Puck Daddy - NHL

 

(No, the first decade of the 21st century doesn't technically end until 2011. Save your bellyaching. But we've had nine NHL seasons and one stolen from us since 1999-2000, and Yahoo! Sports has decided it's time to rank the best and worst of the last "decade." Enjoy, and snark freely in the comments.)

Puck Daddy's Best & Worst of the Decade lists will run on Tuesday, Thursday and Saturday through the end of 2009. (Yes, that includes holidays; cynical appraisal never sleeps.)

First off, know this: Immortality in the National Hockey League is not measured by the Prince of Wales or Clarence Campbell trophies for conference champions. We'll have a separate entry in our End-of-Decade Rankings for those elite teams that fell short of the ultimate prize.

But to determine the best NHL team of the 2000s, the field must be narrowed to the nine squads that had their names etched on the Stanley Cup during that time.

Yes, "Top 9," thanks to the lockout that killed the 2004-05 season. In fact, hockey is unlike any other sport that will be covered in Yahoo! Sports' "Best of the Decade" projects: The NHL was literally two different leagues before and after the work stoppage, from parity to economics to the very philosophy of how to build a winning team. That's reflected on several of our lists, including this one.

Here are the Top 9 NHL Teams of the Last Decade ...

9. 2005-06 Carolina Hurricanes

A Southeast Division champion with 112 points in the first regular season following the lockout, Peter Laviolette's group had four 30-goal scorers including Eric Staal's(notes) 45-goal, 100-point career year.

Outside of their star center, it was a solid but unspectacular team, and was carried through the postseason by rookie goalie Cam Ward's(notes) Conn Smythe performance (.2.14 GAA, .920 save percentage). Had the Buffalo Sabres not been missing four defensemen in Game 7, Carolina may not have advanced. Had Dwayne Roloson(notes) of the miracle Edmonton Oilers not suffered a knee injury in the Finals, Carolina may not have won the Cup.

But they did, they're here, and someone had to be ninth. Kudos to Canes management for figuring out how to win in NHL 2.0 before anyone else did.

8. 2003-04 Tampa Bay Lightning

In the last season before the lockout, the Bolts were division and conference regular season champions (106 points), with a Hart Trophy winner in Marty St. Louis (38 goals, 94 points). Nikolai Khabibulin(notes) recorded five shutouts in the postseason, Brad Richards(notes) won the Conn and the Lightning rallied from a 3-2 deficit to the Western Conference No. 6-seeded Calgary Flames to win the Cup.

St. Louis, Richards, Vincent Lecavalier(notes), Cory Stillman(notes), Dan Boyle(notes), Dave Andreychuk ... this team had some players. Like the Canes, they struggled to the win the Cup; and as Martin Gelinas can attest, they also got their share of breaks. But the Lightning were a little better in a different era than the Carolina Cup team.

7. 2002-03 New Jersey Devils

This was the Pat Burns-coached Devils squad that went seven games with the Ducks in the Cup final. They were division champs with 108 points, good for second in the conference. This was a stifling defensive team in front of Martin Brodeur(notes), backstopped by the holy trinity of Scott Stevens, Scott Niedermayer(notes) and Brian Rafalski(notes).

A perfect example of a very good hockey team that probably wouldn't have hoisted the Cup under NHL 2.0 rules changes.

6. 2008-09 Pittsburgh Penguins

After Dan Bylsma took the helm, this Penguins team was a force of nature, streaking to 99 points and fourth in the conference. They had 100-point seasons from Evgeni Malkin(notes) and Sidney Crosby(notes), who both continued their dominance in the postseason (36 points for Geno in a Conn Smythe effort, 31 for Sid). Marc-Andre Fleury(notes) also shut up the critics, once and for all.

A well-constructed team by GM Ray Shero that whose sum was greater than its parts. They get knocked down a few pegs here because it's as much about the journey to the Cup as winning the Cup, and the Penguins were middling until Bylsma captured lightning in a bottle. Plus, the five teams ahead of them were a little deeper.

5. 2007-08 Detroit Red Wings

An incredible regular season that saw the Wings win the President's Trophy with 115 points ended with the team's second Stanley Cup of the decade. Henrik Zetterberg's(notes) 27-point playoff run, combined with shutdown defense, was subtly astonishing.

The question we know you're asking: Why is this team ranked ahead of a Penguins team that essentially defeated the same group the following season?

Top to bottom, this is a better team than the Penguins' squad that won the Cup, especially when you compare the blue lines. They were all a year younger, faster and more durable; and had the Chris Osgood(notes) that played in this run (14-4, 1.55 GAA) been the one that faced the Penguins in the rematch, we may have been talking about a third Detroit title in the 2000s.

Plus, no Marian Hossa(notes). Hence, they won the Cup in 2007-08.

4. 2006-07 Anaheim Ducks

Pacific Division champs with 110 points, it's amazing to look at all the bright young offensive talent in the lineup below Teemu Selanne's(notes) ridiculous 48-goal, 46-assist season: Corey Perry(notes), Ryan Getzlaf(notes), Dustin Penner(notes), Chris Kunitz(notes), Andy McDonald(notes), Travis Moen(notes). But the backbone of the team was J.S. Gigeure in goal, and Chris Pronger(notes) and Conn Smythe winner Scott Niedermayer on defense. 

A stout, truculent bunch that Brian Burke can wistfully reminisce about as his Maple Leafs enter their fifth decade without a Cup.

3. 1999-00 New Jersey Devils

This was arguably the best Devils team in franchise history, and yet it took a coaching change with eight games left in an already-successful 103-point regular season to turn it into a champion. Lou Lamoriello flipped Robbie Ftorek for Larry Robinson, and the affable coach led the team through a wild postseason that included rallying from a 3-1 deficit to the Philadelphia Flyers in the Lindros-concussed conference finals and five overtimes in the final two games of their Stanley Cup win over the defending champion Dallas Stars.

What a lineup: They had Patrik Elias(notes), Scott Gomez(notes), Petr Sykora(notes), Jason Arnott(notes), Claude Lemieux(notes), Alex Mogilny, Bobby Holik(notes) and Randy McKay up front; Conn Smythe winner Stevens, Niedermayer, Rafalski, Ken Daneyko, Colin White(notes) and Vladimir Malakhov(notes) in front of Brodeur.

2. 2000-01 Colorado Avalanche

We said "arguably" in the last entry because some consider the 2000-01 Devils even better than the Cup champs, which makes this Avalanche team look all the more impressive in overcoming them in a seven-game final.

Thanks to the media saturation and the unfortunate presence of his retired number in Denver, everyone remembers this as the Ray Bourque Cup team, but that's shortchanging the juggernaut. It had 118 points to win its division and the President's Trophy, in a year that saw Joe Sakic(notes) win the Hart and the Pearson with a 118-point campaign.

The assemblage of talent on this roster, deftly managed by Bob Hartley, was extraordinary: Sakic, Peter Forsberg(notes) (back when he'd give you 73 games), Milan Hejduk(notes), Alex Tanguay(notes), Chris Drury(notes), Adam Deadmarsh, Bourque, Rob Blake(notes) and a slew of quality role players. Tying to all together was 35-year-old Patrick Roy, who had a 2.21 GAA in the regular season and a 1.70 with four shutouts in the playoffs.

A scary good team. Just not as scary as these guys ...

1. 2001-02 Detroit Red Wings

Unless you're one of those fans that blindly hates everything with a Winged Wheel, this one is indisputable. These Red Wings were a 116-point monster in the regular season that finished second in offense and defense; touting four 30-goal scorers in Brendan Shanahan(notes), Sergei Fedorov(notes), Brett Hull and Luc Robitaille, with Nicklas Lidstrom(notes) winning this second Norris Trophy as best defenseman. The grand master, Scotty Bowman, orchestrated it all from the bench.

As we mentioned in the opening, it's almost unfair to compare this traveling all-star team with any from the capped era. They won the Cup with a payroll around $65 million, and the roster read like one a kid with a video game would put together: Along with the five players mentioned earlier, there was Steve Yzerman, considered on the wane until he led the team in playoff scoring; Igor Larionov, Chris Chelios(notes), Tomas Holmstrom(notes) and Pavel Datsyuk(notes). Their foot soldiers were in their prime, too, like Darren McCarty(notes), Kris Draper(notes), Kirk Maltby(notes).

Back-stopping it all was 37-year-old Dominik Hasek(notes), who had a 2.17 GAA in the regular season and a 1.86 in the playoffs. How big-game was the Dominator? He had five shutouts in the regular season and six in the postseason.

The Wings teams in the 1990s that had Yzerman, Fedorov and Shanahan in their primes were a little better, but this 2001-02 Detroit team is clearly the best of the 2000s and one of the best of the last two decades. If you needed validation of that, visit the Hockey Hall of Fame in about 15 years and see how many players from this roster have entered into immortality.

digg delicious
more

245 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. richardfoc
    1. Posted by richardfoc Tue Nov 03, 2009 10:17 am EST

    Report Abuse

    Hahahaha! But Buffalo WAS missing four defensemen in Game 7! And Dwayne Roloson of the miracle Edmonton Oilers DID suffer a knee injury in the Finals! And Carolina DID win the Cup.
    Suck it haters!!!
  2. jesse d
    2. Posted by jesse d Tue Nov 03, 2009 10:28 am EST

    Report Abuse

    Not to sound like sour grapes, but I find it ironic you poo-poo all over the canes cup. Then you say the lightning got all the breaks against the flames,...but then you put the 08-09 pens way up there. I'm sorry, i'll say this till i die, If the wings were rested (instead of being injured) and if malkin gets suspened for his fight with Zetterberg the pens don't win the cup. But i know what ifs amount to absoutly nothing and the pens won fair and square.
    Also, carolina being in at dead last,...that doesn't have anything to do with them stunning NJ to advance that year does it wysh?
  3. Marc
    3. Posted by Marc Tue Nov 03, 2009 10:29 am EST

    Report Abuse

    #1 on this list is bang-on.
  4. The Ol Seven Deuce
    4. Posted by The Ol' Seven Deuce Tue Nov 03, 2009 10:32 am EST

    Report Abuse

    You actually did a nice job with this. Though it's a tough pick between one and two. If I recall correctly the Dominator had his struggles that postseason. I don't ever recall Roy struggling.
  5. Jerk Store
    5. Posted by Jerk Store Tue Nov 03, 2009 10:35 am EST

    Report Abuse

    id forgotten robitaille was on that red wings team.. jeebus that team was amazing.
  6. bringbackthejets
    6. Posted by bringbackthejets Tue Nov 03, 2009 10:38 am EST

    Report Abuse

    Adam Deadmarsh was traded for Rob Blake so that would make him a king and wasn't there to win the cup!
  7. bringbackthejets
    7. Posted by bringbackthejets Tue Nov 03, 2009 10:38 am EST

    Report Abuse

    Adam Deadmarsh was traded for Rob Blake so that would make him a king and wasn't there to win the cup!
  8. Geoffrey S
    8. Posted by Geoffrey S Tue Nov 03, 2009 10:38 am EST

    Report Abuse

    jesse d: and if the refs called penalty shots for wings closing their hands on the puck in the crease, the Penguins would have swept. wah wah wah keep crying.
  9. Benny
    9. Posted by Benny Tue Nov 03, 2009 10:44 am EST

    Report Abuse

    Suck it haters? Your team was 9th out of 9 teams. I needed Wysh to remind me who even won the cup that year. If this list ranked the best cup teams from the last 25 years, they'd be 25th. The only thing people remember about that finals is the Canadian fans awesome rendition of both National Anthems. That moment deserves to be ranked above the Canes.
  10. tmr
    10. Posted by tmr Tue Nov 03, 2009 10:48 am EST

    Report Abuse

    Hasek was great in the playoffs of '01-'02, but he enjoyed netminding behind an air-tight Wings "D" that was near impenetrable. That is what was lacking last season (and this season so far). Not trying to bash Hasek - he was huge when they needed him to be. All I'm saying is that was some great hockey...
    Also, slightly disagree with the Avs at #2. The Avs were a terrific team, but I thought the Devils were better. I got your back, Wysh...
  11. The Great One
    11. Posted by The Great One Tue Nov 03, 2009 10:48 am EST

    Report Abuse

    05-06 Bruins!!!!!
  12. Matt L
    12. Posted by Matt L Tue Nov 03, 2009 10:57 am EST

    Report Abuse

    What about the 1977 Charlestown Chiefs of the Federal League?
  13. richardfoc
    13. Posted by richardfoc Tue Nov 03, 2009 10:59 am EST

    Report Abuse

    @Benny = Hater. Please suck it!!!
  14. bfrank27
    14. Posted by bfrank27 Tue Nov 03, 2009 11:02 am EST

    Report Abuse

    I don't know if this is so much a list of the best teams as it is a ranking of the 9 cup winners. There are likely better teams in the decade that didn't win a cup than some of those on this list that did. For example, look at the sharks last year, they had an unbelievable regular season, but they laid an egg in the playoffs, or (even though the list is already heavy with Detroit) the 05-06 Redwings 124 points? Are these really the best teams in the respective years? or just a rank of the winners in those years?
  15. Phil Wood
    15. Posted by Phil Wood Tue Nov 03, 2009 11:02 am EST

    Report Abuse

    Even though they were 9th, when the topic comes up for best group of playoff beards, the Hurricanes are #1 - those are some stoutly beards, men. Of course, for those counting, Scott Niedermayer nearly defeated them all single-handily.
    Hard to argue with this list - for once. Even I was rooting for the Wings (mainly because Carolina ousted the Leafs who really deserved to go to the finals and get pounded by the Red Wings). What a team. Thankfully, I've never felt any affinity for them since.
  16. campbellmcdonald32
    16. Posted by campbellmcdonald32 Tue Nov 03, 2009 11:02 am EST

    Report Abuse

    Had Justin Williams not carved out Saku Koivu's eye, the Swirling V@ginas would not have even got to Buffalo, much less Edmonton. They weren't even the best team of that season, much less one of the top teams of this decade.
  17. Dewman
    17. Posted by Dewman Tue Nov 03, 2009 11:04 am EST

    Report Abuse

    #4... Hasek had one of the best GAA of the playoffs ever that playoff, if not the best. He also had the most shutouts ever in a post season I believe at that time. The only games he "struggled" in were the first two games against Vancouver, and even those goals were all a bunch of lucky crap deflection point shots. Hmm... Roy didn't struggle at all huh?? How about McCarty's hat trick in Game 1 against Roy and four goals total in the series. How about that glorious statue of liberty play that killed the Avs. How about the 7-0 destruction in Game 7. Yeah, just keep telling yourself that he didn't struggle that year.
  18. campbellmcdonald32
    18. Posted by campbellmcdonald32 Tue Nov 03, 2009 11:04 am EST

    Report Abuse

    Then you've got the Lightning, who prevailed when Gelinas's goal was not counted and the Penguins, who were allowed to ice 7 men, avoid suspension of their star despite a highly suspendable hit, and got enough breaks to last several NHL lifetimes /did I mention the fixed Crosby lottery?
  19. campbellmcdonald32
    19. Posted by campbellmcdonald32 Tue Nov 03, 2009 11:07 am EST

    Report Abuse

    And Mike Ilitch is one ugly woman.
  20. tmr
    20. Posted by tmr Tue Nov 03, 2009 11:07 am EST

    Report Abuse

    @ bfrank27...I thought it was a ranking of the 9 cup winners.
  21. Justin K
    21. Posted by Justin K Tue Nov 03, 2009 11:08 am EST

    Report Abuse

    Of course ways will be found, but it's hard to hate on a Stanley Cup team. In the end, the fans of the winning team can always say "Stanley Cup champs" to shut up any opposition. If they weren't the best team that season, why did they win? You can claim injuries, but seven game series produce no flaws.*
    *Except when they do.
  22. Wyshynski
    22. Posted by Wyshynski Tue Nov 03, 2009 11:08 am EST

    Report Abuse

    @ bfrank27 --
    If you read the opening, we're going to also have a list of the top teams that never won a Cup.
  23. richardfoc
    23. Posted by richardfoc Tue Nov 03, 2009 11:08 am EST

    Report Abuse

    @campbellmcdonald32 = Hater. You can suck it too!!!
    Hahahaha! I love it! Nothing, absolutely nothing, will change the fact that the Hurricanes WON THE STANLEY CUP and you haters can't stand it!!! Woo! Woo, woo, wooooooooo!
  24. jason
    24. Posted by jason Tue Nov 03, 2009 11:12 am EST

    Report Abuse

    Those turn-of-the-century Devils teams were unbelievable. Only thing keeping them out of the "team of the decade" conversations was the sudden retirements/wanting-to-play-with-his-brother of most of the defense.
    And Dewman (#17), Broduer subsequently went 1.65 GAA with 7 SO in '02-'03, besting Hasek's 1.86 GAA and 6 SO.

Puck Daddy

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Greg Wyshynski

Puck Daddy is an NHL blog edited by Greg Wyshynski. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Puck Daddy Recent Readers

Watch Live Hockey Online with GameCenter Live™