Mon Oct 20, 2008 2:49 pm EDT

The dissection of the Tampa Bay Lightning's early season misfortunate has become a sport of its own.
Rumors that Barry Melrose is out of touch, disorganized and losing his team are becoming gospel in NHL circles; fact or fiction, his well-manicured head has been placed on the chopping block by more than one media outlet. There are those who can't decide if the defense or the offense is more pathetic. And then there are the brave souls who peddle optimism about this team, partially blaming the European trip for the incompetence and feeling confident in the team's enthusiasm.
The pessimism is a little too excessive for this early in the season, and obviously comes from a place (for some critics) of disgust over the character or conduct of the Lightning's unorthodox new ownership. Which, of course, fails to consider that some people have things besides hockey on their plate in October; like, for example, scaring the living crap out of people with spooky viral marketing phone calls to promote a horror sequel.
But while any slump can be broken, there's one that should be of particular concern right now for the Bolts: High-profile free-agent winger Radim Vrbata's embarrassing pointless start to the season. We could be looking at the biggest UFA bust of the year.
From the Tampa Tribune comes word that the former Phoenix Coyotes sniper, who signed a three-year, $9 million deal with Tampa, has struggled to the point of being removed from the lineup:
Saturday, RW Radim Vrbata watched the Lightning's 1-0 shootout loss to Minnesota from the press box as a healthy scratch. In the first four games, Vrbata, who signed a three-year contract worth $9 million, has zero points and 10 shots on goal while averaging more than 13 minutes of ice time. Last season with Phoenix, Vrbata scored a career-high 27 goals.
"Vrbata hasn't been giving us what we hoped," Lightning coach Barry Melrose said. "Vrbata has played four exhibition games and four regular-season games now and he hasn't got a goal and hardly any scoring chances. So the message has to start going to the guys, you start giving us what we want or you are going to be out of the lineup, and that goes for everybody."
Vrbata was signed, in part, to be the goal-scoring threat for rookie Steven Stamkos. His inability to generate offense no doubt has contributed to Stamkos's slow start. Before he was removed from the lineup, Vrbata was dropped down to Chris Gratton's line.
That's a $3 million free-agent winger, swapping places with Adam Hall. Let that one roll around your mouth like a rotten olive for a while.
The only commendable thing about Vrbata's signing at the time was that Tampa Bay didn't break the bank for him. Otherwise, he was the epitome of a contract-year star with Phoenix. Out of all the Bolts' moves in the offseason, this one had the greatest potential to blow up in their faces.
Yes, we're including Melrose on that list.
Puck Daddy is an NHL blog edited by Greg Wyshynski. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Chicago 7, San Jose 2 (Nov. 25)
Posted Nov 24 2009
Washington 2, Buffalo 0 (Nov. 25)
Posted Nov 24 2009
Pittsburgh 3, Montreal 1 (Nov. 25)
Posted Nov 24 2009
Edited by MJD
Edited by 'Duk
Edited by J.E. Skeets
Edited by Greg Wyshynski
Edited by Matt Hinton
Edited by E. Brennan
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Steve Cofield
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Andy Behrens
29 Comments
1 - 25 of 29
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Let's see...AHL caliber defense? Check. Over-the-hill coach? Check. Random assortment of contract year over-achievers? Check. No discernable style of play, system, or hockey identity? Check. Oh yeah, and OLIE BLEEPIN' KOLZIG and MIKE BLEEPIN' SMITH as your goalies? Check and check.
Yep, if that doesn't scream playoffs, I don't know what does anymore!
It never ceases to amaze me how easily the media is swept up in hype.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
/The Scoresheet
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Many thanks to the Lightning for taking his salary off our hands!
But I think Melrose is a decent coach... he's just relearning EVERYTHING. lol
Report Abuse
Wow, it is gonna be hard for us to catch what he's droppin when he lands another TV gig.
Hey, at least the weather's nice!
Report Abuse
well said, but smith is a good goalie. blame that awful Defense where ranger is topps on the chart. i cant believe they gave malone all that money and i cant believe i drafted stamkos 9th round in fantasy
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
I've been asking myself this in several ways.
Did I stop drinking it when they let the defense go to crap?
Am I still drinking it because I believe the pieces are here and Melrose is the problem?
Can I claim to still be drinking it if Melrose is the problem?
Report Abuse
radim vrbata - a guy who never scored over 50 points until last year, due to getting large amounts of ice time on the yotes
steven "daigle" stamkos - an 18 year old kid who hadnt played a game in the NHL, but had already been proclaimed a success in the NHL (let me point out that even Alex the not-so Great had 37 pts in 47 games his first year)
barry melrose - a guy who's coaching career was inflated by the fact that he had the greatest player of all time on the roster
yeah, I totally didnt see this coming. I am really shocked. wow. holy jeebus.
Report Abuse
Vrbata was a poor choice, but at least they tried to do something. You roll the dice and see. Not every transaction will be successful.
The key to Tampa's team has got to be the system they play. Given their roster, the caliber of players they have as the centerpieces, they need to play an up-tempo offensive game, almost like the old Oiler teams of the 80's did. Puck pressure, puck possession, quick puck movement. Put the pressure on the other teams' defense to try and contain. Tampa still seems to be a team in limbo because they have not adopted a consistent system.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
@Wysh
you ever going to light that cigar or what? lol
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Try watching the Lightning play and not evaluating them as being wretched. And given that, a mere few months into his tenure, Melrose is reportedly losing the locker room...a turnaround seems unlikely.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Like Will Smith, I just bite it, I don't light it.
OK, that's a lie. I smoke like a Texas BBQ joint.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
but hey, it's easy to tear down, especially the bolts.
vrbata on the other hand, has been terrible.
Report Abuse
I'm not surprised...
http://onefansperspective.com/2008/06/12/vrbata-might-be-free/
http://onefansperspective.com/2008/05/17/the-value-of-radim-vrbata/
1 - 25 of 29