Wed Jul 30, 2008 9:23 am EDT
J.P. Barry, the agent for Mats Sundin, moves the goalposts one more time: Now it appears Friday is "like a soft deadline" for the free agent to decide on whether or not he's going to bestow his Messianic splendor on the National Hockey League.
Should he decide to play, which team would he sign with? HEY, QUIT BEING SO PUSHY! He's only had close to four months to figure this out ...
Teams like the New York Rangers and the Detroit Red Wings remain on the periphery for Sundin, waiting like the rest of us. GM Cliff Fletcher of the Toronto Maple Leafs said his team "started to operate on the basis that [Sundin] probably won't be back" earlier this month. Please notice he never said the Leafs wouldn't welcome him back.
Then there's the ugly girl at the school dance, the Vancouver Canucks, who continue to have a standing offer of $10 million a season on the table for Sundin that he ignores. It's gotten to the point where the media in Vancouver has been reduced to making marijuana jokes in an effort to recruit him.
And, of course, the captain of the cheerleading squad, the Montreal Canadiens, who offered Sundin a healthy salary and a chance to compete for the Stanley Cup in his twilight.
As if getting his name on the Chalice actually matters to him.
For a lot of fans, questioning Mats Sundin's heart is one of hockey mortal sins. But that's on the ice; off the ice, his behavior this summer has created significant questions about his desire not only to be a primetime player on a championship team but to be a player at all.
Mats has already shown he values comfort over competition by refusing to waive his no-movement clause last trade deadline. He didn't want to leave Toronto, didn't want to go to a new team with new faces and help them compete for the Cup. He didn't have it in him then, and his protracted dance with the Habs -- as legit a championship contender as the Eastern Conference will produce next season -- shows that winning isn't a priority now.
Then there's the question of whether Sundin actually wants to return to the NHL. As Mark Spector of the National Post opines:
You have to want to be an NHL player. It doesn't work if you're playing for the money, or any reason other than the pure hunger to win it all.
Right now, Sundin is like a guy who has paid $29.95 for brunch, but has no room left after a single plate. He sits in Sweden, knowing he is healthy enough to still play, knowing that the Vancouver Canucks two-year, US$20-million offer is something he should snap up, knowing there is a buffet table there for the pillaging.
But there is just one problem. Sundin isn't hungry anymore. Judging by the effect a lack of hunger for the game has had on the games of great players like Niedermayer, Selanne and Forsberg, why would a semi-committed Sundin fare any better?
Here's the difference between those three players and Mats Sundin. Scott Niedermayer and Teemu Selanne signed back with a team they helped lead to the Stanley Cup; not for money, but to do it again.
Peter Forsberg didn't come back to the NHL and sign with Vancouver; he went to Colorado, in the hopes that he and Joe Sakic and Adam Foote and a cast of kids could win the Stanley Cup.
If Sundin decides to return to the NHL ... why? To feed a competitive fire that burns hot enough to prolong his playing career but isn't scorching enough to fuel his desire to win a championship in Montreal?
Will it be for money, like the $20 million he could earn from the Canucks over the next two seasons? Is that enough to bring him out of a comfort zone, even if it keeps him away from the Cup?
Will it be for consolation, opting to continue his legacy in Toronto even if the Leafs are about as close to winning a Stanley Cup as the Raptors are?
Having never been an NHL player, I don't understand how the mind of a veteran star works. Sundin still talks about bringing a championship to Toronto, but he doesn't talk about getting his own name on the Cup. Is that selfless leadership, or did he long ago convince himself that winning it wasn't going to be a part of his NHL legacy?
In other words: Is a ferocious competitor on the ice shying away from the immense pressure of winning a title before times runs out, and the undeniable disappointment that he was unable to bring one home to the fans that adore him?
Only Sundin knows. And we've all become quite acclimated to his leisurely thought process.
Puck Daddy is an NHL blog edited by Greg Wyshynski. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Montreal 5, Columbus 3 (Nov. 24)
Posted Nov 23 2009
Posted Nov 23 2009
Top Goals of the Week: November 24
Posted Nov 23 2009
Edited by MJD
Edited by 'Duk
Edited by J.E. Skeets
Edited by Greg Wyshynski
Edited by Matt Hinton
Edited by E. Brennan
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Steve Cofield
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Andy Behrens
61 Comments
1 - 25 of 61
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
As you were.
Report Abuse
GO WINGS.........REPEAT IN 09....
Report Abuse
Sure, everyone can question his desire to play now, and rightfully so. It's been a long time since he played his last game, but don't base it on the last four months. Base it over his career. The guy was nothing but a leader for the Toronto Maple Leafs. Never surrounded with prime talent, but ending up the highest scoring Toronto Maple Leaf. Ever. That's something to be proud of.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
2.) Um, have you seen the Raptors squad this year? They have the best middle court in the league, not to mention guys who are apparently little known (judging by your analogy) like Calderon, Kapono, Bargnani, etc. etc. That team will be dominant as hell this year, be ready to put your foot in your mouth (if you haven't already). Oh, this is coming from a Pistons fan who is already worried about the TO damage.
Report Abuse
Didn't think so.
Report Abuse
1. I didn't say Forsberg lacked hunger. In fact, I said just the opposite: That he wanted to win a Stanley Cup and went to Denver to do so. The columnist I quoted questioned his heart.
2. Um, it was a joke: The Leafs are as far away from winning the STANLEY CUP as the Raptors. You see, because the other team plays basketball. Hoo-hoo.
3. Read to achieve.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
http://newfaux.blogspot.com/2008/07/matts-playing-cat-and-mouse-with-nhl.html
Report Abuse
So are you telling us that the Raptors will win the Stanley cup? Are you sure they have someone who can stop Zetterberg?
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Sundin has a reputation for class and leadership, which in Toronto means that he always did his post-game interviews. That's pretty much the only factor that determines a player's rep with the Toronto media. Win or lose, he always delivered his monotone post-game cliches, so that makes him a great guy. (If a guy like Tucker got mad after a loss and stormed off, well, he's a jerk and a cancer.)
Sundin already showed at the deadline that he doesn't want to win a Cup. Now he seems to be showing that he doesn't want to play at all. This is the guy that a contender like Montreal wants to spend all their cap space on? Really?
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
When the time comes, he'll make his decision, and he's earned our respect whatever that decision happens to be. I'd love to see him in Montreal, but I'll take it as a bonus if that happens.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
wyshynski, we know you've never played at the pro level, but where is the caveat "i've never claimed to be an intelligent journalist, or even someone with a half-respectable blog..."?
calling the vancouver canucks the ugly girl at a dance... having a world top 3 goaltender (who will bring canada the gold in 2010) makes you an ugly girl? or does offering a chunk of cap-space money to a solid swede forward make you an ugly girl?
can we also assume that posing in sunglasses and with a cigar hanging out of your mouth while pretending a super coo 'editor' makes you an ugly girl?
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Sorry dude, the dream was over before it began.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
don't get me wrong, sundin has done more than his fair share for the leafs and the nhl to earn the right not to waive his no trade clause and it's great he exercised that right. but make no mistake, that wasn't about giving back to leaf nation, that was about doing what was best for mat sundin.
Report Abuse
Well that's spot on...I'm sure it's all that pure hunger that drove Ron Hainsey to sign in atlanta....it had nothing to do with the 4.5 million a year he's getting
Everyone knows Atlanta = Stanley Cup
Talk about hunger!
1 - 25 of 61