Puck Daddy - NHL

After the dust settled on Sean Avery's newly-vented spleen this afternoon, my prayers for Avery faded but my thoughts did not; specifically, thoughts about what kind of reaction the belligerent New York Ranger might have for the New York Daily News, which misreported that Avery was unconscious, had stopped breathing and was in cardiac arrest early Wednesday morning.

This is, after all, a player that already has one libel claim to his credit this season. Avery went after a Toronto radio reporter who claimed that Avery make derogatory references about Jason Blake's cancer, inciting a skirmish before a game against the Toronto Maple Leafs. Reporter Howard Berger later retracted the report and apologized on FAN 590 to end the ordeal.

In speaking to some friends in the newspaper and legal businesses Wednesday, the Daily News shouldn't have reason for concern. It quickly corrected its reporting, scrubbing its original story of any reference to "cardiac arrest" after the Rangers and other media outlets reported that Avery has instead suffered a lacerated spleen. There's also an absence of malice here ... unless the newspaper's refuted report that Avery was in the little black book of a high-end Manhattan madam can somehow indicate a pattern.

After a full day of silence on his Blueshirts Blog, Daily News writer John Dellapina -- who shared a byline on the "cardiac arrest" report -- addressed the situation at the end of a blog post previewing Game 4 of the Rangers' series against the Pittsburgh Penguins. His defiant comments seem to indicate he believes there's some truth to the original story -- and that tales of lacerated spleens were concocted for easy consumption by his gullible peers in the mainstream media.

Dellapina wrote:

Finally, for all those from other media outlets and newspapers who have sarcastically dismissed our initial web story about Sean Avery's hospitalization since the Rangers refuted it Wednesday afternoon, I wonder:

Was your initial reaction that the story couldn't have been correct or did you simply race up to the MSG Training Center to get player reaction? And, did you call the hospital and/or Avery's representatives to get the real story or did your "reporting" simply consist of taking the team's word for what happened?

Fortunately, the intrepid men an women of the press who have exposed baseball's steroid problems didn't similarly regurgitate what they were told by people who understandably want their businesses viewed as beyond reproach.

So is Dellapina simply slamming his peers for lazy reporting on a story the Daily News stuck its neck out to break? Or does "taking the team's word for what happened" seem to indicate he thinks that the "lacerated spleen" is a conspiratorial cover for something much more sinister, despite the denials that Avery had any heart problems?

And if it is a cover story ... what does Dellapina know that he isn't sharing? What does he believe the Rangers, and Avery, are hiding?

digg delicious
more

34 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. Baldodad
    1. Posted by Baldodad Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:01 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Avery is a punk and should have gotten that cup-check in the first round. Hats off to Fluery for the huevos to do that. Sure, the guy lost a spleen but (in the end) does it really matter if the Daily News lied? I mean, it's just a game. And, a person who goes around beating up players for the fun of it. The Pens were just defending their goaltender at the end of a taut game.
    Go Pens!
  2. iLIKECHEESE
    2. Posted by iLIKECHEESE Thu Sep 03, 2009 6:54 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    typical pens response. Go ahead and win with your cry baby, dive bombing, crosby who the media loves to pole jock. Hope the pens Choke
    Go Habs Rags or Flyers.
  3. Kevroc
    3. Posted by Kevroc Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:50 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Right, Jagr wasn't splashing around in Game 3?
  4. WayneP
    4. Posted by WayneP Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:34 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    While you never want to see someone get seriously injured, it couldn't happen to a more deserving person! Avery is a punk, and I, for one, am glad to see him out of the playoffs. Granted, it sux that the NY papers have to make up stuff cause they're too lame to actually learn something to write, but...
  5. gbrobagelman
    5. Posted by gbrobagelman Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:06 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    agree w/ #6..
  6. Marc-Andre Fleury beat chuck norris in a fight!
    6. Posted by Marc-Andre Fleury beat chuck norris in a fight! Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:30 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Its about time avery got what was coming to him, he is a disgrace to the NHL. no sympathy for him, but thoughts to his family...Typical rangers response to this, Pens dive pens dive....#1 PK and PP in the league, STFU!
    GO pens, bring on whoever thinks they can take us out, you will fall to our knees.
  7. Justin B
    7. Posted by Justin B Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:30 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    wow, has anyone else noticed what a joke the officiating is in this series? i think its pretty ****ing laughable how the nhl simply needs crosby to reach the finals and it really deosn't matter how he gets there. the nhl is simply looking for ratings, thats it. they have no interest in crowning a true champion. what ever, let the nhl acquire a bunch of know-nothing morons to their fan base. they will only be losing those of us who truly appreciate the game..... not much of a sacrifice for the nhl that has no integrity and is run by a bunch of money hungry cowards.
  8. Ben
    8. Posted by Ben Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:32 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Justin B you obviously are a part of that know-nothing moron fan base if you attribute the Rangers losses to the refs. What an idiot. Grow up. The NHL wants to lose stupid fans like you.
  9. Editor
    9. Posted by Editor Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:49 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Greg, love your stuff, but maybe a little digging would've been in order before going with this. Dellapina didn't drive either story, the other reporters in the byline got the info from the hospital and on the madam's black book. Dellapina's byline was for providing background info on Avery and checking with Ranger sources on the stories the other reporters got. His blog item is not a hint that there's more to the story, but should be taken at face value that there's more to reporting than just getting the official story from the team.
  10. Julie H
    10. Posted by Julie H Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:44 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Go pens!!!! :)
  11. HipCheckJimmy
    11. Posted by HipCheckJimmy Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:05 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    By any journalistic standards and ethics, dear readers:
    When a newspaper prints or reports a story containing a factual error, the preferred way to correct the error is to 1) Print a separate correction with a referrence to the original inaccurate article. Alternatively, the paper can weasel and 2) Print an article with the corrected information. The article should, however, contain mention of the original innacurate report. The same standard should be applied to online/blog reporting. Since I don't read the Daily News, (or The New York ComPOST), I can't say whether this was done, but from your blog and the comments above, I'd say the News and their reporters failed to demonstrate any integrity or accuracy here.
  12. Slacker
    12. Posted by Slacker Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:49 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Sheesh, everyone with the "got what he deserved" comments are just sad, sad people. You guys really need a reality check and to get your lives into some kind of perspective.
  13. pghpatt
    13. Posted by pghpatt Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:48 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Looks like the Pens came up with their own Avery rule:When he talks smack--de-spleen his a$$!
  14. sean s
    14. Posted by sean s Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:30 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    im pens fan and i hate avery as a player but i dont think anyone deserves a ruptured spleen for being a punk agitator. justin b... the pens dont need help to get to the finals this year... but i am pretty sick of the crosby hipe... the nhl is so desperate for another gretzky and thats not gonna happen anytime soon with crosby or ovechkin, or malkin who i think is the best of the three. but who knows theyre all still young
    go pens
  15. Wyshynski
    15. Posted by Wyshynski Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:13 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    @ Editor --
    I've met John and I like John. Liked him since his days covering the Devils.
    "Dellapina's byline was for providing background info on Avery and checking with Ranger sources on the stories the other reporters got. His blog item is not a hint that there's more to the story, but should be taken at face value that there's more to reporting than just getting the official story from the team."
    If that's what you read into it, and that's what John intended, it's just another case of MSM blogs needing a little editorial oversight. Bringing the steroid investigation into the conversation completely clouds his point, because the MSM reaction to steroids was to swallow the company line and not dig for the "real" story. In Avery's case, it seems to indicate that the rest of the media accepted what the Rangers had to say while the NYDN was the SF Chron on the steroid beat.
    I understand he didn't drive the story. I know how these Metro desk/Sports desk mash-ups work. But then just let it die on the vine; for Dellapina to address it on his blog, he's pouring salt in the NYDN's self-inflicted wound.
  16. PHILIP
    16. Posted by PHILIP Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:09 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    wow these comments are all over the place and all passionate =)
    look heres the scoop...
    Avery is and idiot and has been since juniors, talented but classless...amazing how he tried to play the Broduer thing as having Marty the one who lacks class, so basically he can act like a total goof towards someone, on and off the ice, and as soon as someone disrespects him, they are the ones who lack class? honestly if Broduer punched him out during handshakes id respect him even MORE. Im very sure that most of his own teammates dont like him either, just like the flyers felt about Bobby Clarke back in the day.
    As for Crosby...of all the players to call him out..Jagr does it? Jagr was the biggest diver in the 90's during his 'hayday' and for some reason now he finds it wrong? wonder why that is. After watching that apparent 'dive' ive come to the conclusion that Crosby was impeded but over did it a bit. I also wonder why some fans dont like Crosby either, theyre the same fans who wouldnt have liked Gretzky when he started out, they got a problem with young good looking kids who are immensely talented. Im not saying Crosby doesnt get special treatment, but if Jagr thinks he wasnt getting special treatment back in the 90's he needs to watch those videos of him with that ridiculous haircut and see how generous the refs were to him.
  17. PHILIP
    17. Posted by PHILIP Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:09 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    also i hope Avery is alright but like the saying goes...what goes around comes around!
  18. Todd S.
    18. Posted by Todd S. Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:53 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The NYR fans whine like Jagr, it's crazy. Lets face it spending mulit-millions on free agents who netted less points than Crosby who played 53 games. You can't buy the Cup and the better team is winning the series. Going 7-0 in the playoffs is not a fluke.
  19. jasonicus
    19. Posted by jasonicus Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:29 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    So everyone else but this guy got the story wrong? Come on now. This guy is a hack and should be fired for bad reporting.
  20. zstalin235
    20. Posted by zstalin235 Thu Sep 03, 2009 11:02 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I will comment on things I see here which I find dubious:
    Justin B - Clearly you have no clue. If the NHL wanted ratings, they would be pushing for a NY - LA matchup.....think about it.....think a little more.....the bigger the market.....the more ratings....something called math, as as you may spell it MAFF. As far as the officiating, Rangers had 2 (5-3) power plays, the PENS have had 0. Otherwise, the penalties have been even. The problem for you is that the Rangers CAN NOT score on the power play - not the REFS. You are one of those morons you talk about, and its no great loss if you leave.
    As far as Avery goes, obviously no one wants to see anyone hurt in sports. Play hard, but play fair. I don't believe what Avery was doing to Brodeur was fair. I do believe in something called Karma. Without getting too metaphysical - here are the basics. If you act like a BIT*H, the universe will smack you like a BIT*H, to put you back in line. Balance things out. Thats what happened to Avery. Who cares what was reported - in the heat of the moment, anything can be reported or mistakenly heard.
  21. David
    21. Posted by David Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:44 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    yo justin B just so you know the rangers got two 5-3 power plays in a row so yeah the refs are realy trying to give them the series ha ha ha ha ha. Bring out the brooms so we can take the garbage out and rename the garden to the pens and pitt panthers garden.
  22. michael c
    22. Posted by michael c Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:02 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    WOW you all are terriable. I'm a die hard B's fan and dislike the Rangers as much as the next guy. But look Avery is still a person and could have lost his life, You all understnad that your spleen can puncture you lung and it will colaps and you could die. I know most of you think he is a punk, He was doing his job. He is not out there to score goals but to get under peoples skin, He did not deserve what he got it was and it was unfortunate that this happened. I'm glad he is ok. Go Bruins( Next Year anyway) LOL
  23. Yaj Nettihw
    23. Posted by Yaj Nettihw Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:29 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    What do you guys want with all this "Crosby dives" ranting? Really, tell me, what's the problem, what do you want? More power plays for New York? You mean those two back to back 5 on 3 power plays weren't good enough? Well, OK, apparently not, since the Rangers couldn't convert on either one. So maybe we'll do it like this: every time Crosby goes down for whatever reason, it doesn't matter what (we'll give Jagr a whistle and let him decide), every single time, New York gets a 5 on 2 power play for 5 minutes, OK? Would that shut you guys up?
  24. The Tank
    24. Posted by The Tank Thu Sep 03, 2009 6:58 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Pens fans are jackasses. I can't believe they boo Jagr when he's in their house. That would've been like booing Messier when he showed up with the Canucks.. doesn't happen in New York, we appreciate the people who bring us the cup.. our heroes. You'd think they'd be even more appreciative of Jagr due to the fact that their team hasn't done $hit till Crosby and Malkin arrived. I guess some fans are just plain immature.

Puck Daddy

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Greg Wyshynski

Puck Daddy is an NHL blog edited by Greg Wyshynski. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Puck Daddy Recent Readers

Watch Live Hockey Online with GameCenter Live™