Puck Daddy - NHL

The condolences started coming in just after noon. E-mails that simply said "sorry" followed by a link to Tom Gulitti's breaking news about New Jersey Devils goalie Martin Brodeur, who will miss up to four months after "surgery Thursday morning to repair a torn distal biceps tendon in his left elbow."

JP, a Capitals fan, sent one with the subject header "Vomit." Derek Felix, a longtime colleague and a New York Rangers fan, sent an IM of sympathy before penning a blog titled "A Ranger fan's view on a Devil fan's eternal Hell." Hockey friends and non-hockey friends acknowledged the news and its impact on yours truly, a lifelong Devils fan. By mid-afternoon, so much empathy had come my way, I started ending all my e-mails with "in lieu of flowers ..."

It reminded me of 2003, when the high expectations for the New York Jets proved as fragile as quarterback Chad Pennington's hand in a preseason game against the Giants. The Jets stumbled to 1-4, and finished 6-10.

It also reminded me of the last life-altering injury to a significant Devils player: When Scott Stevens was diagnosed with post-concussion syndrome in January 2007 2004. The tantalizing possibility of his heroic return to the lineup haunted the team into the playoffs; they needed him more than ever in a first-round battle against the Philadelphia Flyers, but Stevens couldn't answer the bell. It was his final season in the NHL.

Brodeur said this afternoon on a media conference call that it's not an injury that will linger or reoccur; basically, that this isn't career-threatening. So we've got that going for us, which is nice.

Marty sounded upbeat, because he's perpetually upbeat. Devils fans are born cynics, both due to our systemic inferiority complexes and Jersey breeding. So what, exactly, does this injury and absence do to the Devils and the rest of the NHL? I can think of 10 significant aftereffects.

1. The Devils' defense has lost its safety net. As we said in the season preview, this continues to be one of the most underwhelming collections of defensemen Brodeur had ever played behind, defensively and especially offensively. The combination of Marty's time-tested abilities as a third defenseman and the team's defensive system carried this unit to fifth in the League in goals against last season. The team is currently eighth in the League; it's difficult to conceive that ranking improving over the next three months.

The biggest adjustment will be in the puck-handling for the defensemen. They'll have to do more chasing of pucks, make more first passes than when Brodeur's back there. The Devils have more puck-handling defensemen than bangers on the blueline right now; winning pucks will be an issue, but bringing them out of the zone shouldn't.

2. Either Kevin Weekes or Scott Clemmensen must be the answer. GM Lou Lamoriello has already told Gulitti that the Devils don't plan on trading for a goaltender, so one of these two (or both) will hold the fort until Brodeur returns.

Weekes played outstanding hockey last night against the Buffalo Sabres, but doesn't have one iota of the puck-handling skills that Brodeur has, which affects both the defense and the offense. Clemmensen's puck-handling has improved; the keeper who gets the most minutes will be with one that fits the system the best.

Brodeur said Weekes has been "a good sport" playing the backup role; he's going to have to be better than good in Marty's absence. Beat writer Rich Chere said today, "Kevin Weekes could be a No. 1 goalie on several NHL teams." Uh, name'em, chief.

3. Sutter and the system. After watching the pathetic offensive output from the Devils against Buffalo, the last thing Coach Brent Sutter should do is overcompensate for Brodeur's absence by reeling in the scorers and overplaying the checking lines, trying to win every night 1-0 or 2-1 in a shootout. There's nothing hyperbolic about saying this is Sutter's greatest challenge as an NHL coach. He needs to strike a balance between extra help for the new keeper and finding some kind of consistent offense from the team's forwards. That ain't easy when your offense looks different every night.

4. Get, and stay, healthy. Brodeur's is the most significant of several injuries currently plaguing the Devils. Defenseman Andy Greene, center Brian Rolston and center Bobby Holik are all on the shelf; defenseman Paul Martin is battling through an "upper body injury." This team is wafer-thin on defense and can't afford injuries to the blueline. Getting Rolston back and contributing is now a priority; he's started skating again, coming back from a high ankle sprain.

5. The Devils at the deadline. The NHL trade deadline is March 4. That will be about four months after Brodeur's surgery, so the Devils should either have him back or understand the timetable for his return. They don't have much cap room; but perhaps this injury will serve as a chilling reminder that if the team is near the playoffs and Brodeur is healthy, the window of opportunity is still thankfully open -- for now.

6. If the Devils make the postseason, Marty will finally be rested. Complete, utter silver-lining B.S. from a Devils fan in shock, but here goes: If the knock on Brodeur in the postseason was that he didn't get enough rest during the regular season, then he should be all-world come playoff time. (Assuming he doesn't rehab his bicep with a mix of glazed and Boston Crème.)

7. The Vezina race has been restarted. James Mirtle had the early Vezina candidates as Ryan Miller of the Buffalo Sabres, Henrik Lundqvist of the Rangers and Carey Price of the Montreal Canadiens, which might be news to the Western Conference. Brodeur is a candidate every year, but obviously won't be this year. This would seem to help Henrik Lundqvist the most, although obviously there are other keepers in the East that will still cipher votes away from the Rangers' keeper. (Provided he doesn't follow his New York/New Jersey goalie brethren to the IR.)

8. Are the records on hold? At the very least, NHL.com might want to reconsider the Brodeur Watch. He's eight wins away from passing Patrick Roy (551) for the all-time mark in the NHL, and he's six shutouts away from passing Terry Sawchuk (98) for the all-time lead in shutouts. From Marty the Optimist: "Hopefully, I'll come back healthy and with enough games to be able to reach it this season." Sawchuk, obviously, will wait.

9. The attendance problem. Paul Kukla didn't like the attendance last night at The Rock (10,567), but that's a Monday night in October or early November against Buffalo for the Devils. Always has been. But the real impact of Brodeur's injury is the timing of it: The next month is when Devils ticket packages are purchased for the holidays as gifts, and the attendance gradually increases for non-rivalry games going into the new year. Will Brodeur's injury have a dampening effect on those sales? More to the point: If the Devils go into a tailspin without him, will 10,500 become the gate number for games in February? Is this the, gulp, future of the Devils' attendance in a post-Marty, post-annual playoff contention world?

10. Ditch the mask. Finally, there can be no doubt any longer: The egomaniacal "MB 30" mask that Brodeur has adopted this year insulted the Hockey Gods, has bad juju and must be thrown into the fires of Mount Doom. This is essential.

digg delicious
more

68 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. jibblescribbits
    1. Posted by jibblescribbits Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:34 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    So now Wysh is cheering for a team with an underwhelming defense, A goalie that's going to be under a hubble-sized microscope over every single goal against and an offense that doesn't have enough talented forwards to score enough goals.
    Wysh.. Avs fans welcome you to frustrationville.
  2. MarkR
    2. Posted by MarkR Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:09 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    i think Weekes could be the #1 goalie for Colorado. Budaj is god-awful.
  3. Ryan
    3. Posted by Ryan Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:57 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    #9 is so right on target. This team was pretty close to moving after their first cup win. Without any big names to draw, and an arena in a not so nice area of NJ, they'll be at the bottom of the league in attendance pretty quickly. Should have taken that ticket to Tennessee years ago - Rangers have too big a fan base for the Devils to draw.
  4. 5 4 fighting
    4. Posted by 5 4 fighting Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:01 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Actually with Scott Stevens he COULD hear the bell and probably the whistles as well, thus the reason for the saying:
    "Every time you hear a bell ring- it means a devil gets his bell rung"
  5. James D
    5. Posted by James D Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:45 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    now we can all see how much of a joke the devils really are
  6. abmjimmy
    6. Posted by abmjimmy Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:44 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Sorry for Marty. It sucks when anyone gets hurt especially when its your #1 guy.
  7. Al S.
    7. Posted by Al S. Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:51 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    @ Ryan- yeah, because the Predators have been drawing incredibly. BTW, the team was close to moving BEFORE their first cup win. The cup win cemented them in NJ forever.
    Hey Wysh, under Ranger logic, if the Devils pull off the miracle and make the playoffs, and then a rested Brodeur brings them to the Cup, he only wins half of one, right?
    I'm going to laugh like hell if somehow the Devils pull this off. Then again, we did a pretty similar thing after the lockout. Mediocre with Elias on the shelf, and then an amazing comeback to win the division from the Rangers.
  8. A Yahoo! User
    8. Posted by A Yahoo! User Tue Nov 04, 2008 5:36 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    For the record the 10,000 draw last night was only because the devils were offering 10.00 tickets to the local youth teams. This franchise is in trouble--nobody wants to see them play, and they shoved the real devil fans way up on the sides and nobody can hear them. A total waste of a beautiful arena.
  9. Bubbabanjo
    9. Posted by Bubbabanjo Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:05 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Stop whinin...........Marty is a goalie god. But they will do fine. Thats just what I was sayin.....a fresh Marty at the end of the year will be scary.
    Wyshynski your cry baby devil whinin stinks!
  10. Chak
    10. Posted by Chak Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:27 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    If Kevin Weekes can play like he did last night, the Devils will be fine, if not they can kiss the playoffs good-bye.
  11. twoeightnine
    11. Posted by twoeightnine Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:25 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    So you're saying if they didn't play the Sabres last night the attendance would have been about 7,000?
    (As it stands right now i think there's a group of 200 of us going together to the next game.)
  12. ballgames
    12. Posted by ballgames Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:05 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    sad day in jersey
  13. Curtis W
    13. Posted by Curtis W Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:32 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    OH my sweet Jesus I can't believe Marty-The-Ironman-Brodeur is hurt, I rely on my strong goal tending to win all my fantasy series without Brodeur I'm pretty much done.... Carey Price and Tim Thomas better kick ass while hes gone or I'm going from first place the last 4 weeks to last.....
  14. The Hippomaster
    14. Posted by The Hippomaster Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:12 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Sad to see a good player like that go down anywhere.
    On the semi bright side though, someone else will probably win the vezina.
    I reall thought nabokov had it last year.
  15. The Hippomaster
    15. Posted by The Hippomaster Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:12 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I could be goalie for the kings...
  16. Eric B
    16. Posted by Eric B Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:42 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    who cares about the Devils,the fans damn sure don't. Its just another reason y the arena won't fill up. The Devils and their "fans" are a joke
  17. mkbrillantes
    17. Posted by mkbrillantes Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:23 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    11. Patty will win his hockey pool. Three years of not picking Brodeur because he had to break down sometime has finally paid off.
  18. Wry Terrill
    18. Posted by Wry Terrill Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:18 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    A guy I beat the tar out of in fantasy hockey last week was actually wasting a roster space on Scott Clemmensen when I played him.
    Maybe should ask him who's going to win the elction...
    P.S. Weekes could probably start for LA/Atlanta/Ottawa as well as the 'Lanche. If he's not decidedly better than what they currently have, he's certainly not decidedly worse...
  19. jeremy b
    19. Posted by jeremy b Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:33 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I, for one, as a life long Devils fan could care less if the arena doesn't sell out every night! I never have troubles getting tickets to a game, don't have to wait forever to get a drink or take a leak. The real fans are there each and every game and the seats fill in when they need to.
  20. big audio
    20. Posted by big audio Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:04 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I don't think Brodeur's loss will be that much of a downer for the Devils. I think, while he is a good goalie, that he is in fact overrated, and that Weekes can definitely fill in admirably until Flopsie returns. it is of course going to have some effect for sure, but good teams use things like this to rally around each other, and for the Devils' sake they had better. Weekes can play and will not lose you too many games.
    Poor Flopsie will have to j/o with his other hand for a few weeks.
  21. Snoop
    21. Posted by Snoop Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:13 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Hey Wysh, Scott Stevens was on his way to the Hockey Hall of Fame in 2007; I think you meant January of 2004 when #4 was diagnosed with post-concussion syndrome (and that diagnosis sadly ended a great career).
  22. Rumpelstilzchen
    22. Posted by Rumpelstilzchen Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:32 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    kevin weekes is the answer, haha, funny. Maybe Weekes can be a transformational figure, a black goalie in a racist league, at least the first not to use coke. Anyways, the devils are done, wah-wah.
  23. Death by Leafs
    23. Posted by Death by Leafs Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:16 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    This is like Tiger going out within a year's worth of Majors (which he can do) or - and dont chirp me as a cheerleader - Crosby getting repeat leg injuries (I dont think he will crack 200, but 150-160 is possible with the right supporting cast [pun intended or not, take your pick]. I also think he's the only guy on the horizon to have a chance at 2000 for his career).
    I like seeing guys go all out and do ridiculous things. It bothers me when guys have the potential but never get the chance.
    See also: Spezza, Briere, Afino, DiPietro, Havlat, Gaborik, Elias, Forsberg, Bure, Lafontaine, Neely, Lemieux, Orr, Bossy, etc. etc. etc.
  24. mitchconnor
    24. Posted by mitchconnor Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:25 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I don't understand all of these people who say that Brodeur is overrated. He was on pace to set some records this year, no? I also can't help but wonder if something else was bothering him before his injury. He really did not look like himself against the Flyers a couple of weeks ago. It's a shame to see someone with his talent go down.
    This changes the whole complexion of the season for NJ. It also helps to prove my theory that Dainus Zubrus is the kiss of death. Whenever he plays somewhere, they end up being lousy, no matter how good they are to begin with. Buffalo fans can tell you that - didn't they get him at the 2007 deadline?
    Sorry to hear about this, Wysh, and I mean it. Hang in there.

Puck Daddy

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Greg Wyshynski

Puck Daddy is an NHL blog edited by Greg Wyshynski. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Puck Daddy Recent Readers

Watch Live Hockey Online with GameCenter Live™