Puck Daddy - NHL

With the news yesterday that ESPN hockey analyst Barry Melrose would be leaving the network to take over the head coaching duties for the Tampa Bay Lightning, the one question many had wasn't, "How will he turn that team around?' but instead, "Who will replace him as the Worldwide Leader's main hockey analyst?"

Since 1996, Melrose has been working at ESPN and over the course of his 12 years in Bristol he found himself, much like majority of SportsCenter anchors, going from commentator to character. Melrose became more famous for his mullet than for his thoughts on the hockey world. When news began circulating that the Tampa Bay Lightning and their new owners Oren Koules and Len Barrie were interested in possibly bringing "The Mullet" on board to take over for the dispatched John Tortorella, there were mixed feelings. Some thought it was a good move and others, like James Mirtle, disagreed entirely

One thing is for sure, with rumors circulating about a possible NHL-ESPN reunion in the near future, the network's hockey coverage just took a big blow. Melrose was all over ESPNews on Thursday nights during the season as well as hosting his own weekly podcast with ESPN.com hockey editor Joy Russo. If ESPN is going to get back into bed with the NHL in the future, it'll need its hockey coverage to have a solid cast of opinion makers, just like Melrose provided since 1996.

On that note, who could possibly be in line to take over for Melrose once the puck drops again in October? Vote on the choices below and if you select "other," let us know in the comments who you would like to see head up ESPN's hockey coverage.


Who will be ESPN's next NHL analyst?

[Note: There is a poll within this post, RSS readers. Visit Puck Daddy to cast your vote.]

I don't know any of the contractual obligations for the following people; these are just names to throw out there and see what hockey fans think. Here are snarky bios for our nominees.

EJ Hradek: Best known these days as co-host of XM's NHL Live radio show with Don LaGreca, which is also simulcast on the NHL Network. A senior hockey writer for ESPN the Magazine, Hradek knows the game of hockey (though, not according to this guy) as he was a pro-scout for the Dallas Stars in the mid-90's before joining up with ESPN. With Melrose gone, Hradek is probably next in line since he's been a loyal employee since 1998.

Mike Milbury: ESPN has been known to bring in some analysts who've been magnets for controversy. Michael Irvin, Sean Salisbury, Bobby Knight, Rush Limbaugh, and Keyshawn Johnson are just a few. Milbury is kind of that guy during NBC and TSN broadcasts, always saying outlandish things, and in the end is reminded of his wonderful reign as New York Islanders coach and general manager. He's known as "Mad Mike," but I think there's way too much hatred for the guy to fill the position. 

Ed Olczyk: A knowledgeable hockey guy who's played and broadcasted the game for over 20 years. The color commentator for the Chicago Blackhawks and lead color man for the NHL on NBC and NHL on Versus broadcasts, Olczyk has worked for ESPN in the past as a game analyst. Edzo is known for his crush on Sidney Crosby, yet at the same time, distaste for the Penguins who fired him 31 games into the 2005-06 season, his second with Pittsburgh.  I think Eddie O would rather enjoy the next few years watching the Blackhawks grow up and stay in the Windy City instead of flying east to be buried behind college basketball highlights.

Maggie the Monkey: Just because it's fun to include monkeys into any discussion. And she probably has a better chance than Milbury, too.

Bill Clement: This is my personal choice. "Clement, Clement, hands of cement" worked for a long time at ESPN as the network's top color commentator alongside Gary Thorne.  When the NHL's contract was not renewed after the lockout, Clement headed to Versus and hosted their pre-game studio show until he was fired last summer. His replacement, Bill Patrick, was scorned by hockey fans who scratched their heads as to why Clement was let go. The man with the fantastic mustache was also not brought back by NBC for their studio coverage, instead deciding to go with Pierre McGuire and Mike Milbury, as well as Bob Neumeier during the Stanley Cup playoffs. I'm sure Clement would love to reunite at ESPN with Thorne, but the lack of a television contract with the NHL will probably hurt any desire to move at this point in time.

So there are my choices. What say you? 

digg delicious
more

67 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. commit to the indian
    1. Posted by commit to the indian Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:17 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    As long as the games are on versus who really cares who espn gets!! ESPN doesn't show any hockey highlights on sportscenter anyway so nobody is going to tune in. Barry Melrose went back into coaching because he knew ESPN's hockey coverage isn't what it used to be.
  2. jkrdevil
    2. Posted by jkrdevil Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:36 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The obvious choice is Maggie the Monkey since she is the most knowledgeably of the potential candidates. However ESPN has never been known to hire knowledgeable commentators so they will probably hire Milbury.
  3. Adam Jones
    3. Posted by Adam Jones Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:45 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    After reading his blog during the playoffs, I gotta go with Kevin Smith.
  4. smooth1js
    4. Posted by smooth1js Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:30 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Darren Pang
  5. Matt
    5. Posted by Matt Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:18 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Get Roenick to retire. I know he's signed for next year, but this is an opportunity of a lifetime!
  6. Paul Nicholson
    6. Posted by Paul Nicholson Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:42 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I know Canada would never let him go full time, but since we are only talking about a 10-15 minute spot every few nights, i wouldn't be surprised (or personally mind) if they broaden their Don-Cherry-on-loan agreement. Personalities don't get any bigger and they've already introduced their audience to him.
    Crackpot theory: I'd be willing to bet that Melrose let ESPN know he was looking at coaching again and they went and grabbed Cherry during the finals to test him out and see how the ESPN audience responded. I bet it's him.
  7. Leahy
    7. Posted by Leahy Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:27 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    panger is a good one...but i think he's got it made living out in phoenix. hell, even wilbon does pti from there
  8. Patrick
    8. Posted by Patrick Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:14 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Eric McErlain?
  9. amma.marfo
    9. Posted by amma.marfo Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:53 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I thought Don Cherry had already been hired to replace Melrose?
    That's what made me first take the Melrose to Tampa rumor seriously...the fact that ESPN was already looking to replace him.
    If they want to try to take hockey seriously on that channel, Cherry would be a GREAT start.
  10. Johnathan B
    10. Posted by Johnathan B Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:38 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    don cherry... obvious choice
  11. R F
    11. Posted by R F Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:44 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I only like Milbury because he was the only one smart enough to stand up to Eagleson when he was a player, so he has half a brain at least. I thought the Republicans passed a bill so the oil companies could start drilling for oil in Melrose's hair. Damn, I was looking forward to cheaper gas.
  12. R F
    12. Posted by R F Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:44 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I say they need to get Scotty Ferrall, sh-sh-shake it up!!!
  13. golferandy
    13. Posted by golferandy Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:56 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    olczyk is a terrific color commentator on game coverage. he should stay with that strength and not be a studio analyst. darren pang would be a good choice ..... hard-working and insightful and a good people person. these traits would generate lots of interesting stories as a studio analyst.
  14. Jason C
    14. Posted by Jason C Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:29 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Dave Coulier.
    Rocking it since the early 80's, he proved that even if you have a mullet, you can still be a cool, funny, kinda creepy, comedian/fake uncle.
  15. whattheF
    15. Posted by whattheF Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:43 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I want to choose 'Other' but do not see it there...but my "other" choice would be don cherry...who else??
  16. baller13zg
    16. Posted by baller13zg Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:58 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The monkey for sure. LOL!!!
  17. James M
    17. Posted by James M Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:35 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I'd keep the spot open, Melrose will be back..............soon.
  18. Swift34
    18. Posted by Swift34 Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:21 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Brett Hull would be great.
  19. J-D
    19. Posted by J-D Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:31 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    John Buccigross and Ken the Otter.
  20. Raskolnikov
    20. Posted by Raskolnikov Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:07 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Hakan Loob!!!!
  21. AMeyer
    21. Posted by AMeyer Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:22 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I HATE DON CHERRY.
    Rick Jeanerette is my vote. There is no commentator that can match his excitement, look up Sabres highlights on YouTube and you will see what i mean.
  22. Jim
    22. Posted by Jim Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:35 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    For hockey highlights on ESPN I would go with Darren Pang or Eddie Olczyk or EJ Hradek. Hradek could get the nod over the other 2 guys I listed. But I would like if ESPN brought back their old 30 minute hockey show that was hosted by Bill Pito. It would be great to see Pito and the fill in for Melrose have a nightly highlight show together.
    If the NHL comes back to ESPN they have to team up Thorne and Clement. They made the ESPN Hockey Nights great.
    One guy I would love to see the National exposure but would to lose him is Daryl Reaugh with the Dallas Stars. Razor has filled in on Both ESPN and VS game of the weeks. And has done a great job.
    Folks who need to be fired because they suck...Pierre McGuire, Mike Milbury and Bill Patrick...I can't said watching or listening to these guys talk.
  23. Whale4ever
    23. Posted by Whale4ever Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:21 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Man, Roenick would be a veritable freakin' hoot. Dress him up in John Garrett duds; it'll go well with the Bud Light. Loads of opinion, little analysis. Hook him up with a Clement- or Pang-type and we've got our very own MacLean and Cherry.
    Just imagine a disagreement between Panger and JR. Broadcast gold.
  24. Whale4ever
    24. Posted by Whale4ever Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:21 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Jim - superb call on Reaugh.
  25. Mike
    25. Posted by Mike Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:17 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Forget the others get Don Cherry!

Puck Daddy

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Greg Wyshynski

Puck Daddy is an NHL blog edited by Greg Wyshynski. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Puck Daddy Recent Readers

Watch Live Hockey Online with GameCenter Live™