Wed Aug 27, 2008 12:03 pm EDT
Every weekday in August, Puck Daddy presents "5 Ways I'd Change the NHL," in which a cross-section of sports media and hockey personalities offer solutions, suggestions and absurdities to remake the League to their liking. We're thrilled to have Eric McErlain, hockey blogger for The Sporting News and lead blogger for AOL Sports' NHL FanHouse, contributing his list today ...

By Eric McErlain
1. Say Goodbye to the Winter Olympics. I'd really like to believe that sending NHL players to the Winter Olympics has helped promote the game to the casual fan, but I'll be damned if I can find any evidence that's the case. Truth be told, sending professional hockey players to the Winter Olympics have done more for the event and NBC than it's ever done for the NHL. So let's save on airfare, cancel the World Juniors once every four years, and send those young, hungry and inspiring kids to the Olympics instead of the professionals. The World Juniors consistently delivers more drama every year than the Olympic Tournament does every four years, so much so, that I think it deserves to be played on far larger stage.
2. Say Goodbye to the Shootout. There was a time when I believed in the shootout, and there are few fans of the game that would dispute the fact that it's delivered some drama -- albeit manufactured. Unfortunately, that sort of drama has come at the expense of teams retreating into a defensive shell late in the game, turning more than a few third periods since the resolution of the lockout into a snooze fest. I don't blame the players or the coaches for the current state of affairs, as they're only acting in their own best interests. If you've read anything about game theory, you know that the current setup actually encourages teams to conspire to get to the extra period so each team gets a guaranteed point. I don't know about anybody else, but I'd trade away the shootout for more frantic third periods filled with desperate play. The next question becomes, what do you replace it with?
3. Three Points for a Win, One Point for a Tie, No Guaranteed Points. If you want to change behavior, you need to change incentives. As I wrote above, the current system incents teams to keep things close in the third period and play it safe. If you'd rather see more attacking hockey, you need to offer an obvious reward for teams to play that way, and an extra point for a victory is just the way to do it. We'd keep the five minute OT period, but there shouldn't be any guarantees once you get there. Want to retreat into a defensive shell to get that extra point? To do it, you're going to have to forgo the possibility of two extra points. What we want to create is the feeling that in order to force a tie, you're going to have to withstand one heck of an onslaught and sacrifice a chance to move up in the standings -- and with teams banking three points for regulation wins as well, I think more teams would gamble in OT.
4. Overhaul the All-Star Game. It's been a long time since anyone outside of the league's sponsors who get wined and dined in person cared about the NHL All-Star Game. Now that it's broadcast on Versus, even the folks in the U.S. who would like to watch it can't find it anymore, which is problematic when the goal of the game is to create some positive buzz about the sport in the midst of the season. And with the Winter Classic generating real excitement, the All-Star Game has managed to lose even more luster.
To reinvigorate the event, why not revive the original format of pitting the defending Stanley Cup Champions against a team of All-Stars from the rest of the league and play it before the start of the season? The same method works in the English Premier League, where the previous year's winners of the EPL and the FA Cup play for the FA Community Shield one week before the start of the regular season. All in all, it's a nice way to remind a casual fan that your sport is back in business. And when you start your season in October and go up against playoff baseball, you ought to find a way to make a big deal about it. Even better, think of it as another way to reward the Stanley Cup champion by letting them play the All-Star Game as part of an extended homestand, instead of abusing them the way the league did with the Anaheim Ducks just one year ago.
5. Bring Back the Canada Cup. The two most intense hockey games I ever watched in person were the clashes between Team Canada and Team USA in their opening games in the 1996 and 2004 editions of the World Cup of Hockey. The 1996 game in Philadelphia was a 5-3 American win that set an early tone to a tournament they would eventually win, and came complete with Claude Lemieux and Keith Tkachuk dropping the gloves just 20 seconds into the game.
Now that's hate you can bottle.In 2004, I carried the only visible American flag into the Bell (now Molson) Centre to watch Team Canada win 4-1, and spent most of my evening defending the honor of Canadian-born Brett Hull, who had the temerity to lace 'em up for Team USA. The tournament is also the source of my greatest hockey regret, as I grudgingly gave up my tickets to the 1996 Semifinal in Philadelphia, a matchup that turned out to be a classic, as Team Canada edged Sweden 3-2 in double overtime -- the longest game in international hockey history.
And we traded all that excitement in exchange for watching Tommy Salo get bonked in the melon against Belarus? What the Hell were we thinking?
Bring the tournament back, and bring it back now. And when you do, drop the name World Cup. The World Cup is for Soccer. Canada is the birthplace of hockey, and if you want to win hockey's ultimate international championship, you should have to tear the Canada Cup out of the cold, dead hands of Team Canada on their home ice, whether it's in Montreal, Quebec City, Toronto, Hamilton, Calgary, Edmonton, Winnipeg or Vancouver.
Eric McErlain is also the founder and editor of Off Wing Opinion, which is the reason many hockey bloggers are today blogging about hockey. Coming up on Thursday: Stu Hackel of the New York Times.
Puck Daddy is an NHL blog edited by Greg Wyshynski. Email him, and follow him on Twitter.

Ottawa 2, Columbus 1 (Nov. 26)
Posted Nov 25 2009
Vancouver 4, Los Angeles 1 (Nov. 26)
Posted Nov 25 2009
Chicago 7, San Jose 2 (Nov. 25)
Posted Nov 24 2009
Edited by MJD
Edited by 'Duk
Edited by J.E. Skeets
Edited by Greg Wyshynski
Edited by Matt Hinton
Edited by E. Brennan
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Jay Busbee
Edited by Steve Cofield
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Chris Chase
Edited by Andy Behrens
68 Comments
1 - 25 of 68
Report Abuse
DOWN WITH THE PITY POINT!!!!
Report Abuse
I remember the last game of the 1996 Cup so well. I was in college and the game wasn't on TV where we were, so one of my fraternity brothers from Buffalo had his dad tape it (VHS) and mail it to us while we avoided the result for a few days (easy to do in those relatively early internet days). The game itself was pure joy to watch, especially since it included a personal favorite generic hockey moment - scoring on a team after their goalie has been reinserted in goal post-empty netter. Good, good times. Viva Ron Wilson!
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
DOWN WITH THE PITY POINT!!!!
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Wyshynski you stink!
Report Abuse
3pts win in overtime
2pts win in shootout
1pt loss in overtime or shootout
That will make teams player tougher in overtime because you are rewarding them w/ 3 points for victory and 2 points for a shootout victory. That extra point will make a BIG difference for some teams late in the season.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
2) Shootout accomplishes nothing but determines a winner. For years a tie was a perfectly fine way to end a game, bring it back. The shootout only highlights the individual and not the team and the team is what hockey is about.
Report Abuse
4) All Star game at the end of the year played every year in Toronto. Much like the Pro Bowl in Hawaii, reward the players that play well all year round and not on the merit of what they did previously in their career or what they did in a half of a season. Baseball kills me to see someone get elected to the all star game that is in a slump all year or worse injured for most of it. Hockey isn't much better.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Enough with some games being worth 2 points and some being worth 3,
Regulation Win:2
OT/Shootout Win: 2
Regulation Loss: 0
OT Loss: 0
Then we have a total of 2460 points awarded every season rather than having it range from 2460 to 3690 points total in a season. 2732 points were awarded last year. 272 points were awarded last year due to the OT loser rule.
As soon as I can find a set of expanded standings I am going to punch up a set of real standings for teams had we not had the its-okay-you-lost-here-is-a-free-point system.
Report Abuse
Man, NOW I've seen it all.
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
I'd really, really like Canada Cup-like tournament, too.
As for the All-Star Game format, McErlain's idea is interesting. But what brand of hockey will then be displayed ?
Report Abuse
Great column - -
Report Abuse
Report Abuse
So thanks to wikipedia and me counting all the OT games for each team I have finished with the true standigns for last season. Wins are 2 points, Losses 0, and Ties are 1. All Shootout games were assumed as ties. The West doesn't see any placement changes just changes to the numbers. The East however has the playoff picture changed pretty readically. East Team Points
1 Montreal 95
2 Pittsburgh 91
3 Carolina 87
4 Ottawa 88
5 New Jersey88
6 Philly 87
7 New York 86
8 Washington85
9 Boston 83
10 Buffalo 83
11 Florida 77
12 Toronto 73
13 New York Isle69
14 Atlanta 64
15 Tampa Bay61
West Team Points
1 Detroit 108
2 San Jose 98
3 Minnesota 93
4 Anaheim 93
5 Dallas 89
6 Colorado 84
7 Calgary 84
8 Nashville 83
9 Vancouver 81
10 Chicago 79
11 Phoenix 77
12 Columbus 73
13 Edmonton 71
14 St. Louis 68
15 Los Angeles62
Report Abuse
that goal against salo is still one of the funniest (and best) hockey memory i have
den glider in baby...
1 - 25 of 68