Puck Daddy - NHL

In winning six Stanley Cups as a player, Edmonton Oilers GM Kevin Lowe had 1,498 regular-season penalty minutes. There is no quantifiable way to determine how many of those penalties were intentionally committed or instigated by a crafty opponent. But one could assume, based on Lowe's confounded diatribes last week against Anaheim Ducks GM Brian Burke, that a great number of penalties were drawn from Lowe.

Because Kevin Lowe is, apparently, a sucker.

Maybe Burke is "a moron," like Lowe said during a blistering denunciation on Edmonton's Team 1260 last Friday. But Lowe is a chump; an ex-jock in a businesses suit who allowed himself to be goaded into spectacular unprofessionalism by an exasperating bully.

LCS Hockey compared this to the Scut Farkas affair in "A Christmas Story," when Ralphie snapped and beat the living crap out of his school-yard tormentor. It's a rather perfect link: Lowe responded to Burke's pot-shots about Edmonton adversely affecting the NHL's salary structure by leaping on top of him and pounding away wildly with his mittens; spewing a bunch of profane gibberish that the neighborhood kids cheered as cathartic.

Yet, like Ralphie, Lowe's just a petulant child who let his juvenile discontent nearly undermine what's been a rather joyous season. Rhetorically, he shot his eye out, kid.

Some TSN coverage of the Burke/Lowe affair, to get you up to speed:

The quote that set Lowe off was from Burke during a conference call after Corey Perry re-signed with Anaheim: "Most [general] managers don't like starting fights with any other managers. ... Thanks to the Edmonton Oilers, the second contract [for players] has disappeared. ... You go right now from entry-level to what used to be the third contract, thanks to two offer sheets from Kevin Lowe."

Going on to call the Oilers "dirty bastards" couldn't have helped, either.

No one wants to be blamed for the salary escalation in the NHL and certainly not someone as frugal as Lowe, who only offered $9 million a season for Marian Hossa.

So he uncorked a scathing, hilarious rebuttal that we will now fact-check:

• LOWE: "He's a moron, first of all."

Read Burke's take during the lockout and tell me he's a moron. When it comes to the insanity of a "hard" cap and the owners' piggy banks, he's practically a soothsayer.

• LOWE: "Secondly, he really believes that any news for the NHL is good news. Thirdly, he loves the limelight and I don't think anyone in hockey will dispute that."

He's a self-promoter who loves the limelight. No wonder Toronto's hot for him. I'm in awe of Lowe's powers of observation.

• LOWE: "Lastly, he's in a pathetic hockey market where they can't get on any page of the newspaper let alone the front page of the sports, so any of this stuff carries on."

Rudy Kelly from Battle of California had a rather definitive take on this faux pas from Lowe. Pissing in someone else's cereal like this may not be the best move for a city that just got the gas face from Hossa, despite offering him the gross national product of Uruguay.

Lowe is right that he's not alone is having grown the salary scale in the NHL. But when Columbus gives Rick Nash his money or Atlanta gives Ilya Kovalchuk his money, there's a slight difference than when Edmonton signs a significantly lesser player like Dustin Penner to a five-year, $21.25 million offer sheet. And Lowe knows that.

Back to the Burke-bashing from the interview:

• LOWE: "He's an underachieving wanna-be in terms of success in the NHL. He won a Stanley Cup? Great. I've won six Stanley Cups, you want to count rings? Who cares, it's just a little pathetic that he carries on."

As my colleague Ross McKeon wrote yesterday: "How classic is that, Lowe flaunting his hardware." Like I said before: An ex-jock in a business suit. When the chips are down, throw on your old varsity jacket and try to score a one-nighter with a townie at the local pub to show that you've still got it.

If anyone should be dancing around, pointing at the Jumbotron, chanting "scoreboard," it's Burke. Lowe was absolutely destroyed in the Pronger trade. The Penner compensation could also be lopsided if Jake Gardiner and (especially) Nicolas Deschamps become the players they could become. So it's 1-0 Burke, potentially 2-0.

Of course, the quote above just underlines the silliness of this entire feud. Lowe got his rings on Gretzky's and Messier's teams, and Burke got his ring with Bryan Murray's team. Lowe has had his hits and misses for Edmonton as a GM, and he's correct when he says Burke gets way more credit as a player personnel man than he deserves. His draft history makes the LA Clippers look like the Red Wings.

But Burke deserves all the credit he can for being a Vince McMahon-level heel who managed to keep this grudge with Lowe going with constant cheap shots and snide remarks.

And despite what his cheerleaders in Edmonton say, Lowe deserves nothing but criticism for his outburst. He swallowed the bait and diminished a rather remarkable off-season for the Oilers that nearly became a blockbuster. He accepted a fight better left for the back rooms at GM meetings or between puckheads on fan message boards. He took a swing at an opponent begging to be punched, who's now skating away bloodied and laughing.

And that's why Lowe never won a Stanley Cup without Jeff Beukeboom or Dave Semenko on his team. Never, ever take the punch yourself if someone's asking for it.

digg delicious
more

29 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. somarycherry
    1. Posted by somarycherry Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:32 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    You're absolutely right - Lowe bit hard. I thought he sounded a little drunk myself. Can you imagine what things will be like if Burke becomes GM in Toronto?
  2. Brett J
    2. Posted by Brett J Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:12 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Don't you find it funny that Lowe is shown to be a "chump" for a few comments on one day in his life, and Burke is hailed as the king of "tactical fighters" for spewing nonsense for a full 365 days? I have not seen an article in a long time where the writer can use (or should I say twist?) information for the purposes of his mediocre writing.
    Nice article...
    Frankly, the fact that either one is saying anything is stupid, so Lowe bit hard, he is stupid. Burke sounds a little too much like Nelson from Simpsons in my opinion. Shut them both up!
  3. brad g
    3. Posted by brad g Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:16 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    did burke give you a nice reach around while you wrote this article?
  4. Wyshynski
    4. Posted by Wyshynski Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:21 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    @ brad g --
    Yes. Yes he did. But much like his time with the Ducks, Bryan Murray already did most of the most of the work before he got there.
  5. lyle s
    5. Posted by lyle s Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:59 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    lowe is just low...thats all i gots to say bout dat...
  6. TIM L
    6. Posted by TIM L Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:46 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The best article I've read all season!!!
    It's so funny how people point out the fact that burk inherited some good young players (perry, getzlaf)that bryan murray drafted but so easily forget that he got rid of some underachieving baggage (fedorov, sykora, etc) and brought in some great players (s.niedermayer, pronger, kunitz, selanne, etc) and turned it into a team that had missed the playoffs in 04-05 into a team that went to a western conference final and then a stanley cup champion.
    Hey dewman - I remember in the 07 playoffs when the ducks beat the red wings (you might want to forget) and the red wings complained being held up a lot. Fast forward to 08 when the red wings had to do the same things to penguins to beat them. The penguins also complained!!
  7. Bubbabanjo
    7. Posted by Bubbabanjo Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:05 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Wyshynski you and Burke stink!
  8. Doogie
    8. Posted by Doogie Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:30 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    And yet you don't point out how Lowe actually did address Burke's principal criticism -- that he was somehow responsible for the death of the (cheap) second contract. It was already happening, and started right after the lockout with the Rick Nash deal and had been filtering down from there ever since. The most you can credibly say is that he accelerated the process somewhat, but whether we reached this level now or in another year or so, this was going to happen regardless.
  9. Doogie
    9. Posted by Doogie Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:30 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    (continued)
    Lowe used a valid tool in the CBA to try to improve his team; if Burke wanted to prevent it, it's been proven repeatedly that he could have taken Penner to arbitration. While desperation probably did get the better of Lowe last season (see also Sheldon Souray), if it wasn't him, it would have been someone else, and really, I'm not exactly seeing how Burke was the better executive last year. Bertuzzi? Bryzgalov? MacDonald for Weight? Sewer, indeed.
  10. Earl Sleek
    10. Posted by Earl Sleek Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:50 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    "The most you can credibly say is that he accelerated the process somewhat, but whether we reached this level now or in another year or so, this was going to happen regardless."
    It was a significant move with significant RFA implications (and distinct repercussions from a Kovalchuk or Nash deal); I don't think Burke's wrong in saying that. Penner was never drafted and was playing for league minimum; he wasn't on a path to $4M+/yr until Lowe put him there.
    Lowe certainly had his motivations, and it's still too early to judge the Penner deal, I'd say, but it's pretty clear that the move has impacted RFA contracts, and don't mind Burke saying so.
    "I'm not exactly seeing how Burke was the better executive last year."
    I don't know how that's really relevant; Burke was dealing with some extraordinary factors in Niedermayer and Selanne, and in preventing their retirements, he did have to make some tough moves. "Sewer" is a tough label for a Ducks team that did end up fourth overall in standings points despite an awful start to the year. I'd argue that Burke did well with a tough situation, and had it not been for a Pronger suspension and a Perry injury, he probably would have had stronger postseason results.
  11. Rumpelstilzchen
    11. Posted by Rumpelstilzchen Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:32 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Bah, 13, Burke called Lowe all sorts of generic kiddie insults early on in l'affaire and over a whole fraggin year, which are nevertheless enjoyable to spew and sometimes effective.
  12. lyle s
    12. Posted by lyle s Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:59 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    #13 -great post kudos!!! #14..not so much..
  13. brad g
    13. Posted by brad g Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:16 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    " Penner was never drafted and was playing for league minimum; he wasn't on a path to $4M+/yr until Lowe put him there."
    at the very least tho, you have to admit that Penner did lead the Oilers in goals scored
    most folks don't quibble too much about paying their top goal scorer top dollars
    now if penner had put up 10-15 goals, bash him all you want~
  14. Brodie30
    14. Posted by Brodie30 Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:46 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    @ Wyshynski - That reply made me laugh so hard I spit my cereal this morning.
  15. El Sharko G
    15. Posted by El Sharko G Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:53 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    That' probably Burke's stogie in your mouth.That's the least you should get from him for jocking him so hard you duchebag!
  16. Dave
    16. Posted by Dave Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:45 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Chris Pronger wanted out of Edmonton in a bad way (for personal reasons) and Lowe wasn't going to get anything for him because he had no bargainning power. It didn't matter which team he traded with, he wasn't going to get much in return as everyone knew in the league knew that.
  17. Mr. Kevin
    17. Posted by Mr. Kevin Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:06 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The author of this article is a moron like Burke. I'm not saying Lowe is a good GM but Burke had it coming and I'm glad Lowe called him out. Just because Burke is a better GM than Lowe does not mean he's a good GM. Burke hasn't drafted well and he way overpaid for Schneider and Bertuzzi which has prevented the Ducks from having any sort of secondary scoring. Burke's reputation can't live off the Pronger trade forever.
  18. Hollywood
    18. Posted by Hollywood Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:30 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Everyone talks about how great Burke is but I just don't see it. Yes he put the finishing touches on a largely Murray built team and got a Cup. But what now? It seems like Anaheim is headed for the same situation Vancouver was when he was there. They are now gutted and have little left for the future. They're struggling to stay under the cap. They have an offense that finished 28th in the league last year and looks no better this year, especially if Selanne doesn't return. As far as their defense goes it's just getting older. Both Niedermayer and Pronger had sub-par years by their standards. Niedermayer will probably be playing his last year and Pronger is someone who's age will catch up with him quickly as he relies heavily on physical play, not to mention he's looked gun shy since being suspended again.
  19. cataphractspirit
    19. Posted by cataphractspirit Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:19 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I love this $hit! Why Bettman did you have to stop it?!
  20. Dutch
    20. Posted by Dutch Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:07 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Both these guys are chumps for the way they're carrying on. It is kind of funny, but this is just the kind of $h!t sleazebags like NBA commissioner david "worse than Bet-man" stern jump on to make claims of his rigged league's superiority. Burke has been given far too much credit for his GM skills, he still has to prove he can do it himself rather than inheriting a club on the verge of greatness. Time for him to grow up and cut the snide remarks about fellow "Professionals".
    As for Lowe, big deal about the 6 rings! Can you say ROLE PLAYER! Ummm..Gretzky, Messier, Kurri, Fuhr, Coffey etc..etc..etc...get me a pair of skates Kevin I'd win 6 Cups standing around at center ice 18 minutes a game! Also Lowe is one of the guys putting strain on the whole cap system, sure he's entitled to spend his limit as he sees fit, but much like Tampa did this season with the Ryan Malone contract and Edmonton TRIED to do with a $9M/9yr. offer to Maid Marian, the NHL is going down the same old slipery slope of escalating salaries. Any new big money TV deals in the works Bet-Man? Hope so, NHL is going to need the $$$. I'm sure Kevin Lowe is not well liked in Buffalo where he set the table for a bidding war for some of the Sabres stars which ultimately benefitted his buddy Glen Sather. Hell Buffalo had to break the bank to keep Thomas Vannick as well just to hemorrage the bleeding, thanks to Kevin Lowe.
  21. lesISmore
    21. Posted by lesISmore Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:01 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    why is burke still harping on the penner signing 11 months after the fact? he acts like a psycho girlfriend who continually complains about the ex boyfriend (usually at least 2 boyfriends ago), because he wouldn't watch dr. phil with her.
  22. Michigander21
    22. Posted by Michigander21 Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:35 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Why this makes Lowe look bad: Usually a well behaved, good guy, who works hard, and cares.
    Why this doesn't make Burke look bad: Everyone expects this from him.
  23. 5 trick pony
    23. Posted by 5 trick pony Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:05 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    You hear stuff like this from Burke all the frickin time, which for me removes the depth of his statements. I get tired of Burke going off at the mouth on every topic he comes across. It seems like it's a little to "entertaining" for Burke, and it shows. On the other hand, how often do you hear Lowe turn the nhl into the Jerry Springer show? (Burke should just start his own show, then I wouldn't have to use Springers name.) Now in hearing Lowe say a few words about Burke, I found it refreshing to hear something other than Burke going on and on. I think it's pretty safe to say you won't see Lowe doing and saying whatever he can to keep this circus on the road, while I'd put money on Burke trading McDonald for Weight... Weak article, i'm sure if you could, you would hang out with Burke, stroke his ego while laughing at the funny things he has to say about other people.
  24. 5 trick pony
    24. Posted by 5 trick pony Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:05 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    P.s- Who'd you take as your friend?? Let me guess, you don't think Burke would sweep you under a rug if he didn't need you anymore... I'm takin Lowe, good people before good Gm's.
  25. Nick
    25. Posted by Nick Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:44 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Well after reading this load of crap article I have the feeling Greg Wyshynski and Burke are just the best of friends. How much did Burke have to pay you to put these simple minded bias thoughts together...?
    Have you been listening to Burke for the last 1-2 years? All his blubbering and temper tantrums have more than justified the response from Kevin Lowe.
    I am pretty sure it was the Edmonton Oilers in 2006 who thumped the powerful ducks. You failed to mention this fact in your article. By the way that 2006 Oilers squad was nothing, but mediocre. So the score is not exactly 2-0 Burke.
    As for us "cheeerleaders" in Edmonton, I am pretty sure thats what fans are suppose to do...CHEER...
    I also noticed you failed to mention any of Burke's contoversial remarks throughout this article. You should probably back up your argument with "supporting evidence" from both sides if you want someone to agree with you.
    I have lost all respect for any opinion that you, Greg Wyshynski, offer in the future and will no longer waste my time reading your articles.

Puck Daddy

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Puck Daddy Recent Readers

Watch Live Hockey Online with GameCenter Live™