Tue Nov 18, 2008 1:15 pm EST

The debate over what to do with Jordan Staal has raged throughout PensNation for quite some time now. Some fans believe he'd be valuable trade bait to bring in a quality winger for Sidney Crosby and others think Staal is the type of player you win championships with.
Whatever side of the discussion you're on, this is a very important season for the future of Jordan Staal. He becomes a restricted free agent on July 1, but if Pittsburgh Penguins General Manager Ray Shero has his way, Staal will be locked up long-term well before then:
"If they really want to be here," he said Wednesday, "we'll find a way to make it work."
Puck's in your end now, Jordan.
But the key factor in this equation is what Shero hinted at: Does Staal want to stay in Pittsburgh?
If he remains with the Penguins, he'll find himself behind guys named Crosby and Malkin on the depth chart at center. The 20-year old Thunder Bay, Ontario native has emerged as a dynamic shutdown center man on the third line for Pittsburgh. His long reach and strong skating stride makes it tough for opponents to out skate him, as evidenced by Staal's back-check on Detroit's Pavel Datsyuk to set up the overtime winner last week.
While he's able to play wing at times, it seems as if his true role isn't the 29-goal scoring rookie we saw during the 2005-06 season -- it's that of a perennial Selke Trophy candidate.
In order to remain with the Penguins, Staal will have to ignore the lucrative offer sheets he'll likely receive should he make it to July 1 without a new contract; and like Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin, Brooks Orpik and Marc-Andre Fleury before him, commit to the Cup instead of the paycheck.
Last week, Staal was talking more like he won't mind leaving some dollars out there: "I have a lot of great friends here. It's a great fit for me. It's a team I want to be part of. We're young and we want to grow together."
It's obvious he realizes the promise in the Penguins locker room, but a few extra zeros on his paycheck can easily sway a 20-year old.
Over the weekend, the Pittsburgh Tribune-Review's Rob Rossi tossed this nugget into a round-up column that gives hope to those Penguins fans hoping to keep Staal:
"C Jordan Staal's representatives and the Penguins are now cautiously optimistic of reaching a tentative agreement on a contract extension for the center, who can become a restricted free agent on July 1, 2009. Friends of Staal say he has conveyed to his agents a strong desire to sign a long-term deal - preferably soon. Staal's agent is scheduled to be in Pittsburgh on routine business this week."
Pittsburgh currently has about $36 million committed for next season among six forwards, five defensemen and one goaltender (Fleury). How much of a hometown discount would Staal take to remain with the Penguins? There's the chance of him receiving offer-sheets in the neighborhood of $4-5 million/year.
If Ray Shero isn't able to lock up Staal before July 1, that $4-5 million/year offer could be too much for the Penguins to match.
Puck Daddy is an NHL blog edited by Greg Wyshynski. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Philadelphia 3, New Jersey 2 (Feb. 8)
Posted Feb 7 2010
San Jose 3, Toronto 2 (Feb. 8)
Posted Feb 7 2010
Phoenix 6, Edmonton 1 (Feb. 8)
Posted Feb 7 2010
Edited by MJD
Edited by 'Duk
Edited by J.E. Skeets
Edited by Greg Wyshynski
Edited by Matt Hinton
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Steve Cofield
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Brooks Peck
Edited by Andy Behrens
88 Comments
1 - 25 of 88
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
2. Staal isn't worth a monster contract to either the Pens or another team. But with that said Edmonton will still empty the bank for him.
3. He is good trade bait, but I'd keep him in the fold unless the deal is far too good to pass up. (IE: Non-rental superstar goalscorers)
4. He's in a really good situation to win and get some cups. Thus his value will be raised exponentially when/if he hits the UFA market in years to come. His payday will come. Later if not sooner.
Report Abuse
And, how did you know I was at the Isles game last night? Stalking me now for those free t-shirts?
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
And even if they did pay primarily on potential, Staal is in his 3rd year playing alongside 2 of the top 5 or 6 forwards in the league, and what does he have to show for it? His point total last year was barely more than half what it was the year before. If he has great potential, he has had every chance to turn it into results.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
A two-way center like Staal is a rare commodity. He's the kind of guy you long for if you're embarking on a long playoff run. You don't give a guy like that up. You just don't.
Report Abuse
Sarge is making 5 mil this and next season. Whits is scheduled to make 6 I think. Teams looking for veteran scoring D-men might take the chance on Gonch at the deadline, but that's very improbable because if he does come back before that, It'll be doubtful he'll have enough playing time to showcase himself. Whits might be moved and clearing his salary would be huge, but the team will have to have absolute confidence that Letand and GoGO are the replacements and I'm not sure if compatible trade partners will think as highly of Whitney's salary as Pens Management does.
Report Abuse
--Jon A
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Here's a kid that not only seems to be developing into an absolute defensive monster, but can also put home about 25-30 goals per year. He also plays his best hockey in big situations (his playoff performances so far, 3rd period/OT against the Wings). What about his game don't you like?
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
How do know were you are at all times? I have the Sword of Omens. It gives me sight beyond sight. Plus how many people go to a hockey game in batman Pjs?
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
So I guess he only scored 12 goals in 82 games last year because...
And his "best hockey" in "playoff performances so far" which you speak of consists of only 7 points in 20 games last year (0.3 points/game) with a -4 rating (unusual for a team making it to the SCF) and 3 points in 5 games (0.4 points/game) and -1 rating. How is that his "best hockey?"
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
I think they would move them if moving the salary made sense to them. Between 2 players you have 9 million in combined Salary. You also have a glut of young defensemen on who a decision will have to be made. Sign to let them go after the time spent developing them.
Facts are facts. The Pens face salary cap issues and they have players they want to sign and very little wiggle room to do it. After Gonch's contract expires, he's not going to be resigned. If you can move him early and free up the salary now, you do it.
I am not a Whitney hater. Quite the opposite, I like his game and I understand what he brings to the team. However, if you feel that Letang or GoGo are equal to Whits and can be resigned for less, Whits becomes a valuable trade commodity to a team looking for a top 2 defenseman signed long term and not at ridiculous money "Campbell-money."
If the Pens expect to keep Staal and get the scoring winger, they need to free up space somewhere and right now, with the other moves made so, that makes sense. If future moves change that, then you reexamine.
Report Abuse
Anthrax is the best Metal band ever. Too bad Scott Ian is a camera whore.
1 - 25 of 88