Puck Daddy - NHL

While I still consider the KHL to be more Red Menace chum for hockey pundits than an actual threat to the NHL, this summer has created a sense that we're at the dawn of Hockey's Cold War. And there is going to be a contingent of nationalists in North America that are completely fine with this, because they yearn for the simplistic days of common enemies.

It's the Don Cherry crowd, the one that never believed there was a Russian word for "Rock'em Sock'em"; the one that's been waiting for Martin Straka to head back "where he comes from" because they believe there's a surge of BC-bred Milan Lucics waiting for his job. In other words: There's already a built-in audience for an NHL/KHL Summit Series, bringing this international animosity to the ice.

The original Summit Series was born of a much different era, of course, with Canadians cheesed off about getting their asses handed to them in international competitions by Russian hockey teams that were about as amateur as Jenna Jameson. In fact, the script would be flipped: North America would be the superior talent, and the Russians would be clawing for respect.

Garrett of Puckhead's Thoughts blogged about this idea, and it was the first time I really thought about the rivalry between these leagues beyond Alexander Radulov and transfer agreements (which has, by the way, raised the level of off-season tedium to near-record levels):

With now two seemingly good leagues separated by the globe, could an interleague super series be in the future? It's an interesting question and many on the KHL side would like to see NHL franchises compete with their teams. A thought that I am sure has crossed the mind of Gary Bettman. A super series with games both played here in North America and over in Russia.

Imagine Alex Ovechkin playing in his home town of Moscow in a Capitals sweater against his former team Dynamo Moscow or Jaromir Jagr suiting up for Omsk to play against the New York Rangers. Both games heavy with storylines that both Russian and North American fans would understand and both be interested in.

The pros and cons for this NHL/KHL series are entrancing, perplexing and in many ways insurmountable.

The advantages are rather obvious: The inherent drama and the stakes at hand, even for an exhibition series, would make the Winter Classic look like a Peanuts snow globe by comparison.

The thought of Alexander Ovechkin and Ilya Kovalchuk suiting up for the NHL in order to prove its superiority over a fledging League back in the homeland. The notion of an ex-pat like Jagr exacting revenge on a League that turned its back on him. Canadians and Americans teaming up against Russians on the ice, reproducing the king of athletic tension their fathers used to recall with tales of Paul Henderson or Herb Brooks.

For the NHL, it would be a world stage on which to curb-stomp the competition. An eight-game series with a decisive victory and a goal differential of 45-10 would cement the League as the superior product, at least symbolically. ("In Russia, puck plays goalie...") Suddenly "take the money and run" will be accompanied by "to that inferior garbage league" for bitter GMs seeing free agents skate across the pond.

But the cons for the NHL probably outweigh any benefits. Simply put, there's nothing tangible to gain for Gary Bettman and the League. The KHL can crow about capital and expansion into other parts of Europe. But the NHL is the gold standard; simply inviting the KHL to the party increases its cache. It'd be like an eight-game infomercial on a global stage.

There's a reason third-party candidates don't get invited to Presidential Debates: The perception of equal footing.

God forbid the NHL actually takes it on the chin from the feisty Russians ... that's a PR nightmare that would make the Chris Simon incident seem like a love-tap. You didn't exactly see an NFL/USFL Pro Bowl, did you?

I keep coming back to the NFL/USFL comparison, but in the end (depending on the KHL's foray into other European countries) it could be more NFL/AFL. I've said since the beginning that, ultimately, I expect the NHL and the KHL to create some sort of global super league down the line. If KHL President Alexander Medvedev's goal is indeed to "find a way to develop hockey worldwide," competitive interaction between the leagues would serve that end and potentially lead to a more long-standing relationship many moons from now.

From a fan perspective, I'm sure this idea has many of us already salivating. The hockey could completely suck, but the dramatic tension of this "international conflict" would keep us watching from the drop of the puck. Especially for the fans who just want to root for the home colors and bash the commies again.

That's the underlying narrative buried beneath all the backroom maneuvering we've had in recent weeks: That NHL players aren't the only ones eager to have a rival league in Russia; it's pretty good business for flag-waving jingoists, too.

There are likely too many philosophical and economic pitfalls to make a new "Summit Series" happen, but it's foolish to think it wouldn't sell to the "Rocky IV" crowd and that the Leagues couldn't handsomely profit from a venture like this. 

As long as Rocky wins the fight, of course. Or else you can forget "NHL v. KHL II."

digg delicious
more

39 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. kevin s
    1. Posted by kevin s Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:50 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    FIRST ,#1 WOOOO ,HELL YEAH ,PARTY WOOOO!!!Sure am glad Jagr is gone,take Forsberg with you!!
  2. Brad_Lee
    2. Posted by Brad_Lee Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:10 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    That one dude witht he flag wants to eat an unborn Canadian baby he's so pumped up.
    This would be like the NFL playing the winner of another competing league in some big title game. And everyone knows that would never happen.
  3. phntomsoul
    3. Posted by phntomsoul Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:10 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    good luck getting american media to embrace broadcasting sports events live from a time zone that's at an almost completely opposite time of day from our prime-time -- especially in the western parts of north america. sure cbc may be interested, but for those of us south of the border, we can't even get a real national broadcast contract for our own prime-time games (everyone knows nbc is a joke and is really only doing it because its free...)
  4. tmr
    4. Posted by tmr Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:04 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    If the other shoe drops and a couple of blue chip Canadian or American born players go to Russia for "an offer they can't refuse" possibly starting a trend, I wonder what the equation looks like then. All those European players aren't coming over here now just because they like American beer (that CAN'T be the reason). They're following the money. If Russia came up with the money, I wonder who would go?
  5. tmr
    5. Posted by tmr Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:04 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Not to say that it's probable...but it IS possible...
  6. Booger
    6. Posted by Booger Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:40 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I think that this is the story that the NHL needs to start to get back on the right track and get more nation wide coverage.
  7. Dewman
    7. Posted by Dewman Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:42 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Players will want and NEED an offseason. This would almost ensure no offseason whatsoever. Who wants to go from winning the Stanley Cup, to MORE playing half way round the world. I think I would rather take the Cup to my local Bar and party. Maybe drop the Cup a few times along the way.
  8. tmr
    8. Posted by tmr Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:04 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    If they shortened the regular season by two weeks to make room for a "World Championship" after the Stanley Cup Finals, the guys could still get a summer break. But the owners would never go for it.
  9. Old 7-9er
    9. Posted by Old 7-9er Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:42 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Wow - we once torched like a bale of ganja at a Dead show back in '75 at the old Spectrum. Gonna miss that place, man.
  10. Hyphen
    10. Posted by Hyphen Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:24 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I don't know much about the KHL as a league outside of what I have read or heard, but what I have heard is that there is a large gap in goaltending between the KHL and NHL. If games were to be played, would they become one-sided All Star-esque games? 11-1 Red Wings beat Omsk?
    Personally, I would love to see more international play televised state side. We don't get to see much, if any, of the World Championships and outside of the Olympics, the only hockey we see is the NHL which gets when can best be described as minimal coverage. International clashes between European-only leagues and the diverse NHL teams would be awesome. I invision a 8-team playoff, 4 NHL, 4 KHL. It would be fun to watch.
  11. MOP
    11. Posted by MOP Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:51 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Where's BubbaBanjo?
    I wouldn't bet my money on this happening. KHL may not last longer than 5 years. If it last 10, I may consider putting money down, but does the NHL play the Swedish Elite teams? Or are they AHL to the KHL? Get real.
  12. JohnB
    12. Posted by JohnB Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:06 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Yeah, never going to happen... there's no upside for the NHL. If they win, they were supposed to and nothing is gained. They lose, players leave for other leagues, players stay in their homeland, making the NHL weaker and damaging the league. Let the JV NHL go on all they want about how good they are. Anyone with half a brain knows they can't compete and we don't need anyone questioning that.
  13. Dead Presidents
    13. Posted by Dead Presidents Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:49 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Why wouldn't the NHL embrace a super league like the football (soccer) Champions league? You can shorten the NHL regular season by 12-14 games, then have the playoffs. Not sure if greedy owners would go for this though due to loss of revenue from the teams that DON'T make it. Then you can send the Conference Finals participants (4 teams) the this new super league to face off against the KHL's 4 teams in a shortened 14 game mini season and then use the same or similar format that they use for the Canadian Memorial Cup or possibly something like the champions league uses aggregate scoring. North American and Russian each play a home and home series against the other teams. Or another option would be to have the same rules as they use in the Hockey World Cup but with only 8 teams.
  14. NYC
    14. Posted by NYC Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:02 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Hello,
    I would just say it is a VERY STUPID IDEA TO DO NHL VS KHL.
    BETTER DO US MLS [soccer team] against IRAN and let say COLUMBIA. It will make more sense.
    DON'T MAKE IT POLITICAL AS those idiots in 80s :))))
    SPORT should not be a part of politics. ICE HOCKEY COLD WAR ???????? Keep it for yourself idiot.
    NYC.
  15. JamieYaheard
    15. Posted by JamieYaheard Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:25 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    awful... americans and canadians teaming up to play russians? you made that way to simplistic... it's going to be the same nations playing the same nations... it's not canada vs. russia anymore the teams are way too diluted... the only way i see this going down maybe a co-all star game... no other way...it would actually be canadians, americans, russians, fins, swedes, slovakians, czechs playing canadians, americans, russians, fins, swedes, slovakians, czechs from another league... that's all... no passion unless you seperate the nations into groups... but that's why we have the iihf world jr, men's and women championships and the olympics in case you forgot....
  16. Quebecois
    16. Posted by Quebecois Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:22 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I want to see a lot of International games but you should stop this "Cold War" crap ... it is over !!!
  17. checkit
    17. Posted by checkit Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:12 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Champions league soccer is different because most of the games are played during the regular season because the travel time is very short. The hockey Supercup will probably be only 2 games (1 home 1 away). Although traveling to Russia and back is quite an arduous trip. I guess it's easier in business class but still.
    I don't think that Russia has enough money to get all the best players but there will be at least one highly paid player on each team and the NHL can draft players all it wants but they will not come until the NHL pays more to rookies (with a signing bonus or otherwise). This will force the NHL to draft mostly North American players with European players mostly being FA signings and I'm not sure how Gary Bettman plans to regulate that.
  18. ChuckFromDetroit
    18. Posted by ChuckFromDetroit Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:27 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    If the KHL works I believe it will merge with the NHL one day and there will be a Europeon Conf. although the N. American Conf and Europeon Conf. Champions will meet for the Stanley Cup like the old days of MLB when both the American and National League Champions only met in the World Series.
    I do see an NHL Europeon conf. with teams in Sweden, Finland, Russia etc...............The NHL of the last 15 years is like when the negro players finally were let it where we seen players like Mays, Aaron, Gibson and so on and so on. Everything has become more global and the reason why the NHL plays games in Europe now is obvious. I wonder how many kids in Sweden are wearing Red Wings sweaters, eh? People who are all about tradition will not like this but money is money and there is a lot more money to be made by the NHL in Europe.
  19. Bill
    19. Posted by Bill Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:04 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    the russian league will never be the NHL, and who the hell wants to move to russia if they are not from that area, jagr is from the area and like he said its not a big deal for him to live in russia, an american or canadian would have a hard time adjusting, and god please send us a network deal.
  20. ChuckFromDetroit
    20. Posted by ChuckFromDetroit Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:27 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The winner of Moscow v. Helesinki will face the winner of Toronto v. Detroit for the Stanley Cup, eh? The fact that I even mentioned Toronto in the Conf. finals is my way of saying this new NHL is still many, many, many years away.
  21. cristobal
    21. Posted by cristobal Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:24 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    as half of these posts prove, the arrogance and ignorance of the average north american knows no bounds. the nhl is on a downward spiral, the regular season is almost interminably unwatchable, and there are teams in markets that don't even want them.
    the only problem with this scenario of khl vs. nhl is that the khl is adopting many of the flawed ways of the nhl, apparently - salary caps, a draft, no promotion and relegation. the european soccer leagues pit only the best of the best from the european club leagues. a champions league of hockey could work if the dummies running the nhl wanted what was best for hockey's future.
    there is a tremendous amount of money in russia and europe. its not in their best interest to destroy the nhl, but to work with it. interleague play would benefit hockey and open up some minds as to how great sports can really be.
    change the structure of the nhl (no draft, shorter regular season, less teams in the top flight, promotion and relegation) and things will get better and hockey will win.
  22. cristobal
    22. Posted by cristobal Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:24 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    interleague play would also require a compromise on rules - would fighting warrant ejection? automatic icing? nhl or olympic size rinks? no commercial time-outs?
  23. youraveragepsychometrist
    23. Posted by youraveragepsychometrist Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:58 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Is it just me, or does the guy with the flag at the top (aka the baby-eater referenced in another post) look like Joe Francis, the mastermind behind Girls Gone Wild?
  24. chris c
    24. Posted by chris c Thu Sep 03, 2009 11:00 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Ratings have been up for the NHL for the past 3 or 4 years as compared to the NBA which has gone just about nowhere since Jordan left the game. LOL
  25. cristobal
    25. Posted by cristobal Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:24 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    nielsen rating for the end of april 2008
    http://tvbythenumbers.com/2008/05/05/top-sports-shows-april-21-27-nascar-talladega/3615

Puck Daddy

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Greg Wyshynski

Puck Daddy is an NHL blog edited by Greg Wyshynski. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Puck Daddy Recent Readers

Watch Live Hockey Online with GameCenter Live™