Puck Daddy - NHL

We're not much into guarantees, but let's lay this one on the line: Bruce Boudreau will be the only head coach in NHL history to both win the Southeast Division and get name-checked on the "Slap Shot" DVD commentary track as an actor. Now watch one of the Hansons take over in Tampa Bay and ride Vinny and Stamkos to glory ...

If Alexander Ovechkin was the sizzle in the Washington Capitals' remarkable season, Boudreau was the steak: The perfect temperament and tactician for a team that looked destined for the lottery in November. In many ways, Guy Carbonneau of the Montreal Canadiens shared many of the same traits in bringing the same kind of stunning success to a team that some very smart people had predicted would finish dead-ass last in its division. All Carbo did was lead a roster that had, at different times of the season, 13 players born after 1985 to a regular season conference championship.

Boudreau and Carbonneau are up for this year's Jack Adams Award against someone who didn't share their obstacles of expectation and of inexperience: Mike Babcock of the Detroit Red Wings, who played a stacked deck and won a President's Trophy in a competitive conference.

If we had a vote, it would have been cast for Boudreau, who was a revelation behind the bench in his first year in the NHL, following what seemed like a century in the minors. Here's the skinny on this year's Jack Adams field.

Why Babcock Deserves the Adams: Knocking Babcock because he has an amazing array of talent at his disposal is rather unfair. It's the "Joe Montana Theory": It's one thing to be surrounded by talent, but it takes real skill and aptitude to utilize it. This is a Red Wings team that was good enough to go wire-to-wire as a conference leader, but there was a time when they weren't considered an automatic. What Babcock brings to the team is a background in psychology that enables him to adapt to adversity, and a dedication to such nebulous hockey beliefs as "puck management." In other words, he's sort of a nerd; which explains his deft handling of difficult literary classics like "The Grinch Who Stole Christmas."

Why Boudreau Deserves the Adams: The Capitals were 6-14-1 when Boudreau took over for Glen Hanlon on Nov. 22, but the situation was even more dire than that. Veteran players had quit on Hanlon, the team's grunts still weren't living up to their potential and Washington's piss-poor special teams continued to be like an anchor sinking the Caps to the bottom of the standings. Enter Boudreau; enter what amounted to a cure-all. Dormant players began to respond to his system and his personality. The power play went from 24th in the League last season to eighth overall this year. He's had that kind of special-teams success wherever he's coached. Unless Babcock gets a stuffed ballot from the West, or Carbo gets a load of Canadian support, this is Boudreau's prize.

Why Carbonneau Deserves the Adams: Because they vote before the postseason. Carbo's getting slaughtered for his decision to sit Carey Price in Game 4 against the Philadelphia Flyers. But in the regular season, he's a coach who pushed all the right buttons and led the team to its first 100-point season in 15 years and first conference title in 19 years. He deserves credit for managing one of the most exciting offensive teams in hockey that just also happened to be one of the youngest. Montreal arrived ahead of schedule this season; in many ways, so did Carbonneau. Could this slot have gone to Brent Sutter or Barry Trotz? Perhaps, but it's hard to put one of them over any ot the three coaches up for the Adams this season.

digg delicious
more

10 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. jbeallson
    1. Posted by jbeallson Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:30 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Boudreau has to get this award. Babcock and Carbonneau had great seasons but what Boudreau did with a team that was dead in the water was remarkable. Making the playoffs and taking them into a game 7 overtime against a Flyers team who may be playing in the Stanley Cup Finals.
  2. stuandallie
    2. Posted by stuandallie Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:45 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    What I don't understand (I know I am going to sound like a homer here), how isn't John Stevens not up for the award. He took a team that finished last, last year. Also has a very, very young team, dealt with 5 players being suspended during the year and their #1 scorer last year being lost for the season. Sounds like coach of the year to me.
  3. .................................................!
    3. Posted by .................................................! Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:44 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    "dealt with five players being suspended" -- Stevens oversaw the most undisciplined team in the NHL. The ability to keep your players under control is important.
    Boudreau wins this hands down. The Caps were an awful team with Hanlon, and one of the best with Boudreau. Doesn't get any more Coach Of The Year-y than that.
  4. Timothy H
    4. Posted by Timothy H Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:10 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    "One of the best" teams? Wow, they won the weakest division since the early years of expansion and got pounded out in the first round by last year's bottom feeders. Sorry, a team with that many high draft picks in its recent history ought to have more than that going on before we start calling them "one of the best,"--or before it's coach is anointed coach of the year, for that matter.
  5. Timothy H
    5. Posted by Timothy H Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:10 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Not to mention the fact that the team that sent them off to their tee times was, in your words, "the most undisciplined team in the NHL,"--as well as being last year's bottom feeders.
  6. Jak-0
    6. Posted by Jak-0 Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:45 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    1-Babcock
    2-Boudreau
    3-Carbonneau
    Harky-Barky!!
  7. Jay
    7. Posted by Jay Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:56 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I don't want to take away from the Wings and Babcock's 50 win season (again), but I personally would give the nod to Barry Trotz from Nashville. They made an amazing end of season run to get into the dance, put up a hell of a fight against the Wings, and did it 'right' all season, in a way that was good for hockey. I am somewhat underwhelmed with the Caps, sorry.
  8. Fred C
    8. Posted by Fred C Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:23 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Babcock needs to deliver the goods to validate his regular season totals.
  9. craz4wings
    9. Posted by craz4wings Thu Sep 03, 2009 7:42 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Mike Babcock has done a fantastic job this season (and all of his tenure with the Redwings) He deserves to be recognized for the accomplishments. The team went through its share of rough spots and injuries and they prevaled and continue on a fabulous post-season run. Reward Him!! Why are the Redwings are so overlooked when they lead EVERYONE!!!
  10. murphys law
    10. Posted by murphys law Thu Sep 03, 2009 2:56 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Stevens has a all star line up hello. philly stop playing off this underdog thing basement dwellers thing. its old .your money has bought the best teams money can buy the last ten years. dont be upset you got pushed to 7 games by a minor league coach and playoff first timers with a goalie we got a few games before the playoffs. coach b better win this award or the refs will call a penalty on the caps for no reason just like in the flyers series

Puck Daddy

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Puck Daddy Recent Readers

Watch Live Hockey Online with GameCenter Live™