Puck Daddy - NHL

John Buccigross's ESPN.com column on Brendan Burke -- who came out as a gay man to his father, Toronto Maple Leafs President Brian Burke, two years ago -- has been the talk of the hockey world in the last 24 hours.

(ESPN.com labeled his coming out as an "admission" on the top of Buccigross's story, which is about as faintly damning a term as can be applied to someone coming out to their parents.)

Not only has this been buzz-worthy because it reignites one of the hottest of hot-button issues in professional sports (homosexuals in the locker room), but because it instantly transformed Burke, that steadfast promoter of truculence and testosterone, into a de facto gay icon. Brendan Burke has become hockey's Mary Cheney of the moment, though both child and parent are treating this public outing with much less political parsing than Dick Cheney did in an election year.

From Damien Cox in the Toronto Star:

Burke believes there will be those who won't embrace the family love inherent in his acceptance of his son's orientation or of Brendan's decision to go public with his sexuality. Burke remembered that when he was in California in November to vote in the U.S. presidential election - he voted for Barack Obama - he was aggressively confronted by anti-gay activists protesting a same-sex marriage proposition on the California ballot.

"I told them to (expletive) get lost," said Burke, who also voted for the proposition. "But over the next two weeks, yeah, I expect to get some hate mail over today's story. There is going to be a backlash. All I care about is if Brendan is prepared for it. It takes jam to do what he's done."

What has he done, exactly? Has Brendan Burke helped drag professional hockey from its close-minded, closeted traditions regarding gay players with his story? Or is this just a personal choice and a compelling narrative without political impact? (To that end, we recommend Big League Screw's "it's a personal choice" essay on gay athletes coming out.)

To help answer those questions, we reached out to Justin Bourne, the former minor league player-turned-columnist whose piece on gay slurs in hockey for USA Today is actually the reason the world now knows Brian Burke has a gay son. (Follow Bourne on Twitter here.)

The following Q&A is an attempt to clarify what this news means and if, in the end, it's actually newsworthy.

Q. How did you initially stumble upon the story of Brendan Burke and how did it end up on ESPN? 

BOURNE: After my USA Today column on gay slurs, Brendan wrote me a personal email -- he appreciated the article, and told me his story.  I thought it was great (and actually, I assumed it was common knowledge), and asked permission to share it with my readers.  He had to clear that with big Burke, and his employer, Miami of Ohio University's Enrico Blasi.

Once I got the go-ahead from everyone, I tweeted that the story would be coming.  Not sure what happened from there, but I ended up getting an email from Brendan saying he had the opportunity to take the story to more eyes through ESPN's John Buccigross, and that John asked him to ask me not to write my piece until he could.  Eventually, John wrote me himself. 

Of course, this story is much more valuable if people actually read it, and I know my blog gets maybe kinda slightly possibly just perchance less daily traffic than ESPN.  So I respectfully waited for the story to come out.

He's been out for two years; why hadn't this story been written before, do you think?

No idea.  I'm gonna guess media people just didn't know?  I don't think it speaks to anything bigger than that, like "growth of acceptance" or something.  No idea.

What do you find most compelling about his story?

That Brendan is gay? 

Okay, no, it's that it's Brian Burke's son.  It's the stark contrast in his personality to the perceived personality of a gay male, and how Brian hasn't so much as flinched about the whole thing. 

It's like in "Billy Madison" when Sandler convinces the kids it's cool to pee your pants - when someone like Brian Burke, a perceived alpha male, says "it's all good, you gotta problem with it?", you halfway expect all the lessers in line to go "no sir, I've always been okay with it too."

I've heard complaints about this lacking "news value," both from people who are offended by the notion that coming out is an "admission" (as ESPN's headline on the Web page termed it) and that it's not exactly someone with a direct relationship with the NHL. Your thoughts?

Lacking "news value"?  You don't have to like the piece, or Brendan's story, or the concept of the story -- it's just an interesting piece on an interesting NHL-tied family.  A columnist isn't limited to writing about scores.  Look at Rick Reilly -- as much as that guy has started mailing it in the last few years, he writes about the people in sports, not the sports themselves.  And, he's been fairly successful at it, I've heard.

Arguing about the value of the story misses the point -- just enjoy a neat story about a hockey family living through something that our culture makes matter, when in reality, they're a healthy, happy, family (the best response to the article might be "so what?" Not long after corresponding with Brendan, I almost lost my brother at age 29. That's the stuff that actually matters.  As Burke mentioned - who by the way counts as a "direct relationship to the NHL -- it'll be great when this isn't a story).

Your question reminds me of something I've learned along the way -- part of the problem with speaking in defense of gay rights as a straight man (though please note, I understand where they're coming from on this) -- it's suuuper touchy.  For a guy ripped right out of the dressing rooms of professional hockey (i.e. me), you end up feeling petrified of making the situation worse, or seeming to be insensitive, strictly because you don't know. 

I know now that the word is "acknowledge," not "admit," because they've done nothing wrong.  And that "sexual preference" is offensive because it's not a choice -- use "orientation."

One facet of this that made me uncomfortable is the assumption of what being a gay man means intrinsically. By that I mean: Brian Burke is known for brutal, physical hockey, and hey, he has a gay son. Doesn't the story live or die on the stereotypical "femininity" associated with gay men, juxtaposed with Burke's reputation and that of hockey?

Yeah, you nailed it.  But that's what makes this story so valuable. 

A guy (Brian) who blatantly frightens people and seems to have the Grinch's heart in the "before" picture is okay with having a gay son, seemingly without hesitation.  About 40-50 years ago, guys a "manly" as Brian Burke are the exact reason gay men were uncomfortable coming out.  The culture towards them was vicious and hateful -- I think this shows that things are changing, acceptance is possible. 

If you're a gay player today, and Brian freaking Burke is cool with it, how much farther does that go than if some polite, out-of-the-spotlight guy is the one "marching arm in arm" with his son on this?  I say a whole bunch.

Finally, there wasn't a lot in the piece about gays in the NHL, which you and I agree is the only discussion/disclosure that's going to shift the paradigm here. Were you surprised by that, and does this ESPN piece perhaps make it easier for us to get to that point?

Hmm, not sure I do agree, actually.

I think an openly gay player in any professional sport could help advance the discussion, and further, an openly gay player at even the lower levels helps.  This isn't going to happen overnight, like, "hurray, the NHL approves of gays today!" 

This is a process, and anyone rooting for the rights of people to just be themselves should understand that every little piece of progress helps right now, and this is one.

Like some bad high school counselor, all I'm saying is, the more we talk about it, the easier it gets. 

digg delicious
more

171 Comments

Post a Comment
  1. John
    1. Posted by John Wed Nov 25, 2009 11:43 am EST

    Report Abuse

    "...but because it instantly transformed Burke, that steadfast promoter of truculence and testosterone, into a de facto gay icon." Huh? Wha?
  2. Brian C
    2. Posted by Brian C Wed Nov 25, 2009 11:44 am EST

    Report Abuse

    Good on Brian Burke. I can't wait for the day when someone being gay isn't newsworthy, it's just something people are and everyone wonders why we made such a big deal out of it. Let people live their lives as they wish.
  3. Brian C
    3. Posted by Brian C Wed Nov 25, 2009 11:45 am EST

    Report Abuse

    jc - because he accepts it, and supports it. He is a "macho manly man" who is cool with his son being gay, openly supports gay freedom (voting on same-sex marriage, and telling off anti-gay demonstrators).
  4. John
    4. Posted by John Wed Nov 25, 2009 11:53 am EST

    Report Abuse

    I like Bucci but that blogumn was just...idk...weird. How do we know Burke is a gruff and tough man at home? All Bucci did was profile Burke as the work man, not as the family man and then he try to get the reader to assume Burke would be pissed off and disown his son. Just not that great, it's personal stuff, not work related.
  5. Peter D
    5. Posted by Peter D Wed Nov 25, 2009 12:04 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    considering burkie's role in the public eye, there is no way he ever would have disaproved of such a thing.
    sure its his son, but here have been situations where children have come out to their parents, only to never talk to them again
    burke would have been roasted if he shunned his son
    i wouldnt say he is a gay icon, he just undersands his role
  6. JohnG
    6. Posted by JohnG Wed Nov 25, 2009 12:05 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    I read the article and this maybe superfical, but its a real shame that this kid had to quit playing hockey because of this. The kid clearly had talent and judging by the fact that he's a manager for his college's team, has love for the game. I think that is were the newsworthiness comes from; it places this issue in a more traditional sitting, ie a lockerroom, than what other settings in which gay issues are prevelant. I'm a lacrosse coach and have been from time to time know to drop some slurs, but I am def going to stop doing that now. I don't want anyonel or be the cause of someing quiting, to quit playing/doing something they like over it. And, if players use those terms, well lets just say they'll be very well conditioned. Although, it was a good topic, I didn't like style bucci used in the article.
  7. B M
    7. Posted by B M Wed Nov 25, 2009 12:10 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Nothing wrong with being gay. What somebody does in their own lives in nobody's business. People should mind their own business. End of story.
  8. Max_Powers
    8. Posted by Max_Powers Wed Nov 25, 2009 12:14 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    "I can't wait for the day when someone being gay isn't newsworthy"
    Same here. It's just people being people.
  9. Richie
    9. Posted by Richie Wed Nov 25, 2009 12:21 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    The crux of the issue here is that this is even news. I get that doing nothing and hoping it's just become a non-issue naturally is not the right way and that all discussion should ultimately make a person's sexual orientation in sport redundan, however I don't like the somewhat patronising way it was dealt with in the ESPN piece. It's a shame Justin didn't get the opportunity because I've always found his writing insightful and unabashed with the more delicate topics.
  10. Daniel H
    10. Posted by Daniel H Wed Nov 25, 2009 12:23 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    So, um... how is this an issue, again?
  11. books
    11. Posted by books Wed Nov 25, 2009 12:23 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Being gay doesn't make you a sissy...just ask the Greeks of old. Would you call Alexander the great a wuss? He was wounded numerous times as he always fought at the head of the army, but well - it wasn't just a ladies man and in many ways would be the equivalent of or even surpass Gretzky/Lemieux/Howe in hockey terms. Their gods engaged in homosexual acts (and even homosexual necrophilia but that's a different subject...and besides it was Dionysis - so he may not have exactly been sober at the time), their heroes (read the Illiad - Achilles and Patrokoles (crap forget how to spell that one) were more than just good friends) and everybody knows about how soldiers treated their shield bearers (I could mention certain artifacts depicting the defeat of the Persians but that may be too crude for this disucsssion as it is more technically rape.) Further, it was also considered beneficial to have a young man to have an older male lover to help guide him into manhood (see Plato and Socrates).
    Irrelevent? Possibly although - cliche warning - if you avoid the lessons of history your doomed to repeat them. How homosexual indiviudals are viewed is influenced largely by how our society tells us to. I'm straight myself but know a number of people of this 'type' and while some definetly fit the mold of the great poof of Python fame, most act just as any so called normal person would. We are all products of our societies views but what actually is - is often much different to what most people beleive. There are gay people all around you - it's a fact -deal with it. Right or wrong it exists, always has always will. Some cultures have accepted it, others haven't. Ours hasn't really.
    So what am I saying? Our views change over time but we haven't. The greatest evils ever committed have come when someone tried to force their views on others. And now for something completely different...
  12. Fin-atic
    12. Posted by Fin-atic Wed Nov 25, 2009 12:26 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    I think it has no bearing on hockey whatsoever. Anyone who does is probably homophobic.
  13. Joe E-Devils onslaught
    13. Posted by Joe E-Devils onslaught Wed Nov 25, 2009 12:31 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Let people do their thing, who cares. I'll tell you one thing though, I bet things won't be as hard on Sean Avery anymore.
  14. Magnet-Crotch
    14. Posted by Magnet-Crotch Wed Nov 25, 2009 12:35 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    My god Burke has a fat face. And that has just about as much relevance to hockey as him having a gay son. Actually, no, it is more relevant. So where's the story on Burke's big fat face?
  15. Windy City Hockey
    15. Posted by Windy City Hockey Wed Nov 25, 2009 12:36 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    being gay is not newsworthy. It's not a vice or a virtue. It's just someone's sexual orientation, which should be a private issue. Blasting things like this all over the news just stirs the pot, and usually makes any type of backlash worse.
  16. Thomas P
    16. Posted by Thomas P Wed Nov 25, 2009 12:39 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    It's a real shame that the root of this story -- father loves and supports his son -- is an issue simply because Brenden is gay. Here's hoping this story helps others who have far less supportive parents.
  17. MTL_WINGS
    17. Posted by MTL_WINGS Wed Nov 25, 2009 12:55 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Look at the size of his head. Last time I saw a cranium that large I was at the smithsonian.
  18. habs1rule
    18. Posted by habs1rule Wed Nov 25, 2009 12:56 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    There was a story recently about kids that runaway from home. And we all know what's waiting for them out there when they do leave. One of the largest groups nobody talks about are Gay kids that through no fault of there own are simply told to leave by angry, unsupportive and uncaring parents. Anyone here reading this should see what these kids sometimes have to do to survive...Just like All of our Runaways!! I joke around alot, but please, Love your Children, they are a Gift..Without any Conditions. A better world starts at home.
  19. breakaway
    19. Posted by breakaway Wed Nov 25, 2009 12:57 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    I wish we could have openly gay athletes, especially in hockey, without it being a problem, but our culture hasn't reached that point yet. This article is progress. It pushes the issue instead of hiding or denying it. Plenty of people make a big deal out of someone being gay, so we have to make a big deal about a prominent person and an organization being perfectly okay with someone being gay before it doesn't need to be an issue anymore.
    There are still families and parents out there who completely reject their children for being gay. I'm always happy to hear of any case, like this one, that's different.
  20. Tony
    20. Posted by Tony Wed Nov 25, 2009 1:00 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Another Sidney Crosby piece. C'mon Wysh can't you write about something else?
  21. Sllim
    21. Posted by Sllim Wed Nov 25, 2009 1:32 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Is he dating Sid Crysby?
  22. Pat
    22. Posted by Pat Wed Nov 25, 2009 1:33 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Political Correctness Day! I guess the fact that most Americans oppose at least some variation of "gay rights" is only because they are stupid or "homophobic".
    Because the media and Hollywood are so much smarter than the 2500 years of religous and philosopic teaching that has sustained (and made great) Western Civilization.
  23. Sports are just a game calm down
    23. Posted by Sports are just a game calm down Wed Nov 25, 2009 1:41 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Pat: You are exactly right.
    "It has come to our attention that you may have violated the TOS
    (http://www.yahoo.com/r/ts) on Yahoo! Sports (http://sports.yahoo.com).
    Please reread the TOS and cease any use of your account that may
    violate the TOS.
    If your use of your Yahoo! account is brought to our attention again,
    and we believe that such use violates the TOS, then we may terminate
    your account without further notice."
    Because I oppose homosexuality? Yahoo! has made their bed with Satan
  24. habs1rule
    24. Posted by habs1rule Wed Nov 25, 2009 1:53 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    Pat..Great comment...Especially that "Sustained and made Great that Western Civilization" thing... Did you know more people died in the name of Religion than any other Wars...Then throw in the genocide of entire races of people, and sprinkle in a few Wars caused by fear or nationalism...Yep, we are doing just fine.
  25. Guy F
    25. Posted by Guy F Wed Nov 25, 2009 2:01 pm EST

    Report Abuse

    "It takes jam to do what he's done."
    Or a lot of lube...
    j/k

Puck Daddy

Add to My Yahoo! RSS

Teams

Customize to follow news and rumors on your favorite teams. [ Sign in ]

Related Photo Gallery

Y! Sports Blogs

Puck Daddy Recent Readers

Watch Live Hockey Online with GameCenter Live™