Puck Daddy - NHL

As hockey fans, we live and die with our teams. Every miniscule move is broken down and discussed to death. Maybe that's why we find rumors and speculation on possible trades and player signings so addictive. No matter how ridiculous a rumor is, for whatever reason, people can't just dismiss it and move on. They need to have seven pages of back and forth discussion on a message board saying how silly the rumor is.

I think it's safe to say hockey fans know whom to trust when it comes to rumors. You have the solid choices like Bob McKenzie, Lyle Richardson and Darren Dreger. On the other hand, there are folks out there who create rumors to boost page views or sell newspapers, and have their "rumor" discussed across the hockey world for a few days. 

The last two weeks have seen rumors surface just about every day about every single free agent, just like they have at every trade deadline and summer free-agent frenzy in recent memory.

Here are some of the best of the worst rumors we, as hockey fans, have had to digest and regurgitate over the last several years:

Mario Lemieux to sign with the New York Rangers, March 2003 - Larry Brooks

The Penguins were in some financial difficulties around this time. Mario Lemieux owned the team and was in his third season since coming back from an early retirement. Brooks, of the NY Post, came up with the brilliant idea that Le Manifique was going to sell the team and force general manager Craig Patrick to trade him to a big market club; namely, the New York Rangers. This was before the salary cap, so the rumored $10 million salary for #66 was affordable by the Rangers, who were overpaying everyone they could find to put on a pair of skates.

Ryan Smyth signs with Edmonton, Trade Deadline 2007  - Dwayne Klessel

Smyth was one of the hot commodities at the trade deadline last season. Coming into deadline day, there was talk "Captain Canada" (video) would sign a new deal to stay with the Oilers and others speculating where he might be traded. During Rogers Sportsnet's frat party/deadline day show, they had on Wyshynski's good buddy Eklund as their "insider." Mr. Klessel not only disputed a report by Bob McKenzie about Gary Roberts waiving his no-movement clause, but he also "reported" that Smyth had signed with Edmonton. A little bit later, news broke that the Islanders of all teams had swooped in and acquired him. Swing and a miss!

Kyle McLaren to the New York Islanders, January 2003 - Sportsnet

"Sportsnet has learned that a deal between the New York Islanders and the Boston Bruins involving unsigned restricted defenseman Kyle McLaren is imminent." Two weeks later, McLaren was donning a Sharks sweater. There never was a solid explanation on how a deal can go from "imminent" to non-existent. You would think someone would take the time to do some detective work and try to find out what possibly could have gone wrong between the Bruins and Islanders. Instead, the rumored deal fades away into gossip heaven, but not to be forgotten.

Evgeni Malkin to the Los Angeles Kings, June 2008 - Bruce Garrioch

This was the rumored deal that forced me to come out with this ridiculous statement.  From the onset, I knew this was total B.S.  No way would the Penguins trade Malkin, especially not when he still have another year left on his deal. Luckily, Rich Hammond of the "Inside the Kings" blog actually spoke with one the two general managers supposedly involved in the trade, Dean Lombardi, who was just as shocked as everyone else upon hearing the news: "I had to call Ray (Shero, Penguins GM) this morning and say, ‘I hear I'm trading for him. What am I giving you?''' So basically, Bruce Garrioch heard this rumor from "league sources," yet never even called Lombardi or Ray Shero to find out if there was any traction for the deal. Well done, sir!

Marian Hossa (and his gloves) to the Montreal Canadiens,  February 2008 - Press of Montreal

Marian Hossa has taken the double award for this season as being the hottest commodity at the February trade deadline as well as the July 1 opening of the free agency market.  Around trade deadline day, Montreal was the hot rumor as the destination for the former Atlanta Thrashers forward.  Things really began to heat up when it was noted in the La Presse article that a pair of red, white, and blue gloves labeled "HOSSA" were spotted inside of the Bell Centre. No one seemed to want to believe that those gloves were really for Marcel Hossa, who was on the Rangers at the time and in Montreal to play the Canadiens. Oh, those silly rumors.

As you can see a lot of rumors turn out to be just that, rumors. It's fun to speculate on trades and where a player may sign; but you must, as an old teacher used to say, "consider the source."  We know guys like McKenzie, Dreger, and Richardson are solid as they come and of course will have their blips, but you know what you're getting from these guys: solid fact checking.

When you read some of the ridiculous rumors as we see above, what you're really reading is a feeble attempt to bump page views and feed the salivating fans eager for some sort of speculation.

digg delicious
more

42 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. Richard Thatcher
    1. Posted by Richard Thatcher Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:09 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Yeah and Gordie Howe will suit up with the Hartford Whalers after both institutions are risen from the ashes in 2008.
    first
  2. ~jai~
    2. Posted by ~jai~ Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:21 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    In the race to break a hot story no one bothers to confirm anything because they don't need to... no one has to admit "I made things up" or issue an apology unless someone sues. With blogs and personal sites it's not an issue but you would think at some point a paper/broadcasting company would stand up for respectable journalism.
    Speculation is just that and when the person gets it right no one seems to recall the other 999 times they had it totally wrong.
  3. Wyshynski
    3. Posted by Wyshynski Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:21 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    BY THE WAY: We'd of course invite you to add your own trade rumor busts in the comments. I was hoping Leahy would add Brooks' Fedorov for Scott Stevens deal, but we could list Larry Brooks's famous misses until the start of the 2019-2020 season ... when, I believe, DiPietro's contract is up.
  4. Paul K
    4. Posted by Paul K Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:14 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    ovechkin to nashville!
  5. Captain Trips
    5. Posted by Captain Trips Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:12 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    As I said in the Malone post comments: Darren Dreger knows everything. Just ask him. He'll tell you.
  6. Leahy
    6. Posted by Leahy Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:27 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    we could actually start an entire new Internet with all the misses from Eklund...
  7. Wyshynski
    7. Posted by Wyshynski Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:21 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    @ Paul K
    I had someone very, very smart tell me that Ovechkin to Nashville was the real McCoy.
    And I still don't believe him.
  8. beer_man_beer_here
    8. Posted by beer_man_beer_here Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:25 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    The whole Nashville team for Lidstrom!
    And Detroit still got shafted...
  9. BD
    9. Posted by BD Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:06 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Was it Sportsnet's gaffe that has the Fourthperiod.com have the McLaren for Isbister on their front page?
  10. The Franchise
    10. Posted by The Franchise Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:49 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    I read a rumor once back in the day that said the rangers would trade rick middleton for ken hodge..i mean how ridiculous is THAT one.....uh wait....
  11. Silent Storm
    11. Posted by Silent Storm Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:39 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Upcoming trade...
    Sean Leahy to Kukla's Korner for IwoCPO and a Dodge Charger Daytona Hemi...
    Yeah, it's BS, but it's fun BS.
    Anybody top that one?
  12. J.P.
    12. Posted by J.P. Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:42 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Back in 2000, I saw a "Florida for Gore" rumor that was relatively quickly dismissed.
  13. Nate
    13. Posted by Nate Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:03 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Madano to the bruins should have made this list
  14. Leahy
    14. Posted by Leahy Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:27 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    @Silent Storm: do I get a no-movement clause when I sign the contract at KK?
  15. Kimmie
    15. Posted by Kimmie Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:21 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    It's our perogative as fans to discuss things until they've been beaten, picked up, killed, resurrected, and then killed again. But what you believe is entirely up to you. If people are going to believe every ridiculous rumor they hear, it's their problem when it doesn't happen. Believing a rumor isn't going to make it happen or not happen, nor is discussing it to death. Get over yourself and realize that the offseason is full of people looking for attention (ahem!). It happens, deal with it.
  16. k c
    16. Posted by k c Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:16 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    A Joe Sakic plus 5 other players for the #1 overall pick in 1998 (Lecavalier) rumor might make the list.
  17. TMR
    17. Posted by TMR Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:39 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Between Eklund and yahoo sports, these rumors almost never hold any truth.
    check out my blog
    http://newyorktrueblue.wordpress.com/
  18. BD
    18. Posted by BD Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:06 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Leahy: unfortunately, it is a no bowel movement clause
  19. Wyshynski
    19. Posted by Wyshynski Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:21 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    @ Silent Storm
    Leahy can bring back way more value than that. I'm talking with Deadspin for the rights to Slate's Robert Weintraub.
  20. bleah
    20. Posted by bleah Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:30 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Brooks slings a fair amount of BS but he's a more entertaining hockey writer than you, bub.
  21. Joe
    21. Posted by Joe Thu Sep 03, 2009 4:35 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    @Nate: That was the very 1st rumor that popped into my head when I sawe this article's title (obviously except for the Mario-Rangers one). Nice call.
  22. BD
    22. Posted by BD Thu Sep 03, 2009 3:06 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Not a freakin chance. Greg, Sean and a lot other webheads can write rings around some of these newspaper guys who are flailing at trying to score a solid piece these days. The new school vs the old school....at least in case of fringe types who work for rags, is not even a battle. Brooks could sling his own feces and might be better.
  23. Weed Against Speed
    23. Posted by Weed Against Speed Thu Sep 03, 2009 10:42 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    Possible captions for photo:
    1) "ARRRGHHH, mateys!!"
    2) "Another thing I got is a sensk of humiligration. Now, maybe you swabs can pool your intelligensk and sees that I'm axsking you for an apologeky."
  24. Wyshynski
    24. Posted by Wyshynski Thu Sep 03, 2009 8:21 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    @ bleah
    Brooks is a very, very entertaining writer. So are Stephen King and John Grisham and any number of other who use their imagination to make money and attract readers. The only difference being that the majority of them self-indentify their work as fiction.
    BTW, thanks BD. If there's an example of a writer whose ideas and perspective create conversation in a way 1,000 bland MSM writers could never create, it's you, sir.
  25. Leahy
    25. Posted by Leahy Thu Sep 03, 2009 9:27 pm EDT

    Report Abuse

    @bleah: i'm not a writer, i'm a blogger :-) i'm just here for the free Yahoo! t-shirts

Puck Daddy

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Puck Daddy Recent Readers

Watch Live Hockey Online with GameCenter Live™