Tue May 27, 2008 9:02 am EDT

It may appear that NHL linesman Pierre Racicot is merely trying to hold down Pittsburgh Penguins forward Gary Roberts, in order to keep him away from his opponent. Actually, he's attempting to place him in a modified sleeper hold, so Roberts can feel how the majority of non-Detroit Red Wings fans felt watching that NyQuil-on-ice last night.
Game 2 was boring. Really boring. Mark Messier reading his grocery list boring. And this was a game that featured Valtteri Filppula's remarkable goal, two goalie interference incidents with Chris Osgood, Pavel Datsyuk throwing punches and Roberts attempting to take out Johan Franzen in his first game back. Stuff happened, and yet none of it could escape the gravitational pull of the black hole that was Game 2. The ratings will hopefully remain strong, but how many casual fans are going to subject themselves to this series again on NBC?
As we've been saying since the Flyers' series: Take away the middle of the ice from the Penguins, and you neuter that offense. The Red Wings aren't just taking away the middle of their defensive zone; they own the neutral zone all the way to the Penguins' blue line. Pittsburgh isn't a bad hockey team -- it's just out of its element. Like when Lindros discovered he couldn't bull through NHL defensemen like he could the boys in juniors. Like when a high-school big shot realizes that the same voodoo that worked on the girls back home doesn't fly at college, because there's always going to be another dude with a better car and an off-campus apartment. The Penguins are stunned, none of it is working, and the Cup is slipping away.
As for Detroit, it's rather amazing how the mainstream hockey media is falling over themselves to praise the Red Wings' stifling, joy-destroying defense.
If this were Nashville or Washington, we'd be on the verge of rewriting the rulebook to ensure this sort of defense was banished from the Stanley Cup Playoffs, despite its utter legality. But certain teams are praised for great defense, and other franchises are demonized. Remember: The Rangers play quality positional defense, but the Devils trap. That's just the way it is.
If nothing else, this series reminds us that defense wins championships, and that goals mean zilch for entertainment value if they aren't accompanied by good offensive flow. That's why it's pure comedy that the NHL is going to once again shave down goalie equipment; how, exactly, will that get Evgeni Malkin more than one shot in the Stanley Cup finals? Because that's the real issue with this snorefest, not the other numbers on the scoreboard.
LCS Hockey believes this is still a long series, and the Penguins can get back into it with physical, smart hockey:
Detroit did its job. It protected home ice. Now it's Pittsburgh's turn. The Penguins haven't lost at the Civic Arena since the Ford administration, and I see no reason why that will change in Game Three.The Pens did a lot of good things in Game Two. They finally came to terms with having to dump and chase. They started to physically punish the Wings, battering Zetterberg, Datsyuk, and Franzen over the second half of the game. And they generated some quality scoring chances. It's not like Osgood is stoning them. The Pens are butchering their best opportunities. They'll eventually go in. And once they get one, they're probably going to get a bunch.
Detroit has had a 2-0 lead in all four series this postseason. They've also lost two straight games in two of the previous three rounds. It can happen again. Nothing to it but to do it.
Sounds fair. But at this point, we'll take any semblance of entertainment over what we've seen for the first two games of this series. We were promised a heavyweight fight, and all we've gotten is the most tedious punching-bag session in boxing history.
Puck Daddy is an NHL blog edited by Greg Wyshynski. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Ottawa 4, Washington 3 (Nov. 23)
Posted Nov 22 2009
Colorado 5, Philadelphia 4 (Nov. 23)
Posted Nov 22 2009
Boston 4, St. Louis 2 (Nov. 23)
Posted Nov 22 2009
Edited by MJD
Edited by 'Duk
Edited by J.E. Skeets
Edited by Greg Wyshynski
Edited by Matt Hinton
Edited by E. Brennan
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Steve Cofield
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Andy Behrens
174 Comments
1 - 23 of 174
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
At times, the Wings' play is reminiscent of the Russian Five.
If you ever saw them play, it was scary the way they held the puck.
I've been watching the Wings for 23 years and this is just as dominant a team as the 2002 Cup winner.
Two flags up on the car, two more to go!
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Explain yourself. Were you entertained last night?
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
So, we get criticized for not filling up the arena. Then the Wings get criticized as being "too old" the keep up with the golden boy that is Crosby and his team of young stallions. Now the Wings are trouncing them and it's "boring hockey" Give me a break. Sorry this series isn't going your way Wyshynski.
You know what's boring? When the announcers can't shut up about Crosby in the beginning of the game, Pavel had a nice move to break through three defenders early in. Was in noted? Nope, just had to mention Crosby's last shift again. Finally after the Wings scored two goals they let up a bit. And just for the record, overall I think Crosby is a fine athlete. I don't dislike him, just the media's obsession.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Go Pens.
Report Abuse
How can they comment on how boring the series is if they heven't even watched a game? Because anyone watching can see the Penguins are as likely as not to get shut out four straight games! I am a penguins fan and even in my fantasies I can't see a puck getting past Osgood. Maybe the home crowd will make the next two games competitive, but they probably won't make a 4 goal difference which is what the Pens need to win a game.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
I am one of the people who suggested the Avs were beat up beyond competitiveness, and the Predators wouldn't dream of making the playoffs in the East.
Obviously it is the Penguins who would on;y dream of making the playoffs in the west.
As for the column this thread is on, it is dead-on that this series is boring, but it's not Detroit's fault. Pittsburgh can't even DREAM of being competitive. Don't blame Detroit for that, but it IS going to hurt hockey after all the hype.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
I wasn't really looking to whine here...OK, maybe that's not true. I think a lot of us approached this series hoping for something spectacular, and we've gotten a one-sided affair. The game was boring. The series has been boring. Them's the facts. This isn't some request that the Red Wings stop playing their style; it's a lament that no matter what the NHL does, we're always going to have great defensive teams shutting down great offensive teams because *that's how you win.*
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
1 - 23 of 174