Puck Daddy - NHL

Historically, the NHL doesn't like its coaches speaking out of turn following contentious happenings on the ice. After the lockout, the League fined then-head coach of the Maple Leafs Pat Quinn and Anaheim Coach Randy Carlyle for making critical remarks about the post-work stoppage rules changes. In the 2006 Stanley Cup Finals, Oilers Coach Craig MacTavish was fined $10,000 for calling out referee Mick McGeough, even after the NHL agreed that he blew a critical call; saying that "It was a retarded call" and "He should be suspended."

The League doesn't like its decisions or decision-makers publicly questioned or ridiculed; but, more to the point, it doesn't want snarky coaches engaging in unsportsmanlike conduct through the media.

Like, for example, a playoff coach telling the media that an opposing player "deserved" a sucker punch to the face?

When faced with Philadelphia Flyers Coach John Stevens's characterization of Tom Kostopoulos's punch as cowardly, Montreal Canadiens Coach Guy Carbonneau called out Philly defenseman Kimmo Timonen for taunting: "If you score, go to your bench, be happy. Take the two points or the game. Just go home ... I think (Timonen) deserved it."

We were worried that Carbo's validation of an after-the-whistle blow to the face might rattle the NHL's thought police from their slumber. But Jason Portuondo of Sportsnet said it right: Carbonneau's comments were forged in postseason fire, and he probably had a point about Tauntin' Timonen. So while a coach validating an attack on an opponent grabbed big headlines after Game 2, there's no chatter this morning about any monetary punishment.

No extra slap on the wrist for Kostopoulos, no censoring of Carbonneau. Kudos to the NHL for understanding that the Stanley Cup Playoffs inspire some unsportsmanlike behavior, whether it's a coach saying a player deserved a left hook or a pest giving the finger to a TV camera.

digg delicious
more

31 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. JeffP
    1. Posted by JeffP Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:43 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    If Steve Downie had sucker punched Saku Koivu, it would have been the lead story on the NHL Network and Downie would have been suspended 10 games. Then if John Stevens said that Koivu deserved it he probably would have been fined and suspended as well.
    And Guy Carbonneau played enough in Philly to know that he had better watch his mouth. I loved how he scampered off the bench after game 1 like a little kid who stole $20 out of their mom's purse. Merry Christmas Guy, you should be down 0-2. Remember when one of you classless fans doused Mike Richards with beer in the penalty box game 1? You may want to bring an umberella tonight pal!
  2. John K
    2. Posted by John K Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:39 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Typical Canadian hypocrites.
    Flyers in 6
  3. greg s
    3. Posted by greg s Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:45 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    should of taken a moment to consider you're going back to philly .
    kost. better have his head on a swivel,cote and downie are comming.
    if the flyers are up by 2 w\ a minute or so left ....look out.
  4. MatthewW
    4. Posted by MatthewW Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:32 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I didn't notice and gloating or showboating. It seemed to me that he was just celebrating with the rest of his teammates. Did I miss something?
  5. Kerry Frasers Hair Gel
    5. Posted by Kerry Frasers Hair Gel Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:03 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    greg wyshynski is on realjock
  6. Wyshynski
    6. Posted by Wyshynski Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:13 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    @ Kerry Frasers Hair Gel -- I'm proud to say I had to Google "Realjock" to get that joke.
  7. nonhltoday
    7. Posted by nonhltoday Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:40 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Kostopoulos should have been suspended immediately following the game. They say he punched him in the face but it sure looked like the back of his head to me. If he had done that to Crosby, Ovechkin, Malkin, or one of the other Assman boys, it would have been a suspension.
  8. Kerry Frasers Hair Gel
    8. Posted by Kerry Frasers Hair Gel Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:03 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    sure Greg Wyshynski you know damn well if Downie had made that hit all of Canada would be up in arms, but the simple fact that it happened to a Flyer makes it ok. The league and its double standards are a joke. Where was Koivu in that play? He jumped in 3rd man, and wasnt on the ice at that time, yet he was in teh Scrum? This league has been a joke all year with the great work taht Colon Campbell has done.
  9. Vince S
    9. Posted by Vince S Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:22 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Carbo sounded petulant. Whaaaa.
  10. Jb8810
    10. Posted by Jb8810 Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:30 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Canadiens suck, Rangers suck, Penguins suck. Go Flyers!
  11. dickmo
    11. Posted by dickmo Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:25 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    All you Flyers fans need to quit your f&%$ing whinning. Just because the Canadiens have a better team from top to bottom and don't need to rely on the officials to win games for them (see 1st round game 7 overtime) dosen't mean you can get mad when they face superior team speed and skill. Then you get your panties all bunched up when another team beats you at your own goon/cheap shot/no skill games. There is hope - Carter and Richards are great young skill players, but your team is too weighed down with the Hatcher et all anchors. Enjoy your soon to be hard earned exit from the playoffs.
  12. D H
    12. Posted by D H Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:38 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    dickmo,
    RE 1st round game 7: The refs TRIED to give the Caps the advantage by not calling the FIRST flagrant trip on Sami Kapanen. What game were YOU watching?
    Face it, the league is against the Flyers, and they're proving they can beat everybody.
    Go Flyers! DH
  13. MoltarRocks
    13. Posted by MoltarRocks Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:15 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Hey Dickmo, until you realize there's a double standard, you have no room to talk. Just don't cry when Downie checks Kotsopolous so hard he wakes up speaking Greek, ok?
  14. Bill W
    14. Posted by Bill W Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:59 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Why were on the topic of Refs...... they couldnt get the call right with the above the crossbar goal in Game 1, you had to know the War Room couldn't get right located in Toronto, CANADA!. That call with a 1:30 left in the 3rd period of game 1 that sent Mike Richards to the box. Since when are we not allowed to check players with the puck anymore? I think this series might be skewed toward Montreal (only Canadian team left in the playoffs) just a little bit. The Flyers should be lucky that there not down 0 - 2 in the series!
  15. dickmo
    15. Posted by dickmo Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:25 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    DH, I'm pretty sure I watched the same game you did. Neither of those "trips" was flagrant and neither resulted in an obvious advantage/scoring opportunity for the Caps. I guess I am a bit old school, but I think the refs need to let 'em play in a game 7 overtime - let the players decide who wins a playoff series not you, the official. And the league is not against the flyers as many Flyers fans percieve they are. They just know that their team is not very likeable or enjoyable to watch, and you flyers fans enjoy that group energy the 'nobody likes us everbody hates us' attitude generates. You were so unfairly treated when 5 of you players were suspended in the first quarter of the season for dangerous hits that the league must hate us. Boo fricktey hoo. It is unfortunte that your young talent isn't generating the positve attention it should (like it has done for the Caps). Richards is nearly as enoyable to watch as Ovechkin, but no one knows that because so many folks are focused on the dirty hits and all the complaints about the league treating them unfairly. And Frasers Gel, I don't deny the fact that Hatcher is a man, but he is indicative of the Flyers big slow non-mobile defense. ;And the only reason the series is not 2-0 for the Canadiens is that Biron is playing great right now.
  16. dickmo
    16. Posted by dickmo Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:25 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    MoltarRocks has illustrated my point perfectly - rather than pointing out the Flyers superior skill and ability to actually win the series by scoring more goals - he goes straight to a threat of hard checking. Hard hitting is an important part of the game, but when that's the only part of your team's game you tout - that's a problem. And I didn't realize they spoke greek in Mississauga, Ontario. Hmmm...
  17. klusterfuk
    17. Posted by klusterfuk Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:52 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    While I'm no fan of the Flyers, I've got to call cheapshot on that one. I say the Flyers answer in kind to Koivu or Kovalev. Maybe Kostopoulos should have tried harder to prevent the goal, then he wouldn't have had to take the cheap shot.
  18. joeblob
    18. Posted by joeblob Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:43 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    i wonder what would happen if it was sean avery giving that punch...probably banned for life from the nhl and half the world calling him bush league..
  19. MICHAEL C
    19. Posted by MICHAEL C Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:18 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Series is tied 1-1 There are good calls bad calls in every series.The punch was no big deal but it will be dealt with on the ice im sure and should be at that. I do not see a bias, i see 2 even teams playing good hockey. Quit crying and enjoy the playoffs it will be over before you know it. Go Wings.
  20. dickmo
    20. Posted by dickmo Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:25 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Avery has allready proven he is bush league with his little flash dance routine in front of Brodeur in round 1.
  21. Bill W
    21. Posted by Bill W Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:59 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    It will be over before you know for the Wings!
  22. MICHAEL C
    22. Posted by MICHAEL C Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:18 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Yea right.
  23. Fr. Orange and Black
    23. Posted by Fr. Orange and Black Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:07 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Always a double standard. When Downie punched Blake from behind in a fight situation that Blake was turtling form with the help of the officials he was belittled by everyone. But when a player on a Canadian team commits something that "has no place in hockey" suddenly it has a place - to stop ALLEGED trash talking. Well the standard is set. The next time Kovalev says something according to Carbopneau he should get suckerpunched and their should be no recrimination. If Crosby mouths off - spear him. Yeah, we'll see if a little unsportsmanlike conduct is really allowed because it's the "playoffs". Get real. He should have been suspended for two games and Carboneau should be fined heavily. Heck Brian Burke almost faced criminal charges for possibily motivating Bertuzzi's action.
    Go FLyers!
  24. Fr. Orange and Black
    24. Posted by Fr. Orange and Black Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:07 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Hopefully we will show more class than the Canadien fans. Remember we have to go back to Montreal for game 5. Living among the Montreal barbarians makes Philly fans look like Lady Byng candidates. Remember when the Toronto prosecuter broght charges against the Flyers for going into the stands but there were mysteriously no charges for the Fans that provoked the exit form the ice to the stands.
    We should have the Canadiens help up at Philly airport. Have customs confiscate their equipment - rip open the goalie pads and break all the sticks to make sure they're aren't carrying drugs. Nah just kidding we can beat them anyway!
  25. Fr. Orange and Black
    25. Posted by Fr. Orange and Black Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:07 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Dear DMO,
    Regarding the blatant trips - you're missing the whole point. The Caps were stying in the zone too long and got beaten by checks which forced them to trip the Flyers to avoid odd man rushes the other way. They didn;t give the Caps a scoring opportunity they kept theFlyers form having scoring opportunities.

Puck Daddy

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Greg Wyshynski

Puck Daddy is an NHL blog edited by Greg Wyshynski. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Puck Daddy Recent Readers

Watch Live Hockey Online with GameCenter Live™