addition than anyone that was moved at the deadline anyway. But the Canucks were clearly in the running for Jay Bouwmeester and didn't pull the trigger. Will they regret it?

GM Mike Gillis said in his press conference that he was looking at deals that "in the short term are high risk and in the long term are total risk." He's been a guy who seemed willing to take a risk, but perhaps flipping Mason Raymond and Kevin Bieksa was too rich for his blood.

Gillis can rest on having a team that's won 11 of 12. "If that's the mix that we have, we were perfectly happy moving ahead with it."

Minnesota Wild: Another team on the playoff bubble, and another team that stood pat. Michael Russo of the Star Tribune explains how it went down:

I was told by a very good source that Marian Gaborik was in play, but clearly the Wild wasn't able to find a market. Asked if he tried to trade Gaborik, Risebrough would only say, "No." Like I said, I trust my source though, and it would make no sense that the Wild wouldn't at least dangle a carrot.

Assistant GM Tom Lynn said the Wild was in a "major deal" up until this morning, and then it fell through. Talking just now to Risebrough, and reading between the lines as you'll read tomorrow, I think it was for Jokinen again. The Wild was just not willing to give up a young player and definitely not willing to give up a first-round pick in any big deal, Risebrough said.

Olli Jokinen on the Wild would have been an interesting fit, but giving up a No. 1 for a player that still wouldn't elevate Minny to elite status was probably a smart decision.

Nashville Predators: I'm absolutely stunned that they didn't upgrade their offense. Dave Pagnotta of TFP reports that "the Predators tried to acquire Alex Ponikarovsky" from the Leafs, but fell short.

The Forechecker offers this assessment:

Several players were available that could have helped this team; yes, they all have defects to some extent, but that's why you have a coaching staff that puts players into the position that best allows them and the team to succeed.  Miroslav Satan could have been had basically for free, and would have been well suited as a 2nd/3rd line winger and power play specialist, which is the exact hole that Poile had been seeking to fill.

Even if the asking price was too high for other forwards like Bill Guerin or Nik Antropov, then why didn't one of the pending UFA defensemen like Greg de Vries, Greg Zanon, or Ville Koistinen get traded for future assets? The impression one is left with is that Poile's infamous patience got the better of him. While the team on the ice is doing the best they can, the front office just failed in their biggest test of the season.

Agreed, wholeheartedly. Look at what the Columbus Blue Jackets did, and look at what the Predators didn't do. It's as simple as that.

digg delicious
more

76 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. Larry
    1. Posted by Larry Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:58 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Where's Leahy?
    1st!
  2. rwl060
    2. Posted by rwl060 Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:57 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I would have dug Neil as a Wing, but yeah, they hardly needed any sort of upgrade.
    Any other claims won't be validated until the end of the season ... For instance, I don't think Mats Sundin is a bigger move than Jokinen, but time will tell.
  3. James S
    3. Posted by James S Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:02 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Habs dont make a move, others fighting for a playoff spot do. Na na na na.
  4. Rick
    4. Posted by Rick Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:15 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Go Leafs wish they woulda unloaded one of the unmovables but maybe draft fix that and
    1st!
  5. Slacker
    5. Posted by Slacker Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:49 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I would have like the Flyers to be on this list, but instead they decided to dump Upshall AND a pick to get more chances for shorthanded goals.
  6. Sllim
    6. Posted by Sllim Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:37 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Go McCarty! Bring on Claude Lemieux....McCarty only needs one punch this time.
  7. habs1rule
    7. Posted by habs1rule Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:15 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Several Canadiens sites are calling for Gaineys resignation after today. Wonder if Habs fans werent showing up every game, sitting 21,273 every night, if the team would be more agressive to ice a winner here? Some teams have to put a decent product on the ice to draw fans, in Montreal, its taken for granted.
  8. Guy Incognito
    8. Posted by Guy Incognito Thu Sep 03, 2009 6:57 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Habs didn't need to replace Lang - they already have Plekanec - a solid player who has exploded with Lang out of his way
  9. mother pucker serif
    9. Posted by mother pucker serif Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:00 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Shouldn't the Devils be on this list, or does Havelid count as being a deadline move?
  10. Andrew
    10. Posted by Andrew Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:12 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I enjoy reading Yahoo's hockey blogs, but I feel like the coverage of the deadline was really sub-par in comparison with other sports sites. tsn destroyed all.
  11. carl_vs_mastershake
    11. Posted by carl_vs_mastershake Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:18 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Nylander is an overturned semi on the beltway. I'm sure the caps wanted to bring some people in but when you have a giant contract like Nylander taking up all the lanes, it's hard for others to get by.
  12. Big Sexy
    12. Posted by Big Sexy Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:34 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Lets go rangers!!!
  13. tom w
    13. Posted by tom w Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:35 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    for real dumbest move for the flyers to bring in another "tough guy", thought thats wat cote's role was but i guess i was wrong
  14. Chad
    14. Posted by Chad Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:16 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I'm surprised nobody picked up Satan.
  15. Lambo-Greenie
    15. Posted by Lambo-Greenie Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:58 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Wysh... every caps fan on the blogs/message boards agrees with you, we needed a d-man and now we'll end up going no where because our coach and GM think that Jeff Schultz is "the real deal." But as a member of the caps message boards described him "he looks like a giraffe on rollar skates"
  16. Hangovers are for the weak
    16. Posted by Hangovers are for the weak Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:47 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I may never doubt Ken Holland or the rest of the Wings front office, but I was kinda hoping for at least a look at some new goaltenders.
  17. Stephanie M
    17. Posted by Stephanie M Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:41 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Note of clarification to Hawks fans - they traded Wisniewski and Kontiola for Pahlsson, defenseman Logan Stephenson and a draft pick. I'm much happier with this deal now that I know all the details.
  18. Garth the Hoser
    18. Posted by Garth the Hoser Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:06 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Nashville's an AHL franchise. They can't afford to load up. Same with Phoenix and Tampa.
    Three franchises with about 18 games left to play before they fold.
    Dispersal draft to follow.
  19. Jon A
    19. Posted by Jon A Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:11 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Jbird
    I was with you on the Gaborik question. But the more I think about it, to acquire him, you'd have to give up significant talent, and you would *maybe* have him for the playoffs, considering his permanent DTD status. Why not wait till he's a FA?
  20. 4th and long
    20. Posted by 4th and long Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:19 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    think antropov is a great move for rangers and detroit should have done neil for samuelson
  21. Patrick
    21. Posted by Patrick Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:28 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    #17.
    Red Wings philosophy on Goaltenders.
    Mr. Holland has bestowed onto us Wing Nuts the two goalie system and rides one of the two goalies that is HOT at that particular time. Mr. Holland will do anything to surround the goaltender with top notch talent. First and foremost with the blue liners. No ONE goalie will ever get top dollar in Motown. Mr. Holland will spend that money elsewhere. Seems to me his system is working. Don't you think?
  22. Sledge Longfellow
    22. Posted by Sledge Longfellow Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:30 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Another note of clarification for Hawks fans ... since many of you didn't actually follow hockey back in the dark ages when the Ducks won the Cup. Pahlson was robbed of the Conn Smythe for the sentimental favorite Niedermeier (sp?). Pahlson was the real MVP of that team. Of course he'll never play like that again, but tough nuts.
  23. Andre
    23. Posted by Andre Thu Sep 03, 2009 6:49 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Are you kidding Theodore isn't a problem in Washington ? He gets scored on way too much when he's in good position and the puck just goes through him, as Chara did to push the game in overtime Saturday afternoon.
    The Caps might have chosen him and are willing to stick with him, but they'll be singing a different tune when they get ousted of the playoffs.
  24. Temple of Poetry
    24. Posted by Temple of Poetry Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:19 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    ...And just like real Christmas I am left with greed not entirely sated, bickering with my figurative siblings over who got better presents.
  25. habs1rule
    25. Posted by habs1rule Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:15 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Guy, If you think Plekanec is a good player, you didnt see last years playoffs. One hard hit by a Flyer, and he was a non factor, passing from the perimiter, and avoiding the net. EXPLODING, hahaha.

Puck Daddy

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Greg Wyshynski

Puck Daddy is an NHL blog edited by Greg Wyshynski. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Puck Daddy Recent Readers

Watch Live Hockey Online with GameCenter Live™